Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Coming Out To My Church????


Guest PatrickLee

Recommended Posts

Guest PatrickLee

I have, very recently accepted God and His everlasting love into my life. The youth minister at the church I attend is a kind and caring man. He was there for me and gave me his thoughts on some of the things I was doing in my life and told me how much better life can be if I only prayed and asked for it. It is because of his exelent advice that I now love God and appricate all the blessings He has given me, including my being a transsexual.

One of the only issues with me coming out to every one (not just my closest friends) is that most of the people I know are VERY religious and take their beliefs to the extreme. I do not want to lose the support that I have been granted just because I wish to have the body of a man. I know God has accepted me into his arms and I'm trying very hard to convice one of my friends that I can be loved by God and be a transman. I don't know if I really want to come out to my youth minister but I feel as though I have to. He has put alot into me and helped me on my journey into accepting and loving myself in ways that he doesn't know about. I want to thank him for everything. That means I have to tell him everything.

Is there anything I can say that might make this go a bit easier? Or is there a scripture that could help? I'm pretty lost on what to say to him... I plan on telling him on Wendsday or next Sunday.

Any and all advice would be greatly appricated

Thank you.

Patrick

Link to comment

This is one of the hardest decisions that you will have to make.

Most churches tend to be so conservative that they will have difficulty in even trying to understand.

If you feel that you must tell your youth minister right away, please do approach him with the positive aproach and tell him how much he has helped you already and ask him not to discuss this with anyone else until you are ready.

Good luck,

Sally

Link to comment
Guest PatrickLee

Thanks for the advice.

I want to do this as soon as possible so I can 1)get it over with and 2)continue on with trying to tell my family...

hope it all goes well

Link to comment
Guest michelle.butterfly

Hi Patrick,

I would say it depends on the denomination of your church and whether you are ready/willing/able to be an advocate for the transgendered within your congregation. It's possible that you will be accepted with open arms and love as one might hope, or it's possible you will face an uphill battle for acceptance. On the one hand, yours would be a very powerful testimony, on the other hand it can be a big blow to your faith if you find those in the church to be other than as you would expect.

If your youth minister was an important part of you accepting God into your life then I can understand why you would want him to know who you are, and I will pray that you find the love that Jesus taught in him and your church. However if for some reason you do not, please do not find it a reason to abandon your new-found faith as there are other denominations and other churches in which you may be able to find the communion with others that you are looking for.

Just for a little bit of background on where I am coming from, I was raised Southern Baptist, however over time I have come to find myself in much closer affinity to the United Church of Christ. UCC churches are free to choose their own particular doctrines, but in July of 2003 the national delegate body of the UCC (a Synod) adopted a resolution encouraging the acceptance and inclusion of the transgendered into the church, which, when I found out about it not too long ago, simply reaffirmed my belief that it is a very close match for me.

http://www.ucc.org/assets/pdfs/2003-AFFIRM...UMAN-RIGHTS.pdf

"...THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT all congregations of the United Church of Christ are encouraged to welcome transgender people into membership, ministry, and full participation; and

"BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT all settings of the United Church of Christ are encouraged to learn about the realities of transgender experience and expression, including the gifts and callings and needs of transgender people, and are encouraged to engage in appropriate dialogue with transgender people; ..."

With much love,

Michelle

Link to comment
Guest PatrickLee

Its a 1st Baptist church. I know the preacher personally and know his veiws on the GLBT communitee. They don't agree with my views in the least.

Thanks for the link. I'd print it off but I dont have a printer... Although its kind of sad that there had to be a bill that passed in order for this to come to be. On the other hand, it shows that there are people fighting for this.

I am ready to be an advocate, whether or not people are ready for me is the question.

I have been fought against, pushed around, thrown down, called hurtfull things all my life. (even though 18 yrs is a short time...) I can and will be able to fight for the things I believe in. I really hope it doesnt come down to me fighting the church...

I know God is on my side. I will let His love shine thru me and hopefuly someone else can see it.

