Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Susan R

Even “Inclusive” Churches can have “LGBTQ-phobic” members

Recommended Posts

Susan R

Back in 2003, I stopped going to a Christian church that I had been attending for ten years.  I actually quit all organized religion after that because they didn’t accept my wife for being previously divorced.  They treated her like a second class citizen.  In late 2013, I started a community bible study in my home that I kept going strong until shortly before I came out to the world last May 2019.

 

Shortly after stopping the Bible study, my wife and I decided we wanted some new Christian fellowship that we could do together.   We started looking for an inclusive Christian church together last fall.  We found one we really liked after attending 3 other churches off and on.  It was actually the same church where our PFLAG support group met so I knew they weren’t completely opposed to people like myself.  The new church we found and started to attend regularly had voted in favor of the affirming inclusiveness of LGBTQ+ Individuals almost 2 years ago but is just now starting to educate their congregation about it in an attempt to to get them onboard.  I had assumed the church was much further ahead in their inclusiveness than they actually are.  The church is actively promoting doctrine that is LGBTQ+ inclusive and that is nice to see.  They have an LGBTQ+ Diversity Team which is now creating classes, groups and events that help with this newly adopted “mission”.

 

It was either my first or second visit to this church last year that I encountered my first negative reaction to being either Lesbian or Trans during a service.  It’s very hard to know exactly which part of me the person despised.  I won’t go into details because some of you already know them from a previous post.  I was hoping with all the recently new focus on inclusiveness that this might be an isolated incident within this church...but it was not.

 

Today, during the service, the couple directly in front of us turned around to greet us near the beginning of the service as prompted by the Pastor.  After my wife and I traded introductions and shook their hands, it seemed like all was good.  But then the wife right in front of us leans over to the husband and says, “They’re lesbians!” like we weren’t even there.  I’m not sure how many people heard it too but I actually couldn’t believe the audacity of these professed Christians.  I was curious as to what gave them this impression about our sexuality in the first place.  My wife and I did not show any outward PDA or endearments that could have caused this rude statement.  To top it off, when they turned around at the appropriate time later in the service to offer the ritual of “peace”, they acted somewhat normal.

 

I’m not going to let this event spoil my attempts to become a viable member within the church if I decide to become a member.  I know some of us would just say “forget this bs” and leave for good.  My thought is...If I did leave, they win.  So just because a church has the inclusiveness rainbow stickered all over their windows, it doesn’t mean they've all arrived yet.  This negative momentary event was countered nicely with my wife and I staying afterwards and chatting with a few members for over an hour.  There’s definitely hope but it looks like it’s going to be a long road ahead for the both of us.

 

Susan R🌷

Share this post


Link to post
VickySGV

South of you here  I am on the Episcopal Diocese of Los Angeles LGBT ministry team as a lay person, and have been for nearly 8 years.  The Constitution and Canons of the National Church say that LGBT people are to be welcomed and accepted at all levels of membership and have been that way for LGB for 25 years and almost 5 years for Trans people.  Even with all that, I have experienced what happened to you several times as well.  Usually it is a matter of someone who has not met an LGBT person before and their reaction is really surprise that we are really just the humans that they are.  We are not sexual predators or ferocious animals  but still if they have not gotten to know us or knowingly met one or more of us and it is not an intention to reject us of shun us.  I was at a Parish recently where they were celebrating the dedication of a Service Center for their LGBT members and community members, and it turned into a very nice party.  I was standing around talking to people as the party was breaking up and a 50's age couple came up to me since I had been given a host name badge and were telling me how much fun they had and how welcomed they felt, and then told me they had come late and not known what the party  was really about.  When I told them, the jaws dropped and they looked puzzled, and then we talked a bit more and the smiles came back as they realized that LGBT was not at all what they imagined and instead of other feelings they had imagined about us they now felt wonderfully comfortable with us and not strange.  The wife told me it would take a little getting used to to see same sex couples kissing or holding hands, but their experience had been so nice they knew they could be friends of the community if not allies. Three way hug as they left  -- I never did come out to them as Trans though.

Share this post


Link to post
Cyndee
1 hour ago, Susan R said:

 But then the wife right in front of us leans over to the husband and says, “They’re lesbians!” like we weren’t even there.  

 

Sorry to hear this Susan, for many "Cis Het" folks anything that is out of their comfort zone can bring out the strangeness. 

 

Mathew 7:2 comes to mind after reading your post. 

