Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

The Gender Recognition Bill


Guest Zenda

Recommended Posts

Kia Ora

Umm I'm beginning to like this poll set up...I wonder how long that will last...

I have put this in the general forum because not all trans-people who wish to live full time in their preferred would call themselves 'transsexual'

I know to some, this may sound like a weird question to ask, but I was surprised to find that not all trans-people are fully supportive of this…

The British government passed the ‘Gender Recognition Bill back in 2004.

The act was in fully swing late 2005…What this meant was transgender people regardless of whether they have had bottom surgery or not were entitled to be fully recognised in their socially acquired/affirmed gender...

All that a trans person was required to do was to have been diagnosed with gender dysphoria and have been living full time[name change and HRT] in their affirmed gender for a minimum period of two years…And sign the necessary documents stating that they would live out the rest of their lives as their acquired gender…

Now I personally would have taken it for granted that ‘all’ trans-people around the world would be fully supportive of such an act being past by their governments…But was shocked to find that some trans-people were dead set against such a thing happening…Two trans women that I know[both happen to have had their surgery] have said that they didn’t believe that a trans-person who has not had genital surgery should be legally recognised as their affirmed gender…

This would mean that the gender on their birth certificate could not be changed, meaning they would have no legal rights such as to marry the person of their choice[if they were heterosexual] nor could they obtain a passport in their acquired gender if they wish to travel overseas or go ‘stealth’ job wise if they were fortunate enough to blend in…

Those of you who have already had or are planning to have surgery[can afford to] would you support such a bill?

And those who can’t have surgery for whatever reasons medical or finance, do you think such a bill would be a good thing?

Happy mindfulness

Metta Jendar :)

Link to comment
Guest Christine-Louise

Hi Jendar,

As I live in the UK and have My gender recognition and birth certificate, I have to say that it was well worth waiting for, The Gender Recognition Bill that is, for without it I wouldn't have all the benefits that I now get (The likes of a Female Pension), even though I cannot have any surgery for medical reasons, I am one of those that consider themselves extremely lucky to be in My position, I get everything that I could have ever wanted, apart from Genital Surgery, I should add that I have had five yes five heart attacks, and also suffer from Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, I have an assurance that if I undergo Surgery there is an 95% certainty of death as a result, also they can't find an Anesthetist willing to take Me on anyway with those percentages, but I am happy to get as far as I have been able to get, I don't do too badly to get chatted up by Men though I don't let it get out of hand, as I have no interest in a relationship not at My age, I am happy just Lucy and I.

So in conclusion I would like to say just what a wonderful thing that (The Gender Recognition Bill) is, and that there should be something similar everywhere.

Link to comment

I could say that I would oppose it because without it, you would be required to think more about your decisions before making them. No acting on impulse here. With it, you could easily get far into the process before realizing you made a mistake.

Link to comment

I'd definitely support such a bill, although I do have a transsexual friend who is opposed to it (interestingly, she is post-op. I wonder if she'd feel the same if she was still pre-op). At the end of the day, I don't need a birth certificate saying "female" to validate my gender identity, but of course, it would make things so much easier if I did have that legal recognition.

Link to comment
Guest lisa49

I think they should remove gender from all legal documents. It is just a form of discrimination. Any two people should have a right to marry. Besides there are people born that do not fit the definition of one gender or the other. Let us do away with binary discrimination. With today's records on computers there is no such thing as 100% stealth.

Link to comment

Kia Ora Haythrox and others.

:rolleyes: First I would like to apologise to all…I thought I had set up a proper poll, but I must have clicked the wrong icon, but this seems to be working just fine…

An act such as the GRA would not have any impact on those who have had or can afford to have surgery…But would greatly improve the quality of life for those who can not for whatever reason….

By opposing such a bill don’t you[Haythorx] think you would be condemning people in a similar situation to Christine Louise to a life of awkward, embarrassing, moments, for example, when people in her position need to present legal documents which state their birth sex ?