Thank you for your support on this... I have already been... not kicked out... but its difficult to go back to my old church because I came out as bisexual. I gave up in that fight. I wont give up now until I have made my views clear and they have made their decission, what ever it may be.

Thanks again.

~Patrick

Link to comment
Guest ~Brenda~

Dear PatrickLee,

This message is for you and all others that I hear a recurring theme about the angst of "coming out". Don't concsciously be concerned about coming out. Be who you are and "coming out" will take care of itself. I know this probably seems meaningless to you, but it is so important and true. If you continue to be who you are, you will find that one day everyone knows who you truely are and the cat is out of the bag. Without conscious effort, you will have come out to everyone one day. Just be yourself!!!

Love

bernie

Link to comment
Guest michelle.butterfly
Its a 1st Baptist church. I know the preacher personally and know his veiws on the GLBT communitee. They don't agree with my views in the least.

Then it sounds like you know what you are getting into. :)

Thanks for the link. I'd print it off but I dont have a printer... Although its kind of sad that there had to be a bill that passed in order for this to come to be. On the other hand, it shows that there are people fighting for this.

You're welcome. Actually, the UCC has for a long time been one of the most inclusive Christian churches, and it's likely that most individual member churches were already quite accepting prior to this, it is just an explicit addition to their already very inclusive "Open and Affirming" recommendations. And, really, even prior to that it's likely that most individual member churches were already quite accepting of the LGBT community.

I am ready to be an advocate, whether or not people are ready for me is the question.

...I can and will be able to fight for the things I believe in. I really hope it doesnt come down to me fighting the church...

That's awesome, and you know we will be here to support you and bring you cookies and cocoa (ok, well I'm to lazy to make cookies and cocoa but I bet I can convince Sally to... HEY SALLY!).

I know God is on my side. I will let His love shine thru me and hopefuly someone else can see it.

You got it, hon. Let your light shine. I know I try, although I have not chosen to do it at a church. :)

Much love,

Michelle

Link to comment
Guest michelle.butterfly
This message is for you and all others that I hear a recurring theme about the angst of "coming out". Don't concsciously be concerned about coming out. Be who you are and "coming out" will take care of itself. I know this probably seems meaningless to you, but it is so important and true. If you continue to be who you are, you will find that one day everyone knows who you truely are and the cat is out of the bag. Without conscious effort, you will have come out to everyone one day. Just be yourself!!!

Yeah Bernie, y'know, you are very wise. :)

As a whole you are absolutely right, and I think there are a lot of people that need to hear that! Although I do understand there is sometimes an internal desire or external need to 'come out' to particular people (for me it was mostly people that I wanted to hear it from me instead of someone else, and I did have to explicitly 'come out' at my job since I wanted them to start using my name because they were sending out proposals with my old name on them.) :D

But your point is well-taken; we've been talking about this more and more lately and it's actually something I think I'm about to post a topic on--the division I see between those of us that feel there are some rules that should to be followed if you are TS (less so if referring to non-TS TG) versus those of us who believe it is all about being yourself, without worrying so much about the "rules'.

With love,

Michelle

Link to comment
Guest ~Brenda~

Dearest Michelle,

You have a very good point about explicitly coming out to a certain person under your own terms. I have done the same thing. For me, it was my ex-wife. I had to tell her directly. All I can say is this... explicitly or indireclty, coming out must be natural, not forced. When I came out to my ex-wife, the time was so clear that it was time to come out, there was no real choice!!

thank you so much for your thoughts and love.

I so respect you!!

bernie

Link to comment
Guest PatrickLee
This message is for you and all others that I hear a recurring theme about the angst of "coming out". Don't concsciously be concerned about coming out. Be who you are and "coming out" will take care of itself. I know this probably seems meaningless to you, but it is so important and true. If you continue to be who you are, you will find that one day everyone knows who you truely are and the cat is out of the bag. Without conscious effort, you will have come out to everyone one day. Just be yourself!!!

Its not meaningless, trust me. Its great advice. One that I will try to live by.

