Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Inhibition Theory and "True Self"


Heather Nicole

Recommended Posts

Heather Nicole

Ok, so this isn't directly an "alcohol abuse" topic per se, but its an open ended question that does relate to both alcohol and trans-ness, and as far as I can tell, this seems like the best place to ask something I've been wondering about for a long time...

 

I've noticed an interesting phenomenon: While I'm usually very questioning and hesitant about being trans (on and off, to varying degrees), literally ANY time I consume even a moderate amount, all doubt disappears and I "know" my true desire is to be female and that transitioning is absolutely right for me, no doubt whatsoever. And not that I remotely advocate it, or have any reason to imply any validity whatsoever to "alcohol-fueled ideas", but strictly for the sake of relevant data, I have definitely noticed that the more I drink, the more certain I am. (Which, yea, again is perhaps very much in line with alcohol-driven impulsiveness and impaired judgment and all.)

 

I'm not saying any of that means anything, but I find it an intriguing potential(?) piece of the puzzle that is "me".

 

Related to this, when I was in college, I had a friend who took...some kind of psychology course. Not sure what class exactly, but there was one thing in it he mentioned to me, and I found it such an interesting, plausible concept that it stuck with me, even decades later. Granted, I have zero background in psychology so I have no basis for judging the validity, but the idea was this:

 

Alcohol is well known to break down "inhibitions", therefore (so the theory goes), it brings out one's "true self", whether that be an angry abusive individual, a sorrowful one, a fully-content happy social one, or whatever else. I know that's only a theory...but my fully-amateur-at-psychology mind finds it intriguing and plausible...And I have always been absolutely full of inhibition...OMG, like you have NO idea...

 

I'll fully admit, there's a part of me that definitely wants this to be a clear sign that transitioning is right for me. But the trained-logician side of me (which I have very deliberately cultivated over the years and value very much) goes, "Whoa...there, buddy! Better do your due diligence first, and fully research all your assumptions and guesswork!"

 

So that's where I am. Aside from the very obvious "Yea, I should limit/eliminate my drinking!", which I won't disagree with...Anyone here have any background in psychology? If so, any insight into this "theory of alcohol"?

 

Or even more generally, is this something anyone here can relate to? If so, what experience can you offer?

Link to post

I can totally relate to this. And while I have a biology degree, my experience in psychology is zero.

 

I can say, however, when I thought i was a cross dresser, I would often begin with a glass, or three, of Shiraz. It certainly calmed me and I recall my feelings of "this is exactly how I want to spend the rest of my life" were far greater after the alcohol relaxed me.

 

Hardly scientific evidence, but I can relate.

Link to post

I have no background in psychology. For what its worth, I don't think cis people question their gender too much.

 

Hugs,

Mike

Link to post

I have only a basic understanding of psychology and can not offer any advice as that is not my place. I would say this though, alcohol very well may lay our inhibitions to the side when we drink it. That does not mean that we will react to these moments with a responsible and well thought out plan of action. The very concept of using a substance and gauging our true selves based on this experience has too many potentially negative outcomes. One very big problem is in how this becomes a crutch and is still an act of hiding behind something which is feared in an effort to find comfort. That, to me, seems like something we should wish to avoid. Just my uneducated opinion.

 

Great now my head is all hurty and stuff. :blowup:

Abi

Link to post
  • 2 months later...

I have also had that experience.  Reading your post just reminded me of that.  Like you, I would like to get a professional opinion.  I guess I'll have to bring the subject up in my next session.  Thanks for the nudge.

Link to post
  • Forum Moderator

I can't help but agree that alcohol fueled a loss of my inhibitions and my first steps towards my true self.  This gals first high heeled steps were towards the door of a gay bar.  That being said alcohol may have prevented any chance for an early transition.  I could face the world as myself after a few shots but without that fuel......... The night would end and was quickly replaced with guilt and shame.

