Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!


Introductions, Hellos, Messy Personal History Stuff, etc.

Recommended Posts


CW: talk of anorexia, dysmorphia and dysphoria, questioning

So... yeah. Hi and hello.


My name is Andrea (not really, not legally, but perhaps one day). I've been lurking for a while, debating whether or not to stick my foot in this forum's door—if I belong and if there's a place for me here. In other words, probably (like with most things in my life) overthinking, well, everything. But it's time.


I *think* I belong here. I'm pretty sure I do. Like... 95% positive, but still experiencing flashes of doubt—of "why do I feel this way, am I really thinking of potentially blowing up parts of my life to follow this through," and the like. I'm sure many of you know how it is. I hope so, anyway, because being the only one to feel this way would, well, suck.


For reference: I'm a 38-year-old asexual, white, male-bodied writer/editor, and, well, trans. I'm also nonbinary, and while that best describes how I feel and identify on the inside, I -desperately- wish I had a feminine body. As in, it's almost all I think about some days. But I've long struggled with identifying outright as trans for a number of reasons, and I'm curious how many, if any, of you can relate. First, because of the nonbinary angle. I feel, deep in my guts, that were I to transition tomorrow, I would still want to ID as enby. It feels *right* in terms of where my brain and heart are and have always been, but then I wonder: If that's the case, is it enough to simply crave a feminine body to also ID as trans? I've heard the refrain on Twitter, "If you want to just be a girl (or guy) you can be a girl (or guy)," but there's a needling part of my brain that wants to know if the wanting is enough. Because, of course, there are gatekeepers everywhere, especially with respect to levels of dysphoria.


And for the record, I do have some measure of gender dysphoria. It started when I was only five and has popped up here and there, but was never anything extreme or debilitating. The only time in my youth that I had an extreme situation in that respect is when in twelfth grade I succumbed to pretty severe body dysmorphia and anorexia, and damn near killed myself (not via a suicide attempt but from dropping to a dangerously low weight). That was twenty years ago, and only just now have I started to really overcome the eating disorder's stranglehold. How? By starting to look at the body I have as *not* what I want or wish for. Because the things I'm most critical of in a male body, or at least in mine, are some of the things I appreciate most in a feminine body, and find myself even wishing I had. But I don't know if that sort of dysmorphia falls under gender dysphoria as well or if it's something different.


The uncertainty has popped up in other ways, too. I've struggled with adopting trans full-stop because, to be blunt, parts of my body have always felt wrong or alien, but not the whole. Like, I have spent a lifetime wishing for a different lower half, even going so far as to wish something horrible would happen to my genitalia to *force* doctors to have to just, you know, give me the opposite (I know, a silly fantasy, but still), but have never found myself wishing I had breasts beyond how much better they might fill out a dress or offset my wider-than-I'd-like shoulders.


But over the past six months or so, I've started to accept more and more that this is or might be enough—that I am, in fact, maybe, possibly, trans. And every bit of makeup, every bit of non-male-coded clothing I've brought into my life thus far (and yes, I fully know it's so, so much more than just what you put on) has felt just... right. Like, deep-in-the-core-of-me right. I've told a handful of trusted friends and chosen family, most of whom either saw something like this coming from a mile away and claim they were just waiting for the day (apparently I give off a lot of femme energy, which I'm not complaining about at all but is... interesting, when you've never been aware of it yourself), but some who, upon hearing, said they didn't see it coming per se but that it actually brings into focus a lot of disparate aspects of myself and how I move through the world.


And yet.


I still find myself asking: Is it enough? To be even more blunt about it, am I trans enough? Is there such a thing? Have I written far too much and lost most of you by this point? Is it enough to have spent a not-small portion of your childhood and early adulthood imagining how if your life went to hell and you had to leave it all behind, that you would disappear to some northern European nation where nobody knows you and simply start living as a woman? Is that compulsion enough, or do I have to have been coming apart at the seams, aching to be seen as I want to be, in a body not of my birth gender?


*sigh* Hopefully some of this makes sense. Thank you, anyone who's read this far. I'd love to get to know some of you, and hear from you.

Share this post

Link to post
Carolyn Marie

Welcome to Trans Pulse, Andrea.  If you've been lurking for a while, I don't have to encourage you to look around; you've already done that.  What I will encourage you to do is post your thoughts and questions as often as you can, because that's the best way to learn, and also the best way to get to know us, and vice versa.