You're right, of cource. I should just be who I am and not worry about the actual 'coming out'. If they will see me for who I am, thats great. If they don't and there is a need to directly 'come out' I'll do it.

Thanks and chocolate chip cookie dough to all who gave me advice! (its wat Im eating right now...)

It will all be taken to heart and used at some point and time, I'm sure! :D

Thanks again,

Patri

Link to comment
Guest Elizabeth K

Patrick

I am against the grain on this one. You will not be understood, regardless of whom you come out to, in the grocery store, in a prayer meeting, in a restaurant. Only transgendered understand the transgendered. Just be prepared. Many people, good intentioned and otherwise, interpret GOD's Will as they see fit.

I am much older. I will NEVER witness my transitioning with a church memeber, preacher, priest, youth minister or otherwise. This is because it is too much of a temptation for people to use scripture - such as a man shall not put on the vestments of a woman... etc. TOTALLY out of context.

Actually there is NOTHING in the Bible regarding the accident of being born in a body that is not a reflection of a person's sense of self. I have studied the Bible for years, but for understanding, not verses to quote. There is nothing about 'gender reassignment." But people will intreret there is PLENTY in the Bible, and call us homosexual and an abomination in the eyes of GOD.

I answer any criticism, and had it from my own wife, who asked why I would shun GOD's gift of my body?

Well... I had a specialized situation in I ASKED for resolution - to gender dysphotia, not my transsexuality, which I was unaware at the time. I was definately and miraculously led to this resolution. I won't witness, but I could as it came to pass under supernatural conditions, an intercession from the Blessed Mother. It is as clear as it can be, I am delivered to my transitioning by GOD's Will. Anyone who debates this is insulting GOD's Will, not me.

Please let us know how it works out if you decide to continue. And I wish you the best, hopefully with a compassionate Christian response.

End of story - that's all I have to say on that (Forrest Gump).

Lizzy

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   6 Members, 0 Anonymous, 74 Guests (See full list)

    • Vidanjali
    • Ivy
    • Abigail Genevieve
    • Ashley0616
    • Astrid
    • Jet McCartney
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.6k
    • Total Posts
      768.2k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,022
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Asher the Enby Goddex
    Newest Member
    Asher the Enby Goddex
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Bebhar
      Bebhar
      (41 years old)
    2. caelensmom
      caelensmom
      (40 years old)
    3. Jani
      Jani
      (70 years old)
    4. Jessicapitts
      Jessicapitts
      (37 years old)
    5. klb046
      klb046
      (30 years old)
  • Posts

