Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Susan R

Giving Advice and Second Guessing It

Recommended Posts

Susan R

My wife & I are attending an inclusive church regularly now and afterwards we attend an adult class at the church.  Right now, we’re in the middle of a 7 week study called ”Dialogues on Sexuality”.  The class focuses on LGBTQ+ inclusiveness, birth gender, gender roles, church patriarchy, and gender identity.  It’s been very good.  I think this class is the church’s way to get the members of congregation to learn, understand and adopt their “inclusiveness doctrine”.  It’s early in the game but they’re trying so hard and for the most part, we feel very welcome there.

 

My wife brought one of the class members over to me after the class was over.  My wife had been talking to her and confided with her in the small group time.  The nice woman had an interesting question for me. Her daughter is a 36 year old MtF.  The daughter is now called by her new female name by everyone except her.  So this lady asked me, “If my daughter hasn’t specifically asked me to call her by her female name but has asked others in front of her to use her female name, should I continue to use her male birth name?” Then added, “Do you think she minds?”

 

I had to pause and think.  I said, ”You're using all the correct pronouns, why not match that when you address her and do what she asks the others around her to do.”  I added, “I think out of respect and love, she is simply not correcting you.  Make her day and starting right now, only use her new female name...see how she reacts. Or you could just ask her but doing it out of your own volition will probably make her happiest” 

 

I honestly don’t know if I gave her the best advice because on the small chance her daughter wanted only her to call her by her birth name I could of messed up a good thing.  I just saw it through my own eyes.  Well, this lady and then my wife started tearing up and she now wants us to get together.  I’m just hoping I helped instead of hampered the situation.  I really don’t know the daughter so it’s a hard call and wondering if I there was any advice, different or not, you all would’ve given this nice lady.

 

Susan R🌷

Share this post


Link to post
Jackie C.

I would have been a little more direct and said, "Maybe you should ask her." That's just me though. I can't think of a reason I would be uncomfortable if my mother started calling me by my actual legal name and using the correct pronouns. Well, I might be a little skeeved out. We're not close and she's been hostile about it up until now. She'd be up to something. Your new friend though, she seems sincere.

 

I don't see anything wrong with your answer. It never hurts to try and make a loved one more comfortable when you're talking to them.

 

Hugs!

Share this post


Link to post
VickySGV

Asking the Trans person is always in good taste and correct manners.  My only caution is to do it at a private time between the two of them.  

Share this post


Link to post
Susan R

Thanks ladies, I trust both of you for your sage advice.

 

Susan R🌷

Share this post


Link to post
Charlize

I would have done the same thing you did Susan.  I say that from my own experience.  It has taken my son many years to properly name me and not refer to me as Dad in public.  When we are together in private it doesn't bother me but in public it can cause confusion and embarrassment.  If the woman does use her daughters chosen name and it disturbers her daughter i'm sure she will say something.  My guess is that she would see it as a final acceptance.

 

Hugs,

 

Charlize

Share this post


Link to post
Jani

Well yes and no.  My dad still uses the nickname I used for decades.  It sounds silly when he does it.  My wife even commented on it when we last saw them.  I'm at the point of not caring anymore since I'm comfortable with who I am and if its said loud enough in public, he's the one who seems odd.  Plus we don't see my parents face to face regularly.   So the daughter just may see it as not worth the effort. 

 

1 hour ago, Charlize said:

My guess is that she would see it as a final acceptance.

This would be a nice outcome.  

 

Jani

Share this post


Link to post
Susan R

@Charlize @Jani Thank you both for the reassurance.  I never want to ruin a good thing with a family relationship.  I was playing it safe to some degree but when you have only bits and pieces of a particular situation you’re serving an entree of ‘best guess’ with a side of ‘wisdom’.

 

Thanks again,

Susan R🌷

Share this post


Link to post
Carolyn Marie

I think you did just fine, Susan.  I would have replied in pretty much the same way.  I hope it brings mother and daughter closer together.

 

Carolyn

Share this post


Link to post
Susan R
2 hours ago, Carolyn Marie said:

I hope it brings mother and daughter closer together.