To answer a couple of your questions:  there is no litmus test for belonging, there is no bar to climb over or measure yourself against.  Everyone's journey is different, but it is a question we get a lot.  I knew what I wanted and who I wanted to be as far back as I can remember (which is pretty damn far).  Some folks don't have that realization until they're nearly an adult.  Most folks I know had terrible dysphoria, but I didn't.  That didn't mean I wasn't trans, but because I didn't I questioned my motives and my authenticity, just as you're doing.  So yes, it all makes sense to me.


As you'll hear often around here, what you probably need most is time with a gender therapist to help you sort through all those feelings, doubts, and experiences.  But that's for another day.  Today, just get a feel for this place, and know we'll be here to support you, and know we won't ever judge you.




Carolyn Marie

Share this post

Link to post

Welcome Andrea. I think we all have doubts and question our feelings at some point, I know I do. It comes and goes though.

As Carolyn mentioned, a therapist helps. I don’t have have major dysphoria either, and what dysphoria I do have didn’t really kick in until my mid 30’s, though I had some inklings something was up since I was a kid. We all awaken or “crack our egg” at different times. 

So continue to post and share, we’ll do the same and hopefully we will all continue to grow and find help and comfort among the TP family. 


Share this post

Link to post

First I would like to welcome you and congratulate you for stepping forward here.  Like the others said. You stated you have lurked on and off and most likely have seen at least some ray of hope here to finally join and post.  It was not a mistake let me assure you.  This place has helped me so much I can not begin to explain it all.  

While reading your post I said to myself "I had very similar thoughts and feelings".  I can see that it is a huge mind twist for you at times, and others its not.  Like me.  I have the same fears of destroying a life I had built, a marriage, a home.  Looking towards an uncertain future both emotionally and financially.  I feel guilty for this most days as I feel "I am" doing this to everyone else. Me!  I'm making life hard for others. Then I realize I am doing this to simply be Me. Not doing anything to hurt others or destroy anything maliciously.  Just trying be me.  Which there is nothing wrong with being.  Everyone else CIS gets to be who they are naturally, and accepted fully without question, why not us?

As Carolyn had said.  There is no benchmark or line to cross to being trans or whatever term you wish to use.  There are many to describe us folks here but none of us truly like to be labeled so I try not to.  No guide lines for sure on how to fee,l and when to feel or what to do.  Its a feeling in your heart and soul that nags at your brain to get with the program.  Your brain knows all about you inside.  It just tries to protect and keep you on a path of least resistance.  Safety.  Survival.   For many it is finally survival that convinces us we have to make this change.  Regardless of the fall out.  Or we could literally die from it.  At least to me it was.  

It took me a good part of four decades to come to terms with it.  Even after coming out to some family and my wife I questioned if I was really a MTF candidate.  What the hell was I doing? If I could really be a women on the outside too?  I had so many confusing thoughts on who I was inside, I knew a big part was female but then again I knew male at some level too and always just covered it up on the outside.  Doing what was "safe and acceptable to others".  Always worried about "others" and what they though of me as a person.  Even while being fully male.  

My journey has been full of discovery.  As I am sure most could attest to.  Everyone is different in how they proceed, what they want, and will do and not do.  I have seen great strides in some folks here that came in just like you not knowing what the heck was going on.  Heck I have only been here a month or so. 

So read more and ask much.  Accept others and I know we will you.  Help where you can as it is therapeutically to be helpful while seeking your own answers.  None of us are therapist as far as I know but we ALL have been there, or ARE there, and going through the same things, just at different rates and times.  It's a family to me.

TransPulse is an accepting place for all of those people and more.  



Share this post

Link to post

Welcome Andrea. It took time for me to find a path to peace with my gender issues.  There is certaonly a place for you here!  You are much as i was, unsure and unable to make even the smallest step.  I found that my time here and therapy has helped me immensely.   Hope you find the same.

You are not alone.





Share this post

Link to post

Hello Andrea. Welcome. I got here going through a similar process of feelings, dysphoria, convincing myself that I was asexual, etc.

I'm kind of in the middle of where I'd like to be: accepting myself as female inside, understanding that nearly age 70 this body has had 60 years of testosterone that isn't going to go away easily, realizing that I can become more feminine but will still look like a football linebacker.

So I'm aiming to get to a happy place for me.

I'm sure you'll find friends, answers, questions and things to think about here.

Share this post

Link to post
NB Adult  (Inactive)

Hey Andrea, welcome to our universe!

Share this post

Link to post
Jackie C.



I just wanted to welcome you to the fold and mention that, yes, I've had the "howling at the moon, wishing so hard you were female that you thought you might just burst" feelings too. I also had a similar experience with my friends. I came out to them and they basically said, "Well, duh," and we got back to what we were doing. They're good people.