    • Abigail Genevieve
      Men's t shirt, women's jeans, hipster panties, flip-flops that could go either way.
    • Abigail Genevieve
      Common sense seems to be missing from a lot of these discussions.  In my Taylor story he is jumped brutally in a boys' bathroom his freshman year, something he is still trying to straighten out 8 years later and has a radical effect on his life.  Bullying can go either way. Transwomen in the prison system are happy to go to women's prisons, but I have heard that transmen stay in the womens' prison, because they would be killed in the mens' prison.   I am leery of blanket "every kid should...." statements and laws everywhere.  To echo a writer you may never heard of, Preston Sprinkle, you should work these things out with the child, and if necessary, with the parents, and communicate.  I don't think a child capable of penetration should sleep with girls on an overnight, or be in a girls' locker room.  Trans kids have limitations as a result of their condition, sort of like people in wheelchairs cannot go mountain climbing, but here is the social realm. Accommodate as you can, but there are limits.  The cisgender kids have rights.  I am not sure where to draw the line as to whose rights should win out.  Nor am I sure regulation imposed by a Legislature or a school board is the way to go.  We saw Louden.    I see no reason for an mtf who transitioned before puberty to not play girl sports, but a child who goes through male puberty has enormous physical advantages over the girls, and we are seeing girls injured.
    • Abigail Genevieve
      Years passed.  The kids grew up and they were empty-nesters.  Lois went full-time at her company.   "We have a Halloween party every year."  He had heard of that.    "You've upheld your end of our bargain for so very long.  How about - do you have something appropriate to wear in the female line?"   Did he.  She was dressed like a penguin, but he wore a women's skirted suit, dark hose, one-inch heels, gold jewelry, well-done makeup and a wig.   "I would not recognize you.  What's this?"   "Padding."    "If I didn't know better I would think you were just a rather tall businesswoman.  No one at the party knows you, no one is expecting a man in drag.  How about your voice and walk?"   He had obviously been practicing them.   The party was a blast.  Odie was happier than she had ever seen him, freer somehow, reveling in being feminine. Lois liked "her" as a charming friend.   "That was fun," he said, driving home.   "It is hard now to think you are a man," she said, and looked at him.   "To tell you the truth I had such a wonderful time I never want to wear men's clothing again. I will, because I must."   "I mean, you are convincing as a woman.  More than you are as a man."   "I think we need to get some professional help."   And they did.  Lois was determined to walk through this, as was Odie, and when he learned she was not walking out but working through, he was overjoyed.    
    • Ivy
      I am aware of this.  It seems a little unnecessary considering that most of us do this at home every day of our lives.  But okay.  It does seem a bit harsh to require the trans kids to go outside and find a bush to poop under.  Stalls with a little more actual privacy might help.  But the real problem is trans people's existence.  Not to worry, the GOP is working o that one. I don't think this would be as much a problem if the transphobes didn't harp on it so much.  There are already laws about stalking and assault. Perhaps, if as a society we were more open about our bodies we could get past this.  Not that this is likely to happen tho.   Yeah.  That's the problem with these laws.  Kids - especially teens, need some privacy of their own to grow up into who they are.  I can see where a kid might experiment with pronouns for a couple of months, and then decide it's not for them.  Pity for them to get beat up in the meantime.   I (thankfully) didn't know everything my kids got into.  And I know my parents didn't know everything about me.   We can give our guidance, but ultimately they need to figure it out on their own.
    • VickySGV
      Parenting and Parental Control play a significant role in my backstory including my addiction history both as child and parent of 3 children now in their 40's.  Big take away that keeps proving true even with new friends and with one of my children as the parent of 3 teenage children is a statement made by one of my parenting counselors and confirmed in other places --   Parents, NEVER do the best they CAN or could do, they will however do the best they KNOW HOW to do.    Getting hit with that statement and some other things did lead me to see that I needed to learn my job better as a parent, which I went ahead and did, and have since made major changes.  It made me very aware that my parents had both had very strange and ineffective parenting skills taught to them which I mistakenly was carrying on with my three children.  My children's  other parent who removed themself due to other personal problems was no better due to their background of parenting either.  I am happy to say that my grandchildren benefited from their parents making intentional efforts to be sure that bad family practices were changed and updated.  Result is that one Gender Questioning and two decidedly Cis  grandchildren have supportive parents where bathroom and sports discomfort is based on actual threats of real physical harm or on invasion of personal boundaries.  Possession of a particular anatomy is a neutral subject there.