 I am an alcoholic in recovery. Five years into recovery i transitioned.  I faced issues as a sober woman rather than as a drunken man.  I mention this not to say that alcohol does not lower inhibitions.  It does.  It may well give a glimpse of one's true self.  That understanding may help some.  To be a positive experience that glimpse could lead to therapy.  For me it  may a factor in my addiction.

 

Hugs,

 

Charlize

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to post
On 9/22/2020 at 12:52 PM, Heather Nicole said:

 

I'll fully admit, there's a part of me that definitely wants this to be a clear sign that transitioning is right for me

Hi Heather. 
I think this is totally natural, and inline with how most of us behave when a bit high.  Our inhibitions drop, and we don't feel as confined to social norms.  We've all felt that way, I am sure, and we've anecdotally probably seen the meek co-worker dancing with a lampshade on their head at the office party.  It probably doesn't mean they want to be a "lamp" but it likely does mean they feel free to openly express themselves and their true feelings that they normally suppress. 

If you Google the subject you will find lots of studies about alcohol and effect on inhibitions.  Most declare that its complex, and not always a direct correlation, but seems the connection is clear.

 

For me, and my definite inhibitions about coming out socially, I would say it would be more of a confirmation of my true self-identity.  But I would probably also prefer that determination be in counsel with a good gender therapist (and I have. and I am) ❤️

 

Link to post
  • Admin

I do have a significant level of psychology training (minor degree to another Behavioral Science degree & subsequent coursework to see if I could figure myself out) and the answer is --- drum roll --- MAYBE.  

 

That said, I abused alcohol to try and get my GD out of my head and keep it from bothering me. (That was alcoholic thinking  really).  I wanted to quickly accept the GD and then put it behind me as of no importance as I had for so many years.  I had known of my problem for years and had avoided it through family duties, work, religion, community service etc.  In my current recovery though (12 years) I got slammed against the facts that GD is Consistent, Persistent, and it had reached its maximum load of Insistency, still while drinking I was not going to act on it but I was going to kill myself.  Again, Alcoholic Thinking at its finest.  I did give into the need for counseling on the GD and they said that addiction recovery was part of that counseling in my case.  Without the alcohol it would have been a direct shot to the GD counseling, but I had to take a different way.  SIGH. 

Link to post

@Heather Nicole

I think this is a very interesting thread, and well presented.  For mostly people who are "not psychologists", I am so impressed with the intelligent responses to this, and many other threads I read on this site.  Some of us know that no one can help an alcoholic like another alcoholic.  Perhaps the same can be said of a trans person.  These are the most helpful people I've encountered on the subject.  I really appreciate everyone's insight.

Link to post
On 9/21/2020 at 11:52 PM, Heather Nicole said:

Or even more generally, is this something anyone here can relate to? If so, what experience can you offer?

I do not 'drink' at all but there is another 'no lie' mood altering drug that completely pushes me over the edge in terms of wanting, overwhelmingly NEEDING, to transition both sexually and socially. While addictive in the sense that I'd probably do it all the time if easily available I've long since stopped completely and, for the last 14 years, have simply contented myself with steady HRT instead.

IMHO cross-gendered feelings only become a "mental health issue" if excessive behaviors negatively impact one's everyday life functioning (which 'cocaine', just another 'diagnostic tool' for me, most certainly did!)

Link to post
  • Forum Moderator

Addiction to any drug whether alcohol or any of the countless other mind altering substances is definitely an issue that trans folks may face. 

This site has always included forums where we can confront these issues.  The serious nature of addiction for our community puts those forums along with suicide as the first ones one sees here.

We can pay a terrible price for a loss of inhibition.  Too many of us suffer jail, mental institutions or even death because of addiction.  If you have issues there are trans folks who understand and can help.  Reach out....