Thank you Carolyn Marie, that’s my hope too.  If it was me and my mother started calling me Susan without my ever mentioning it to her, I’d be ecstatic. But everyone’s different.

Share this post


Link to post
ShawnaLeigh
10 hours ago, Carolyn Marie said:

I think you did just fine, Susan.  I would have replied in pretty much the same way.  I hope it brings mother and daughter closer together.

 

Carolyn

I agree.  I see that you did just fine.  

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Who's Online   5 Members, 0 Anonymous, 143 Guests (See full list)

    • Kyler R.
    • Alice_H
    • Katharina
    • A. Dillon
    • Jackie C.
  • Topics With Zero Replies

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      69,932
    • Total Posts
      632,481
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      6,255
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Yurian Ariake
    Newest Member
    Yurian Ariake
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. FrozenWinter
      FrozenWinter
      (18 years old)
  • Posts

    • A. Dillon
      I am proud of you boo, keep the good work up! It takes a very big man to apologize when he is in the right, but you are the biggest man I have ever had the pleasure to know.
    • Aidan5
      This made me smile a whole lot, thank you :)) I do try my best to be a gentleman and have manners but he needed a reality check.    I tried explaining this to him, even our parents explained it to him, he never learns. I told him he doesn't have to like or accept us, he just has to respect us and keep his thoughts in his own head.    I already have apologized, he ignored me like always. I also feel sorry for the reality check that his younger brother can be stronger than him.  This sounds like something I should look into because I hate having to use my fists, I would rather have him fall and me have time to get to his head.    Thank you all for the support and advice ❤️
    • VickySGV
      I am an Episcopalian and came out in the parish (congregation) I had been in for 20+ years at that point in time.  10 years later I am still part of that parish and the only LGBT person there now.  (When I came out, our Organist / Choir Director had been a gay man).  I am generally happy where I am and am actually one of the Lay leaders in the congregation which I had not been prior to Transition.  The Episcopal Church has canons in place that include Trans people at all levels and positions in the church since 2015 although the specific rule to that effect had been proposed in 2009 but required ratification at three General Conventions which take place every three years. We do have Trans clergy in several parishes nationally.  The main issue is that there are very few of us and it does take a bit of "development" to fully engage allies in individual parishes. I have become a "known quantity" at our Diocesan (regional group of congregations) Level and as a result I do attend other parishes on occasion for Sunday services and for weekday LGBT activities that do happen, including use of our new Renaming Rite and Pride Mass  Celebrations and thus I know people even in national church offices and work with them too. I have contact with clergy members in our Diocese who encounter questions from parishioners who have Trans children or grandchildren, and have trained staff at several church schools and day care centers on dealing with Trans children.   I am much busier than I know you want to be or can be just now, and where I am has taken just about a decade to come into being.  It seems that every time I get ready to pull back, something comes up to draw me in even deeper.  My suggestion is to follow your heart in this.  Simple, friendly service and participation in a church over time is the best way to get people to know you and to realize your difference is not harmful or scary to them and they will turn out as fine people.  I have one person in my parish who has just recently begun looking at me and smiling as she says "Hi Vicky" instead of giving me a brief look and hurrying on.    
    • TammyAnne
      Thanks for sharing that. It got me giggling! I understand about the light, says the person with ten large floodlights in her studio pushing the LED equivalent of 1500 watts of 6000°K light. TA
    • TammyAnne
      The military services sometimes seem to cultivate an environment where "-awesome person-" is used casually to describe anyone who doesn't measure up or flagged on the two mile run, etc. Unacceptable but still very widespread. For most of my adult life I have practiced Tai Chi Chuan, a "soft martial art" that tends to frustrate attackers because they usually fall down by themselves without any obvious reason. I don't encourage anyone to start thinking of fighting as a solution; the old cowboy movies preached that no matter how strong, fast or good you might be there's always someone out there that's stronger, faster or better. Please don't fight. Sibling rivalry is a real thing, though. It sounds as if you may be encountering some version of that as well in the mix with your brother, Aiden. I can promise you that your brother will come back from "boot camp" a changed person after having drill instructors treat him like an infant for weeks on end. Part of the process is forcing someone to learn self control. If that's not possible, they cannot control themselves, they are ultimately kicked out of the service. No room for bad apples. TA
