Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Safe Kind Of Estrogen Vs Herbal Estrogen


Guest chinee

Recommended Posts

Guest chinee

This is something new to me that there are so called "herbal estrogen" that us MTF should get rid off on HRT. I was not aware that "estrofem" is one of the herbal estrogens. My doctor prescribe this estrofem for my estrogen. I am only 1 month old in HRT. So on my next appointment I will ask my doctor to change my estrogen if this "estrofem" is really a herbal thing and if this herbal estrogen is really bad for HRT among MTF.

Some say on other thread that estradiol valerate is the estrogen that most prescribe in US by doctors to MTF patients. Please confirm this if all the things I stated here are correct and valid. I was not aware that there are kinds of estrogen like this and I thought when you say bioidentical/natural like from plants are safer but now I am scared because of the things I read here about herbal estrogens.

Girls please share the kind of estrogen you are taking and what method (transdermal/oral/inject) and if you know supporting facts about the issue I stated above, feel free to share it here. :)

by the way, this is the picture of the estrofem my doctor prescribe

http://www.bestdrug.org/estrofem_l.jpg

Link to comment

Hello Chinee,

The products sold in the Philippines may differ from what's sold here in the USA. Possibly your doctor is prescribing the right thing. Please check with your doctor if you have questions.

Love, Meg

Link to comment
Guest chinee

the packaging might be different but when I check the content, it is the same with the contents we are talking about here... but I will be asking this questions to my doctor on my next appointment. For now, I want to be enlighten first by your experiences and facts about these estrogens so that i could enumerate this to my endo.

Link to comment
Guest Maria_B

I know there is two different estrofems

One is herbal one is synthetic. Not sure which is which, though.

I think the herbal is EstroFem. But don't take my word for it, I'm not a doctor.

Ask yours about it.

Link to comment
Guest Miss_Construe

according to wikipedia: EstroFem = Esterdiol valerate

EstroFem is prescription only so is approved by the FDA as Oestradiol according to UnitedPharmacies.com

hope that helps.

April

Link to comment
Guest Julie T

Chinee

Honey check with your doctor, but this question has been asked. My research first showed Estrofem was an herbal phytoestrogen. But later I retracted that as in certain areas of world there is an Estrofem that is a true estrogen. Apparently the herbal is a rip-off of the name and puts a space in the middle "Estro Fem." So again, you are probably okay, but talk to your doctor.

Julie

Link to comment
Guest Alainaluvsu

There are 2 different types of what you are referring to. Estrofem is the real deal containing oestrogen. EstroFem is the phytoestrogen.

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean

There are 2 different types of what you are referring to. Estrofem is the real deal containing oestrogen. EstroFem is the phytoestrogen.

That is how I understand it, too....

But...see your doctor....ok?

Huggs

Dee Jay

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

I guess there's more than one Estrofem. I was reading the ingredients of Estrofem made by Hitech and it's green tea extract, Black cohosh and other herbal stuff. I also found the one which you had a pic of and the ingredients were didn't appear to be herbal based.

Link to comment
Guest Sascha

Estradiol isn't a herb, but there is a slight catch.

What many people do not realize is that most estradiol for a HRT regimen are synthesized copies from herbs with a few exceptions such as estradiol valerate which is completely created in a laboratory. I hope I didn't confuse you yet? bare with me... The synthetics or the synthesized do not have the same metabolites as the pure herbs because they are purified and synthesized, meaning: all the bad stuff is removed. The synthesized copies are bio-identical, and if not, they are altered to be identical to the human body.

If you notice this list, you will see what I mean:

Synthesized from herbs

Micronized estradiol/Estrace

Estradiol/Alora

Estradiol/Climara

Estradiol/Estraderm

Estradiol/Fem Patch

Estradiol/Vivelle, Vivelle-Dot

Estradiol/Estring

Esterified estrogens (estrone, equilin)

Esterified estrogens (estrone, equillin)

Micronized estradiol/Estrace

Estropipate/Ogen

Estropipate/Ortho

Ethinyl estradiol/Estinyl

Synthesized from animals

Conjugated estrogens/Premarin

Now, as you can see Ethinylestradiol also comes from herbs, I do not say which herbs, but they are. So if you take the herbs they are in, you are basically playing Russian Roulette since it's one of the most potent and dangerous estrogen which can kill you. That's why herbs are dangerous. Point being, if you take herbs you will get secondary metabolites and elevated triglycerides which in term can create havoc in your liver, and may result in liver failure, liver cirrhosis, deep vein thrombosis and strokes.

