Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Transgender People Banned From Military By Trump!!


Guest Angelgrlsue

Recommended Posts

  • Forum Moderator

I only skimmed through this but it seems the official broadcast medium is Twitter :?

What happened to democratic process, or is it just a case of the press winding people up as usual!

Tracy

 

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

This is unfortunately real!  While i have never had a desire to serve in the military there are many who do for various reasons.  The cost of our medical care is a poor excuse.  Trump spends more of our money than that traveling to his golf outings.   Well at least we won't have to register or get drafted?

 

Hugs,

 

Charlize

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

All hail the commander in tweet. What a cowardly way to tell brave Americans already serving in our military you are no longer welcome. He gets off on tweeting and watching the world react, how evil....

Link to comment

I'm starting to wonder what is going to happen first. The Orange Clown gets impeached or the Orange Clown gets assassinated because he keeps making someone's life more and more miserable?

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

I'm glad your feeling better.  These things do hurt my feeling of self worth.  

You are not alone in your feelings.  

 

Hugs,

 

Charlize

Link to comment

I'm confident that this is a bump in the road. It's just like what happened with Civil Rights and Gay Rights. Some jerk(s) come along after the conversation gets started and try to derail the whole thing with their bigotry. This is why I'm all about being public. I feel like we are hitting tip over. It's time to push forward harder than ever now. I refuse to go back into the closet!

Just remember, nobody can make us feel small unless we let them! Go watch Wonder Woman and get inspired! ;)

Love and Light!!

Link to comment
  • Admin

Lots of analysis today, and opinions from law school types, military types and political types.  What seems clear is that nothing about this is clear, despite Trump's seeming definitive pronouncement.  The military wasn't on board with this, and the latest I heard is that they are currently saying that currently serving and out service members are not going to be forced out.

The problem is that the only person who gave this any thought is Trump, and we all know how little he actually does of that on any given subject.  So its best to just wait and see what the follow-up is, what the military brass says in a week or two.  Even the ACLU isn't going to do anything until and unless they see an actual written policy.

Bottom line is, this is not the time to panic.

Carolyn Marie

Link to comment
  • Admin
2 hours ago, Carolyn Marie said:

Bottom line is, this is not the time to panic.

Panic, NO. but indignation and frustration are up there for consideration.  Having Twitter block him is high in the national interest to be sure.

 

Link to comment
12 hours ago, Cindy Truheart said:

I'm starting to wonder what is going to happen first. The Orange Clown gets impeached or the Orange Clown gets assassinated because he keeps making someone's life more and more miserable?

I wonder if there is going to be a massive boycottt of the trump brand. 

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

Costs?  I've read the military spent $84M on viagra last year.  And the Military Bands cost $437M.  I think $2.4M to $8.4M estimated cost is a bargain.

Jani

Link to comment
Guest KatherineR

The cost argument is ridiculous. Discharging a qualified person to save a few thousand dollars for HRT only makes sense to a financial genius like Trump. Many in the military have had one to two or more years of training costing hundreds of thousands of dollars. By the time I reached my ship the navy had paid for four years at a private university, six months of classroom training in Florida, six months of practical training at a nuclear reactor in Idaho, and three months of submarine training in Connecticut. 

Link to comment

Here is an interesting read from politico. 

http://www.politico.com/story/2017/07/26/trump-transgender-military-ban-behind-the-scenes-240990

In the end it appears that members in the house were upset at paying for "the surgery" and were about to loose a house vote on it and went to trump. Trump in turn just said he would ban transgender troops.

Link to comment
Guest JaneShannon

Sorry, I have to be a bit of a dissenter on this, or present a different point of view.

The only question worth considering to me is "how will this affect readiness?" 

If inclusion of trans peoples will negatively impact the ability of the military to fight and win the nation's wars we are not needed.  If trans-people will not negatively impact readiness then we should not be excluded. There are two important sides to military service.  Wanting to serve, and being fit to serve.  Being fit to serve means that when called upon the Service Member is ready to deploy and fight.  Military service is not about what you want, but about what the nation needs.  Remember JFK, "ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country."

So does taking on a Service Member who will, or does, require medical interventions degrade readiness?

The answer is...it depends.

If you are an otherwise healthy person who requires an inhaler to control asthma you will probably be medically disqualified.  

Here is another example.  If a recruit is a healthy, genetic female, who has the potential to become pregnant she can join.  Remember readiness, once she becomes pregnant she will be non-deployable for year or more.  Yet the military regularly accepts genetic females knowing pregnancy could (and usually does) happen.  So future impacts on military readiness do not bar people from military service.

I would think if a trans person is medically stable there should be no reason not to be accepted to military service.  I doubt a cis-gendered person on HRT would be disqualified.  Further, the military would then fund this person's medications, and monitor the impacts of those medications.  