    • TammyAnne
      Michelle, I sincerely hope things go well for you. Reassuring your wife may not be easy, but surely there are ways in which you will remain the "same old michael" for her, be it fixing the leaky faucet or checking out the bump in the night. For now holding some of those up may convince her that she's not losing everything to this new person. I often wonder if others think trans people are like "pod people" secretly replaced in the dark of night, when in fact we've been the same person all along. TA
    • Willowtry
      Huh...I wasn't expecting this to be a thing. I hope there will be more as time passes.
    • TammyAnne
      Coming from a conservative religious background I understand The Church (composed of all the Christian faith) is made of imperfect, flawed people just like the world around us. That several denominations have been dragged kicking and screaming into the inclusivity category has been difficult to watch: the Methodist church I grew up in is suffering a serious and probably permanent rift; Episcopalian churches have mostly tried to become more affirming and inclusive; the Catholic Church has tried to split the difference  (in my opinion) and have it both ways. For myself it is helpful to see a church as extended family. Are these the people you want to spend holidays with? If not, look further afield. If so, then dive in. TA
    • TammyAnne
      Transition requires patience anyway, regardless of what we wish or others think. As said above, it's lots of baby steps that done appear to give much of a result. I prefer to think of it more like glaciation... it is slow to the observer and possibly even gentle but it is steady, powerful and inevitable to anything impeding it. Things like shaving yield instant but temporary results. Permanent hair removal (I chose laser hair removal) is a drawn out process that is rewarding (despite the pain) in most cases giving nearly instant results aside from the ongoing crop of persistent stragglers that have to be treated over the next year. It has certainly buoyed my spirits to have that done. Choose your steps well. Shaving your head is a more obvious step than shaving your body or wearing softer underclothes. I tend to avoid the obvious when I can, although my hair is now past shoulder length. But that's been a gradual process. Even starting HRT won't be a magic bullet, but a slow process of a second puberty over several years. TA
    • VickySGV
      This is an herbal compound which may not be discussed on these forums per Rule 14.  I am locking this thread for further discussion.  If it has caused the phenomena you are describing you should cease its use immediately and consult your doctor.  Herbal or "phyto estrogen" compounds that give quick or distinct reactions only do so from allergy reactions and are not generally effective otherwise.  
    • Jackie C.
      Interlude: Supplies They DON'T Tell You About   The most important one for me was a mirror. I bought an indestructible mirror with a wide handle, easy to grip and durable you could drop it down a flight of stairs. Awesome, right? Wrong. It was, well, not useless, but not as useful as you would think.   The SECOND mirror I bought was a lighted makeup mirror. I hadn't realized that the quality of light in my bedroom was quite that bad. While the durable mirror is great for general aiming and maneuvers, if you want to take a good, solid look and actually SEE anything, you want the lights. Especially important while you try to figure out how many dots you've got crammed into your new anatomy. With the durable mirror, I couldn't really tell at all.   Hugs!
    • Jackie C.
      I still have hackles. 😋   Hugs!
    • catiosern
      Amazon... "Pueraria Mirifica Serum. Natural Breast Enhancement. Truly the Best Natural Breast Lifting Anti-sagging Product - 100% Money Back Guarantee (1 fl.oz) " by Swiss Botany   Yes I read the rules, "You may not advertise good or services, ask for money, or otherwise solicit our members in any way.", but only responding to a direct question. Please don't ban me.
    • Belle
      I didn't think that was possible any more. Sorry... off topic.
    • Ms Maddie
      Thanks Google. Oh lady!   Sounds like your wife is ok with you having a female side, but not with losing the male.  What will become?  Time..   Happy that you are seeing some support coming back at you Meta😊  
  • Upcoming Events

×
×
  • Create New...