Jump to content

Gender nonconforming worries

Recommended Posts




I'm new here, but looking for some advice/feedback about my daughter.  She is now 14.  I just recently stumbled across the term gender-nonconforming, which seems to be a much better descriptor than "my daughter might be transgender, not sure yet." ;-)


I've read a lot of stories from parents who tell how their son (assigned female at birth) told them from very early on that he was really a boy (or vice-versa).  I've also noted the "insistent, consistent, persistent" paradigm.  Needless to say, that ain't my kid.  But I'm also aware of many people that transitioned in college or later.


We live in a really liberal, open, accepting college town, which is great.  And as a parent, I am open and accepting to anything my daughter tells me she is - even if that turns out to be a cisgendered heterosexual.  But parents always gotta worry about something right?  The biggest worry that my wife and I have is that our daughter has always been uncertain, but instead of following her feelings has been guided by how she should behave in order to be accepted by her peers, and that by suppressing her true identity now, she will suffer more as she grows older. 


In other words, I'm happy to wait to find out, as long as the reason for the waiting is not causing harm.  Hard to tell if we've got a gender-fluid child, a cisgender child who was going through an 8 year phase, a transgender child who is suppressing their true identity, or...  Here's the story...


Even from a young age, DD was not into the typical girl things, said she wanted to have a penis (so she could pee standing up), wanted to cut her hair short, hated girl clothes....  But she never said she was a boy.  From about age 6 through elementary school, she shopped exclusively in the boy's department.  She liked to dress up - but in boy's dress clothes.  She wore boys boxer-brief underwear (but, she was deathly afraid that one of her friends would find out).  I told her that boxer briefs (which I wear) were comfortable - and it would be cool and edgy, not necessarily boyish, for a girl to wear them.  Yeah, that didn't make a dent.  Swimwear was trunks and a rash guard shirt.  As she got older, she seemed to feel more different from the girls in her class, but she was never one of the boys.  At 5th grade moving up ceremony, she was the only girl not wearing a dress, and she really didn't like feeling different.  She always kept her hair pulled back in a tight ponytail and when viewed from the front was frequently mistaken for a boy.  She apparently didn't like this.  Around age 8-10 when she asked to get her hair cut short, we said sure, if you want to - whatever makes you feel good.  Just be aware that if you do, you will most likely be assumed to be a boy more often than you are now.  She decided to keep the hair long, and keep it in a pony.  She seemed to be becoming more distanced from her peers and we were worried about her.  Towards the end of 5th grade, we spoke about our concerns with a therapist familiar with transgender kids (without our daughter).  The consensus from that meeting was wait and see.


Then she got to middle school and found her peeps.  She plays ice hockey (on a girl's team) and found some good friends who were more like her.  From outward appearances she seemed to be feeling more comfortable in her own skin.  As boy's pants really just wouldn't fit her anymore, she switched over to wearing sweatpants bought in the girl's department.  She's still not too keen on girl's cut t-shirts, but now in 9th grade her wardrobe has morphed to be much closer to that of a typical teenage girl.  And those factors together seem to make her feel comfortable and accepted.


In terms of wardrobe, she has left boy's clothes behind.  She now wears tight-fitting jeans, which she would have gagged at a few years ago.  In warm weather she wears girl's Nike running shorts, but sometimes tighter-fitting jean shorts (as long as the inseam is not too short).  Shy typically wears unisex-cut t-shirts, but she also wears button-down flannel shirts from time to time (cut for a girl). She wears a girl's cut winter jacket.  She doesn't have a large chest, and probably won't ever, but she always wears the most flattening Nike sports bras.  Footwear is generic sneakers, but now she will wear Birkenstock sandals in warmer weather.


Of course, at the time she went through these changes, she was also going through puberty - so that's another confounding factor. She's 14 now and some of her friends are starting have boyfriends and girlfriends,  but neither my wife nor I have ever been privy to any expression of interest in "dating" or even in whether another person is attractive.  She still seems totally asexual, which I am perfectly happy about :-).  I know that sexual preference is different from gender identity, so even a preference one way or the other wouldn't necessarily say anything about gender.


