Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Progesterone Problems


TessaOKC

Recommended Posts

Ive been on hrt for 3 years, a  high dose of estradiol each day (yes I know it's higher than normal, doc prescribed) and spiro. I started on progesterone last month. The first time I noticed extreme bitchiness and mood swings, enough that I stopped. I tried again weeks later and the same symptoms plus depression.

 

I'm also 50 and I question the benefits of progesterone.

 

Anyway, just wondering if anyone else has had a bad ride with progesterone and if you think the benefits are worth the risk???

 

Thanks so much,

 

Tess

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

First let me say that i removed the actual dosages you mentioned.  Dosages are strictly forbidden in the forums as too many try to self medicate with terrible side effects.  

From what you have mentioned i would talk to your doctor.  I know my MD who is quite well known as a leading surgeon and expert in transition rarely or ever prescribes progesterone due to the well documented side effects.  Please talk to your doctor and i would think a second opinion may be a good idea.

 

Hugs,

 

Charlize

Link to comment
  • Root Admin

Hello Tessa,

 

For the safety of other members who may be tempted to emulate your medication dosage without being prescribed by a doctor, the posting of dosages is not allowed. See rule 12 of the site rules. Thanks for understanding.

MaryEllen :)

12 You may not share the dose of any medication you are taking, including hormones. What works for you may well be fatal for someone else.

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

One of the known side effects of progesterone is depression so I would talk to your doctor about your experiences and determine if this is really something you need.  

 

Jani 

Link to comment

The last time I saw my doctor in November I asked about progesterone being added. She didn't think it was wise because there was no evidence that it is any benefit to MTF individuals. She also follows the guide line set out by WPATH so that's my 2 cents on the subject.

 

Laura Beth

Link to comment

Thank  you everyone for your input. Yeah, didn't realize the dosage no no on this site. Happy New Year everyone!

Link to comment

Hi Tessa! I've been on HRT for around 3 months (ish) and I take progesterone too. I too have had teething issues with it. For me I just started taking the full prescribed dose without ramping up, and it took a while to figure out what hormones where doing what....I did end up cutting out Progesterone for 4 days once, and then another time for about 6 days because I was really irritable and hard to deal with. Occasionally I will just take a day off of it because I feel like it's hard on my body.

 

As it turns out, progesterone was part of the irritability problem, and taking a few breaks really helped out. Somehow, I gravitated back towards it and it stopped contributing to my moodiness. So, at this point I take it just about every day, and will do until my prescription runs out. No problems anymore.

 

The endo that I see advised me to take it for the first 6 months and then discontinue it. The dose is probably on the low side.

 

In terms of breast development for me......it seems to have a noticeable impact. My girls are really starting to grow!

 

One interesting thing is that sometimes within the first hour or two of taking it, my breasts ACHE like all get out.....!!!! Today was like that, and I could barely handle my lab coat on at work. I was walking around for a while with my arms crossed, trying to stop anything from brushing up against them. That included clothing. Usually for progesterone for me, that means its super sensitive right behind the nipple area.

 

Hope you find something here useful. It good to hear from others taking the same meds. 

 

Take care!

 

Sunny Kay

Link to comment

Sunny Kay,

 

Thanks so much for your response. So I'll give you the details, lucky you!!! Starting taking it months ago and it was not easy with the mood swings but I toughed it out and got over it. I got a terrible rash on my legs and the doc wanted to make sure it wasn't the Progesterone so I discontinued it. Ended up being poison oak so a month later back on the progesterone I go. OMG, I grew three heads all of which could spin a full 360!!!! Depression then kicked in, it was depression on steroids I swear!! So I self discontinued again. Since returning to my human form I look at that pill bottle as the lurking monster in the closet!!! lol

 

My breasts have grown considerably (3 years HRT) full B cups. I took the progesterone just months ago so it was late in my hrt. I will prolly try the every other day option you have adopted. My doc said that as well. Stay tuned!!

