Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

How Do I Know If I'm Faking?


NathanThePlatypus

Recommended Posts

While researching the topic of transition, I came across mention of 'transtrenders' and I've been told by my sister that when you read/watch a lot about something you can make yourself feel something that isn't real. This made me scared that I somehow made myself think I was transgender to be like the people I was watching.

How do I know if I'm just making this up? The reasons I'd say I'm not are that I've felt uncomfortable my whole life, and it got much worse around puberty when I began to hate looking in mirrors and leaving the house, and the sound of my voice. I've always hated attention and sympathy, and the idea of standing out, so I wouldn't say I'm inventing it for attention. I also wouldn't really want everyone I met to know I was transgender if I transitioned - I just want to be seen as male (a common thing I saw related to the idea of 'transtrenders' was people who always introduced themselves as transgender to sound 'cool'). Also, now that I have been thinking about being transgender I cringe (sometimes physically) when people call me 'she' or 'miss' or 'young lady' and it made me grin like an idiot when a waitress called me 'sir' the other night at a restaurant - but that's only started since I began thinking about it. I'm also insanely jealous of a lot of cis men, which has always been the case but I used to just think I was jealous of their fame/looks/intelligence until I realised I wasn't jealous of women in the same position. The main thing for me is that I don't really have bottom disphoria per se - I don't hate what I have, I'd just much rather have male parts. As for top disphoria I used to have it worse before I started thinking I was trans but I feel like I almost got used to it and now my only real issue is that it means people immediately see me as female. I still hate the sound of my voice, and I always have, and I've always tried to make it sound lower. And the main thing I get disphoria with is my lips and height - but men can have thick lips and be short, and transition wouldn't change either of those things! 

I'm very confused at the moment and could really use advice. Did anyone else have the same thoughts when just figuring themselves out? How do I know if I'm just delusional/ fooling myself?!?!

Link to comment
  • Root Admin

Unless your sister is a trained gender therapist, I would doubt very much that what she told you is true. A qualified gender therapist could lead you on the path to finding out whether you are transgender or not.

MaryEllen

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

My suggestion is not to worry. If you are heading toward transition then it is essential and required to have professional advice anyway.

Mentally it is possible for a suggestion to become an obsession but it is in very few people that it becomes a problem. We naturally question ourselves as it is natural to think and work our way through life.

Personally I am very similar as I am not as concerned as many about my body but am far more mentally aligned as a woman. That said, I do think about it at times. In fact the very things you are worried about. I do wonder where things will end up but I don't worry too much. By and large people accept me for who I am and I am confident enough to live and dress as I feel. I regard myself as androgyne or non binary. I will admit that compared with many here I am not fully transexual. It worries me not, but I do think about how I am viewed by others. My view for myself is to live as a women with what I have got, knowing that there is no such thing as the ideal woman. As with any woman I work with what I have. I just have more issues than other women.

No - Don't get into mind games! Accept yourself for who you are and move on. Whatever the situation, you are who you are. If you are worried then approach your GP for referral to gender therapist. You are not the only person here to worry about this issue, and there will be more than the two of us!

Tracy

Link to comment
Guest Laura Beth

At first I thought I had a split personality but after talking about it with my counselor that I had been seeing for a few years prior she said that I didn't. I had looked up the signs and everything to the point that I even felt like I had two people living within me. After talking about it with my counselor I came to the realization it was the repression of who I real was that was trying so hard to surface and break free. Since that time I have been living the life I was more meant to live to the point that my spouse can't wait for me to start hormones.  I feared that ones would think that I was transitioning to follow a trend because of all the ones coming out trans at the time but my spouse said to not worry about what others thought about my decisions because I needed to live my life and be happy.

Laura Beth

Link to comment

Woah! I could almost have written this! I'm new to all this too and feel the same as you in so many aspects!  :/

I've been reading stuff on transgender topics and get concerned I'm just convincing myself into it. So you're definitely not alone in that. The thing with pronouns is the same for me too, it sometimes bothers me when I get called "she" "daughter" "girl" etc. but I never noticed it before looking into this stuff (or at least don't remember noticing it). Ugh, and that not liking attention but also feeling you could still just be convincing yourself. D:

As everyone always suggests, gender therapy may help find some clarity but that's all the advice I really have. Also, really try to listen to what you want, don't try to force yourself to align to a certain label which you think is "you" (I sometimes find myself wearing stuff I dont feel like wearing that day just coz it's more masculine and I feel like I "should" be wearing it if I'm not just making this up in my head- don't do this). 

