Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Gender Detectives


Guest NatashaJade

Recommended Posts

Guest NatashaJade

I work closely with a gender detective. He is constantly trying to figure out if she is(was) really a he. His main target is one teacher in particular. I always try to kill the discussion, thwart his investigation with a quick denial of his suspicion (if she is trans, she's so stealth I cannot tell), but he is rather piggish in his jocular thug musings...

Anyone else have any experience with these gender dicks? How do you handle it?

Gin

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean

Yes, Gin....

Had that experience in the past with some cretin...

And I did like you and killed the discussion because it was hitting dangerously close to home....me!

We get to the point where we just want to be able to blend in...

We don't need some idiot trying to "figure it out"!

It doesn't require being figured out!

And if anyone has any good ideas on how to handle them...I'd like to hear it, too....

Donna Jean

Link to comment
Guest NatalieRene

I think I would probably turn it around on the person and infer that I think they are an trans person. And if they are asking open endedly without naming names I would choose to misunderstand it and act like they where beating around the bush about coming out themselves. It's more aggressive then I usually am but these sort of things need to be nipped in the butt

Link to comment
Guest Miss Aeryn
And if anyone has any good ideas on how to handle them...I'd like to hear it, too....

I say this completely tongue-in-cheek:

'It's like I've always said. You can get more with a kind word and two-by-four than you can with just a kind word.' Marcus, Babylon 5

:D

Link to comment
Guest Astro_Liz
Babylon 5

Now THERE is a show I miss! Lots of great little quippy lines. :)

I didn't even know gender detectives existed. Nothing better to do with their time, seriously? *rolls eyes*

Link to comment
Guest NatashaJade
I say this completely tongue-in-cheek:

'It's like I've always said. You can get more with a kind word and two-by-four than you can with just a kind word.' Marcus, Babylon 5

:D

Ahhh, B5. I miss thee :D

Link to comment
Guest julia_d

2x4 .. indeed.. just never needed any after 2 years as a rock club bouncer.

Last idiot I encountered like this had more than enough skeletons in closets for me to scare them off easily after just a little digging..

Link to comment
Guest Janessa

People like that really make me angry. There was this one guy online that kept calling me a boy just because I wouldn't show him a picture as proof of my sex, despite me constantly saying I don't want my picture on the net and accusing him of being a stalker. I didn't give him one of course, but it took so long just to get rid of him. >.>

I really think they need to mind their own business both online and offline. Disappointing it happens offline too, but not a surprise. =\

Link to comment
Guest AshleyRF
I work closely with a gender detective. He is constantly trying to figure out if she is(was) really a he. His main target is one teacher in particular. I always try to kill the discussion, thwart his investigation with a quick denial of his suspicion (if she is trans, she's so stealth I cannot tell), but he is rather piggish in his jocular thug musings...

Anyone else have any experience with these gender dicks? How do you handle it?

Gin

Why does it matter to this person so much? Are the people in question potential dates? Is he going to physically harm them if they are? Or is he just a chaser? I think this person has far to much time on their hands.

Link to comment
Guest Ryles_D

I try to figure it out sometimes, too. But I don't try to find out if "she" used to be "he" and I'd never confront them about it or tell anyone who might not be accepting. :angry: It doesn't matter if she's trans or cis- that's just not nice.

I think the best thing you can do is thwart his plans, and the idea of joking about his interest being because he's trans might work. People like this annoy me. :/

Link to comment
Guest NatashaJade
Why does it matter to this person so much? Are the people in question potential dates? Is he going to physically harm them if they are? Or is he just a chaser? I think this person has far to much time on their hands.

I think this particular teacher rubs him the wrong way and he thinks it's funny to mock her by calling her a man. I have seen him question the gender of other women, though. I don't think he would physically harm anyone. He's not the type. He's just kind of a jerk and, sadly, I have to work with him a lot and I'm not in a position to mock him or do anything more than quickly change the subject.