 

I'm sorry for your experience but I'm glad I'm not the only one. I just want to do whatever i can to reach full potential as a trans female so when progesterone was offered it was a no brainer. Your poor breasts and that terrible lab coat!!! lol  I remember the early breast pain and how painfully awesome it was! LOL

 

I sure hope your transition is going well and nice meeting you!!!

 

Hugs,

 

Tess

Link to comment
On 1/2/2018 at 1:40 AM, Laura Beth said:

The last time I saw my doctor in November I asked about progesterone being added. She didn't think it was wise because there was no evidence that it is any benefit to MTF individuals. She also follows the guide line set out by WPATH so that's my 2 cents on the subject.

 

Laura Beth

 

Thanks Laura Beth,

 

I heard the same but hang onto the "What if" !!! I'm off it again but ramping up for another try!!!!

 

Tess

Link to comment

Tess! You're so funny.............

 

15 hours ago, TessaOKC said:

Since returning to my human form I look at that pill bottle as the lurking monster in the closet!!! lol

Link to comment

Tess,

 

So you are pursing the Progesterone! I think I always think it's best to try....it's hard for me NOT to try anyways, and I'm always curious too. If someone told me not to take it I'd probably find some way to see if it worked. I guess that's just the way I'm wired. I also got lucky getting to see an Endo that didn't take issue with it. But, I will be pleased when I don't take it anymore since I generally avoid pills of any sort if possible.

 

It's interesting to me that you are already so far along your transition and you are only taking it now. I hope it works for you! You are lucky to have attained B-Cup status! Good for you!

 

I guess the worst case scenario is, you simply have to stop taking it which is not really a bad deal in my opinion if it stops the problematic symptoms. 

 

So nice to hear your experiences, it's always wonderful to get someone's take on the details of the HRT experience. 

 

Fuzzy Hugs,

 

Sunny Kay  

 

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

Please be very careful.  The studies on women who used progesterone showed such a high injury and mortality rate that they were ended.  That is the main reason why WPATH does not recommend it's use.  For me or any with any heart issues it is definitely terrible as it can be for anyone who plays with it without strict medical supervision. 

As to breast growth and tenderness, my girls grew just fine.  I was painfully aware of in the process on a low dose of a topical estrogen.

One small hint while they are growing is to get some pads to give them a bit of a bumper.

 

Hugs,

 

Charlize

Link to comment
  • 2 months later...
  • Forum Moderator

I have only had 4 cycles of the progesterone so far... I do ramp up and down in a 10 to 12 day cycle, but I felt pretty darn nice getting on for the first 4 days, the rest of the cycle I just felt normal, then 3 or so days after ending the cycle I definitely felt a touch bitchy... I did have some lobular formation and growth that I did not have prior to taking progesterone, but there is no concrete way to link the two events as it could have just been timing as well. I remember the ouchies went away that first cycle, and the firmer duct tissues that were easy to palpate under the surface of the nipple softened and have gone away since starting the progesterone. Again, it could just be timing...

Hugs,

Jae

Link to comment

While in the hospital last year for an infection on my leg, they did an ultrasound and found a blood clot, which my doctor was convinced was caused by taking progesterone and he highly recommended I stop taking it. Well, my endo said going cold turkey with progesterone is a bad idea, so she suggested during the following 3 months while I take a blood thinner, to quickly wean myself off progesterone. My moods became more stable since I stopped taking it, and my family celebrated. 

 

I'm not entirely convinced it did much for breast development or even breast fullness. It may have been wishful thinking on my part. I was already on HRT for several years prior to starting this. In fact, since I was doing injections, my previous endo told me I didn't need to take progesterone but I could if I wanted to try it and see if it helped development.

 

I was hoping to grow some big ol' hooters on it but that didn't happen.

Since then, I thought maybe milk or beef that farmers injected with growth hormones would do for me what it did to so many of my lady friends but of course now everything is all "no growth hormones added". 

Can't catch a break, I tell ya.... :unsure:

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

HA! Yup, I have to agree that I don’t think the progesterone did much to help breast growth... but then I have not taken it very long. I don’t think I will continue with it after my endo ramps up my E, although I too had visions of giant sugar plumbs in my head!? What the boob faery does not bring I shall amend with top surgery... I hear Tyson chicken is loaded with the breast hormones that make chickens explode! Might have to eat a lot of nuggets to get anything from it, but then again I do like nuggets and hot mustard!