So yeah, I've completely embraced my femininity and haven't looked back. It hasn't blown up a lot of my life, but there's no guarantee that parts of my life wouldn't have blown up anyway. I was pretty self-destructive, that did plenty of damage all by itself. There aren't any sure things in life, so you need to reach for whatever happiness you can.


I hope you have a lovely time here. Best wishes and welcome!



Share this post

Link to post

Thank you, all, for the warm and kind responses, and for sharing a little of your own experiences. I'm sure I don't have to say it but I will anyway (because I'm nothing if not repetitive), but it's great to know that even in the minutiae of my experiences I'm not alone, and that there is so much commonality among us.


I already feel welcome here. And while it'll be a while before I can see a gender therapist specifically, I do have a therapist (mostly for anxiety and eating disorders) with whom I am able to discuss aspects of my gender ID and journey. It's not the most desired in that sense, I'm sure, but I will take kind and educated ears wherever I can get them.


Thank you again. I want to say more but am still processing so much. So I'll just express all the gratitude I can and say, sincerely, that I hope to get to know a great many of you as I continue to browse what this forum has to offer.

Share this post

Link to post

Hi Andrea, welcome. After reading all the responses above, I can relate to something each person said that relates to me.  I’ve been on my journey for nearly 70 years and only within the past few years have accepted myself as transgender.


I’m pretty much out to my wife but not really to others around me. I feel feminine inside and have to present other wise on the outside. 


Give yourself time to sort things out.  This sight has helped me tremendously and I know you will feel the same soon as well.


For me, I have accepted who I am and am happy.


Take care and hugs.



Share this post

Link to post

Welcome Andrea. As a fellow lurker for quite a while before posting and reading others posts on here, I came to realize finally who was in this 70 yr old male body. I am sure as you continue your journey and exploration of yourself that you will find who is within as well.

There is no rush to find out as time and searching within, will disclose that for you. So sit back, listen to your mind and body, ask questions, read, and you will find the new you.


Everyone here is a great source of experience and information, just take advantage of it, as we who came after have. :)


Welcome aboard.


Big Canadian Hug


Share this post

Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Who's Online   9 Members, 0 Anonymous, 59 Guests (See full list)

    • J.Ryan
    • A. Dillon
    • Jackie C.
    • MetaLicious
    • DeeDee
    • Debra Michelle
    • CodePoetSarah
    • Calvin 😝
    • kodi23
  • Topics With Zero Replies