The British Gender Recognition Panel [working with the help of the local trans-community] had to come up with what they believe to be a just and workable model, that would not be seen as discriminatory, but with conditions in place that would to a certain extent safe guard one against making a mistake that could cause much grief …a loss that could not be retrieved…

Those trans-people who have not had bottom surgery and obtain this recognition, if they change their minds and decide a life of the opposite sex is not for them-apart from the effects of HRT, their bottom male/female parts are still in tacked…

It’s possible the British government, not just out of compassion but also for economical reasons passed this bill- In the UK for people who pass all the evaluations, psychiatric assessments and the RLE [set out and approved by the necessary health authorities] G.A.S[gender affirming surgery] is government funded-costing the tax payer thousands upon thousands of pounds a year… It’s possible some trans-people may not necessarily want surgery but feel they must have it done to be ‘legally’ recognised in their acquired gender… I feel that the British government has giving the long suffering trans-person a ‘choice’ and it is a choice… One does not have to apply for this recognition if ones does not want too…

The Gender Recognition Act has now made it an equal playing field for the haves and the have nots…and the cans and the can nots...

But again some of you might still see things quite differently and that’s your prerogative and I hope you will share your reason/s why…

Happy mindfulness and may such a bill be past by all governments

Metta Jendar :)

Link to comment
Guest Christine-Louise

I would like to add that for those like Myself who apply for Gender Recognition on Medical grounds, that there is a six year period of transition before you can apply, with proof that you have lived in the preferred gender for all of that time, a panel of people not all medically trained sit and discuss every application on merit, and as long as you can satisfy them that you are genuine you get passed to the next stage, and I have to say that not everyone gets through, I used to have a friend who didn't so it's not a foregone conclusion, after surgery She re/applied and was accepted, all in all it's not quite as simple as it might sound.

Link to comment

Sorry for the misunderstanding, I didn't mean to say that I oppose it, but if I was, this would be the reason. Any politics regarding trans issues is a wacky world. It's not very simple. I don't really have a stance concerning this, if I was to oppose it, I would because of decision making related issues. It may be reversible, but it still would be a hassle (being recognized as a man then a woman then a man again). If I was to support it, probably because the actual surgery is just a physical modification and not a true reflection of the person.

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...
Guest Sarah Marie

Once again the UK is way ahead of the US in humane domestic policies. This law is very definitely needed here in the US for several reasons. First, until reassignment surgery is completed, one's gender marker cannot be changes on most legal documents and records, including those maintained by Social Security. Second, until such a law is passed, male to female transsexuals (in particular) face serious problems with proper public restroom usage. Just last year a trasnssexual fully dressed as her female self was arrested and charged with disturbing the peace in Boise, ID after being seen entering a women's restroom. If written right, such a law could address this dilemma.

What I feel is needed in this country is a new Federal law, similar to the UK law, that mandates the issuance of gender identity-conforming photo IDs (driver's licence or state ID card) by all states. Otherwise there are states (Idaho is definitely one) that will never address these issues.

Sarah Marie

Link to comment

I tend to believe that the government should have less control of our lives, and thus I don't think we need several new laws requiring people to act certain ways. It would be nice if people could just act they way they were made to act...

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...

is it just me or is haythorox something im not seeing? behave as we are supposed to act as men and women from birth? your advocating that on a trans site i smell something fishy here....

Link to comment
  • Root Admin

We all smelled something fishy. That's why Haythrox has been banned from the site.

Link to comment
  • Root Admin

A lot went on behind the scenes that the general membership didn't see. The banning was justified.

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean

Thanks, Mary Ellen, for keeping an eye out....I know that you see lots behind the scenes that we don't get the chance to see and would most likely be really p.o. ed if they were posted. I know that you try to be as fair as possible.....everyone must remember that this is not a democracy, that this is Laura's site and she makes the rules- some decorum must apply. We are all guests here....check out many of the polls and discussions..all views are allowed as long as it is kept civil and clean. All sides and opinions are chatted about.

