Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Realization of gender


Msecret

Recommended Posts

Hello everyone. I'm an inexperienced poster/forum member but am excited to engage. Please let me know if this is the wrong spot. I'm also new (as of early this year) to coming out of the closet to myself (psychological conditioning and high testosterone, (among other factors) made this unthinkable not long ago). As an AMAB coming to the acceptance of at least non binary gender in mid 40s, there are internal questions as to why now and if I'm just imagining this or kinking or something. Some people I interact with are of the belief that trans people know their true gender as toddlers, which would make me some kind of pretender or fake if this was always true. Then there are sociologist people I know that are of the belief that it's environmental and social conditioning that determines internal gender, which implies that I could unlearn this with the right conditioning or therapy. These two sides are opposite and willing to fight each other. I don't think it's as simple as that. Could a traumatic vasectomy I had a couple years back trigger this? (anesthesia failed, can't even describe such intense pain). Also testosterone does decline after 30 naturally (maybe a factor?) My male libido (which I view as more a burden than fun) had been on a steep downtrend for some time after vasectomy but was on a shallow downtrend already before that already. I started cross dressing/cross dreaming in my basement early in year which brings joy in levels I would have never guessed, but is not something I had not done before though. I know I need to discuss this with psych but figured I would put this out here first because I can't discuss this with wife, family, or friends without being a misunderstood disappointment. Dysphoria with genitals as well as the way that the male gender acts and thinks bother me more as time goes by. How could I have not known decades ago? That's the rhetorical question I contemplate. Recalling things that may be clues. I'm curious about non obvious clues others have found in thier reflection as well. Thank you for reading.🙂

Link to post

Hello @Msecret,

    Nice to meet you. I just want to tell you that the way you feel is ok. People of all ages come to these realizations and there is no real time that it should happen by. We all have different experiences that make us who we are. It's a great idea to get a guide, like a gender therapist, to help you sort out your feelings. They tend to have crucial insight and advice. They can help you gain the confidence to talk with family and help you achieve a safe place to do so. This isn't a race either.

    Now that you've started questioning these feelings, you may feel overwhelmed by all of it. I suggest writing down some of these thoughts, feelings and experiences. There is a lot of content here on different threads that may lead you to see similarities. There are thousands of hours of content about being a transgender person on youtube as well. Ted Talks are all very good ones. Topics may come up that you can relate to as well. The worst thing you can do is expect anything to go exactly as you think it should or would normally go. The main thing is taking it slow. Tiny steps to see how things make you feel. Find the ones that make you feel good and explore them. Happiness is very important.

 

 I hope the best for you as you seek your answers.

 

Abi

Link to post

Thank you 🙂 Abi. Very thoughtful reply and ideas and I'll incorporate these into my life. 

Link to post

Welcome.  We all come down this path differently so don't fret over being "late to the realization"  A gender therapist can help you sort things out.

In the meantime, here's your topic being discussed by Dr Z whom I love.

 

Link to post
KathyLauren
On 9/24/2020 at 6:56 PM, Msecret said:

Some people I interact with are of the belief that trans people know their true gender as toddlers, which would make me some kind of pretender or fake if this was always true. Then there are sociologist people I know that are of the belief that it's environmental and social conditioning that determines internal gender, which implies that I could unlearn this with the right conditioning or therapy. These two sides are opposite and willing to fight each other. I don't think it's as simple as that.

 

Hi, Msecret.

 

You are right to question the popular mythologies.  It is quite untrue that "most" trans people know their identity as toddlers.  This myth is promoted by people whose agenda is to label us as fakes.  Some trans people do indeed know their identities as toddlers.  But most of us figure it out only later.  For trans-masculine folks, the most common age is at puberty.  For trans-feminine folks, it is more common to figure it out in middle age.  Or later.  None of that implies fakery.

 

As for the other myth, the best scientific data we have suggests that whatever makes us trans is present before birth.  There is no social or environmental reason that we are the gender we are.  The reasons (and there are likely several) are biological.  A person can't "become" trans, nor can they stop being trans.  If you are, you are.

 

I figured out that I was trans at age 61.  Suddenly, all the little clues over the years, stretching back to when I was 7, made sense.  That is how it typically works: we figure it out mostly in hindsight.

 

I would strongly recommend seeking out a gender therapist to help you work out who you are and what you want to do about it.  A general therapist might be able to help you get started, but you really want one with expertise in the field of gender issues.

 

Regards,

Kathy

Link to post

Thank you Kathy for a very thoughtful and informative response. I feel a little bit more at peace with myself. I will plan to seek professional beyond regular psych. 