Sorry, this got long.  As I work through this, I do not see how a healthy transgender person would negatively impact readiness. Therefore, identification as transgender alone should not bar someone from military service.

Link to comment
15 hours ago, KatherineR said:

The cost argument is ridiculous.

Katherine - this is so true.  Isn't it amazing how much training goes into readiness.  Just like private industry, so many times the we loose sight of how much $$$ goes into recruiting, training, and orienting good people.  Investing in good people...not just good men, or good women, but good people, always pays off.  If you're a good leader, in the end all you want is a well-trained, capable, dedicated person.  Doesn't matter if there's a twig and berries or a Gucci purse down there as long as you have the above.

 

7 hours ago, JaneShannon said:

The only question worth considering to me is "how will this affect readiness?" 

Jane, this is also interesting to consider.  My Marine friend ended up with a medical discharge due to a simple blood disorder that he developed 10 years in.  The basic treatment was daily iron.  Because of this, it was determined that it would be too difficult to provide consistently in the field affecting his readiness so he was deemed undeployable and given a medical discharge.  Crushed him!  How readiness and if someone is deployable sometimes sees like a rather subjective thing.    

Link to comment
On 7/28/2017 at 8:41 AM, Briana said:

Jane, this is also interesting to consider.  My Marine friend ended up with a medical discharge due to a simple blood disorder that he developed 10 years in.  The basic treatment was daily iron.  Because of this, it was determined that it would be too difficult to provide consistently in the field affecting his readiness so he was deemed undeployable and given a medical discharge.  Crushed him!  How readiness and if someone is deployable sometimes sees like a rather subjective thing.    

Another factor that they consider for readiness is the impact of someone not getting their medication when deployed. In the case of your friend and in the case of a friend of mine who was also discharged and fought it all the way to the top, not getting their medications means that it could kill them. That is what they look at, and in our case, if we don't get our HRT it would totally suck, but we won't die from it!

Love and Light!

Link to comment
  • Admin
5 hours ago, Cindy Truheart said:

, if we don't get our HRT it would totally suck, but we won't die from it!

Nailed that one!!

Link to comment
21 hours ago, Cindy Truheart said:

 if we don't get our HRT it would totally suck, but we won't die from it!

Love and Light!

Not directly, but it can lead to us not taking care of ourselves, depression, and a whole host of other bad behaviors because some of us just won't care anymore. 

 

Link to comment
1 hour ago, MarcieMarie12 said:

Not directly, but it can lead to us not taking care of ourselves, depression, and a whole host of other bad behaviors because some of us just won't care anymore. 

 

But from the military's view, it's not life threatening, therefore it can't be the basis for denial of service. They don't have a leg to stand on for denying transgender people the right to serve in the military. That is what I'm saying here. Not getting HRT would eventually be a problem for us, but knowing that we can go back on it as soon as the situation we're in is  resolved would be enough for most soldiers. We are talking about extreme circumstances here, it's a war time situation kind of thing, and it isn't like you are being forced to de-transition, you would still require people to use the right pronouns and be able to be yourself.

Link to comment

Cindy, and the military is wrong in that regard. They do not see the forest for the trees. Now in an emergency/combat situation you always make do with what you have. Barring WWWII I don't see getting soldiers their prescription to be a problem unless they are located in some remote outpost in hostile territory. 

Link to comment

trump is nothing more than a bully and  roll on to the next election  hopefully he be booted out of office soon and he most likely behave like a spoilt child about it  but goodness know what mess he will do in the mean time 

 

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

Welcome Alexx.  It's lovely to see that positive thought coming from your side of the pond.  Being from the USA i must say that i'm embarrassed (and more than a bit horrified) that  he ever became our president.

 

Hugs,

 

Charlize

Link to comment

ID be embarrassed too if he was ruining my country the way he is  hillary would have been better She wouldnt have done anything like what he has done 

She also would have done something about the death camps in Russia that are killing lgbt  people which hasnt been in the mainstream news at all  Trump would do nothing about this sorry to be all doom and gloom  but the guy needs kicked out  by impeachment or by election 

 

All LGBT people who want jobs in the military and who are fit to be there should be allowed jobs  this is very 1960's  when stonewall and lgbt rights was non existent  . that why i think things like lgbt pride  and Trans pride are important and more awaresness of the issues for LGBT people We are stronger together 

 

sorry for the rant 

(((((( hugs for all )))) 

Alex 

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   8 Members, 0 Anonymous, 102 Guests (See full list)

    • MaeBe
    • Abigail Genevieve
    • Ashley0616
    • Ivy
    • Karen Carey
    • LucyF
    • SamC
    • Mmindy
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.7k
    • Total Posts
      768.4k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,029
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Selkimur
    Newest Member
    Selkimur
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Anyatimenow
      Anyatimenow
      (23 years old)
    2. Aria00
      Aria00
    3. Ava B.
      Ava B.
      (24 years old)
    4. Claire Heshi
      Claire Heshi
    5. CrystalMatthews0426
      CrystalMatthews0426
      (41 years old)
  • Posts

