Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Why do we believe what we believe?


Ivy

Recommended Posts

11 hours ago, Robin.C said:

The day I was able to see that religion, any religion does not own God was the day I felt I could continue living.

This is a good point.

 

Although I no longer consider myself to be a christian, I do not consider myself to be an atheist.  It's just that my concept of "God" has changed.

Link to comment
On 5/3/2023 at 9:10 PM, Robin.C said:

I was raised a Roman Catholic and at the moment I still detest what I went through with them (not all Catholics are bad, just putting that in there) and because of that I refused to believe in God.

 

As mentioned, I too was raised a Roman Catholic & I know how difficult that detesting can be. Mercifully, I can say that the bulk of my resentment has been surrendered, though those impressions cut deep. For instance, I find it difficult to believe (keeping with the topic of belief) that ppl find actual solace in practicing Catholicism. I am aware that people do. I admire some works of Catholic mystics. When I find myself having thoughts about delegitimizing the authenticity of devout Catholics' experience, I try to check myself. Just because something hurt me doesn't mean it's fundamentally wrong for everyone. I remind myself that my thoughts are a reaction to my personal trauma. Thus, I endeavor to un-do that belief because I truly deeply desire to not judge or dismiss others. I do not enjoy the idea of feigning superiority. I desire serene humility. 

 

I refused to believe in God for some time as well. 

 

On 5/3/2023 at 9:10 PM, Robin.C said:

The day I was able to see that religion, any religion does not own God was the day I felt I could continue living.

 

Did this come to you suddenly, or was it a gradual process? 

 

On 5/3/2023 at 9:10 PM, Robin.C said:

...indoctrination from the church ?

 

I know that my negative experience with the church is not uncommon. What's unique to me might be the way in which that indoctrination was administered. My Catholic family was also highly dysfunctional, wrought with mental illness, and very fearful & isolationist. If I were raised in a high functioning, trustworthy family, I wonder how my experience with the Catholic church might have been different. At this point in my life, thank God, I do not yearn for my past to have been different as the challenges I have overcome have strengthened me. I deeply resented the challenges of the past while they were happening - in retrospect I suggest because I could neither see nor imagine a light at the end. Specifically regarding why I believed what I did - that I was filthy, rejectable and practically irredeemable - I internalized this by what I was told by my family. I don't think that's exactly what's taught by catechism, but it's certainly how my family believed it to be. 

 

On 5/4/2023 at 8:57 AM, Ivy said:

Although I no longer consider myself to be a christian, I do not consider myself to be an atheist.  It's just that my concept of "God" has changed.

 

I realize in retrospect that my actual period of atheism was devotional. I had to spend a lot of years learning to un-believe the beliefs I had internalized. I rejected not Thee God, but the fictitious "God" who terrorized my existence for so long. Gradually, I became receptive to experiencing God through spontaneous experience, through teachings which resonated with me & through intuition which is like the antenna of such resonance. Given all that, it's the relative ease and lightness I experience which validates the beliefs I wish to keep & strengthen as faith. Similarly, it's the stress of experiencing fear, shame, guilt & pride which help me to identify beliefs which need to go. 

Link to comment
9 hours ago, Vidanjali said:

Did this come to you suddenly, or was it a gradual process? 

 

It was a sudden realisation. God works in mysterious ways as they say :)

 

 

Link to comment
On 5/3/2023 at 9:10 PM, Robin.C said:

Religious beliefs are another topic entirely and often fraught with emotional baggage.

No offense is intended to anyone's religious beliefs I'm just trying to add to the WHY we believe not WHAT we believe.

Thank you to everyone who has and is contributing to this thread.

When it started I was thinking that Why we believe, and What we believe were two different things.  But obviously that is a mistake.  

In my own life what I believe has shifted.  And the why has certainly been influenced by the what.  

 

At one time I believed - or maybe more accepted - because It is written… 

But that kinda depended on who I believed had done the "writtening."  So why did I "believe" who had done the writing?  Was it just a cultural thing?

 

I'm kinda at a place where I will consider what I'm told (or read).  And I might even try it out to see if it works for me.  But ultimately my own experience is all I really have to go on.

 

Is there some sort of "Absolute Truth"?  I don't know.  But it seems to me, that as soon as we try to define it, we've already limited it, and so lost it.

I have sometimes wondered if theology is really a way of actually avoiding "God".  We have this idea that if we can define something, we can control it.

 

I no longer think we can define "God".  And I no longer think I can define myself, nor do I want to.

 

Link to comment

Been thinking on the things that have been shared here, and also still exploring my own journey.

I also am questioning just how much my beliefs have been influenced by other people in my life.  Certainly as a kid I just believed what my parents told me.  I suppose that's pretty much normal, you don't really question things.  I went to a Lutheran school through the 6th grade.