 

You are better than this, and rise above

 

Hugs

 

C

Share this post


Link to post
KathyLauren
2 hours ago, Susan R said:

But then the wife right in front of us leans over to the husband and says, “They’re lesbians!” like we weren’t even there. 

 

I am sorry you had this unpleasant experience.

 

My wife, who is both bratty and very, very quick, might have said something like, "Yes we are.  Aren't you glad you met us?"  She wouldn't let it go, and would have ensured that they knew they were overheard.  Very pleasantly, of course.  :D

 

Regards,

Kathy

Share this post


Link to post
Jani

@Susan R You could have replied, "We've never been to Greece!" but I'm not sure many would get the connection.

 

@KathyLauren I love it!  Your wife is certainly unique. 

  

Jani

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Who's Online   13 Members, 0 Anonymous, 135 Guests (See full list)

    • J.Ryan
    • A. Dillon
    • KathyLauren
    • Jani
    • SarahVA
    • The Viv Element
    • MaryEllen
    • TammyAnne
    • SaraAW
    • KymmieL
    • Akamai
    • Ms Maddie
    • IreneT
  • Topics With Zero Replies

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      69,935
    • Total Posts
      632,519
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      6,257
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Chrissy8888
    Newest Member
    Chrissy8888
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. FrozenWinter
      FrozenWinter
      (18 years old)
  • Posts