    • LucyF
      I've got Spironolactone 100mg and Evorel 50mcg Patches (2 a week) going up to 100mg after 4 weeks 
    • Ivy
      Got a new Granddaughter this morning.  Mother and child (and father) are doing fine. This makes 7 granddaughters and one grandson.  I have 2 sons and 6 daughters myself.  And then I  switched teams.  I think this stuff runs in the family. Another hard day for the patriarchy.
    • Ivy
      Like @MaeBe pointed out, Trump won't do these things personally.  I doubt that he actually gives a rat's a$$ himself.  But he is the foot in the door for the others.   I don't really see this.  Personally, I am all in favor of "traditional" families.  I raised my own kids this way and it can work fine.  But I think we need to allow for other variations as well.   One thing working against this now is how hard it is for a single breadwinner to support a family.  Many people (I know some) would prefer "traditional" if they could actually afford it.  Like I mentioned, we raised our family with this model, but we were always right at the poverty level.   I was a "conservative evangelical" for most of my life, actually.  So I do understand this.  Admittedly, I no longer consider myself one. I have family members still in this camp.  Some tolerate me, one actually rejects me.  I assure you the rejection is on her side, not mine.  But, I understand she believes what she is doing is right - 'sa pity though. I mean no insult toward anyone on this forum.  You're free to disagree with me.  Many people do.   This is a pretty complex one.  Socialism takes many forms, many of which we accept without even realizing it.  "Classism" does exist, for what it's worth.  Always has, probably always will.  But I don't feel like that is a subject for this forum.   As for the election, it's shaping up to be another one of those "hold your nose" deals.
    • Ivy
      Just some exerts regarding subjects of interest to me.
    • Ivy
      Yeah.  In my early teens I trained myself out of a few things that I now wish I hadn't.
    • Abigail Genevieve
      I was thinking in particular of BLM, who years ago had a 'What We Believe' section that sounded like they were at war with the nuclear family.   I tried to find it. Nope.  Of interest https://www.politifact.com/article/2020/aug/28/ask-politifact-does-black-lives-matter-aim-destroy/   My time is limited and I will try to answer as I can.
    • Ivy
      Well, I suppose it is possible that they don't actually plan on doing what they say.  I'm not too sure I want to take that chance.  But I kinda expect to find out.  Yet, perhaps you're right and it's all just talk.  And anyway, my state GOP is giving me enough to worry about anyway. I remember a time when being "woke" just meant you were paying attention.  Now it means you are the antichrist. I just don't want the government "protecting" me from my personal "delusions."
    • MaeBe
      1.  I think there are some legitimate concern.   2. Thoroughly discussing this will consume many threads.   3. I disagree partially with @MaeBe but there is partial agreement.   4. The context includes what is happening in society that the authors are observing.  It is not an isolated document.   The observation is through a certain lens, because people do things differently doesn't mean they're doing it wrong. Honestly, a lot of the conservative rhetoric is morphing desires of people to be treated with respect and social equity to be tantamount to the absolution of the family, heterosexuality, etc. Also, being quiet and trying to blend in doesn't change anything. Show me a social change that benefits a minority or marginalized group that didn't need to be loud.   5. Trump, if elected, is as likely to spend his energies going after political opponents as he is to implementing something like this.   Trump will appoint people to do this, like Roger Severino (who was appointed before, who has a record of anti-LGBTQ+ actions), he need not do anything beyond this. His people are ready to push this agenda forward. While the conservative right rails about bureaucracy, they intend to weaponize it. There is no question. They don't want to simplify government, they simply want to fire everyone and bring in conservative "warriors" (their rhetoric). Does America survive 4 year cycles of purge/cronyism?   6. I reject critical theory, which is based on Marxism.  Marxism has never worked and never will.  Critical theory has problems which would need time to go into, which I do not have.   OK, but this seems like every other time CRT comes up with conservatives...completely out of the blue. I think it's reference is mostly just to spark outrage from the base. Definitely food thought for a different thread, though.   7. There are groups who have declared war on the nuclear family as problematically patriarchal, and a lot of other terms. They are easy to find on the internet.  This document is reacting to that (see #4 above).   What is the war on the nuclear family? I searched online and couldn't find much other than reasons why people aren't getting married as much or having kids (that wasn't a propaganda from Heritage or opinions pieces from the right that paint with really broad strokes). Easy things to see: the upward mobility and agency of women, the massive cost of rearing children, general negative attitudes about the future, male insecurity, etc. None of this equates to a war on the nuclear family, but I guess if you look at it as "men should be breadwinners and women must get married for financial support and extend the male family line (and to promote "National Greatness") I could see the decline of marriage as a sign of the collapse of a titled system and, if I was a beneficiary of that system or believe that to NOT be tilted, be aggrieved.   