 

Hugs,

 

Charlize

Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   8 Members, 0 Anonymous, 73 Guests (See full list)

    • HappyQueen
    • luke_b
    • Shay
    • Audrey
    • Cyndee
    • Jackie C.
    • Bri2021
    • Judy Callaway
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics With Zero Replies

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      72,957
    • Total Posts
      669,403
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      7,938
    • Most Online
      8,356

    rkaplan
    Newest Member
    rkaplan
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Callie40
      Callie40
      (46 years old)
    2. Vanessa Michelle
      Vanessa Michelle
      (46 years old)
  • Posts

    • Shay
    • Shay
      @Cyndee @Jani @Susan R I saw James Gang before Joe Walsh and they were a copy band. I went with my cousin the summer Sgt. Pepper came out and the James Gang was a 5 piece. The guitarist went on to play with Pacific Gas & Electric ("Are You Ready?" fame). They had a keyboard player (they used on New Birth eons after Tommy Bolin and Dominic Tro      
    • Shay
      Sad but happy because of my special friends here................    
    • Shay
    • Willow
      @KymmieL boy that’s a bit of a conundrum.  As bad as she treats you then she does something kind.  I consider buying you a woman’s flannel shirt as an attempt to move towards acceptance.  A tiny step, but none the less, a step.   Like we’ve been talking about here this that morning, women’s clothes fit different.  Does it fit ok?  I’d take that as a win.   Willow        
    • CallMeKeira
      Good morning all. Coffee is hot, apartment is cold, even with heat. My laundry is in a state of limbo, as I have so much men's clothing, a growing wardrobe of comfortable clothing, and no real solution for doing away with the old since I'm only part-time right now. I know what my heart tells me, to just take the men's clothes and just toss them out, because this girl has no desire to wear them. But, my brain goes "That's impractical, Keira. What if you need them?". It's something I'm going to bring up next therapy session, because I feel like I'm could between what is my true life, and a stage performance I've been playing on most circuit productions for 20-some theater seasons. It's vexing. (A note of positive feedback, I am 6' 2", so I feel your pain on skirt and dress length.) -warmest regards, Keira ❤️
    • KymmieL
      Willow,  that job does sound  a little fishy to me.   My wife does  complain when I get something new to wear. Why didn't I get her something.  99% of the time she may wear it once. She  surprised me last week.  She bought me a nice flannel shirt.  Quote "not to manly not to feminine."  So I looked at the tag. Size 20 womans.       Kymmie 
    • Willow
      Back.   Fashion discussion:   if I want a short sleeve T I try 3/4. The are a little long but not bad.  Mini skirts?  Not for me. I’ll go above the knee but just barely.   Next problem is finding full length dresses or skirts that are long enough.  Even long pants often end up Capri length.  My wife is jealous of my feminine appearance.  She is very short, 4’ 10”.   After years of joint compression I am now only 5’ 8”. (Guess I need to hang upside down.). She has mentioned my legs are nicer than hers.  Also my upper body is better proportioned since I have a smaller chest. She is a DD I am a B.  We wear similar sizes so things that were bought on line for her sometimes become hand me downs to me.  She really wants to lose weight before buying clothes (I lost 30 pounds) but then complains I bought clothes.  But I started from zero.  Our closet got too full and collapsed so when I physically can, I have to rebuild our closet. I hate wiremold. It’s quick and relatively inexpensive but eventually the supports tear out of the wall.   Willow
    • Willow
      Good morning everyone    sorry about that last night.  The initial search on the company looked good, so I went forward with their process of applying for a part-time job. Three hours spent answering questions and waiting for the person on the other end to move on gave me time to search further.  Both Indeed and Glass  Ceiling had poor employee reviews and mentioned high turn over.  That made me skeptical.  The last straw was the HR guy telling me to hold on he’d get back to me after I’d accepted their job offer.  I finally had had enough and sent a message back that I rescinded their offer.  Now all of a sudden they were back to me and all but you are set up to start tomorrow blah blah.  Even emailed me more paperwork.  At this point I am skeptical that I was even talking to the real company and not a scammer.  Unfortunately they did get some info out of me that if they are a scammer could be a problem.     So if it was a tease, I’m sorry but I don’t need a job and there were signs in the end the it wasn’t legit.    Willow   