 

But moving on from there, in my late teens I began to question things, and started exploring some things that were definitely outside of what I'd been taught.  I was undoubtedly influenced by 60's music and the "hippie" culture as well.  So again, was I just under the influence of the culture around me?  But the things I "believed" did make sense to me.  And a lot of them still do.

 

That's kinda where I was when I met my (ex) wife.  I had no concept of being transgender, but was questioning my sexuality at the time.  But once we were together I just went with it.  We were kinda "organic" "back to the land" people.  And once we started having a family, we got pulled into pentecostal "holiness" type christianity.  But looking back, I am questioning how much (for myself) it was a matter wanting to belong.  It was easy for me to revert to my christian roots as it were.  Over the subsequent years we kinda wandered through various forms of Christianity.  She still considers herself Christian.

 

But lately I've been wondering about it all.  Part of the tension in our marriage was due to me questioning this stuff again.  And when we split up, it was easy for me to go back spiritually to the place I was at when we first got together.

 

So now I'm asking myself, how much of what I believed at the time, was really the influence of those around me?  And what does that mean for the things I say I believe now?  Can we ever be completely sure about anything?  Or are we only trying to convince ourselves.

Link to comment
5 hours ago, Ivy said:

what my parents told me...Lutheran school...things that were definitely outside of what I'd been taught... 

 

So again, was I just under the influence of the culture around me?  But the things I "believed" did make sense to me.  And a lot of them still do.

 

You were under the influence, but not "just" - you also had a unique attraction to what you gravitated towards as your life progressed. So, you were not completely at the mercy of whatever culture was prevalent from time to time. Each of us as if develops our own culture which is refined over time. 

 

5 hours ago, Ivy said:

I am questioning how much (for myself) it was a matter wanting to belong.  

 

I think we're all motivated by wanting to belong. For trans people there's a unique aspect of that which can often results in our living much of our lives struggling to fit into roles that don't feel quite natural. To the extent a person is self-aware and motivated to do effort versus naive, vulnerable and fearful, their wanting to belong will lead them to try out various ways of life and belief systems. Some get stuck in fear, remaining rather complacent. Others evolve and refine their concept of wanting to belong. The ultimate wanting to belong is the desire for Unity with the Divine. How is one to realize it? It's a journey which entails profound questioning and self-reflection. 

 

5 hours ago, Ivy said:

So now I'm asking myself, how much of what I believed at the time, was really the influence of those around me?  And what does that mean for the things I say I believe now?

 

Influence is powerful. We are all subject to influence. Good influence works wonders. One who seeks the truth will continue to attract auspicious influences or associations. And what no longer serves you may be moved past. 

 

5 hours ago, Ivy said:

 Can we ever be completely sure about anything?

 

We can be sure that everything in the material world is perishable and will pass away. Therfore, if one seeks to know ultimate reality, it is beyond what we detect with the senses, what we feel through the nervous system, and what we think with the mind. 

 

5 hours ago, Ivy said:

 Or are we only trying to convince ourselves.

 

Our minds are pervaded by desires. The ultimate desire is the desire for absolute freedom. Some seek it in a limited way through emotion, others through material comforts. Those who are spiritually inclined seek it through knowledge, through experience of higher states of consciousness & through surrender of attachment. Even spontaneous experience of the Divine (or whatever one wishes to call it) requires reinforcement. The mind does require convincing that what it perceives is not the ultimate reality.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   8 Members, 0 Anonymous, 103 Guests (See full list)

    • Mikayla2024
    • VickySGV
    • Adrianna Danielle
    • MaryEllen
    • Ivy
    • Betty K
    • KathyLauren
    • Amy Powell
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.9k
    • Total Posts
      770.9k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,141
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Charleigh Lucille
    Newest Member
    Charleigh Lucille
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. DaveMK
      DaveMK
    2. Heidi45
      Heidi45
      (46 years old)
    3. Jordy
      Jordy
      (42 years old)
    4. stella
      stella
      (61 years old)
  • Posts