Years ago I worked on a play about a transsexual (Charlemagne by Sarah Miles) and there was, naturally, a bit of interest from the trans community in the work. Every night, there were a couple of techs at the theatre who would play the "is she or isn't she" game, but it wasn't as mean spirited as this teacher is. I was out today in androgynous mode and I'm finally getting to the point that even if strangers notice that my jeans are ladies styled (flare legged...Old Navy rocks!), they wouldn't say anything to me and, if they did, so what? While there may be some gender dicks out there, so long as they keep it to themselves, it doesn't bother me one bit, so I don't have to think about it. I wish I didn't have to work with it though.

Gin

Link to comment

I was detained by one of these crotch police in a restroom. He had always been suspicious of me and came barging in as I was trying to exit and ordered me to pull my pants down. He said if I didn't he would "throw me out the (4th floor) window". So I started screaming, people came running down the hallway, and he ran. That was a couple years ago. Once some guy kept walking by me, back and forth, trying to flirt with me and I was ignoring him because he was gross. Then he got mad and walked right up to me and got within inches of me and started to stare at my face. Then he started to examine every detail and finally said, "are you a man or a woman?" I said, "I'm somebody who knows how to mind her own business and you don't have permission to speak to me". He just walked off mumbling and looking like he had been hit in the head with a lead pipe!

Link to comment

Wow Nova, that sounds pretty scary! I don't think I would be able to stop myself from punching those types of people in the stomach.

I have been asked on multiple occasions if I was a guy or girl, and I always answer, "It doesn't matter" or "none of your business" or something similar. Oh, the stigma.

Whenever I DO pass if a teacher thinks I am male and calls me by the correct pronouns, there will have to always be some idiot gender cup cake to stand up and yell "THAT'S A GIRL I'M GOING TO CRUSH YOUR DREAMS AHAHAHAHAH!" :|

Whywhywhy are people so insecure that they have to tightly categorize people, and just CAN'T stand it if anyone is anywhere close from being the perfect stereotype of those categories?

Link to comment
Guest ChloëC

"Whywhywhy are people so insecure that they have to tightly categorize people, and just CAN'T stand it if anyone is anywhere close from being the perfect stereotype of those categories?"

I don't think it's so much a perfect stereotype as a fear of someone being a deviation from what some people consider as normal. Some of the reasons they 'hate' us is that they fear us, like people fear anything that is different - color of one's skin, religion, part of the country, economic status. It just goes on and on. If ts/tg people are allowed to be, these insecure people will have to wonder about their own spouse/significant other/themselves. A lot just don't ever want to have to go there.

Also, I think some people are just born with a 'hate' gene and as certain segments of life get closed off to them to 'hate' because the law (and society in general) says you can't do that anymore, they will turn to still safe groups to attack, like ts/tg people.

The example I often use, is - I'm walking down the street minding my own business and a dog sees me and barks at me until I am way out sight. I'm walking down another street and a cat sees me and instead of meowing at me, finds somewhere else to be. Which is the more civilized/mature/intelligent? Which would I rather try be a friend to? It's not even close.

Chloë

Link to comment
Guest Miss Aeryn

Sphere, that would have been the least of my response(s).

Suffering bullying and multiple mild-concussions since the age of four through four different schools over 15 years certainly taught me to defend my space, my body, my life. I study kung-fu. Opened up a whole new world.

I'm what you call a believer of dis-proportionate response. The trick is knowing what level of violence to use and when to stop, that can be justified/explained rationally in a court of law as justifiable self-defence, Your Honour...

Link to comment

Hi Gin,

It really melts my head the amount of freakin idiots out there.

I dont have a problem with innocent mistakes, I do that constantly

much to my embarasment , (read back some of my stuff :blush: )

but some folk out there are up to no good and that makes me mad.

That rear end for brains would be outa my circle of friends pronto.

Take care hun, Luv,viv :)

Link to comment
Guest NatashaJade
That rear end for brains would be outa my circle of friends pronto.

Sadly, he's not in my circle of friends but in a very inner circle of coworkers (just the kind I cannot afford to tip off at any point in the near future). Fortunately, the conversations we have generally are not about the trans community and its possible members.