Be-aware.

Love,

Sasha.

Link to comment
Guest chinee

^

so you mean to say micronized estradiol such as estrace/estrofem are synthesized and not herbal. Meaning they are not risky for internal organs like liver?

Link to comment
  • 1 month later...
Guest Sascha

Hi Chinee,

Both are produced from herbs. They are a by-product from the extraction of herbs, which produces an oily substance. I wrote a letter to one manufacturer and they confirmed the herbal origin of estradiol they produce. But, while it has a herbal origin, it is not bio-identical. They make it bio-idential for the human body in a laboratory by modifying it's molecular structure, so it's semi-synthetic. So natural does not mean bio-identical. That's the key issue. because if you take a bunch of herbs you actually aren't getting the bio-identical hormones and are in a greater risk of secondary metabolites, such as ethinylestradiol which causes a warped lipid profile. That's why raw herbs pose a greater risk than the (semi) synthetics. So It's not a 100% synthetic, as another petrochemical substance would be.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   8 Members, 0 Anonymous, 125 Guests (See full list)

    • MAN8791
    • April Marie
    • Ivy
    • Abigail Genevieve
    • MaryEllen
    • Thea
    • Stefi
    • Petra Jane
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.8k
    • Total Posts
      769.6k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,077
    • Most Online
      8,356

    AmandaJoy
    Newest Member
    AmandaJoy
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Angel Jamie
      Angel Jamie
      (24 years old)
    2. CallMeKeira
      CallMeKeira
      (31 years old)
    3. CamtheMan
      CamtheMan
    4. Jona
      Jona
      (22 years old)
    5. jpek
      jpek
  • Posts