    • VickySGV
      They have done so already I am afraid.  Nothing new really, but Cass included views of our home brewed bigots to create this. 
    • Adrianna Danielle
      Met up with a teacher I had back in high school and went good.Was 27 years ago I last saw her after I graduated.Walked into her classroom and we hugged calling me Adrianna.Remembered seeing me as male seeing I was holding something in.Told her I am much happier now and said she noticed it now.Even said seen me as an 18 year old and now as a 45 year old transwoman.Did get to walk down the halls bringing back lots of memories too.Ran into another teacher I had too.She said I changed big time.Told her I go as Adrianna now,transgender on the hormones.Also said she noticed I was unhappy at times and I am much happier now.I did take a picture with both of these two
    • KathyLauren
      Hi, Kayla.   Another Bluenoser!  (Actually, I'm not a real one.  I am a CFA.)    I can't answer your question about the effects of spiro alone.  I started on spiro and estrogen at the same time.  I expect that spiro alone might relieve some dysphoria symptoms, but would not start any physical changes.  But that is just a guess.  The big thing with spiro is to drink enough water, since it is a powerful diuretic.   I started out getting my transition care from the Halifax Sexual Health Centre, but once my hormone regime was stable, I asked my GP if she would be comfortable taking over my prescription.  She was, so I no longer have to do the long commute into the city.   Regards, Kathy
    • MirandaB
      I can't answer your question since my doc's plan didn't start that way, but I do love to quote what she said to me when we began HRT when I see a post like this, "Let's get this party started!"
    • Betty K
      Thanks for listening Vidanjali. And don’t worry, I am now planning two weeks off before I try to write a more in-depth response. I am well aware of how much Cass has been hurting me. 
    • Mikayla2024
      Thank you, Mindy! Such a warm welcome!! I’m excited and honoured to be here !! 😊
    • Ivy
      I don't need that "new math."  My brain does it on its own.
    • Willow
      You know the advantages we had using long division and multiplication, slide rules and log table?  We can look at a result and know right away if something is wrong with it. Kids that have grown up using calculators can hit keystrokes on their calculator but they have no clue that the answer is wrong when there is a factor of ten that they messed up.  Also we learned our basic math tables inside out and upside down. They use this new math that mixes everything up.  
    • Mmindy
      Good afternoon Kayla,   Welcome to Transgender Pulse Forum, I hope you find this place as helpful and fun as I do. There are so many people from all walks of life, and locations in the World. Look around and join in on any threads you find interesting.   Best wishes, stay positive and motivated,   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋
    • Mikayla2024
      Hi All,   So today, I finally met with my Nurse Practitioner in her office to officially go over HRT for me. A little bit of background about gender affirming care in my province I live in - Doctors and NP’s now have the authority to perform gender affirming care as per a new directive recently. I only know because 6 weeks ago when I met with her and telling her about who I truly am, she said that before our appointment she was in a province wide zoom meeting with the sexual health centre in Halifax about gender affirming care and them explaining to all the PCP’s that if they can handle gender affirming care in the community as it would help save resources to focus on the more sensitive clientele such as children and teens.   At the end, I had to sign a document ensuring I understood everything. I grabbed the document so fast and signed away !!   So, she prescribed XXmg of spiro daily in the morning (Anti-Androgen) to start for 4 weeks and then seeing how I respond to that, she’s going to then start me on Estrogen pills. I already have a follow up appointment booked at the end of June.   I trust my NP wholeheartedly, kinda disappointed that I didn’t get the E, but I totally understand why. I’m a little nervous with the side effects however of Spiro, but regardless of side effects I’m going ahead with the plan and trusting in process and becoming who I’m truly supposed to be.   Question though as I’m curious - I know it’s a low dose of spiro but even then what sort of changes can I see from just the spiro alone without the e for those first 4 weeks?    thanks everyone!!   Kayla
    • April Marie
      Very cute!!!
    • Mmindy
      Yes I do... Creating/Building handcrafted gifts for family and friends using wood or metal. Camping and all the things you think could go with that, hiking, fishing, hunting, bird watching, meeting new people, and music festivals. Bluegrass, Folk, Americana. Seeing new parts of the world, and historical locations. Star gazing.   My father use to say he didn't trust anyone that didn't have at least to vises. I'm not so worried about your vises, however I don't think anyone should have less than two hobbies.   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋
    • Mmindy
      Congratulations @LoreleiI hope it works out for you.   Hugs,   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋
    • KathyLauren
      We were not allowed to use calculators in high school.  Even if we could afford one, $80 (in 1970 dollars!) would only get you a four-function calculator, so it would have been pointless anyway.  Everything was slide rules and longhand.  Being a math nerd, that was no hardship for me.   When my brothers and I were cleaning out my father's house after he passed, I found a couple of slide rules in his wife's desk.  I appropriated them and still have them, my own having been foolishly tossed years ago.  
    • Carolyn Marie
      That is lovely, Charlize.  Thanks so much for sharing your thoughts, and congrats on your "anniversary."  It's always been the little things that make me happiest about being a woman outwardly, and I'm glad that it's the same for you.  Getting older can sometimes be unpleasant and difficult, but we who transitioned later in life can appreciate the changes transition has brought us, as much as, or perhaps more than, someone who transitioned young.    HUGS   Carolyn Marie
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...