    • Abigail Genevieve
      He pushed it out.   Years passed.  Graduation, engagement to Lois.  He was 5'10", she was 5'3".  People thought the height difference was amusing.  At one point he thought to himself I will never fit in her clothes.  Bewildered as to where the thought had come from, he suppressed it. Marriage.   Wedding night: sitting, waiting in anticipation of what was to come.  Lois had left her dress on the bed and was in the hotel bathroom.   He drew in a breath and touched it.  Lacy, exquisitely feminine.  He stroked it.  Incredible.  A whole different world, a different gender, enticing.  "Like it?" she said, as she came out.  He nodded.  But she was meaning her negligee.   Later she noticed a small tear in her wedding dress and wondered where it came from.   Over the years there were dresses that had not been hung up properly in her closet, as if they had been taken down and hung up incorrectly.  It made no sense. Her underwear drawer had been gone through.  She checked the locked windows. They had a landlord at that time.  Pervert, coming into apartments and doing this.  She felt violated.   Then they bought a house.  They had two kids.  Her underwear drawer was being regularly gone through. Not Odie. It could not be Odie.  Odie was as macho as they come, something she liked.  It could not possibly be Odie. Finally there was a slip with a broken strap.   "Odie, I found the strap on my black slip torn.  How could that have happened?'   He didn't know.  He looked guilty, but he didn't know.   The rifling stopped for a while, then started up again.  She read up on cross-dressing.    "Odie, I love you," she said, "I've been reading up on cross-dressing."   He had that deer-in-the headlights look.   "I've read it is harmless, engaged in by heterosexual men, and is nothing to be ashamed of."   He looked at her. No expression.   "Look, I am even willing to buy you stuff in your size.  A friend of mine saw you sneaking around the women's clothing department at Macy's, then you bought something and rushed out.  No more of that, okay? The deal is that you don't do it in front of me or the kids. Do we have a deal?"   They had a deal.  Lois thought it was resolved, and her stuff was no longer touched. Every now and again a package arrived for "Odi", deliberately misspelling his name, and she never opened those.  Sometimes they went and bought things, but he never tried them on in front of her.   "The urge just builds until I have to, Lois.  I am sorry. It's like I can't control it." "That's what I read.  But your Dad would kill you." "There is that."   Lois thought the deal would last.  Things were under control.  
    • Davie
      Lama Rod describes himself as a Black Buddhist Southern Queen. He wants to free you from suffering. Lama Rod Owens is seen as an influential voice in a new generation of Buddhist teachers. He blends his training in the Kagyu School of Tibetan Buddhism with experiences from his life as a Black, queer man, raised as a Christian in the South.   https://apnews.com/article/buddhist-lama-black-lgbtq-wellness-506b1e85687d956eff81f7f4261f5e98  
    • MaeBe
      I would have balked years ago, echoing the parenting of generations before me, exclaiming "Parents know best!" at what I just wrote. It hasn't been that long, but I came to a realization that some of that need for control is unwarranted. Is my child really harming anything by identifying a certain way? Are they being harmed by having others in and around their lives that do? I have been more conversational with my kids when it comes to things and when we run into issues. Like when friends that were toxic, start coming back into the fold, I wanted to make sure that bad behaviors aren't (re)occurring. Or when we notice behaviors that concern us that we have a dialogue. Those chats aren't always nice, clean, or resolved perfectly, but we're communicating. We're learning from each other in those moments, which lead to things being shared that I am sure other parents aren't hearing from their kids and we grow as people because of it.   I will say, it's been easier over the past few years (even before hormones) as this more feminine me finds its way out. I'm a lighter touch, I don't get as entrenched as I once did, and I feel connected a little more emotionally. But, of course, I still make mistakes. As long as we learn from them, right?
    • missyjo
      1. attended Keystone conference a celebration of genders with 700 other lgbt friends. it was wonderful, other lgbt folks, hotel staff n town all welcoming n that felt great.   2. part time job in ladies clothing store, bring missy n helping women dress n relating to them as one    3. folks here   4. creepy guys trying to hit on me..laughs..wrong audience but something must be right   your turn friends
    • missyjo
      orange cotton top n sashed jeans..wedges off now..torrid undies in light blue bra n lace panties   I'm trying minimum makeup..shrugs..well see hugs if you want them
    • Abigail Genevieve