Thanks, Mary Ellen for keeping it a great site..... ;)

Peace

Donna Jean

Link to comment

No doubt. I mean "act the way you were made to act"??? How far do you need it to go to be called transbashing? Thats not the purpose of this site. This site belongs in fact to Laura and in spirit to the trans people. ...I feel like waving a flag.

Link to comment

Kia Ora,

:rolleyes: Hey guys, Haythorx came out in the wash[feedback] just like the other 'stains' in this forum have done and no doubt will continue to do so...But some of you still haven't said what you think about such a bill being past in your country??? I'm still waiting!!! ;)

Happy Mindfulness and may the stain removers continue to do their good work...

Metta Jendar :)

Link to comment
Guest Nekomata

I would support it. It would be nice to live in a world where people don't have to take hormones or surgery and be treated as their target gender. Even if the bill was passed it doesn't mean I'd change my personal choices, though. I like the hormones because of what they do for my mood and personality, and I would still want SRS to stop bad hormones from flowing in, for body conformity, and so I could have intercourse the way I want.

Link to comment

i would support it for sure. because let's face it, most of the FTM surgeries suck and i don't want to have an 'F' on my birth certificate for the rest of my life just because doctors can't give me a functional penis that isn't smaller than a mini hot-dog. that's my own selfish reason but i do also believe that it would greatly benefit those who can't have surgery for medical reasons or just don't want surgery. i'm all for it.

Link to comment

Ditto what Drew said. I definately would be for it too. Me choosing to have surgery shouldn't mandate everybody have the same choice. And its especially unfair to those that can't.

....now all we gotta do is figure out how to keep folks who aren't living as given gender from claiming they are so that they can avoid or obtain god only knows what....like being drafted.

Then agian, most of those things shouldn't be gender exclusive anyhoow. :P

Link to comment
  • 3 weeks later...
Guest joanna09

There are some very interesting comments here but I must say thanks to Laura and co for sorting out the good from the bad we don't need comments like that here god alone knows all of us know what we have to go through to be what we want to be. I think laws should be past to recognise us after what harm are we doing so I want to be woman big deal thats for me to worry about and as I can see from this site and others the majority of us are law abiding citzens and want to staty that way. As you can see I am from UK and I am glad to see what they have done I know you guys in the states do have your problems and it should not happen, just going off on tangent when out dressed as Joanna very much in the tourist season here in France the only two nationalities who seem to really stare are those from the USA and from England, funny that here in France the French don't really bother just thought I'd mention that, but at the end its each to their own be what you want to be and don't give in its not always easy, but the thought of not being able to go out as Joanna does not bear thinking about.

Fondest Regards

Joanna

Link to comment

I would very definately support such a law. As it stands right now, we don't really have any rights until after the surgery and how you are treated by governemt agencies will depend on how well you pass. A Gender Recognition Act would help to seperate sex from gender. It would be tremendous for a lot of us who might not ever be able to have the surgery for whatever reason. What's between your legs shouldn't run your whole life.

Sally

Link to comment
Guest julia_d

Also from the UK. I find it to be a wonderfully affirming law. It takes transgender out of the "special" category and puts us firmly in the mainstream rights held by the rest of society. Nobody told me I needed to get one of these certificates, and I thought I was going to have to carry the stigma of my birth certificate to my grave.. which would have the wrong name on it. Why I wasn't informed at any time of the need to do this I'm unsure. Thinking that I lived with a post op for 2 years they would have said something, but I found out since that they are against it as many post ops are. I don't understand their thinking as most actually have a certificate.. Is it jealousy or something deeper.. some sort of "I got what I wanted, but I still want to be treated as special so I will try to leave everybody who comes after me in the hell I escaped from"

I don't know, but the one thing I do know after living in my chosen gender now for 8 years is I want one, and as soon as humanly possible.

