Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

"beautiful Daughters" On Logo Online


Guest sarathompson

Recommended Posts

Thanks Sara, those stories (that Iv'e watched so far) were very touching. In fact, I can only watch a little at a time cause I get so emotional.

Link to comment

I liked it, I just kind of wish it wasn't so Christian-oriented. I felt a little like I was being segregated because I'm an atheist. Overall the show brought up some great points and would definitely be a big help in showing other people what we're thinking/feeling, but it just really bothered me that about 50% of it had a strong Christian influence. It seemed more like the Christian transsexuals were trying to say "See?! We believe in Jesus too, therefore we're good!" while completely ignoring all of our non-Christians, which is actually the majority. If someone said "my faith helped me" and all of that, then fine, good for them, but I thought giving us the big screaming priest and such (even if he was LGBT-friendly) was just too much. There was just a major bias there towards Christianity and that's really the only thing I had a problem with.

愛 Eth

Link to comment
Guest Leah1026
This is pretty cool. Here is a series of webisodes that feature interviews with the cast of the first transgendered-only cast of the V-monologues.

Beatiful Daughters Part 1

Worth watching if you haven't seen this.

I have the video of the whole show on my iPod Touch.

Link to comment
I liked it, I just kind of wish it wasn't so Christian-oriented. I felt a little like I was being segregated because I'm an atheist. Overall the show brought up some great points and would definitely be a big help in showing other people what we're thinking/feeling, but it just really bothered me that about 50% of it had a strong Christian influence. It seemed more like the Christian transsexuals were trying to say "See?! We believe in Jesus too, therefore we're good!" while completely ignoring all of our non-Christians, which is actually the majority. If someone said "my faith helped me" and all of that, then fine, good for them, but I thought giving us the big screaming priest and such (even if he was LGBT-friendly) was just too much. There was just a major bias there towards Christianity and that's really the only thing I had a problem with.

愛 Eth

Eth,

Maybe it was so pointedly aimed at Christians because for some reason they seem to be the most resistant to us.

Atheist never say why don't you stay like millions of years of evolution made you?

It wouldn't make any sense because we just evolved differently, but the Christian fanatics have their holy writings to condemn us.

Love ya,,

Sally

Link to comment
Atheist never say why don't you stay like millions of years of evolution made you?

Well I would... but that would defeat the point of evolution :lol:

Eth,

Maybe it was so pointedly aimed at Christians because for some reason they seem to be the most resistant to us.

It wouldn't make any sense because we just evolved differently, but the Christian fanatics have their holy writings to condemn us.

Love ya,,

Sally

I understand that to some degree, but I still felt disconnected from it because they catered to a single group within the transgender community, making it even more narrow than it has to be. When I see stuff like this, where religion (especially Christianity because it happens so often) is brought in practically inexplicably, it just makes me want to slap them and say "HEY! Not EVERY human on the planet follows your religion!", because it really does feel like they're not even acknowledging the existence of anyone outside of their little microcosm, which is exactly what we're asking cisgender people NOT to do. It feels contradictory.

愛 Eth

Link to comment
Guest AllisonD
Eth,

Maybe it was so pointedly aimed at Christians because for some reason they seem to be the most resistant to us.

Atheist never say why don't you stay like millions of years of evolution made you?

It wouldn't make any sense because we just evolved differently, but the Christian fanatics have their holy writings to condemn us.

Love ya,,

Sally

Now that is an interesting perspective. I am with Eth, except the thing that bothered me most is that they were mostly all prettier and younger than me. The Christian thing was too in my face from my atheist viewpoint. But the thought that this was appropriate since the Christians are the most negative toward us (and I have experienced plenty of that myself) and so in more need of 'coaching' makes sense to me and makes me feel better about how it was done. Thanks for pointing this out.

Allison

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean

Thanks, Sara...

I've had this book marked on my computer for some time, now.

Actually, my therapist gave it to me to watch!

My wife says.."Oh my! You could end up looking like them?".....LOL!

Well, YEP! Heading there right now...!

Huggs

Donna Jean

Link to comment
Guest CharlieRose
I liked it, I just kind of wish it wasn't so Christian-oriented. I felt a little like I was being segregated because I'm an atheist. Overall the show brought up some great points and would definitely be a big help in showing other people what we're thinking/feeling, but it just really bothered me that about 50% of it had a strong Christian influence. It seemed more like the Christian transsexuals were trying to say "See?! We believe in Jesus too, therefore we're good!" while completely ignoring all of our non-Christians, which is actually the majority. If someone said "my faith helped me" and all of that, then fine, good for them, but I thought giving us the big screaming priest and such (even if he was LGBT-friendly) was just too much. There was just a major bias there towards Christianity and that's really the only thing I had a problem with.

愛 Eth

Oh, my god that priest was hysterical. "GOD IS INTERESTED IN THE HEART, NOT IN BODY-PARTS!" My new catchphrase. Lol. And, I haven't watched this all the way through, about halfway through part 4, but it didn't seem to be that christian oriented/influenced/biased at all. Were we watching a different documentary? There was that one lady who was religious and they mentioned it as it applied to her, but no one else said ANYTHING about religion at all. (Unless they do it all towards the end. And even then I can't see it being more than an occasional mention of god as it applies to them personally.)

Overall, very well made (so far). A bit girly for me, but quality, so it wasn't a waste of time. :P I think lots more people should watch it.