    • Audrey
      I'm back, at a more reasonable hour now. Managed to get another hour and a half or so of sleep, then gave up and just got my day started. I went out for my morning exercise routine in the park - and was greeted by the wall of below-freezing air that seems to be gripping much of the Northeast and Midwest this weekend. I summoned the Minnesota girl inside of me and managed to work up enough body heat to do my usual 45 minutes. I can't even tell you how fast I made hot tea the instant I got home.   No big plans for the weekend other than enjoy the brief respite from working. My partner and I talked about going on another hike outside the City, but the cold is proving very de-motivating for that, so we'll probably just be home. There is a Moroccan lentil stew in a cookbook we hope to make, will be perfect with this weather. I'm also looking forward to my virtual girls night tonight though with my West Coast girlfriends! ❤️    @Bri2021 Your sister's home has probably has more square footage than *every* apartment in the six story building I'm living in!   Love, ~Audrey.
    • Cyndee
      Lovely fuzzy , movin' groovin'     
    • Audrey
      I chose the rose gold Apple watch when I bought one. I'd probably chose a phone like that too, except that I'm still using an iPhone 5 like they had on the Flintstones.   @Jackie C.  Super cute and warm! I love the blues with blonde hair look so much!   Love, ~Audrey.
    • Charlize
      Thank you for sharing Timber Wolf. it sounds like your days were long and full of excitement.  I spent some years competing in licensed bike racing(USCF).  Long road races required even longer training rides.  It took several years of very hard training before i was at all competitive.  At first i was alone, working against teams who tried to push others to the side.  Riding at 25 to 40 mph. in Lycra  shorts, 3 inches away from other riders could be intimidating especially when fighting to stay on the pavement.  In time i joined a team with my son.   My  did well until breaking bones in several races.  I was lucky, road rash,  bent wheels and some broken bikes. Riding was an obsession for years until a heart attack,  open heart surgery and an addiction to alcohol made riding impossible.  I guess the high point of my career was winning the state championship in a tandem time trial.  That bike as well as my last road bike hang in the barn.  I do miss riding but today my heart makes riding very difficult at best.  Wonderful memories!   Hugs,   Charlize
    • Audrey
      I have struggled to see Caitlyn Jenner as a role model. Nothing against her of course. I think it's the privilege aspect that makes it so difficult to relate. When I watched the "I Am Cait" series a few years ago, I couldn't help but feel how out of touch she was with the challenges facing the other transgender people she met. Maybe she has changed since 2015. Even still, I do think her high visibility has helped a little with mainstream consciousness of transgender people. Same with Elliot Page more recently. On the other hand, I feel that Rachel Levine and Sarah McBride are excellent role models. They will do important work in their positions, and raise the mainstream acceptance of transgender people in a very different way than a celebrity does.   I expect I will have a similar experience to what @Bri2021 describes when I come out fully at work. Many of my colleagues and clients may never have met a transgender person face-to-face, and only have whatever positive or negative impressions of the community exist in their minds. So I will be the very first one. They hold me in high regard now, and while I know things could change once I am out, I hope I can challenge any pre-existing negative attitudes by building on the positivity that they have felt about me all along.   Love, ~Audrey.
    • CD Rachel
      Good morning all, #ElizabethStar –  I am seconding Bri2021 on the full fashion show! Finishing up my second cup of coffee now. I had to run down and get some blood work done this morning. I hate needles! My first therapy session with the new therapist went well yesterday. Working on filling her in on a lot of my back story concerning my marriage and separation. I will be able to slip another session in next week so I will not have to wait two weeks to see her again. I have to go down to the wife's house today. She needs a light fixture replaced and some plumbing work done so her contractor can close up the walls. Apparently her plumber had a hissy fit when she questioned him on some iffy work that he had done and he stormed out of the house. Why is it so hard to find a good reliable contractor that shows up when he says he will and does quality work without trying to rip people off? Hope everyone has a Super Saturday! Rachel  
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...