Link to comment
Guest LauderdaleLady

I am for a version of the Gender Recognition Act in this country. However, the British act seems a little to restrictive. First, why not have the bill apply to all people who are in gender dysphoria therapy, without any waiting period. Secondly, unlike what I think that the British act does, I think that once someone has had gender reassignment surgery (that was the term they used when I got mine), they should be able to amend/change their records so that their records are no different than someone who was born in their desired gender.

But there is another bigger concern here. We need to be able to get the surgery for free or at nominal cost. I was fortunate while I was making my transition that my insurance company through work was willing to cover the surgery (after some prodding). Now, I think that most insurance plans will not cover the cost of the surgery, nor, of course, will our government.

--Janet

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   4 Members, 0 Anonymous, 65 Guests (See full list)

    • Lydia_R
    • MaryEllen
    • BUGFIEND
    • SamC
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.8k
    • Total Posts
      770.2k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,103
    • Most Online
      8,356

    BUGFIEND
    Newest Member
    BUGFIEND
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Ale975
      Ale975
      (27 years old)
    2. BillieB
      BillieB
      (65 years old)
    3. BrokenDays
      BrokenDays
      (34 years old)
    4. Bryson
      Bryson
      (25 years old)
    5. Jolie
      Jolie
  • Posts

    • Lydia_R
      This internet video thing is pretty amazing.  I'd call it Zoom, but there are other platforms out there.  I prefer Zoom over Teams because Zoom puts me and everyone else in the same picture.  I like seeing the whole group in one shot.  Teams of course is about having so many people that you can't get them in the shot, or is it?   Just saying that I have never met any of my counselors in person.  Doctors, of course I have and I am lucky there.  They are 3.5 miles from my house as is the main transgender surgery place in town.  I've been doing virtual visits with the medical doctors lately though.  It feels like once I became steady state, they don't need to interact with me physically that much.  I have enjoyed going into their office in my nice clothing.
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      I guess a lot depends on where you start and where you wanna end up.  For me, doing the "boy form" thing has come with disadvantages.  Smaller skeleton, thinner bones, and skinny/tiny everything.  I'll never be taken seriously.  I guess the advantage is that my way of blending in is just kind of confusing.  "Mommy, is that a boy or a girl?"    One of the biggest arguments for starting transition early in life is I think it gives a person a greater ability to pass.  My two MtF friends started early, and pass really well.  They never got to the larger bone structure, beard, deep voice stuff.  Me being intersex (which is more complicated) and not getting around to "boy form" until my 30's, my body size and features were pretty much set in stone.      You're lucky.  Some folks pay all that and more, even AFTER insurance.  One of my friends faced the choice last year - pay for her final year of college or pay for her meds.  She's taken a year off from college to work and save up money to finish.    My medical expenses have been more injury-related than therapy or medication   The state covered some of it with a fund for crime victims, insurance covered a lot, but there's ended up being a few thousand dollars spent out-of-pocket since 2022 to put me back together again.  I've never found a decent therapist, but my husband has a psych degree among other things, so I figure talking with him is almost as good.  I do have a good doctor, although I have to drive a long way to a big city to see her.  Mostly she takes a basic look at me, and writes another year's prescription.  Since I'm non-op and only using testosterone cream for a localized effect, its pretty simple stuff. 
    • Lydia_R
      I'm a tracker and I've paid for 100% of my transition costs out of pocket.  Counseling was a huge, huge part of my transition and well worth my money.  Not to be uppity about all of this.  I'm just sharing information I have because I have it and it may be useful for others.  Here is my analysis of my spending on transition over the last 2.5 years:   Medical Doctors and Blood Draws: $2,397 Counseling: $3,800 Medications (brand name): $2,702.85 Medications (generic): $485.39 Total: $9,385.24   I picked up on the internet early in transition that transition is a consumer activity.  I tend to agree with that.   This year (Jan - May 18th, 2024), I've spent: Medical Doctors: $102 Medications: $241.52 Total: $343.52   So I'm on a much more sustainable path with it.  