Link to comment
Guest S. Chrissie

Anyone knows how to download the videos? My internet connection is too slow to actually watch it while it streams..keep getting pauses every other minute or so.

Link to comment
Oh, my god that priest was hysterical. "GOD IS INTERESTED IN THE HEART, NOT IN BODY-PARTS!" My new catchphrase. Lol. And, I haven't watched this all the way through, about halfway through part 4, but it didn't seem to be that christian oriented/influenced/biased at all. Were we watching a different documentary? There was that one lady who was religious and they mentioned it as it applied to her, but no one else said ANYTHING about religion at all. (Unless they do it all towards the end. And even then I can't see it being more than an occasional mention of god as it applies to them personally.)

Overall, very well made (so far). A bit girly for me, but quality, so it wasn't a waste of time. :P I think lots more people should watch it.

I just thought the priest was over the top, really. Just what bugged me was how, if they wanted to get a religious view on it, why was it only from the Christians? I understand why there's no "So you're Atheist, how does that effect your transition?" lol because Atheism is just that- a lack of religion. I wouldn't have anything to say on that either. It just seemed very ... biased towards Christianity in that they had several people go "It's about God" and "It's about my relationship with God" and then that big screaming priest. It felt like they were having Christian transsexuals speak for ALL transsexuals. God has nothing to do with MY transition, or everyone's, so why are we only hearing from one party? That's how I felt about it.

愛 Eth

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 53 Guests (See full list)

    • Petra Jane
    • jamesdavis
    • AcedTea87
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.8k
    • Total Posts
      770.6k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,121
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Amy Powell
    Newest Member
    Amy Powell
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Ctheone
      Ctheone
    2. EliMo_gaytor23
      EliMo_gaytor23
      (28 years old)
    3. Goose
      Goose
    4. Olivia47
      Olivia47
    5. QuestioningTaylor
      QuestioningTaylor
      (19 years old)
  • Posts

    • tracy_j
      It's good to hear some positive notes through all the negativity about at the moment. I am not religious but do see a lot of positivity in many things they do, outside of the normal media attention.   Tracy
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      From what I understand, my GF's early life was influenced by supremacism.  She sniffed around the edges of a couple of groups, and ended up for a while as part of an armed communist organization.  Mostly, just looking for a place to belong, and something to struggle for (and against).  She's told me about some of it, no doubt just the heavily edited Cliff Notes version.  But she did say that hatred takes effort.  It isn't something you're born with, its something you learn or that develops, often through suffering.    I think perhaps it is easier for children of supremacists to leave and do something different than it is for people who come to it through their own experiences.  When they are shown kindness by folks who are different from them, it begins to crack the wall. 
    • KayC
    • KayC
    • Carolyn Marie
      https://www.cbsnews.com/news/rfk-jr-opposes-gender-affirming-care-hormone-therapy-minors/   No surprise whatsoever.  He has seemed very anti-science from the get-go.     Carolyn Marie
    • KayC
      I've come to the understanding that most Angry and Intolerant people are that way because they haven't discovered their True Self.  So they lash out at others instead of seeking internal discovery ... whatever that is.  So for me ... it is not a Surprise but a welcome Celebration of the individuals Humanity.
    • Carolyn Marie
      https://abc3340.com/news/nation-world/nintendo-introduces-transgender-character-in-american-remake-of-mario-game-video-games-super-mario-brothers-bros-vivian-trans-lgbtq-gay-lesbian-gender-identity-wok-life-american-japanese     Carolyn Marie
    • KayC
      Bravo! @Vidanjali!   Their objective is to steer 'the Youth' in a different (and more conservative/intolerant) direction, but they don't realize they will actually push them away and lose them in the long run.
    • KayC
      Me too @EasyE.  But we are ALL on our own unique Journey.  That's what makes it both Difficult and WONDERFUL. Your Journey is SPECIAL - Only you can experience it and appreciate it.  Speed On, Dear EasyE!!
    • Birdie
      That's good, glad things will resolve on their own. 😉
    • Mirrabooka
      @awkward-yet-sweet, bummer about the road trip that isn't. Next time!   @KymmieL, good luck with the job hunting, you deserve it.   @Birdie, I'm happy for you that you have a new connection who seems so supportive!   @Ivy, enjoy!   The issue I referred to in my little grizzle the other day looks like it will resolve itself without conflict. Everything is good. 🙂
    • Mirrabooka
    • missyjo
      cute skirt April   yup I always keep perfume n mascara n panties with stud earrings even in boy mode
    • Mirrabooka
      One of the reasons that I hesitated to sign up to this forum originally was because I couldn't think of a femme name for myself. That stems from the fact that I wasn't seeking one, and still don't, although lately I have become a bit curious.   My username has geographical and astronomical connections. It is an indigenous word that describes the Southern Cross constellation.
    • Justine76
      Again, thank you for these posts @Sally Stone. As a person just embarking on their own exploration, seeing through an eagle’s eye is invaluable. I can understand the desire to compartmentalize. I’m coming out at 47 and have several military affiliated friends. I never served myself but know them via hobbies we share. I’d be nervous about coming out to those whom I didn’t know very well, but some I do know better are openly ‘queer’. Meeting these people definitely challenged my existing stereotypes about the military in a positive way; more regarding those who comprise the services as opposed to stated protocol/mission. 
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...