Gin

Link to comment
Guest Joanna Phipps

I think that most of their problem is that we upset so many apple carts with being transsexual. Face it we were raised with the concept that you are male or female and that is it. Then later on we discover the truth and take the stand ok, that maybe so but I need to switch which one I am. They stand there with their beliefs shaken to the core and their psyche crumbling and can only think of one thing to do, try to ruin our lives because their world view was too narrow to accept that gender (or sex as they might say) is a spectrum, not two fixed points.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   8 Members, 0 Anonymous, 102 Guests (See full list)

    • Ivy
    • Susie
    • Thea
    • awkward-yet-sweet
    • Maddee
    • April Marie
    • Amy Powell
    • BobbiSkunk
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.8k
    • Total Posts
      770.8k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,132
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Kay3Seven
    Newest Member
    Kay3Seven
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. atlantis63
      atlantis63
    2. Blackberry015
      Blackberry015
    3. blackcatkittycat
      blackcatkittycat
      (32 years old)
    4. Charlize
      Charlize
      (76 years old)
    5. GamerGirlEmily
      GamerGirlEmily
      (25 years old)
  • Posts

    • Vidanjali
      Geez sorry for the repeated text in my 2nd paragraph. I have no idea how that happened. Cheers.
    • Vidanjali
      If your back hurts when you cycle you ought to consider getting your bike professionally adjusted at a bike shop. They will measure your body proportions, stride, knee angle, etc. to determine how best to adjust your saddle and handle bars. Sometimes even minor adjustments can make a huge difference.    Unless you have health-based restrictions, I'd say ride as much as you like. But as stated above, first tIf your back hurts when you cycle you ought to consider getting your bike professionally adjusted at a bike shop. They will measure your body proportions, stride, knee angle, etc. to determine how best to adjust your saddle and handle bars. Sometimes even minor adjustments can make a huge difference.    I used to be an avid cyclist. Not into group rides or speed, but I used to ride by myself for hours. It's very enjoyable. If you're looking to improve your cardio health, get a fitness tracker like a fitbit which tracks your heart rate. I do have health issues and for that reason no longer ride on the road. But I converted my bike into a stationary bike very easily with a magnet powered stand which was about 50 bucks. My physical therapist gave me a HIIT (high intensity interval training) schedule to follow tailored to one of my health issues. My case is specific and unfortunately it's a challenge for me to balance getting enough cardio exercise without pushing myself into post-exertional malaise. But I can share with you a general guidine to try to amp up your cardio tolerance.   Determine your "recovery pace" and "base pace" heart rate. There are guidelines online you can find to figure that out based on your age, weight, and other qualities. Then track your heart rate as you ride and develop muscle memory for how much exertion corresponds to those paces. For example, base pace should feel like effort, but not strain. Recovery pace should feel easy, but like you're still in control of propelling the bike. In this way you'll develop better intuition for your bike's gears, especially at different inclines.   Give yourself a 5 minute warm up to get your heart rate to the high end of your resting pace. Then alternate base pace (effort but no strain, keeping your heart rate within a higher range, but backing off if it gets too high) with resting pace (allowing heart rate to lower, but maintaining it just below the low end of base pace) in 4 minute intervals. Finish with 5 minutes cool down allowing your heart rate to lower towards the lower end of resting pace. If you try this type of HIIT routine, your basic workout can be 5 (warmup) +4 (base pace) +4 (resting pace) +4 (base pace) +5 (cool down) =22 minutes. Try it twice a week. Then as you develop endurance, add another 4+4 (resting followed by base) min pair before the cool down.   I hope you are able to get your bike adjusted to be pain free & learn to enjoy cycling and enjoying better overall health.
    • Willow
      Well my day at work is done.  It was a beautiful day here so far.     Yes @Mirrabooka the United States is noted for the tornados and extreme destruction they cause.  We have long wide open areas between the Rocky Mountains and the Appalachian Mountains where weather extremes have a chance to buildup.  Even East of the Appalachians since those mountains are so old and eroded they aren’t very tall anymore.  Geologist say that early in the history of our planet they were as tall as the tallest mountains on earth but now few reach 4000 feet.   But they have no mercy for anything when they get going.   Our continent has just about everything, earthquakes fire floods hurricanes mud slides rock slides, hurricanes blizzards drought dust storms just about everything thing nature can possibly through at us.
    • Ladypcnj