So, as far as I know, there is no obvious way to tell if it's real or if you're just convincing yourself but I can empathise with your feelings. :) ... and if you find any clarity on this I'd be interested to know ;) 

Link to comment

Thanks for the replies :) I can't go into school today because of disphoria so I kind of feel like it's a real problem but I don't know what to do. The worst thing is my attendance is already -crap- and I'm afraid that they'll contact my parents and I'll have to tell them why I've been skipping so much. I could still go in but I'd be half an hour late... I also feel like I can't wear any of my clothes because I only own one men's jumper... the rest of my clothes are all jumpers and jeans but they're tight fitting and it makes me feel so self conscious I just ugh...

 

(also - is your profile picture Gray from Fair Tail? I love that show :) )

Link to comment

My gender dysphoria got worse as I started my journey, that isn't uncommon either. We repress who we are to fit in because we don't have answers and we feel the pressure to be like everyone else. So we learn to ignore things and just move on with our lives.

When I first went out fully presenting as female and was properly addressed as  female is when it started for me. All of a sudden, when I was back in my "man-suite", my dysphoria started getting really bad. It's been difficult to continue going through my life ever since, that was one reason for my deciding to transition. With therapy I've been able to mitigate things so that I can get through the day, and slowly, things are getting better for me!

Don't discount your feelings! Explore who you are and become that person! It can happen! Have faith!

Link to comment
2 hours ago, NathanThePlatypus said:

(also - is your profile picture Gray from Fair Tail? I love that show :) )

I'm a fan. I totallly ship Juliet and Gray. I am sure there is fanfic for it....I so want to see Lucy and Natsu to kiss-though her shielding herself with Happy was funny in the last episode I saw. I am in the middle of season 2 right now. :)

Back on topic, I would also ignore others peoples feelings in this in understanding yourself. How family friends and others react is based on their fear of  loosing the person they know for someone they don't.  I think their opinions are based on this. There is also the stigma some people fear and that factors in as well-especially true for family members. 

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

Hi Nathan,

As far as "faking it" is concerned, early on I wondered the same thing. My questions were pretty well answered by looking at my past. Which came first, feeling like I should be a girl, or studying up on transgender. I felt like I should be a girl since I was a kid, years before I even knew what trans was. That's how I found I wasn't just trying to fit into a group or click.

You mentioned feeling that you're supposed to be a boy long before reading up on transgender. Just because we don't perfectly fit a stereotypical mold doesn't mean we're faking it or deluding ourselves. We are all individual. Each one of us has our own life story. This is something that a GT could help you sort out. 

 

It doesn't sound to me like you have too much to worry about as far as being genuine or not. You sound genuine to me. Just be patient, the answers will come.

 

Lots of love,

Timber Wolf?

Link to comment

Thank you Timber Wolf, hopefully the GT will happen sooner rather than later because I'm driving myself insane here.

Link to comment
19 hours ago, NathanThePlatypus said:

(also - is your profile picture Gray from Fair Tail? I love that show :) )

Lol yes ;) ..though I have to admit I havent actually watched/read Fairy Tail (but Gray looks like a cool guy ;) ). Would you recommend it?

Go shopping (if possible)! :D Getting clothes you like and feel comfortable in is pretty great. 

Did you end up getting to school? Attendance can be a pain. :(  but you can always make up a reason for skipping (potentially even a reason which leads to therapy if you want some.) ;) 

Link to comment
5 hours ago, DrumbeatAlex said:

Lol yes ;) ..though I have to admit I havent actually watched/read Fairy Tail (but Gray looks like a cool guy ;) ). Would you recommend it? 

I would so recommend it :) it's on Netflix I think and probably cunchy roll 

Link to comment

I would too, it is also on hulu. Yes he is a "cool" guy, He's an ice wizard! :D

I am watching it on crunchy roll.

Link to comment
On 3/7/2017 at 5:29 AM, NathanThePlatypus said:

While researching the topic of transition, I came across mention of 'transtrenders' and I've been told by my sister that when you read/watch a lot about something you can make yourself feel something that isn't real. This made me scared that I somehow made myself think I was transgender to be like the people I was watching.