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
    • Most Online

    Calvin 😝
    Newest Member
    Calvin 😝
  • Today's Birthdays

    No users celebrating today
  • Posts

    • Jackie C.
      How rude.   However I know that hospitals have licensing requirements that govern what sort of procedures can be done under their care. For example, a local hospital kept my father in law for a week before they admitted they couldn't perform the heart surgery they said he needed.   Personally, I had mine done at a teaching hospital. I sort of assumed that was the norm from my limited experience (the local guy works out of U of M).   Hopefully your surgeon will get this straightened out and find another place to practice. Deep breath. Everything is moving along. This is just a minor bump in the road. Best to have a bump in the road now. You'll appreciate bumpy roads less after your surgery. Trust me on this one.   Hugs!
    • Jackie C.
      It feels good doesn't it? Just to be treated like one of the girls.   I had the same problem with my pharmacist a couple of months back. She was just having the toughest time finding me in the system until I finally took pity on her and said, "Jackie (because her name is Jackie), sweetie, you know darn well who I am." You could SEE the switch flip over as she put everything together. Glorious. She's much better about it now.   I still get a bump whenever a random stranger treats me just like any other woman. I hope that feeling never goes away.   Hugs!
    • Jackie C.
      Happy Birthday!   May you have many more as your true self.   Hugs!
    • Jackie C.
      Not usually what's discussed when you "Whip Out the Big D," but OK. I have a shirt that says, "She wants the D&D" on it. Susan doesn't get it. Bless her heart.   I'm a little disappointed. I admit I was still holding out hope that she'd see that you're still the amazing person she married and carry you to the bedroom for a weekend of apology sex. Punctuated of course by letting the dogs out at regular intervals because they're dogs. Maybe meals too. You should probably keep up your strength while having a wild weekend of apology sex. You cannot live by whipped cream alone.   That said, what you've got isn't bad. So long as things remain friendly, the divorce doesn't have to be too traumatic to either of you. Disappointing that a lawyer has to profit, but what can you do? I suppose lawyers gotta eat too. We're going to have to call her something besides your wife now. She's being cool...ish about your living situation. A good girl friend or three isn't a bad thing to have. Rooming with somebody you actually like can be a rare treat. I think you'll be OK. I mean obviously you need to make plans for the future just in case one of you meets somebody amazing, but for now things are calm and the two of you have a good new groove that works for you both.   Wardrobe is a forever thing. You get a collection started and you add to it, one or two pieces at a time until it falls on you in the dead of night and smothers you in your sleep. Shoes are the same way. I've got a good start to my collection, but I could use another pair here and there. Of course part of my reluctance is that it's hard to find cute shoes in my size. The bigger a woman's shoe size, the uglier the available shoes. Finding stuff I like that's comfortable and cute is a project. You have smaller feet so you'll be less limited.   Excited about you going out as yourself though! That'll be fun and it's a huge confidence builder! It gives you a chance to stretch your girl muscles and figure out how you like to present... which turns back into buying more work clothes, finding shoes and accessories to match and starting the cycle all over again. Until you're crushed by your clothes collection in the dead of the night.   Hugs!
    • Juelie_Atlas
      Congratulations on 6 years! I can't wait to get to that milestone! 😄
    • Miss Bunny
      Yes, I have wondered if it is me creating a self fulfilling effect.   Mind is a weird thing
    • ShawnaLeigh
      So as some know this has been a looming ultimatum placed on me in regards to presenting female outside of the house or in public.  It was agreed upon that once I do the paperwork starts.   We had a very unemotional and matter of fact conversation about this just this morning over coffee.  As two adults working together for our mutual benefit.  I told her I am getting ready to stop hiding outside the house and once the hospital staff knows about my transition there is nothing else holding me back.  Other then my lack of wardrobe but heck I don’t think I will ever have enough clothing or shoes.   We both came to the conclusion that we have been separated as husband and wife for a few months now and not living as spouses at all but roommates and girlfriends.  Which feels right.   Please don’t misinterpret this to me being upset because honestly I am not.  We have both had time to come to terms with this for a couple months and although we both care about each other it is the right thing to do going forward.  Im actually feeling like the cage door had been opened.  I’m scared but feel freed.   The divorce will be in effect for legal purposes only but our living situation will still remain as is.  For both of our financial security.   I’m ending one phase and heading into unfamiliar territory and I’m both terrified and excited for my future.    
    • SaraAW
      Great way to look at it Kathy! I too passed moderately as a man. 
    • SaraAW
      I’m only a little more than a month on meds, but wow has it helped me mentally. Similar to Jackie, I’d been a mess mentally for awhile, even having attended therapy for months. Within a week of starting, it was like a godly of self loathing and despair lifted. I’m also noticing some more range in emotions, subtle so far, but I’m loving it. Any doubts I had regarding whether hrt was for me are completely gone now. I can’t wait to see how things progress mentally and physically, although I know it’s a slow road, so I’ll have to. Thanks for sharing. Hugs!
    • KathyLauren
      I dislike the word "passing" because, to me, it implies role-playing, or pretending to be something one is not.    However, @Belle, I agree totally with your reasons:   Those are the same reason that I try to have a good female presentation.  And yet, despite #2, it doesn't matter to me if someone guesses or knows that I am trans, as long as they treat me as a woman, they don't voice any cognitive dissonance, and I like what I see in the mirror.   I passed moderately well when I was presenting as a man.  I don't need to pass as a woman, because I am one.   Regards, Kathy
    • SaraAW
      Shawna, so exciting!  Sounds like a great time out, with that one awkward experience. So happy for you. Hugs!
    • SaraAW
      I’m wondering, could this be a placebo/nocebo effect?  The mind is pretty powerful and can actually cause physical manifestations of symptoms in all sorts of ways. Not sure I’ve read any literature around bleeding, but I haven’t done a lot of research in this area.    In would definitely recommend to keep an eye on it, maybe keep a diary, recording the dates, times, activities and other things occurring around the bleeding episodes. It may help you and your doc to figure out what is causing it.    Hugs!
    • Jani
      By now you should be healed enough to be able to apply a lotion (like A&D Ointment) to the area where the pad chafes.  It doesn't take much to make a difference.  
    • SaraAW
      Not really sure where I stand on this at the moment. I’m still closeted, so not trying at all to present any way other than cis male normative.   What I really just want is to be able to just be and be treated as a human with respect and dignity, regardless of how I look or present. Then maybe I’d feel safe and comfortable enough to present how I want to in the moment.    Hugs!
    • SaraAW
  • Upcoming Events

  • Create New...