Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

JBfox

Brain Activity of transgender youth....

Recommended Posts

JBfox

https://www.inverse.com/article/45115-transgender-youth-brain-activity?utm_source=facebook.com&utm_medium=on_site&utm_campaign=mobile_article-top

 

 Have a read. It was too early in the morning to get in arguments with my cis friends over this article, but I thought it'd be good to bring it here for you all to see.

Share your thoughts. Personally I find that the way we currently deal with transgender youth with hormone blockers to be a good solution, and I'm not sure if full HRT is the answer, despite the fact I don't think there's much risk from it as longer as the individual for sure wants to transition. But the doctor talks about lessening GD, and I'm not 100% certain this would help either way. I am more of the leaning that some GD is caused by family, life situations, and by allowing someone to transition it helps relieve it. The only thing I can see here is it may help affirm the individual that they're doing the right thing, and maybe help encourage parents that they are as well.

-Vaelyn

Share this post


Link to post
Ravin

This is interesting. The problems tend to come when people try and apply a binary to differences. For any complex biological trait there is always going to be a range or spectrum, with overlapping bell curves that may have peaks that fall in different places determining what those differences are, not clear-cut either-or situations where every person falls into one or the other of discrete categories.

 

Still, I think in time this could be a tool to help confirm what trans kids already say.

Share this post


Link to post
SugarMagnolia

Yep! Also great to be able to point to evidence that being trans is not a "lifestyle choice". 🙂
 

Share this post


Link to post
MaryMary
22 minutes ago, Ravin said:

This is interesting. The problems tend to come when people try and apply a binary to differences. For any complex biological trait there is always going to be a range or spectrum, with overlapping bell curves that may have peaks that fall in different places determining what those differences are, not clear-cut either-or situations where every person falls into one or the other of discrete categories.

 

Still, I think in time this could be a tool to help confirm what trans kids already say.

 

I can see them developing a diagnostic tool but it will not "detect" all cases because some will fall in overlaps I guess (much like intersex people on a genital level). I also suspect we do not have the full picture yet, I don't think the brain thing explain all the transgender community. My guess is that there's "facets" of this that remain to be discovered / remain to be proven. Maybe, just maybe, not everybody here is transgender for the same reasons / not the same source. The brain is plastic and I suspect there's more to this gender thing then we think, I think the brain might surprise us by how adaptive it can be.

 

I've worked with a neuropsychologist, does it show? Those kind of articles makes my brain go berserk :D

Share this post


Link to post
jo jo

but you could also argue that with transgender the brain is already female in mtf or male in ftm as the complex emotions wanting to be the opposite sex maybe its not the hrt changing the brain maybe its the brain accepting ur decision to correct things if that makes sense

Share this post


Link to post
VickySGV

This is ONE study on a distinct piece of the situation, there are others out there in youth, adolescents, and adults with slightly different angles of observation and the common issue being that those other brain structures which include hormone receptor cell and gene groups all show differences from the procreative organ assignment norm of gender assignment.  Put more simply, gender dysphoria has multiple sources and each person has a unique combination of those sources and some are highly pronounced while others are more subtle, maybe to the point of NOT being dysphoria producing.  Still other studies do show that acceptance by society and family members of the Gender Diversity of the individual reduces stress to a point where our suicide/self harm levels fall below the national average for those behaviors.  (Not by much, but still less.) 

I do read and soak up this stuff and it is fun watching this develop. 

Share this post


Link to post

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Who's Online   15 Members, 0 Anonymous, 62 Guests (See full list)

    • Sally Stone
    • Willa
    • Cyndee
    • Shay
    • Cris31
    • RunValRun
    • QuestioningAmber
    • Liam da potato
    • Rami
    • MiraM
    • Jackie C.
    • Sophie Watson
    • Andrea Jean
    • ElizabethStar
    • Timber Wolf
  • Topics With Zero Replies

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      71,634
    • Total Posts
      651,871
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      7,221
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Newest Member
    Adelaide
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    No users celebrating today
  • Posts