So I'm not sure what I'm asking.  From outward appearances, she seems to be falling into line with gender norms and she seems to be doing fine.  We just still have these lingering doubts about whether this is really who she is, or whether she is just trying fit in.  If it's not doing future harm, then it's all good.  She does often seem to have difficulty expressing any feelings or closeness with people, particularly her family, and that is a concern for us.  Then again, she is a teenager!


So is this just one reasonably normal path for a child to take growing up, or am I missing something?  We just want our child to be who she (or he) is and be comfortable with that.  Thanks for listening.



Share this post

Link to post

Hi Jeb and welcome.  I'm glad you found a place to ask your questions, nebulous and vague though they appear to be by circumstance.  You don't mention in your post whether you've had a gender conversation with your daughter in recent years.  I'm aware of many girls who, at a young age, expressed a desire to have a penis for the very reason your daughter stated her preference.  And you're right that, even added up, all these signs don't point to transgenderism or a gender non-conforming attitude.


Have you considered sitting down with her and asking what her thoughts and feelings on the matter are now?  I know a lot of parents would hesitate to put their kids on the spot with something so personal, but as open and affirming as you and your wife are, I can see a lot of benefit to having a brief conversation with your daughter about this.  If only just to let her know you'll support her in whatever discoveries she makes about herself and whatever choices she makes to fit in.  The key thing is that you want her to be happy, and from the tone of your post I suspect she already knows this. :) 

Share this post

Link to post

Welcome Jeb.  My grandson has had gender issues from before i came out and transitioned.  He is finding his way.  Long hair and some of his choices remain as a sign that he remains a bit fluid at the least.  I know he has support regardless of where he goes.  Of course hormones and peer pressure will affect his path.  I am trying not to influence his decision.  

The path he is taking simply in not going all out one direction or another would never have been tolerated when i was a child, especially as a young man.  It is wonderful that you are supportive regardless fo the final path your child may follow.  We are simply not in control and that is probably a good thing.





Share this post

Link to post

Hi Jeb


In my opinion:


I think that if she is generally happy and appears contented then not to worry too much. I have come across many cis women who often prefer to dress very male, even in mens clothes. I remember some who dressed in this way in their teens, but I am not aware of any who have since come out as transexual. It may be that your daughter is dressing in accordance with her peers, but, if that were more an act, I would have thought things would show somewhere.


The gender spectrum is very broad, and many people sit somewhere toward the centre where the distinctions between male and female are not set in stone. Just be there for her, as we all are for our children.



Share this post

Link to post

Thank you for the replies.  It is reassuring.  While we haven't had a sit-down, "we're going to spend a significant chunk of time talking about gender, etc. now" conversation with our daughter, we do frequently pose leading questions - and the short answer has always been "I'm a girl."  I accept that answer more now - but one is always second guessing and reading between the lines.  A few years ago, I would have interpreted that as "I don't want to talk about it." :-)


I will sometimes listen to "The Moth" in the car, and there have sometimes been stories involving how parents dealt with their child's transition.  My daughter has always seemed more interested in these sorts of stories, and been indignant that any parent (even an accepting one) wouldn't immediately understand and be able to immediately switch over to treating their child as the gender they identify as.



Share this post

Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Who's Online   6 Members, 0 Anonymous, 6 Guests (See full list)

    • Dev
    • CyndiRae
    • MaryEllen
    • Amber L.
    • Kenna Dixon
    • MarcieMarie12
  • Topics With Zero Replies