How do I know if I'm just making this up? The reasons I'd say I'm not are that I've felt uncomfortable my whole life, and it got much worse around puberty when I began to hate looking in mirrors and leaving the house, and the sound of my voice. I've always hated attention and sympathy, and the idea of standing out, so I wouldn't say I'm inventing it for attention. I also wouldn't really want everyone I met to know I was transgender if I transitioned - I just want to be seen as male (a common thing I saw related to the idea of 'transtrenders' was people who always introduced themselves as transgender to sound 'cool'). Also, now that I have been thinking about being transgender I cringe (sometimes physically) when people call me 'she' or 'miss' or 'young lady' and it made me grin like an idiot when a waitress called me 'sir' the other night at a restaurant - but that's only started since I began thinking about it. I'm also insanely jealous of a lot of cis men, which has always been the case but I used to just think I was jealous of their fame/looks/intelligence until I realised I wasn't jealous of women in the same position. The main thing for me is that I don't really have bottom disphoria per se - I don't hate what I have, I'd just much rather have male parts. As for top disphoria I used to have it worse before I started thinking I was trans but I feel like I almost got used to it and now my only real issue is that it means people immediately see me as female. I still hate the sound of my voice, and I always have, and I've always tried to make it sound lower. And the main thing I get disphoria with is my lips and height - but men can have thick lips and be short, and transition wouldn't change either of those things! 

I'm very confused at the moment and could really use advice. Did anyone else have the same thoughts when just figuring themselves out? How do I know if I'm just delusional/ fooling myself?!?!

I was a bit concerned about this myself for various reasons. But the fact remains that I have felt like a woman since I told my father when I was 5. And then periodic issues throughout my life. Nope, I don't think I'm kidding myself. Look within.......

Link to comment
  • 3 weeks later...

Hi Nathan.  I used to feel like you do when I was in school.  I used to wear boys' clothes and tape down my breasts with duct tape.  (This was before I had any idea that purpose-made binders existed.)  As for whether you're "faking," I doubt you are.  I suppose it's just possible that there really are "transtrenders" out there, but in general I can't imagine that people would invent gender dysphoria, which is a very miserable way to feel.  I agree with others that a good therapist who specializes in gender issues would be very helpful for you.  They could help support you during a time when you're feeling very confused and vulnerable.  

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 183 Guests (See full list)

    • MaybeRob
    • Petra Jane
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.7k
    • Total Posts
      768.4k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,024
    • Most Online
      8,356

    JamesyGreen
    Newest Member
    JamesyGreen
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Alscully
      Alscully
      (35 years old)
    2. floruisse
      floruisse
      (40 years old)
    3. Jasmine25
      Jasmine25
      (22 years old)
    4. Trev0rK
      Trev0rK
      (26 years old)
  • Posts