Hugs,

Jae

Link to comment
16 hours ago, jae bear said:

but then again I do like nuggets and hot mustard!

 

Hot mustard dipping sauce is the best sauce!

 

Tyson chicken, you say? I may have to look into that....:D

Link to comment
  • 1 month later...

Every body is different. I've been on micronized Progesterone and Estradiol for 20 years now following a bi-lateral orchiectomy with good results. First of all Provera isn't Progesterone which I'd never use. Next is the fact that I started it after being surgically neutered which put me in the same status as a post menopausal female who still has her female organs, but the ovaries which produce estrogen and progesterone have effectively dried up and are ineffective. They go on HRT with estrogen and progesterone to maintain some semblance of youthfulness. Their breasts continue to remain full rather than turning into empty looking flat saggy bags. In some cases they become larger like my wife a petite women who went from a big B/small C to a D.  It's the result of a combination of the two and especially the progesterone that does it. 

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   5 Members, 0 Anonymous, 93 Guests (See full list)

    • Jamey-Heather
    • Selkimur
    • Carolyn Marie
    • Birdie
    • MaryEllen
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.9k
    • Total Posts
      771.3k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,160
    • Most Online
      8,356

    ShelianJenn
    Newest Member
    ShelianJenn
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. DylanB1452
      DylanB1452
      (19 years old)
    2. Frnk
      Frnk
      (25 years old)
    3. GLS
      GLS
      (31 years old)
    4. HaitRapani
      HaitRapani
      (29 years old)
    5. Josie C.
      Josie C.
      (53 years old)
  • Posts