      Nope, I'm not being paranoid, I had screen shot everything that happened to me, before it got taken down to cover up what they sent me in an email. I contacted group leaders within our community, and I explained and showed some of the evidence, next they referred to contact an attorney within the community. I had not called the lawyer back hoping things would settle down. In the meantime, just recently an  lbtqai+ community held a Zoom meeting, as I explained my story. The board is thinking about getting a guest speaker on how we can be safe online.
    • Ladypcnj
      Hi Ashley, check out the michael kors purses, they have the MK logo on it. 
    • Ivy
      True unfortunately. I do see a bit of difference between gender issues and sexuality, although they are related and frequently overlap.  Hardly a reason to fight with each other though.
    • Davie
      Bless you and the light you show this world, @Sally Stone   —Davie
    • Ivy
      I have maybe 4.  I tend to carry the same one for a long time.  2 of them are from Gypsy Rose that I got from a friend that was running a "hippie" boutique at the time.  They are just big enough to be able to slip my Mac book air in with the other stuff. I do have a plain green one, and a beat-up old leather one that I actually used sometimes as a guy when I could get away with it.  (another tell that I managed to ignore up till I couldn't) This thread is kinda making me think I might expand my collection.  A nice leather bag would be sweet.  But I am a bit particular.  Humm……
    • Davie
    • BobbiSkunk
      Greetings all!   I am looking at bringing some cycling time into my weekly exercise, but honestly, right now my back just murders me when I try to do anything more than 10 minutes.   What that being said, I do have some questions for those here, if anyone is willing to answer.  ^.^   Do you cycle as part of exercise? If so, how much? How difficult is the route you take? What are your ultimate goals?   I'll go first.   I do, but only once a week. Once a week for roughly 15 minutes. I use a very flat, low resistance route. My ultimate goals are to keep the rump and thigh thickness, while working some cardio into the routine to keep it interesting.   I'm asking for advice on what is a good starter range, as I'm not sure if I'm just causing myself discomfort without any benefit with the above routines.
    • MAN8791
      SIGHTLINES   I worship at the point of a gun On Friday nights and Sunday mornings. I pray for peace under the watchful eye of hired men With guns holstered on their hips Who laugh with us Eat with us Pray with us -      Dear God, not tonight      Not this morning      Not my friends      Please, not on my watch And I'm fully aware of the irony of the statement Because too often, our ancestors were forced to pray At the point of a gun because they said the wrong prayers In the wrong languages Loved the wrong person Identified the wrong way But today, I do so of my own free will. When I leave, I say thank you -      That it wasn't tonight      It wasn't this morning      It didn't happen while I sang      It wasn't my friends Because this week the guns stayed silent. But next week and next week and weeks afterward Could be the week that guns point in, not out And I can't will myself to believe it could never happen here because      Someone tried to bomb my Temple,       Someone set it on fire,      Someone shot up the clinic where I go for healthcare      Someone shot up the club my friends danced at So when I pray, I offer a wish to the universe That guns be melted into musical instruments and works of art. If someone wishes to shoot me, They will have to beat works of art into tools for the hand Before they can become instruments of war again.
    • MaeBe
      This is important for us all to keep really close to our hearts, especially as we go through a doubting phase or anxiety wave. I always go to the joy I have found being who I am, a person that does not conform with my birth assignment and the gender I defaulted to for many years. That places me under the trans umbrella and I need to feel comfortable and confident about that.   I am so glad you were able to deal with this person and others that confronted you with grace and poise. It seems like this person targeted your session specifically, they didn't want anything from it but to be a thorn in your side. I highly doubt she was there to expand her worldview. It is hard when your goal is to get through the content and someone wants to make the session a dialogue with them only. Challenges to our worldviews are important, they help us shape and define our beings, but that doesn't mean we have to deal with gatekeeping and hate.   I wish there was more content like your session available out there. I understand recording such content is a touchy subject, with the speakers and audience being general targets, but gosh it would be nice. I volunteered at the Time to Thrive event for HRC and got to sit in a few sessions, both as a moderator and a couple just as a participant, and it was very energizing. Thank you for being out there any speaking your truth, @Sally Stone!
    • Ivy
      There are all kinds of us. My situation at the time enabled me to begin living full time as a woman, and get onto hormones.  I realize everyone doesn't have that option - or want it. I also realize there are people who would consider me not truly transgender because I haven't had the surgery, and probably never will. Whatever…