    • KathyLauren
      Hi, Sarah.  You have come to the right place.   Your story is very, very familiar.  Except for the kids, I could have written it myself.  I was 61 when I was where you are now.    If you can, I would recommend that you see a gender therapist.  They will be able to help you figure out what you want to accomplish and how to get there.   Regards, Kathy
    • SarahVA
      Thank you Viv!  It was hard to write, it's all kind of scary actually.
    • The Viv Element
      Also you look great for someone your age! 😍
    • The Viv Element
      Hi Sarah! Welcome to Transpulse forums  Thank you for sharing your experiences because most importantly these experiences help the gender questioning peeps out there to see a clearer version of themselves when they realize others are going through the same thing & never hesitate to open a post for any questions you might have down the road because that's what we're here for     Goodluck on your Journey Sarah!❤️
    • Cyndee
      Nice Dakota, thanks for sharing here, and good luck !!   Cyndee 
    • SarahVA
      Hello everyone.  Just  joined so I thought I would try to do some sort of an introduction.  I am not very good at these things.  First off, am older (64) identified male at birth, and I guess best descriptor right now would be MTF questioning.  I have felt for a long time that I am not quite right as male.  This is probably a story that most have heard before.  Sarah has been kept in a box for many years.  When little I knew I preferred being a girl.  Back then there was no "gender identity", even transgender wasn't something anyone talked about or even knew anything about.  So I liked girl things and just felt that was what I wanted.  Of course, didn't go over well, got punished, got the "boys don't do that" lectures so that's what I did, boy stuff.  Except for some playing "house" with a friend who wanted a sister, pretty much pushed it all away, figured I was weird or it was a phase.  Put Sarah in a box and kind of nailed it shut for many, many years.  Did all the "right" male things, scouts, military, married, kids.  Sarah would peak out now and then, but basically didn't think about it much, or tired not to.  Fast forward to the internet and I was able to see there were others out there and then started doing some dressing as a woman now and then.  Started with crossdressers but that didn't really seem to describe me and how I felt.  Dressing wasn't a stress reliever, or anything sexual,  it just seemed to be me.  Well fast forward a few more years and now it is more and more  emotional and feeling that it's just not me as a male.  So just trying to figure things out and make some effort to balance it all out.  Hope that wasn't all too long winded.  Thank you.  Sarah
    • Jackie C.
      Neat! So you've got kind of a Hugh Jackman thing going on now? All growly and gravely?   I'm a little jealous honestly, I wish hormones did jack-all for MtF voices.   Hugs!
    • Dakota16
      Hey everyone!   I've been away from here for awhile. Adulting and work have pretty much dominated my schedule over the last several months. When I do have time off, I've tried my hand at writing. My first book comes out on March 17th, and I'm so excited to get a new part of my life going!   I also have a smaller book that's part of an LGBTQ+ author promotion for the month of February. Feel free to check it out with the link below! My book is called Rebuilding Christmas under the pen name Lizzie McCord   https://books.bookfunnel.com/lgbtqfebruarygiveaway/41zv7v6ajn
    • VickySGV
      Not really the case I am afraid.  I had largely been ignored as my male self for some good reasons I may add.  I was simply the dad of two children who were important to their youth program.  If I had simply tossed the kids out of the car on Sunday mornings I would not really have been missed.  They began to cautiously get to know me over a the first two years, but I felt more like sticking my neck out as I Transitioned.  My longevity was a matter of space occupation not really anything more.
    • Jani
      I use an Apple MacBook Pro and have no issue.  When you say it won't connect, does it just take forever and never load or is there some other indication?  Jani
    • TrIIIy
      Week 4, and my voice is different today! Definitely a bit deeper and a little bit scratchy. So excited!
    • Jani
      OH NOOOOOOOOO!!
    • Susan R
      Yes, the timing of the membership orientation was premature in our timeline.  I haven’t written off the church, my wife and I just need more time to make that level of commitment.  I hate letting people down though and that’s what bothers me more than anything.  The Pastors, both of them, call me, stop by to chat after the service and  greet me affectionately every time I see them.  I realize that no reason to attend but it sure makes it hard not to step up to the plate.   I feel love in many people in our congregation.  There are many who would put their lives on the line to help another.  Of course, there are, of course, others that are there for their own benefit.  Overall, I feel more love there than a lack of it.   The church has more outreach operations than any church I’ve visited.  There is no way one individual can participate in every one of them.  They are making a difference here in the local community.  Events are going on constantly.  As a congregation and through the leadership, the church is pouring out love into the community.   I am developing relationships now with some of the members.  Enough so that going out for coffee is an option.  The vacation will be a little longer in the timeline..lol...but who knows?   The main difference here is your long standing in the church.  You had likely proved yourself in that amount of time.  The coming out for me would be nearly simultaneous to my  becoming a member.  Those who haven’t already seen my wife and I as a couple would instantly be brought up to speed.  The church, imho, may not be ready to accept an open LGBTQ+ member.  That won’t likely stop me.   This is what is keeping me attending.  I feel I can help out and I have my wife wanting to assist in this with me.  It would be easier to find another church that is further along in its Inclusion Doctrine implementation but maybe I am there for that specific reason.  I do feel it is a congregation that wants change in this direction...I was just hoping they were already there.  I’m almost comfortable enough to make the commitment. I just think I need a little more time.   Thank you all for your wonderful insights and taking time to read through all I had written.  It’s a very important part of my life and I’m happy that you cared enough to give me your thoughts.   Susan R🌷
    • Jackie C.
      The first point is pretty simple. Cis people don't generally. think about being born the wrong gender.   I get where you're coming from friends-wise too. Being surrounded by other women is my happy place. At holiday gatherings I just wanted to hang out in the kitchen and help out while we chatted. We don't always share the same interests, but I'm willing to make the effort for girl friends. OK, that's like 180 degrees from your experience, but you get the idea. Basically I don't work as a "male." I have some pretty chronic male fail. I remember wanting to be a girl as early as three or so (the date might be off, but I was three when we lived in the place I remember pretending to be a girl). The feelings sometimes got stronger or weaker, but they never really went away. There was always a voice in the back of my mind whispering, "You'd be a spectacular woman." That voice was absolutely right.   As for your next step, while there's no perfect pattern for coming out that works for all of us, at some point you're going to need to sit down and talk with a gender therapist. That's probably what I'd work for next. I can't say exactly how that works for a minor in the UK. I don't live there. You should be able to find a counselor or other resource designed to help people like yourself find the help they need.   Finally, welcome to the site! I think you'll find us supportive and we've recently gained quite a few young men in your situation who you could very well find more helpful than an old woman like me. Please feel free to browse and join the conversation!   Hugs!
    • MetaLicious
      First: Welcome to the boards!  You've come to the right place to ask just the kind of questions you have...  Everyone has a unique experience, but there is a lot of overlap.   My first experience wa long before I even knew the difference between the genders, and it manifested as a jealousy regarding girls' bodies, specifically their tummies. As I approached puberty, I became obsessed with getting rid of all my body hair (which I did, and boy, did it itch!).  It wasn't until my early 20s that I even had a word other than jealousy to describe how I felt. I didn't even think I had dysphoria, because I didn't hate my body - I just really, really wanted a different one.  It took me until me early 50s to realize my assigned gender wasn't a good fit, and that pretending otherwise was not healthy for me.   If you're thinking about changing you gender, you're probably trans, because such a thing never occurs to cisgendered people.  The first step I would suggest is find someone to talk to: a therapist, counselor, or even a trusted parent.  
  • Upcoming Events

×
×
  • Create New...