Link to post

Thank you @Bri2020. I watched video and this doctor Z is informative and comforting and not like anything that came up on web for me when I was researching. What could potentially be the case feels less scary. I will also discuss this with professional. 

Link to post

Reading the comments on Dr.Z's videos is very informative. I find so many different points of view that we all have discussed on her videos. It is unfortunate that her practice is not in every state. She frequently posts and covers a lot of topics relating to transgender care. 

Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   15 Members, 0 Anonymous, 51 Guests (See full list)

    • Cyndee
    • Hully
    • 2beBreanna
    • Timber Wolf
    • KathyLauren
    • Jocelyn
    • A. Dillon
    • Kiara
    • Liam da potato
    • Maddee
    • squish
    • ValerieRun
    • Charlize
    • Gabriel
    • Kellianne
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics With Zero Replies

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      72,534
    • Total Posts
      663,451
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      7,716
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Trish
    Newest Member
    Trish
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Andi
      Andi
      (41 years old)
    2. Bobbie Scott
      Bobbie Scott
      (63 years old)
    3. ewwiot
      ewwiot
      (19 years old)
    4. Grwl
      Grwl
    5. Julialikesfashion
      Julialikesfashion
      (24 years old)
  • Posts

    • Kiara
      At my work we normally only do some very basic decorating, but this year starting with Halloween we've gone all out. Fall/Halloween used to just be some sad foam pumpkins and other little odds and ends, but this year we did fake webs, a ton of paper cutouts all over the walls, a fake ghost, a scarecrow, etc. Thanksgiving was a ton of paper cutouts and printables. Now for Christmas/Hanukkah we have lots of snowflakes and fake trees all over the place in addition to our regular tree and menorahs. We also threw a Santa hat on our scarecrow. We're trying to make things as festive and fun as possible in this dark time and I think it helps people. Meanwhile at home we're considering not getting a tree this year. We normally pick up a live tree, but with everything going on outside and the fact we're not even sure where to put it now, we're thinking of just skipping it this year. It's really sad, but it's an unnecessary expense right now. I've had my co-workers ask about my Christmas shopping and I was a little thrown off. I know it's something people are still compelled to do, but I just hadn't even considered it this year. With the huge spike in case numbers and concern of possible furloughs if we shut down again, I've been avoiding spending any money for unnecessary things.  I see all the things starting for the holidays, but I just don't feel it this year. Even decorating at work is just sort of feels like I'm just going through the motions. We're supposed to decorate at home this weekend and I'm just not sure how into it I will be this year. Hopefully this is all just for this year and next year will be better for everyone.
    • Kellianne
      So, since this is my first wig, I know little about maintaining hair/wigs. I have been shaving my head for 20 years now and never had long hair. I am assuming the style it comes in will not maintain through a washing, which is critical to maintenance just like real hair. Anyone have any tips/advice?
    • KayC
      Hi @Motormouth95!  first time meeting I believe but I want to Congratulate you on your tremendous achievement🎉 You proved to yourself and others that with a clear vector and positive effort you can achieve great things.  Perfect experience for the next steps in you Life!    Thank you for sharing, and hope to hear more from you in the future❣️
    • squish
      And why I can't do it anymore....   So lets start of about 8 years ago. I was watching TV and I was like "wow that girl is pretty" (I'm pretty sure it was like Zendaya or some Disney channel star.) Over the next year I would watch TV or go to school and develop these mini 7-yr old crushes on girls.   So I told my mom. I said something like "mom I dont think i like boys anymore, i mean they are cute but girls are cuter" And she was so confused so I told her how I was watching TV and all that stuff happened and she was like just like "oh" My mom's a lesbian and I came out to her as bi before she came out to me.    Time-skip to 5th grade I told her I was only into girls and she was supportive and about it (why wouldn't she be right? But that didn't last long...  When I got into the 6th grade, I realized I was non-binary. My sister who was in 7th grade at the time came out as genderfluid and pan. My mom tried to be accepting but she kept calling them by her birthname after being told their preferred name many times.    The bad part starts this past winter when I came out as ace and she said to me "you know you're going to get cheated on right?"  And then started making fun of me for being ace When I've been in situations with my gf that could have turned sexual and I felt uncomfortable and she knows Who tells their daughter who's in middle school that your going to be cheated on because you don't want sex?????   Right now I'm in 9th grade and I planned on coming out to my mom as NB but that's not happening  Her and my stepmom say the worst things about people who identify as they Literally yesterday they were talking about Elliot Page and Sam Smith and the part of their convo I heard went a little like this "So now every confused person is trans?" "Her career was flopping that's why she said that, she just needs more money" "Calling people they is wrong! It's grammatically incorrect!" "No babe it's about the personality" "So they are crazy? Like BPD or MPD?" "..." "So I'll call someone they if I see an doctors diagnosis"   Over the summer my sibling called my mom transphobic and she got all defensive saying that she wasn't but they have conversations like this all the time.  If they can't be comfortable/understand people who want to transition or pronouns are they/them I don't feel comfortable coming out to them as someone who identifies as she/he/them    Any thoughts? -squish