    • Willow
      Good morning    Now @Abigail Genevieve and @Mmindy what makes you so certain I didn’t mean it to say bee itch certificate?  lol. Thanks Mindy. I was asleep when you saw this and fixed it, and yes Abigail, as a moderator I could have fixed it myself, or weren’t you pointing out the irony of that?   I use Alexis as my alarm to get up.  And I set the ringer to be two guys telling me to get up.  I was so sound asleep when they started telling me to get up that it scared me and my first thought were I had over slept.  Since I have a difficult time getting to sleep as early as I have to in order to get enough sleep I at least cut back my normal awake time to get ready.  But now I have to do my hair and get going.   enjoyed my coffee and a little time catching up   see you all later, for its hi ho hi ho it’s off to work I go.   Willow
    • EasyE
      Republicans have long committed grave errors by emphasizing their social agenda and moral issues instead of just focusing on the economy, lowering taxes, keeping the public safe, building a strong national defense, promoting business, touting reasonable immigration policies, etc.   The country would thrive economically under Trump's tax and business policies. That's a fact. Another four years of Biden will run this country into the ground financially (including all of our 401Ks and IRAs). But the GOP continues to play right into the Dems' hands by leading with their moral crusades instead of staying the course and trusting their fiscal policies to win the day... 
    • Carolyn Marie
      https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-news/hundreds-athletes-urge-ncaa-not-ban-trans-athletes-womens-sports-rcna149033     Carolyn Marie
    • KymmieL
      Well first day is over and now getting ready for bed soon. Work was OK.   Don't know why but I am feeling down. I am heading to bed. Good Night.   Kymmie
    • Adrianna Danielle
      Boyfriend and I our time at my place.Both admit our sex life is good,got intimate for the 2nd time and he is good at it
    • Abigail Genevieve
      Thanks.  I will look those up in the document, hopefully tomorrow.   I always look at the source on stuff like this, not what someone, particularly those adversarial, have to say. 
    • MaeBe
      LGBTQ rights Project 2025 takes extreme positions against LGBTQ rights, seeking to eliminate federal protections for queer people and pursue research into conversion therapies in order to encourage gender and sexuality conformity. The policy book also lays out plans to criminalize being transgender and prohibit federal programs from supporting queer people through various policies. The project partnered with anti-LGBTQ groups the Family Policy Alliance, the Center for Family and Human Rights, and the Family Research Council. Project 2025 calls for the next secretary of Health and Human Services to “immediately put an end to the department’s foray into woke transgender activism,” which includes removing terms related to gender and sexual identity from “every federal rule, agency regulation, contract, grant, regulation, and piece of legislation that exists.” The Trump administration proposed a similar idea in 2018 that would have resulted in trans people losing protections under anti-discrimination laws. [Project 2025, Mandate for Leadership, 2023; The New Republic, 2/8/24] Similarly, the policy book calls for HHS to stop all research related to gender identity unless the purpose is conformity to one's sex assigned at birth. The New Republic explains: “That is, research on gender-nonconforming children and teenagers should be funded by the government, but only for the purpose of studying what will make them conform, such as denying them gender-affirming care and instead trying to change their identities through ‘counseling,’ which is a form of conversion therapy.” [The New Republic, 2/8/24] The policy book’s foreword by Kevin Roberts describes “the omnipresent propagation of transgender ideology and sexualization of children” as “pornography” that “should be outlawed,” adding, “The people who produce and distribute it should be imprisoned.” Roberts also says that “educators and public librarians who purvey it should be classed as registered sex offenders. And telecommunications and technology firms that facilitate its spread should be shuttered.” [Project 2025, Mandate for Leadership, 2023] Roberts’ foreword states that “allowing parents or physicians to ‘reassign’ the sex of a minor is child abuse and must end.” Echoing ongoing right-wing attacks on trans athletes, Roberts also claims, “Bureaucrats at the Department of Justice force school districts to undermine girls’ sports and parents’ rights to satisfy transgender extremists.” [Project 2025, Mandate for Leadership, 2023; TIME magazine, 5/16/22] Dame Magazine reports that Project 2025 plans to use the Department of Justice to crack down on states that “do not charge LGBTQ people and their allies with crimes under the pretense that they are breaking federal and state laws against exposing minors to pornography.” [Dame Magazine, 8/14/23] Project 2025 also calls for the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services to repeat “its 2016 decision that CMS could not issue a National Coverage Determination (NCD) regarding ‘gender reassignment surgery’ for Medicare beneficiaries.” The policy book’s HHS chapter continues: “In doing so, CMS should acknowledge the growing body of evidence that such interventions are dangerous and acknowledge that there is insufficient scientific evidence to support such coverage in state plans.” [Project 2025, Mandate for Leadership, 2023] Going further, Project 2025 also demands that the next GOP administration “reverse policies that allow transgender individuals to serve in the military.” The policy book’s chapter on the Defense Department claims: “Gender dysphoria is incompatible with the demands of military service, and the use of public monies for transgender surgeries … for servicemembers should be ended.” [Project 2025, Mandate for Leadership, 2023]   …summaries of what’s within the rest of the document re: LGBTQ+ concerns. A person can believe their gender is fixed but incongruent with their physiology, but the authors and Trump (by his own words) just see the incongruity of an “expressed gender” that conflicts with what was/is in a person’s pants.