I'm pretty happy with where I am with it, although I do still desire surgery and am nervous about how that will all unfold.  But my doctors have me on this steady state thing.  I could seek out other medications, but what I'm doing is good enough.  Oh, I'm missing something....  I did a bunch of electrolysis that didn't appear to have any effect.  I've always enjoyed shaving and I use pink shaving cream now (I've got some lipstick blond in me).  It's good enough.  Not sure if I'll do electro or laser in the future.  The need to shave my body has become less and less.  Before HRT, I was shaving my body weekly or even every 5 days.  Now it is more like 2-3 weeks.  Everyone's body hair is different.  My beard is very coarse and stiff while my body hair has been somewhat minimal and light.  It's nice to have smooth legs and not have to shave as much.   Counseling was $200/session.  I tried one or two counselors before I found one who resonated with where I really was.  When I was prescribed HRT, I didn't fill the prescription until 4 months later.  I had to take some time to decide that I really wanted to take on that lifetime financial commitment.  And of course the possibly negative health consequences too, but I think I was actually thinking more about the finances of it all.  Maybe 51%.   I did a lot of work to revitalize my career before jumping into medical transition.  I started counseling 3 months before I got the best paying job of my life.  The pressure of wanting to transition was so great that I couldn't wait any longer.  She was coming out.  Even though I had very little money, I splurged on some nice dresses and a full length mirror and then started counseling.  Sometimes you just have to move forward and hope for the best.  Other times it is better to wait and do some hard work.  The grace of it all..
    • Ivy
      And when the pressure is released it sucks in heat.  I had a regulator leaking and it was covered with ice.  It's how a heat pump works as well.   Why do they always pick names like this?  It's like the exact opposite of what it really is. I hate politics so much.  But I still have to follow it.
    • Lydia_R
      Wonderful!  This reminds me of a discussion I had with my brother a decade ago.  I said that things expand when they get hotter.  He said, no, they expand when they get colder.  And I had to think about that for a while.  The weird thing is that H20 is special in that when it reaches freezing, it expands.   The pressure makes the cold and then we see the condensation.
    • KatieSC
      I used to have a really good therapist, however, she does not accept health insurance reimbursement fees as they are too low. I had to pay 130 per session. When she decided to jack the rates to 185 per hour, I cut bait. Without a doubt, counseling is very helpful. What concerns me greatly is that we are a vulnerable population. Unfortunately, we can easily be targeted for some pretty high fees. How many of us have been in the situation where our healthcare provider, surgeons, or counselors, have required cash payments? We get jammed as well by the health insurance companies as they often will not pay for items that could be essential to our well-being. It is my contention that our chances of being targeted for violence, death, or harassment, go up when we cannot easily blend in with the female population.    For those of us that are MTF, some of us are blessed with more feminine features, and many of us are not. We get the whammy of a larger skeleton, bigger hands, bigger feet, a beard, a deep voice, and masculine face. It takes a lot for some of us to be able to blend in. My belief is that the better we blend in, the better chance we have of not being targeted. In this, electrolysis, facial feminizing/gender affirming facial surgery, voice/speech therapy with voice feminization/gender affirming voice surgery, and body contouring are all potentially lifesaving. Unfortunately, many of the insurance companies deem the procedures as cosmetic, and yet there is no cosmetic that fixes all of these issues.    If you pay your money, you can get anything you want in this world. The sad reality is that for us, many of these procedures would enhance our lives tremendously, yet we face ongoing battles with our very existence. Yeah, an empathetic therapist helps, but is it just the concept of reasonable empathy at a reasonable cost? When my therapist jacked her rates to 185 per hour, I said enough is enough. Your mileage may vary.
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      I don't think the temperature matters as much.  Think about how gases like CO2 are stored in cylinders, and they are basically the same in summer or winter.  Any gas becomes liquid under enough pressure.  What does matter is the strength of the pressure vessel.  If exposed to excess external heat, pressure increases and can burst a tank or a pipe.  Household propane tanks are often painted white or silver and have safety release valves, because sunlight can heat a tank enough to cause a significant increase in internal pressure, even though the contents remain liquid. 
