Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Realization of gender


Msecret

Recommended Posts

Hello everyone. I'm an inexperienced poster/forum member but am excited to engage. Please let me know if this is the wrong spot. I'm also new (as of early this year) to coming out of the closet to myself (psychological conditioning and high testosterone, (among other factors) made this unthinkable not long ago). As an AMAB coming to the acceptance of at least non binary gender in mid 40s, there are internal questions as to why now and if I'm just imagining this or kinking or something. Some people I interact with are of the belief that trans people know their true gender as toddlers, which would make me some kind of pretender or fake if this was always true. Then there are sociologist people I know that are of the belief that it's environmental and social conditioning that determines internal gender, which implies that I could unlearn this with the right conditioning or therapy. These two sides are opposite and willing to fight each other. I don't think it's as simple as that. Could a traumatic vasectomy I had a couple years back trigger this? (anesthesia failed, can't even describe such intense pain). Also testosterone does decline after 30 naturally (maybe a factor?) My male libido (which I view as more a burden than fun) had been on a steep downtrend for some time after vasectomy but was on a shallow downtrend already before that already. I started cross dressing/cross dreaming in my basement early in year which brings joy in levels I would have never guessed, but is not something I had not done before though. I know I need to discuss this with psych but figured I would put this out here first because I can't discuss this with wife, family, or friends without being a misunderstood disappointment. Dysphoria with genitals as well as the way that the male gender acts and thinks bother me more as time goes by. How could I have not known decades ago? That's the rhetorical question I contemplate. Recalling things that may be clues. I'm curious about non obvious clues others have found in thier reflection as well. Thank you for reading.🙂

Link to post

Hello @Msecret,

    Nice to meet you. I just want to tell you that the way you feel is ok. People of all ages come to these realizations and there is no real time that it should happen by. We all have different experiences that make us who we are. It's a great idea to get a guide, like a gender therapist, to help you sort out your feelings. They tend to have crucial insight and advice. They can help you gain the confidence to talk with family and help you achieve a safe place to do so. This isn't a race either.

    Now that you've started questioning these feelings, you may feel overwhelmed by all of it. I suggest writing down some of these thoughts, feelings and experiences. There is a lot of content here on different threads that may lead you to see similarities. There are thousands of hours of content about being a transgender person on youtube as well. Ted Talks are all very good ones. Topics may come up that you can relate to as well. The worst thing you can do is expect anything to go exactly as you think it should or would normally go. The main thing is taking it slow. Tiny steps to see how things make you feel. Find the ones that make you feel good and explore them. Happiness is very important.

 

 I hope the best for you as you seek your answers.

 

Abi

Link to post

Thank you 🙂 Abi. Very thoughtful reply and ideas and I'll incorporate these into my life. 

Link to post

Welcome.  We all come down this path differently so don't fret over being "late to the realization"  A gender therapist can help you sort things out.

In the meantime, here's your topic being discussed by Dr Z whom I love.

 

Link to post
KathyLauren
On 9/24/2020 at 6:56 PM, Msecret said:

Some people I interact with are of the belief that trans people know their true gender as toddlers, which would make me some kind of pretender or fake if this was always true. Then there are sociologist people I know that are of the belief that it's environmental and social conditioning that determines internal gender, which implies that I could unlearn this with the right conditioning or therapy. These two sides are opposite and willing to fight each other. I don't think it's as simple as that.

 

Hi, Msecret.

 

You are right to question the popular mythologies.  It is quite untrue that "most" trans people know their identity as toddlers.  This myth is promoted by people whose agenda is to label us as fakes.  Some trans people do indeed know their identities as toddlers.  But most of us figure it out only later.  For trans-masculine folks, the most common age is at puberty.  For trans-feminine folks, it is more common to figure it out in middle age.  Or later.  None of that implies fakery.

 

As for the other myth, the best scientific data we have suggests that whatever makes us trans is present before birth.  There is no social or environmental reason that we are the gender we are.  The reasons (and there are likely several) are biological.  A person can't "become" trans, nor can they stop being trans.  If you are, you are.

 

I figured out that I was trans at age 61.  Suddenly, all the little clues over the years, stretching back to when I was 7, made sense.  That is how it typically works: we figure it out mostly in hindsight.

 

I would strongly recommend seeking out a gender therapist to help you work out who you are and what you want to do about it.  A general therapist might be able to help you get started, but you really want one with expertise in the field of gender issues.

 

Regards,

Kathy

Link to post

Thank you Kathy for a very thoughtful and informative response. I feel a little bit more at peace with myself. I will plan to seek professional beyond regular psych. 

Link to post

Thank you @Bri2020. I watched video and this doctor Z is informative and comforting and not like anything that came up on web for me when I was researching. What could potentially be the case feels less scary. I will also discuss this with professional. 

Link to post

Reading the comments on Dr.Z's videos is very informative. I find so many different points of view that we all have discussed on her videos. It is unfortunate that her practice is not in every state. She frequently posts and covers a lot of topics relating to transgender care. 

Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   11 Members, 0 Anonymous, 73 Guests (See full list)

    • Charlize
    • Ann W
    • Heather Nicole
    • QuestioningAmber
    • Cyndee
    • VickySGV
    • Jandi
    • sparky
    • Alexx21
    • Shay
    • ElizabethStar
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics With Zero Replies

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      72,288
    • Total Posts
      660,873
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      7,569
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Newest Member
    Danusia
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    No users celebrating today
  • Posts

    • VickySGV
      Shame is a tough one to crack since it is actually fear of what others would think or how we may injure them.  Other people will say you hurt them, but then be unable to say how you did it if pressed for an answer.  In reality the "hurt" was more in your imagination of the hurt to them.  Females dressing in more masculine attire really are no big deal except in isolated areas where "propriety" passions run high, and clothing is considered uniforms.  Ease your way into your masculine presentation with a new hair cut (no beards or mustaches yet), and easing in more male mannerisms over time simply make the behaviors YOURS to own in comfort.  Don't do it all at once will help. 
    • Jandi
      Yeah, this is pretty much what I did.  It was scary at first, but I lived through it.  Now it's just routine. I think the shame aspect was my internalized transphobia - which is a real thing.
    • Shay
      MISPRINT above - I now see the light   I looked in the mirror and I didn't like the person I saw - but now - thank goodness - I am seeing the light and the light is helping me see the real me.................................
    • Heather Nicole
      For me, it doesn't seem quite as strong as it appears to be for you, and I'd be terrified of the nausea, morning sickness, labor pains, etc. But I definitely do feel much the same way about it as you (and also for nursing, too), and I know there others here who do as well. Doesn't help that a much younger co-worker of mine is pregnant and my sister just had her second arrival this year.
    • Shay
      Good Choice @QuestioningAmber one I found today that speaks to me is an old song I never thought of as trans ....   I looked in the mirror and didn't like who I saw but not I see the light   Patto-Jones-Wright I looked into the mirror and it poisoned my mind twice It left me both time crippled And it tossed my fate like dice I looked into the mirror and the devil smiled both times My flesh was sold with no feelings With no reason or rhyme The smile on my face gave way to my feeling But only time was there to tell Somewhere in space my thoughts are still reeling The miror looked through hell And damned me where I fell You mistreated the boxer You held his spirit down (Yes she did, yes she did, yes she did, yes she did) You colored his reflection 'Cause you didn't like his sound But now my head is clearing And I'm startin' to see the light (see the light, see the light, see the light, see the light) Now I'm lookin' to the mirror And I don't know if it's day or night The smile on my face gave way to my feeling But only time was there to tell Somewhere in space my thoughts are still reeling The miror looked through hell And damned me where I fell See the light, see the light, see the light, see the light...
    • Jandi
      I was always so jealous of my ex when I watched her nursing. Welcome, Danusia
    • Heather Nicole
      I groggily misread "awkward" as "award".   "Awkward" makes a lot more sense!  
    • VickySGV
      She is actually higher here than president, the RED QUEEN is more like it.  (Bows low!!)   Imaginations and passions are running higher this year than any I can remember, and the internet and isolation has given rise to false information False Events Appearing Real (FEAR).  The same events carefully communicated by one person will be wholly acceptable to many more people than just an "inner circle" of policy and direction, but the same entire set of actions communicated poorly and only to "trusted disciples" from a different person will be condemned.  This will be my only post in this topic. It was a good topic though, and with the staff we have will be kept in social bounds.
    • QuestioningAmber
      So I recently decided to watch Frozen 2, and a few songs spoke to me to anybody going through a transformation. One in particular speaks to me today: Show Yourself.  
    • Danusia
      I know what it means to be confused about not being able to get pregnant, this is my problem. Sometimes I dream that I'm carrying one child in my belly and the other, already born, I'm nursing, feeding, etc. And we are "waiting for daddy's return to home after work". Sometimes I dream that I'm in the skin of my friend who already has two children, and the third is on the way. I dream that I am her and I give birth at home, a supportive husband is by my side and the midwife instructs me how to breathe and push the baby. For me, making a joke of it all is a pretty good strategy for dealing with unrealistic desires, but I understand that it might be indigestible to someone else. About the environment - I know the current US president is anti-transgender, it is rather similar in my country, but there is no full consequence here.    
    • Jackie C.
      Personally, I just gritted my teeth, pulled on my big-girl panties and went for it. The fear of exposure and shame went away after a few public outings where nobody so much as raised an eyebrow in my direction. I was pretty indifferent to my male persona's appearance. I simply did not care. Not so with appearing as a woman. I color-coordinate my gym outfits. Nobody cares about my gym outfits, but I still put together a coordinated look to go sweat in. It's like night and day.   The point being that going out as yourself is kind of a rite of passage. There's always some fear in the beginning. I have a friend who likened us to vampires because we only come out at night and shy away from bright lights. With practice though, comes confidence. Take the plunge!   Hugs!
    • MiloR
      Hi everyone ! Ok, so... I think I have a question, which might be quite simple, but the anwser to it may not be so. How to deal with feelings of shame regarding gender ? It's just something that I struggle with a lot, and even if I tell myself that I musn't be ashamed to think I'm probably a guy, knowing it and feeling it really are different stories. And I think my shame is blocking me from acknowledging what I feel most comfortable with in being and in the way I want to present. Because for example I feel sad when I dress as a woman, but so embarrassed when I dress as a man because some part of me tells me it's inappropriate or even dangerous... And so, experimenting and presenting myself as who I want to be gets cloaked by my fears and some kind of stupid conviction that it's somehow "bad" and that I'm not normal... So if you had any advice for me to feel a bit better about myself (also to have a clearer idea of who I am without constantly judging if what I do is good/bad), or tell me how you managed to let go of that specific fear of not being normal or anything, it would be greatly appreciated. I'm aware shame must be a common feeling, but you know, if you had any tricks... I think I could see better who I am rather than who I'm taught to be.
    • Shay
      @Jackie C. Better awkward poking then finding problem.
    • Shay
      Just kidding words of wisdom Cyndee
    • Jackie C.
      You are most welcome. We live to serve.   You have to be careful with some of those jokes. I know plenty of transwomen who get torn up by the fact they can't get pregnant and plenty more that have been conditioned to think that's there's something wrong with them. I live in the US. The environment for us here... could be better. 😜   Again, welcome to Transpulse. I look forward to getting to know you better.   Hugs!
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...