    • Shay
      Gosh - the next song I heard tells it - when others give you negative - give them a flower and smile    
    • Sally Stone
      James,   I have identified as bi-gender for a long time.  Born male I enjoyed being so, but there was also a part of me that was female.  I have embraced both the male and female personas sharing my mind, and it has brought me happiness and contentment.  I have no desire to give up one gender for the other, instead, I express both.     Thank goodness things have changed in recent years, but there used to be this unwritten rule that a person had to choose a gender identity.  That is just ludicrous.  We humans are all different and it is absolutely okay to express the gender or genders of your choice.  I say explore your gender identities and express the one or the many that make you feel happy and complete.
    • Shay
      AUGUST 5 - I was thinking this morningthat each of us have our own journey in life and no one can tell you how you should live it and that we all have our struggles but we must embrace our fears and recognize every roadblock is just a short term issue to address to get to the who that you are.....   Secret 'O Life James Taylor   The secret of life is enjoying the passage of time Any fool can do it There ain't nothing to it Nobody knows how we got to The top of the hill But since we're on our way down We might as well enjoy the ride The secret of love is in opening up your heart It's okay to feel afraid But don't let that stand in your way 'Cause anyone knows that love is the only road And since we're only here for a while Might as well show some style Give us a smile Isn't it a lovely ride? Sliding down Gliding down Try not to try too hard It's just a lovely ride Now the thing about time is that time Isn't really real It's just your point of view How does it feel for you Einstein said he could never understand it all Planets spinning through space The smile upon your face Welcome to the human race Some kind of lovely ride I'll be sliding down I'll be gliding down Try not to try too hard It's just a lovely ride Isn't it a lovely ride? See me sliding down Gliding down Try not to try too hard It's just a lovely ride The secret of life is enjoying the passage of time      
    • Shay
      The most difficult thing I had to do (and that was recently) was to come out to friends and my wife. Once I did that I was finally able to move ahead. I am on HRT now, waiting for a new GT and anxious to becoming the woman I've denied all my life.   In regard to the support groups  if you didn't feel comfortable with them - you will need to find another group. At least you are with a support group here that I'm sure you realize TOTALLY SUPPORT you and are here for you always.    Smile - You've come a long way,   Heather Shay
    • RunValRun
      @QuestioningAmber When I first saw the title I thought it was an invitation to the flame wars Since asking to choose between those is akin to asking whether you should use 2 or 4 spaces for indentation - "the war must go on" and no side has clear reason to win (and yes, the battle over tabs is over, they lost) Then I read your post and sighed with a relief 😉   As I am in the midst of transitioning, I am quite invested to know what the future holds, but I guess my only option is to follow the rest of humanity at one-day-at-a-time pace One good thing about IT field is that unless you are in support or other position involved with users' interactions, you only need to be comfortable with your team. Depending on the size of the company, others either don't need to be made aware before you are ready or they will only meet Amber and would not be burdened with prior knowledge. For what its worth, I am looking forward to be a girl on the team - we are definitely lacking in female presentation 🤭  
    • Shay
      Michellle - there are 3 bass players here that are willing to add bass to any tracks you might have need of recording via dropbox.   Heather Shay
    • Robin
      I made the decision to come out to my brother and to a few of my friends very soon after coming to the realisation that I am trans.  This made me feel better as it was then out in the open and "official", rather than just going round and round in my head.   None of the people that I told had anything negative to say about it.  The only problems that I experienced were when I approached two transgender support groups, where, due to my male appearance, I was seen as an "admirer" and turned away.  That severely knocked my self confidence, just as I thought that I had finally found out what was "wrong" with me, and that my life was going to improve.    Robin.
    • ElizabethStar
      This really sounds like some of the things I struggled with. I was questioning and confused for many, many years. I really just needed more time, experimentation and self reflection to be sure.    
    • Michellle
      I agree, some people’s egos hold the whole band back. Me and my brothers always got along playing and recording together. It’s bass players we had issues with. I think they know they are in demand.
    • MiraM
      Very well said. I transitioned in 2000, and then de-transitioned in 2002.  I was miserable living as a man, and knew I was a woman, but I was just as miserable after transitioning, so I stopped HRT, and all therapy, and went back to living as a male...a depressed, alcoholic, suicidal male.  My mistake is that I thought transitioning was the "magic pill" that was going to solve all my problems.  It wasn't.  They were still there.   In 2016, after being laid off from my job, I went back into therapy.  My intention was not to transition at that time, but to try and work out the issues with my depression and C-PTSD.  About a year into therapy, we started addressing the gender dysphoria again, and I was referred to the man gender therapist at my VA Hospital.   After about 6 months of weekly sessions with her, we both felt that I was at a point where trying HRT again was possible.  I went back on HRT in January of 2018, and the outcome was different.  This time I actually started to feel comfortable with me.  I went full time again in August 2019 and haven't looked back.   I can attest to the fact that some of the people that de-transition have the mindset that I did the first time.  It is very important, mandatory in my opinion, that any and all co-morbid conditions be addressed and brought under control before transitioning.  If not, the outcome is likely to not be a positive one.  I for one am glad that my current medical team would not consider putting me on HRT until I had done so.  I think therapy is important after HRT and going full-time as well.  I still see my gender therapist every two weeks.
    • Timber Wolf
      Hi Holly Noel, Welcome to Transpulse. I'm glad you're here!   Lots of love and a big welcome hug, Timber Wolf 🐾
    • Cris31
      Just want to toss in my support and appreciation JamesM.  QuestioningAmber brings up a good point there that hit me pretty hard.  I'm still trying to figure out myself but it brings some comfort that there's a spectrum and not completely feeling like THIS or THAT all the time or completely is okay
    • Timber Wolf
      Hi Rory, Welcome to Transpulse. I'm glad you're here!   You're not alone anymore.   Lots of love and a big welcome hug, Timber Wolf 🐾
    • RunValRun
      OMG @Sally Stone, absolutely lovely nails. I always had preference for long nails, there is something indescribable and powerful they add to the woman's image.  
    • KayC
      Hi @Maren!  nice to meet you and Welcome! I am also at the very beginning and until I get farther along in therapy I don't want to set any specific plans or timelines for myself (and I am also much, MUCH older than you. lol). But, with that in mind, right now your idea of HRT first would also be my most likely option.  Not just for preference (which for now it is) but my inability to come out in the near future (job and location) and the logistics and availability of HRT for me (in Japan).  I am Out to my wife (only) so far, but she at some point has to be part of my decision and timing process. So, I see your option as very viable (and for me, preferable), but everybody is different and there is no one set way to go about it.  Wishing you all the best❣️   Deep breaths ... one step at a time
  • Upcoming Events

×
×
  • Create New...