    • LittleSam
      I think it's disgusting that the Tories are using this as a last panicked attempt to gain power. They know there's alot of hate for trans people and it's seems they are using this to gain popularity and not let labour win. They are playing with people's lives and they don't care who they crush on their way to power. It makes me so mad. I really dislike rishi sunak and his values. Labour aren't perfect either, I understand they too are trying to stop trans women from being in single sex spaces. I'm ashamed of my country right now.
    • April Marie
      A blue/green/white floral popover, a light blue skirt and slip-ons. Picture is in my album in the gallery!
    • Mikayla2024
      LOVE IT!! 💯💯💯
    • Ivy
    • Lydia_R
      I'm 53yo as I write this.  I have been on a M->F transition journey for several years.  My last two female partners died in 2017 and in 2019 and I've been single since then living alone in my medium small sized house until 5 months ago.   For various reasons, mostly financial, I opened my house up to roommates even though my house is technically a one bedroom house.  Since then, I've had 3 Gen Z transwomen live with me off and on.  They have brought their transwomen friends over.  Last week I had a new transwoman friend over who is just a couple years younger than me and we had a good cuddle together.  I dated an older transwoman last year for 3 months.  I had another Gen Z transwoman over a couple weeks ago.  And there is a transman who has become a friend and has been over several times and might be by today.   You can go back to my first posts on this site and read about how concerned I was that transitioning would make me even more isolated than I had been.  And I have been very, very isolated for several decades.  But obviously quite the opposite has happened.  I don't know how representative of the larger world what I see in my house is.  I've played music with almost all of the people that have come through my house.  Most of them are excellent musicians and playing a style on acoustic instruments that is a new sound for me to listen to.   It certainly hasn't been perfect either.  For various reasons, the living arrangement here has been a struggle.  Finances have been a problem for all of us.  I think every last one of us has lived in cars for extended periods of time.  Anyway.  I'm in reflection mode closing this scene down.  Last week was frantic with packing, inventory and cleaning.  I'm mostly in relaxation mode now.  It's 11:07am.  I just finished lunch and I'm a little sleepy.  I've only been sleeping 4 hours a night for the last 3 months because of a crazy unpaid work situation I've been in, so perhaps I'll treat myself to a nap and try to get back to a healthier sleep schedule.  It's been a whirlwind of activity this year and much of that is going to continue on for me.   I feel blessed to have the virtual community on TGP and this physical community in my home.  I wasn't quite expecting this aspect of transition.  I think the first thing my last GT said to me was "you should find some transgender community online."  The first 2 GT I had didn't work well for me and I dumped them pretty quickly, but my last one did great with me.  She always pointed out that I was pretty well adjusted.  It's not like this transgender experience needs to be some mental crisis or medical problem.  I haven't seen my GT in probably 7 months now mostly because of financial problems, but I'm doing fine with it all.  She did a really good job guiding me through this journey.   Just so you know, I tend to not ask questions much unless someone is saying something that I am interested in and have an idea for clarification.  I tend to just spill my guts about things and think that others do that as well without being asked questions.  So....   What has your experience been like meeting other transgender people?  What does the community feel like in your environment?  Is this just crazy liberal Portland stuff or are there pockets of this all over the place?   Hugs, Lydia
    • Ivy
      I think I do live in the moment - perhaps too much sometimes.     As for the demons…
    • Ivy
    • Ivy
      It certainly can be.  But it doesn't have to be.   The sports always come up, it's kinda the gateway.  And yeah, it's not simple.  I think there is no blanket solution for that one.   I also think there is no blanket solution for HRT.  As such it should be left up to the individuals involved.  I don't think puberty blockers, and hormones should be given out like candy - especially to kids.  However, with counseling, and the involvement of the parents and doctors, the state should stay out of it.  For a trans person there is an advantage to starting fairly young.  I wish I could have.   The idea that the human race will die out if we let people transition is ludicrous.  Cis people have no desire to transition and I expect there will still be plenty of people with the urge to [procreate] to keep things going.    Trans people may be more visible these days, but trans people have always existed.  And the last I looked, there are still enough people around to screw things up.
    • Mmindy
      Good afternoon everyone,    While I’m here late today, my morning was filled with tasks. I hope your Monday is going well and you have a wonderful week.    Hugs,   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋
    • Vidanjali
      Grievous, illogical, counterproductive, and shameful. If ciswomen truly require protection via government policy, then by the same token so do trans people. Both the feminist and trans communities essentially want the same things - access to healthcare; autonomy over one's own body to benefit from that healthcare; freedom from violence and discrimination; and the right to be as they are regardless of status quo societal expectations, stereotypes, myths, and biases. These so-called protections do nothing but enforce patriarchal domination while further splintering communities who, logically speaking, SHOULD be allied as not only do they fundamentally have the same goals, but a wealth of knowledge and experience of how to organize and achieve.
    • Justine76
      I was just thinking about how I present in dreams the other day. Interesting topic for sure. In many of my dreams I'm often depersonalized to some degree; like a camera or observer not fully integrated with the content. When I am 'me', I'm usually much younger, late teen'ish - young adult. But gender doesn't seem to come into play much. If anything, I'm agender in most dreams.       
    • Lydia_R