    • Timber Wolf
      Hi Amanda, Welcome to Transpulse. I'm glad you're here.   Lots of love and a big welcome hug,, Timber Wolf 🐾
    • Thea
      Do we have any programmers in the house?! I'm a computer hobbyist. I mainly write code in C and javascript. 
    • Timi
      Hi Amanda! Thank you for sharing.    -Timi
    • KathyLauren
      Around here, a culturally-appropriate gender-neutral form of address is either "dear" or "hun".  It tends to be mostly women who use those, though I did have a man address me as "dear" in a store today.    It could be startling for a come-ffrom-away to hear themselves being addressed that way, but, locally, it is considered a friendly, not particularly creepy, gender-neutral way to address someone.
    • Lydia_R
    • April Marie
      Welcome, Amanda!! You'll find many of us here who found ourselves late in life - it was at 68 for me. Each of us is unique but we also have similarities and can help each other   I understand the urge to move quickly, but remember that your wife also has to adjust as you transition. That doesn't mean you have to move slowly, just give both of you time to process the changes and the impacts.   Many of us have also benefitted greatly from working with a gender therapist. For me, it was literally life-saving. Just a thought you might want to consider. Mine is done completely on-line.   Again, welcome. Jump in where you feel comfortable.
    • MAN8791
      Change. I am so -censored- tired of change, and what I've just started in the last month with identifying and working through all of my . . . stuff . . . around gender dysphoria represents a level of change I dread and am terrified of.   2005 to 2019 feel like a pretty stable time period for me. Not a whole lot of change happened within me. I met someone, got married, had three kids with them. Struggled like hell with anxiety and depression but it was . . . ok. And then my spouse died (unexpectedly, brief bout with flu and then gone) and the five years since have been an unrelenting stream of change. I cannot think of a single way in which I, the person writing this from a library table in 2024, am in any way the same person who sat in an ICU room with my dying spouse 5 years ago. I move different, speak different, dress different, think different, have different goals, joys, and ambitions. And they are all **good.** but I am tired of the relentless pace of change and as much as I want and need to figure out my dysphoria and what will relieve the symptoms (am I "just" gender fluid, am I trans masc? no -censored- clue at the moment) I dread it at the same time. I just want to take a five year nap and be done with it.
    • VickySGV
      Welcome to the Forums Amanda, there are a number of us here who took that long or longer to come to grips with our personal reality.  Join right in and enjoy the company you have.
    • AmandaJoy
      I'm Amanda, and after 57 years of pretending to be a male crossdresser, I've recently admitted to myself that I'm a woman. It's pretty wild. I don't think that I've ever had a thought that was as clearly true and right, as when I first allowed myself to wonder, "wait, am I actually trans?"   The hilarious part is that I owe that insight to my urologist, and a minor problem with a pesky body part that genetic women don't come equipped with (no, not that one). I'll spare you the details, but the end result was him talking about a potential medication that has some side effects, notably a 1% chance of causing men to grow breasts. The first thought that bubbled up from the recesses of my mind was, "wow, that would be awesome!"   <<blink>><<blink>> Sorry, what was that again?   That led down a rabbit hole, and a long, honest conversation with myself, followed by a long, honest conversation with my wife. We both needed a couple of weeks, and a bit of crying and yelling, to settle in to this new reality. Her biggest issue? Several years ago, she asked me if I was trans, and I said, "no". That was a lie. And honestly, looking back over my life, a pretty stupid one.   I'm really early in the transition process - I have my first consultation with my doctor next week - but I'm already out to friends and family. I'm struggling with the "do everything now, now now!" demon, because I know that this is not a thing that just happens. It will be happening from now on, and trying to rush won't accomplish anything useful. Still, the struggle is real . I'm being happy with minor victories - my Alexa devices now say, "Good morning, Amanda", and I smile each and every time. My family and friends are being very supportive, after the initial shock wore off.   I'm going to need a lot of help though, which is another new thing for me. Being able to ask for help, that is. I'm looking forward to chatting with some of you who have been at this longer, and also those of you who are as new at this as I am. It's wild, and intoxicating, and terrifying... and I'm looking forward to every second of it.   Amanda Joy
    • RaineOnYourParade
      Yep, that's the one :P    Smoothies are criminally underrated imo
    • Ivy
      Rain here. I went to Asheville yesterday, and stayed later to visit some before going down the mountain.  Down here there were a lot of trees down in the northern part of the county.  The power had gone off at the house, but was back by the time I got home (21:00).  There was a thunderstorm during the night.
    • Birdie
      I used to get ma'am'ed during my 45 years of boy-mode and it drove me nuts.    Now that I have accepted girl-mode I find it quite pleasant.    Either way, being miss gendered is quite disturbing. I upon a rare occasion might get sir'ed by strangers and it's quite annoying. 
    • Mmindy
      Good morning Ash,    Welcome to TransPulseForums, I have a young neighbor who plays several brass instruments who lives behind my house. He is always practicing and I could listen to them for hours, well I guess I have listened to them for hours, and my favorite is when they play the low tones on the French Horn.    Best wishes,   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋
    • Mmindy
      Good morning everyone,    I had my first cup of coffee this morning with my wife, my second was a 20oz travel mug on the way to the airport. Once clearing TSA, I bought another 20oz to pass the time at the boarding gate. I’m flying Indy to Baltimore, then driving to Wilmington, DE for my last teaching engagement at the DE State Fire School.    Hugs,   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋    
    • Vidanjali
      In my opinion, the gender neutral version of sir or ma'am is the omission of such honorifics.   "Excuse me, sir" becomes simply, "Excuse me", or better yet, "Excuse me, please."   "Yes, ma'am" becomes "Yes", or depending on the context, "Yes, it would be my pleasure" or "Yes, that is correct."   Else, to replace it with a commonly known neutral term such as friend, or credentialed or action-role-oriented term depending on the situation such as teacher, doctor, driver, or server.   And learn names when you can. It's a little known fact that MOST people are bad with names. So if you've ever told someone, "I'm bad with names", you're simply affirming you're typical in that way. A name, just like any other factoid, requires effort to commit to memory. And there are strategies which help. 
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...