    • Vidanjali
      Yeah. Trans folk still cannot update or renew FL drivers licenses. Florida part of the lawsuit against updated trans student Title IX protections. Florida suing Biden admin over ban on discrimination in healthcare based on gender.  Despite injunctions for individuals of some things including trans youth healthcare and using affirmed pronouns in school, bans still in place. The list goes on. Honestly I have stopped keeping up with news as much as I used to for the good of my mental health. Peace, y'all.  
    • Sally Stone
      Post 14 “I’m not Trans Enough”   I have mentioned in other posts my affiliation with the Keystone Conference in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania.  For several years, I facilitated a conference workshop titled “Making the Most of Part-time Womanhood.”  Each time I ran the workshop, it was standing room only, so I know for a fact, the idea resonates with many.   When I originally planned the workshop the target audience was geared towards girls like me, those who weren’t planning permanent transition.  I also expected to attract girls who may have been on the path to permanent transition but because of timing or life circumstances couldn’t.  What I didn’t expect as part of my attracted audience were hecklers and naysayers.  Thankfully, I only had to deal with a couple of those, but it only takes one to ruin everybody’s day.   Sadly, there exists a radical fringe that has permeated our community from the beginning.  The fringe mindset holds to the idea that being a trans woman means you were born a woman trapped in a man’s body, and the only recourse is to live as a woman fulltime.  Anything or anyone not fully aligned with this idea, is a threat to real trans women.  Apparently, my lifestyle choice, and my workshop were just the kind of threats that needed to be eliminated.   I was several minutes into the workshop, had just given a short overview of what I was going to cover when one person told me I should make certain everyone in attendance knew that I wasn’t speaking on behalf of trans women, that instead, I should be quite clear that I was speaking as a crossdresser.  The comment caught me off guard initially, but I rallied pretty quickly and tried to remind this person that the term transgender was an umbrella term that covered a wide spectrum.    Of course, she wanted to argue the point and went on to point out that since I was not going to live my life as a woman on a fulltime basis, I couldn’t be transgender, and then adding cruelty to her rhetoric, she reminded me and my audience that I was nothing more than a man in a dress.    I’m pretty non-confrontational most of the time, but her comments really pushed my buttons.  I could feel my defensive hackles raising and I knew I had to be careful not to stoop to her level.  So, instead of any stinging retorts, and believe me, I was thinking of many, I took the high road and as politely as I could, informed her that if she continued to disrupt the workshop, I would have her removed.  She responded by telling me she was going to report me and my workshop to the conference organizers.  I told her reporting me was her prerogative, and actually encouraged her to do it immediately as a way of getting her out of the room.   She didn’t take the bait and stayed for the entire workshop.  Thankfully, there were no further outbursts, but she used all sorts of overt body language to show her displeasure with my blasphemous views.  When the workshop ended, she cornered me and continued to berate me, insisting I was a simple crossdresser that tended to make real trans women look bad.  I wanted to just let things go, but her cruel comments had pushed me too far, so I reported her to the conference staff.  I figured if she had targeted my workshop, it was likely she would target others.  Conference officers informed her that her views were outdated, bigoted, and not in keeping with the conference’s commitment to inclusiveness.  She was reminded that by persisting in voicing those kinds of views and being disruptive, she wouldn’t be welcome at the conference.   I facilitated this particular workshop for four-years, and thankfully, this was the only serious confrontation I experienced.  However, there were others that espoused similar views, only they didn’t raise their disagreements to a confrontational level.  It bothers me immensely that some within our own community, would seek to marginalize another trans person.  Of course, I’m not naïve enough to think our community would be any different than society as a whole.  Sadly, there will always be some (only a few, thankfully) who inflate their sense of self-worth by putting down others.   It's difficult enough dealing with a general population that doesn’t understand us, but when we are attacked by our own, it tends to hurt even more, and it can cause us to question ourselves.  Ultimately, we cannot let others tell us who we are, and certainly, we cannot let them decide if we are trans enough.  Being transgender is being transgender, period.  Yes, we can be different, but we must remember there is no measurement that ranks how trans we are.   Hugs,   Sally
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...