8.  Much of this would have to be legislated, and this is a policy documented.  Implementation would  be most likely different, but that does not mean criticism is unwarranted.   "It might be different if you just give it a chance", unlike all the other legislation that's out there targeting LGBTQ+ from the right, these are going to be different? First it will be trans rights, then it will be gay marriage, and then what? Women's suffrage?   I get it, we may have different compasses, but it's not hard to see that there's no place for queer people in the conservative worldview. There seems to be a consistent insistence that "America was and is no longer Great", as if the 1950s were the pinnacle of society, completely ignoring how great America still is and can continue to be--without having to regress society to the low standards of its patriarchal yesteryears.    
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Cadillac parts are pretty expensive, so repairing them costs more.  But they don't seem to break down more than other makes.  Lots of Lincoln models use Ford cars as a base, so you can get parts that aren't much more expensive.    My family has had good luck with "Panther platform" cars.  Ford Crown Victoria, Mercury Marquis, Lincoln Towncar or Continental.  4.6 V8 and 5.0 V8.  Reasonable fuel economy, and fairly durable.  Our county sheriff's office was running Chargers and SUV's for a while, but has gone back to older Crown Victorias for ease of maintenance.  GF rebuilds them here.  But they are getting more scarce, since the newest ones were made in 2011.    1992-1997 years were different than the later years.  1998-2001 they did some changes, and apparently the best years are 2003 to 2011.  Check Craigslist, and also government auctions.  GF has gotten a lot of them at auction, and they can be had in rough-but-running shape for around $1,000.  Ones in great shape can be found in the $5,000+ range.  Good for 200,000 miles without significant rebuilding.  Go through engine and transmission and electrical systems, and they go half a million.    Some Chrysler models are OK.  The 300 mostly has the same engines as the Charger and Challenger, so parts availability is pretty good.  But they tend to get timing issues.  The older Chrysler Sebring convertibles were pretty reliable, sometimes going 200,000 miles without tons of problems, although after that they were pretty much worn out. 
    • Abigail Genevieve
      I think I have read everything the Southern Baptists have to say on transgender, and it helped convince me they are dead wrong on these issues.  They can be nice people.  I would never join an SBC church.
    • Abigail Genevieve
      You come across as a thoughtful, sweet, interesting and pleasant person.    There are parts of this country, and more so the world, where evangelicals experience a great deal of finger wagging.
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      It has been an interesting experience being in a marriage in a Christian faith community, yet being intersex/trans.  I stay pretty quiet, and most have kind of accepted that I'm just the strange, harmless exception.  "Oh, that's just Jen.  Jen is...different."  I define success as being a person most folks just overlook. 
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Well, I live in an area with a lot of Southern Baptists, Evangelicals, etc...  We've experienced our share of finger-wagging, as the "standard interpretation" of Scripture in the USA is that the Bible only approves of "one man, one woman" marriage.  My faith community is mostly accepted here, but that has taken time and effort.  It can be tough at times to continue to engage with culture and the broader population, and avoid the temptation to huddle up behind walls like a cult.    Tolerance only goes so far.  At one point, my husband was asked to run for sheriff.  He declined, partly because an elected official with four wives would have a REALLY tough time.  (Of course, making way less than his current salary wasn't an option either). 
    • Abigail Genevieve
      My bone structure is far more female than male.  I can't throw like a guy, which has been observed by guys numerous times, and moving like a woman is more natural.  It just is.  I'm not going out of my way to act in a fem. way, as you say, but I am letting go of some of the 'I am not going to move like that because I am a guy' stuff I have defensively developed.  The other breaks through anyway - there were numerous looks from people at work when I would use gestures that are forbidden to men, or say something spontaneously no guy would ever say.   At one point, maybe a year or more ago, I said it was unfair for people to think they were dealing with a man when they were actually dealing with a woman.    Girl here.  'What is a woman' is a topic for another day.
    • Willow
      Mom, I’m home!  What’s for lunch?   Leftover pizza .   ok.    Not exactly our conversation but there is truth in the answer.     @KymmieLsorry you are sick. Feel better soon.   Girl mode, boy mode no mode, not us. Nothing functional for either of us.   anyone here have or had a 10 year old (plus or minus) Caddy, Lincoln or Chrysler?  How was it?  Lots of repairs?  Comfortable seats? Anything positive or negative about it?  I need to replace my 2004 Ford Explorer Eddie Bauer, it’s eating $100 dollar bills and needs a couple of thousand dollars worth of work and that doesn’t even fix the check engine code.  Obviously, it isn’t worth putting that kind of money into a 20 year old car with a 174 thousand miles.   Willow
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...