  • Posts

    • Dev
      The results are in.  @Cbxshawn, you've won this month with your hot dog shooting phasers!  Would you like to keep your current title (Senior Member) or have it changed to Dec 2017 Winner?
    • MaryEllen
      Hello Alexa,   Welcome to TransPulse.   MaryEllen
    • tracy_j
      I agree with Jani here - It is always easier to get another job when you already have one.   Another thing I have noticed in life is that it always seems the predators notice a weakened individual in the herd and gang up on them. This can easily be seen in animals and really shows in the primeval behaviour of groups at times. Something to realise is that not everyone will be party to this and there will be people at work who won't go with any group behaviour. Also some may use the facillities as a matter of course and not to deliberatly obstruct you. To you it will seem that way as, when depressed, we often think the worst.   I have also noticed a trend in the past in which someone is 'flavour of the month'. ie the current person to be subject to group grief! Usually after getting by this period people's main attention diverts to the next unfortunate individual (more primeval behaviour?).   Following the above, the answer is usually to tough it out and be confident. Think logically and try to supress emotion (I know that is difficult). If you can rise above it you will gain friends and better times will come   Thinking of you   Tracy x  
    • Timber Wolf
      Good morning Everyone!🎅   Happy Birthday megandb!🎂 Happy Birthday MissNexus!🎂 Hope you have a great day!   Lots of love, Timber Wolf🐾
    • Timber Wolf
      Hi Alexa, Welcome to TransPulse. Glad you're here!   Lots of love, Timber Wolf🐾
    • alexastlmo
      Hello hello! Thanks for allowing me to join the site.  My name is Alexa,  at the moment and for a long time now I have consider myself to be just bigender… When I was a young one they called dual gender identity but I guess bigender is more catchy… I am definitely a free spirit I have been through a lot but I have no regrets I wake up every morning and make the most of it. Sure I have bad days but I don’t let it continue forward. I seek now to surround myself with people who are not just open but inspire me to better myself in a multitude of ways. Ask me if you have any questions I never get offended Hakuna Matata
    • Drea
      What are you looking for in "trans friendly".  NJ isn't "trans friendly"?  
    • Jani423
      Hi April,  I started directly with electrolysis since I had a mix of dark and white.  With rosacea you might not be a good candidate for laser since that does heat up the skin quite a bit leaving it with a look of a good sunburn for a number of days.  It is also considered hair reduction as it may not be permanent.  From what I've read the folks who claim it to be permanent are typically younger with less established growth than us seniors.  Electrolysis is no walk in the park since the hair follicle isn't typically completely killed in one zap.  The weakened follicle produces a thinner and finer hair that is eventually killed off after multiple hits.  I have a 100 hours on the table in two years and I'm looking really good.  I've recently accelerated to multiple hours in my weekly sessions.  I didn't have a strong beard to start with so your results will be dependent upon who thick your hair is.   Some people find they need a pain management regimen to get through a session.  Initially I used lidocaine on my upper lip area along with acetaminophen, but I stopped after a few months when I got use to the sensation of each zap.  It's still a mild form of torture but its tolerable since I want it gone so badly.   I don't recall if you're on HRT, but as the T in your system is reduced the pain does seem to go up so start now if you can.   Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but no one promised this would be easy.     Jani   
    • Jani423
      Hi April.  Retirement can be a wonderful time that allows us to do many things we couldn't do or have time for.  I hope your retirement is all you expect of it.  As to relocation, I have considered this for some time.  Now that I'm on E, I find I do not particularly enjoy the cold weather as I once did so I am looking for a warmer climate.  We have a couple years until my wife retires so I have time to research and do some exploratory visits.  I'd like a place with little to no snow, temps > 40 degrees but not beyond the high 90's, good healthcare, a good social environment, in a walkable community.  I have family with homes on the gulf coast of Florida so that may be a consideration.  I've found areas on the West coast that might work although my wife may balk at being too far from the grandkids.   We're also thinking about a condo rather than another single family home.  I am concerned about giving up our great summer weather where we are but I also fear the experience of hurricanes and forest fires found in a number promising locations.  There has to be some great place!  This is a good website to use in your search as they capture a lot of good data points.  https://www.bestplaces.net   Best of luck in your search. Jani   
    • Jani423
      Cindy, I'm glad to hear your cat is doing better.  Thanks for checking in.  As to quitting your job, despite how difficult it is please make sure you have another one before you do.  I don't know how the job market is out there but a new one may not come along quickly.   Best of luck.   Jani
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. megandb
      (35 years old)
    2. MissNexus
      (20 years old)
  • Upcoming Events

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts
  • TransPulse Partners