      Commenting on this kind of thing is a very delicate business for me, but I have strong feelings about it all.   I think my problem with commenting on it is that I feel it is a fairly complicated subject and I would have to write a lot to cover the entire topic.  I don't just blanket support trans rights.  I follow the logic of "our" antagonists.  I think that especially, transgender sports is a "problem".  I'm not at all a sports person beyond enjoying board games, bike rides and throwing a frisbee.  But I can see the point of having transwomen competing along side cis gendered woman being an unfair advantage.  Not this this subject is directly related to this thread....   This thread mentions treating a "condition".  I dislike the label "gender dysphoria" and would never use that to describe myself in the same way that it would be very unlikely that I would ever call myself disabled even if I was confined to a wheelchair.   I was a proponent of marijuana legalization in the 1990's and still am to some degree.  I disliked the term "medical marijuana" and choose not to participate in that system.  When recreational marijuana became legal in Oregon, I eventually went to a store and bought some.  I was in my mid-40's and by that time was so sober and health conscious that I didn't want to hurt my lungs or really even feel intoxicated, so it really didn't do much to me when I smoked it and I didn't smoke much of it or spend any significant money on it.  The law allows us to grow 4 plants, so I did that several times.  I enjoy the process and the smell of the fresh leaves and buds.  When I harvest it, and then smoke it, it's the same thing.  I don't want to hurt my body or feel intoxicated.  So the jar of it sat on the shelf and I got the idea of burning it for incense.  I love the smell of it and it was fun to burn it.  It's been several years since I've done that, but I'll likely do that again some day.   This article also mentions classifying puberty blockers along with cocaine and heroine.  They are all chemicals to consume and in that regard could be considered a medicine.  Food, sugar and caffeine are also chemicals to consume as is paint fumes.  Gun violence is absolutely awful, but you can certainly kill someone pretty quickly with a metal shish kabob or a letter opener.   So, do these arguments, laws and proposed laws hold any water?  Is there something wrong with puberty blockers?  Is the problem that young people are making permanent decisions about altering their body in a synthetic way that destroys their ability to have children?  Is the goal of government to promote a growing economy that is based on population growth?  Is the problem that people are afraid that if a large portion of people experiment with these chemicals and procedures, that population will drop to a point and we'll enjoy not having children so much that we as a species will go extinct?  I'd say that that last argument holds some water, but that we are hardly in a position to go extinct any time soon.   Is the problem that we are afraid that these young people will regret their decisions that kill their fertility and will miss out on getting meaning from life from having children?  If people aren't getting meaning from their children, can they find it anywhere else?   Or is the real problem that people are triggered by distasteful cross dressing?   One of my favorite movies is Easy Rider and the line that Jack Nicholson delivers "they have this scissor happy beautify America thing going on."   I think that stereotypes exist naturally.  Discrimination is a natural thing.  We use color and smell to discern "good" objects (food), from "bad" objects.  It's a material universe.  All objects have borders starting with the round stars and planets.  There is good food and bad food, isn't there?  But we can use that logic as a weapon.   So, what can we do about it?  What can we, as members of the transgender community, do about these laws?  I mentioned in another thread on this site I believe....  Yes, it's here:   https://www.transgenderpulse.com/forums/index.php?/topic/90578-what-do-you-think-is-the-biggest-block-to-lgbtq-acceptance/#comment-856442   Perhaps it is just my personal culture with the whole thing, or perhaps there is a bigger thing going on in the world.  I'm a musician who does not like playing concerts.  I enjoy making solo music for my website.  My last roommate and I got into a lot of intense political discussions and he mentioned that virtually everybody goes to the grocery store.  So that is the most public place there is.  We also got into discussions about different sections of the USA doing a segregation type of thing.  I certainly perceive my environment in Portland Oregon to be a liberal place and all 4 of the transwomen who have lived with me this year said they moved here from the south for the acceptance and medical care.  Is segregating the country like this a dangerous road to go down?   And this kind of thinking can go on and on and I certainly want to mention abortion now and then press on to environmental issues and indigenous cultures.   As someone who claims to be sober, is HRT a designer drug and I'm actually not sober at all?  My driver's license says female on it.  Should I be paranoid about using the women's bathroom?  All the stalls in there have doors on them.  And hooks.  I passed some WPATH steps sincerely.
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Inner demon? I don't think I have one of those...    I do worry some about the future, and sometimes that can make me a bit nippish.  But mostly I am in the present.
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      From what I see, the legal system gives wildly varying results.  And the difference between civil proceedings and criminal proceedings changes things as well.  I have never been on a jury, but I have been through the court process after I was attacked in 2022.  The guy was found guilty and sent to prison, but I definitely didn't get a million dollars.  Of course he had basically no property or money that could be taken, so even if there had been a ruling of that sort it would have been like asking for blood from a turnip.  Maybe Summer Bushnell has a lot of money?  Who knows.   I understand that comparing being hurt by lies and being physically hurt and left with some permanent damage is like comparing apples and oranges, and that comparing results from one location to another has similar issues.  Still, it seems strange that one thing is worth a million dollars and the other is not. 
    • Jani
      Very sad about Jim Gordon, such a talent.
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...