      It was hot that August day, even in Hall J.  Hall J was a freshman dormitory, and Odie had just unpacked his stuff.  He sat on the edge of his bed.  He had made it. He was here, five hundred miles away from home.  His two roommates had not arrived, and he knew no one. His whole life lay ahead of him, and he thought of the coming semester with excitement and dread.   No one knew him.  No one. Suddenly he was seized with a desire to live out the rest of his life as a woman.  With that, he realized that he had felt that way for a long time.  He had never laughed when guys made jokes about women, and often he felt shut out of certain conversations.  He was neither effeminate nor athletic, and he had graduated just fine, neither too high in his class to be considered a nerd or low enough to not get into this college, which was more selective than many. He was a regular guy.  He had dated some, he liked girls and they liked him.  He had friends, neither fewer than most nor more than most.   Drama club in high school: he had so wanted to try out for female parts but something held him back.  He remembered things from earlier in his life: this had been there, although he had suppressed it. Mom had caught him carrying his sister's clothes to his room when he was eight, shortly before the divorce, and he got thoroughly scolded.  They also made sure it never, ever happened again. He had always felt like that had contributed somehow to the divorce, but it was not discussed, either.  He was a boy and that was the end of it.   Dad was part of that.  He got Odie every other weekend from the time of the divorce and they went hunting, fishing, boating, doing manly things because Dad thought he should be a man's man. The first thing that always happened was the buzz cut.  Dad was always somewhat disappointed in Odie, it seemed, but never said why.  He was a hard man and he had contempt for sissies, although that was never directed at Odie. Mom always said she loved him no matter what, but never explained what that meant.   Odie looked through the Freshman Orientation Packed.  Campus map.  Letter from the Chancellor welcoming him.  Same from the Dean.  List of resources: health center, suicide prevention, and his heart skipped a beat: transgender support.  There was something like that here?   He tore off a small piece of paper.  With sweating hands he wrote on it "I need to be a girl." He looked at it, tore it up and put the different pieces in different trash cans, even one in a men's room toilet the men on this floor shared. He flushed it and made sure it went down.  No one had seen him; he was about the first to arrive.   He returned to his room.   He looked in the mirror.  He was five-ten, square jawed, crew cut.  Dad had seen to it that he exercised and he had muscles.  No, he said to himself, not possible. Not likely.  He had to study and he had succeeded so far by pushing this sort of thing into the back of his mind or wherever it came from.   A man was looking back at him, the hard, tough man Dad had formed him to be, and there was absolutely nothing feminine about any of it.  With that, Odie rejected all this stuff about being trans.  There had been a few of those in high school, and he had always steered clear of them.  A few minutes later he met his roommates.
    • EasyE
      yes, i agree with this ... i guess my biggest frustrations with all this are: 1) our country's insistence to legislate everything with regards to morals ... 2) the inability to have a good, thorough, honest conversation which wrestles with the nuances of these very complex issues without it denigrating to name-calling or identity politics.  agreed again... i still have a lot to learn myself ... 
    • Abigail Genevieve
      It's been bugging me that the sneakers I have been wearing are 1) men's and 2) I need canvas, because summer is coming.  WM has a blue tax on shoes, don't you know? My protocol is to go when there is no one in the ladies' area because I get looks that I don't like, and have been approached with a 'can I help you sir' in a tone than means I need to explain myself, at which point i become inarticulate.   But I found these canvas shoes.  Looking at them, to see if they would pass as male, I realized they might not, and furthermore, I don't really care.
    • Abigail Genevieve
      My wife's nurse was just here.  It is a whole lot easier to relate to her as another woman than to negotiate m/f dynamics and feel like I have to watch myself as a male around her.  It dropped a lot of the tension off, tension that I thought entirely internal to myself, but it made interactions a whole lot better.     I read your post, so I thought I would go look.   In the mirror I did not see a woman; instead I saw all these male features.  In the past that has been enough for me to flip and say 'this is all stupid ridiculous why do I do this I am never going to do this again I am going to the basement RIGHT NOW to get men's stuff and I feel like purging'.  Instead I smiled, shrugged my shoulders and came back here.  Panties fit, women's jeans fit.  My T shirt says DAD on it, something I do not want to give up, but a woman might crazily steal hubby's t-shirt and wear it.  I steal my own clothes all the time.    But she is here, this woman I liked it when I saw her yesterday. and her day will come.  I hope to see her again.
    • April Marie
      So many things become easier when you finally turn that corner and see "you" in the mirror. Shedding the guilt, the fear, the questioning becomes possible - as does self-love - when that person looking back at you, irrespective of what you're wearing, is the real you.   I am so happy for you!! Enjoy the journey and where it leads you.
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...