    • KayC
      Hi Sarah!  nice to meet you, and Welcome!  as you can see, we share some geographical (and emotional) commonality.  I know how hard it is to find Community here in Japan, but this Forum has been a great help to me and I hope it is for you also.  I think you will find many of us here who are unique individuals but also carry very common feelings and experiences.  Happy you found a gender therapist too!  I know how difficult that is here.  I was fortunate to also find a great therapist and it has been immensely beneficial.   Welcome again❣️  Deep breaths ... one step at a time    
    • QuestioningAmber
      So I am off for the next two days because I had a trip planned that was cancelled and thought I should still keep the days off. I am not quite sure what I am going to do with that time, because too much free time has proven in the past to be a dangerous thing for me. Work has been slow over the past week still, and I have a feeling won't pick up again until the new year which is giving my mind a lot of time to wander, which again, typically not a great thing for my mental health. It's amazing how right now, things are kind of stacked against mental health:     1.) Quarantine/COVID Restrictions     2.) Slow Work     3.) Time Off (Our company is use it or lose it)   I honestly haven't even been in the mood to mess with makeup, hair, or really get out of PJ's, which probably isn't the best thing. I've gotten dressed a few days to pick up food or coffee, but that is about it. I know I shouldn't be doing these kind of behaviors, I just can't seem to get myself motivated.   Today is therapy day, so we'll see what my therapist thinks of all this, I just know I am going to hear it that I am not doing enough to fight the mood driven behavior. Le sigh ... depression sucks.
    • KayC
      Ahhh..  that's so sweet, Gabriel.  I don't think I've ever been quoted before.    I'm happy that mantra means something to you.  Even the smallest of efforts in the right direction will create tremendous changes over time, just like the wind and water can carve away mountains.  When we look back we will see how far we have traveled. Wishing you a wonderful day🙏❣️
    • Willow
      Good morning everyone    nice day again although a chilly start. Sitting here drinking our morning coffee.  Third day in a row for doctors appointments then off until Monday then another one.  Yesterday’s doctor wanted me to come to Charleston to take an esophagram. After it was set up for Next Wednesday I told her I’d had one in 2018.  I sent her the results and she canceled the new one. The old one showed her what she was wanted to see apparently.   our dog came in to bed a couple times last night. The first time she figured out I was awake so she insisted on being rubbed.  The second time she decided she would leave me alone.  Laid with us a little then left.   y’all talk about cats, well our daughter brought one home once.  I was a nice cat.  Decided that I was it’s friend. It would come sleep with us and particularly on my face.  Unfortunately, I’m allergic to cat dander.  Wife and daughter both no your not you just don’t like cats.  I had to go to an allergist to prove it to them before they believed me.  She kept the cat, but not in our house anymore.     years later it ran off during a thunderstorm and they never saw it again.   Willow
    • KathyLauren
      Vulvoplasty, a.k.a. zero-depth vaginoplasty.
    • Robin.C
      Congratulations, studying is hard enough without all that this year has thrown our way.   Hugs Robin
    • Jackie C.
      Congratulations! Today you are a werewolf man. Definitely a man. Probably.   Buckle up and enjoy the ride!   Hugs!
    • Gabriel
      Morning all!   On my second cup of tea. Today a bit overwhelmed with stress at work, a very interesting prospect at my second job, trying to figure out what the heck I want on my gender identity journey and some health issues.   Well, as @KayC says, deep breath and one step at a time. Wishing you all a lovely day
    • Gabriel
      Hi @Motormouth95. I'm quite new here so I didn't know you from before. Nice to meet you. Yours is an inspiring story. Keep us posted when you can  
    • Gabriel
      Hey, congrats Mason! That's great. Keep us posted how it goes!
    • Gabriel
      Hello @sarahmetal, welcome!   You are definitely not alone. Not in being confused, not in needing deep introspection to figure out what is what, and not in feeling alone and isolated for a long time. I totally relate to all of those.   Gender is never cut and dry and we are all scattered through that line of the gender spectrum, o even out of it. I found really helpful to draw that line  Male-------MidPoint-------Female and put my finger on the place I feel intuitively is my place.    As @Susan R said, a gender therapist was (and is) a huge help for me to sort things out and almost dissolve confusion and anxiety.   There are lovely people around here that identify as NB, bigender, and others. So, welcome  
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...