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      It has been a long week, and I think this weekend is going to be pretty busy.  The high school is having their graduation later today.  Although we don't have any grads in our family this year, my husband is going because he's involved with the school.  And tonight there's the torchlight ceremony for the county cadets who are finishing their program, and the reading of assignments for the new seniors.  One of my stepkids will be a senior this year.  She's talented, and will be assigned a squad leader position.  My husband is really proud of her, and she's well-liked by her peers even though she's very quiet and serious.    I might get to go on a trip to Texas this week.  The storms that hit Houston caused a lot of electrical damage, so no doubt the utilities in that area will be ordering stuff from my husband's company.  When the big hurricane hit Florida in 2022, we made several trips there with badly-needed equipment, and the entire transportation department was involved in the first convoy.  When he travels, I usually want to go along, since 1-on-1 time is kind of rare for us. 
    • Mmindy
    • Lydia_R
      Maybe surface tension?   I was in a political debate yesterday and it got way too focused on social stuff and I just had to steer the conversation back to how natural gas transitions to a liquid under pressure.  One of the people I was debating had a career working in that field and it was a good opportunity to expose stuff like that.  He mentioned that it isn't just pressure, it is temperature too.  So then I mentioned how the lines are running underground and asked how that played a role in it.  He came back saying that natural gas is a liquid under pressure.  I guess I didn't get a straight answer on that, but it did move my thinking one step down the road.  Perhaps I should have been more direct with him and asked him at what temperature and pressure.  Is there a chart?   I feel people would be better off if they paid more attention to the objects in their environment instead of focusing on some of the things that we hear so much of in the news.  People are pretty clueless as to how much trigonometry plays a role in so many things in our society.  Even land surveyors don't really use it anymore because programmers locked it away in a function.  Much like how cascading style sheets (CSS) is a wrapper for math.  I wonder what former president Trump thinks about all of that?  He must have some knowledge of how his buildings are constructed, right?  There certainly is a part of me that thinks he is just putting on a show about all of this.  Perhaps I'm wrong though.  All kinds of people in the world.
    • Jani
      Me as well.  I can use my left hand for many tasks though.
    • Jani
      Hello Jennifer and welcome back.  I find New England to be a great place to live.  I have a number of acquaintances and friends in Maine and I love the state.  It seems you are doing well.     Hugs,  Jani
    • MirandaB
      Oh, my "maybe this person is an egg" story is the (male presenting) piercing person and I discussed body hair removal methods, he says he doesn't want any hair except on his head, which is what I said during a couple hair removal sessions before and just after the egg cracked.     
    • Karen Carey
      I, too, am lucky.  Here in the UK I have a great therapist, a fully supportive GP, and a psychiatrist and endo who look after me and my needs.  I found the therapist on Psychology Today.
    • Lydia_R
      Over the last few years of being on this site and going through medical transition, I've come to own the M->F identification.  Funny, I made a typo of M->T.  It is a curiosity if I'll ever put Gender: Female on this site.  It is my intention to be there someday.   Right now, because of career stuff and a high stress event with an electric hair clipper last fall, I'm feeling much more masculine than I would like.  I think that once I make some decent headway with my third career, I'll settle into a more feminine feeling.   I never really considered gender very much.  I certainly always used a feminine appearance as my presentation goal. I think that when I was young, I briefly had the idea of transitioning, but I convinced myself quickly that medical transition would be a bad outcome, so I put all those feelings and ideas in the closet for decades.  I'm still very apprehensive about medical transition.  I've always taken health to be a high priority for me.  I wrote a book last December about my fears of it all and my conclusion ultimately is that sometimes there is more to life than being a pillar of health.  It's important to take some chances if that is where your heart takes you.
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...