    • Mmindy
      Good catch… I took care of it.
    • Sally Stone
      I'm tired of the two-party system.  It has degraded to a system where there are only two diametrically opposed views, neither of which supports me.  I have conservative views regarding big government and government spending but I have very liberal views when it comes to protecting the rights of individuals.  And just elections of the past, I am stuck with two choices, neither of which I support. With only two parties, each with agendas that are off the left and right scales, I am not adequately represented.    Finally, I'm okay with party affiliated politicians running for office using their party views, but once elected to office, they are obligated to support the entire electorate not just the electorate members that voted for them.  Plain and simple, our government system is broken and dysfunctional.  I'll step down from my soapbox now.     
    • Sally Stone
      Thanks Mae.  She was an amazing friend and I grew to love her like a sister.
    • Sally Stone
      I did Ashley.  Non-rev travel was one of the major factors for taking the job.  At the time, US Airways had the best non-rev policy in the industry.  It cost $10 to fly coach and $25 to fly first class.  We flew first class whenever there were seats available.  
    • Abigail Genevieve
      You should have a moderator fix what you meant to write as "birth certificate".  Ooops.   I've gone over that verse and am wholly and completely dissatisfied with the SBC exegesis of it, so much so that it was one of the things that helped me break out of a mindset of guit.  Sometime I may strut by stuff as a Hebraist and show what it really means.
    • Abigail Genevieve
      I found this   — 450 — Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise Goal #1: Protecting Life, Conscience, and Bodily Integrity. The Secretary should pursue a robust agenda to protect the fundamental right to life, protect con- science rights, and uphold bodily integrity rooted in biological realities, not ideology. From the moment of conception, every human being possesses inherent dignity and worth, and our humanity does not depend on our age, stage of development, race, or abilities. The Secretary must ensure that all HHS programs and activities are rooted in a deep respect for innocent human life from day one until natural death: Abortion and euthanasia are not health care. A robust respect for the sacred rights of conscience, both at HHS and among gov- ernments and institutions funded by it, increases choices for patients and program beneficiaries and furthers pluralism and tolerance. The Secretary must protect Americans’ civil rights by ensuring that HHS programs and activities follow the letter and spirit of religious freedom and conscience-protection laws. Radical actors inside and outside government are promoting harmful identity politics that replaces biological sex with subjective notions of “gender identity” and bases a person’s worth on his or her race, sex, or other identities. This destructive dogma, under the guise of “equity,” threatens American’s fundamental liberties as well as the health and well-being of children and adults alike. The next Secretary must ensure that HHS programs protect children’s minds and bodies and that HHS programs respect parents’ basic right to direct the upbringing, education, and care of their children.   https://static.project2025.org/2025_MandateForLeadership_CHAPTER-14.pdf   First, that is not much, if that is all that is of concern.  Secondly, I have seen all sorts of anti-Trump slander, including the Steele dossier and the lawfare he is now undergoing, to be cynical of any criticism against him, and indirectly this document.    He deserves some of what he is getting, but not all.  Thirdly, I bolded one statement of concern.   I don't think gender identity is subjective.  "Radical actors" is name calling, and there is a lot of that going around.  Maybe I am not seeing everything of concern or reading this right, but i would discuss with the author of this document concerning this.
    • Willow
      Good evening   well I finally finished reading my textbook.  Yeah.  But I still have a lot more to go for the class.     My endocrinologist always asks me about lactation.  And yes I have had some very small amounts of leakage but not on any regular basis.  I figure I blocked the discharge Duce when I pierced my nipples with scare tissue.  But who knows.  I also get asked about mammograms.  I e had my first or baseline and this fall I will need to schedule my second.   As someone in the midst of studying the Old Testament, I can say that I haven’t found any mention of pending damnation for being transgender or intersex.  The closest it comes is a verse that says men should not wear women’s clothing.  Now I don’t know each and everyone’s particulars, but I know I meet the medical definition of female gender, and even in Ohio, a State that until recently refused to allow birth certificates to be changed, I meet the criteria.  Therefore I can only conclude I am not a man wearing women’s clothing.  But there is a somewhat different scholarly explanation of that law that it should not be taken as literally as the haters want.  Mostly men should not pretend to be women to ex ape from their enemies. Or tried to hide from God.     willow
    • Abigail Genevieve
      Well, the left wing has been doing that.    I read a few things while trying to find out what the problem is and liked what I read.  But I am a conservative.    Is there something specific in there that is of concern?  Does it promise somewhere to erase trans folk? That would be problematic.
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...