Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Can I Have Your Opinions?


Guest Robin Winter

Recommended Posts

Guest Donna Jean

Hi, Shi!

Where ya been, Hon?

Ain't seen you around for a while!

Now, I don't really understand the first one and the second gave me a 404 error....

What's it all about anyways?

A transplant?

Donna Jean

Link to comment
Guest Robin Winter
Hi, Shi!

Where ya been, Hon?

Ain't seen you around for a while!

Now, I don't really understand the first one and the second gave me a 404 error....

What's it all about anyways?

A transplant?

Donna Jean

The first one is a twitter page. The second one would have given you a better idea....I'll check the link.

Link to comment
Guest Lizzie McTrucker

That second link still didn't work for me after I tried to copy/paste it on.

But I did find this cute tweet from the first link: is there a Rehab for Lucky Charms? if so where do i sign up?

Link to comment
Guest praisedbeherhooves

Wow. He's HOT. I don't really like him calling himself a "crossdresser" though. He's not, or at least he's not out about it. Gender bending does not give you the right to call yourself a crossdresser anymore than braiding your hair gives you the right to drop the n-bomb. Adapting the outward stereotype of a group does not give you the right to use desparaging names for them.

Link to comment
Guest Elizabeth K
Wow. He's HOT. I don't really like him calling himself a "crossdresser" though. He's not, or at least he's not out about it. Gender bending does not give you the right to call yourself a crossdresser anymore than braiding your hair gives you the right to drop the n-bomb. Adapting the outward stereotype of a group does not give you the right to use desparaging names for them.

I agree here. Beautiful presentation - fortunate genetic inheritance probably - but an exploiter of us all. Not real. The use of the word 'crossdresser" is always a key of an outsider.

Lizzy

Word filter changed t.rann.y to crossdresser

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean

Isn't that the person that did that viral "Leave Britney Alone" video a long time back?

I could be wrong on that......

Donna Jean

Link to comment
Guest praisedbeherhooves
Isn't that the person that did that viral "Leave Britney Alone" video a long time back?

I could be rong on that......

Donna Jean

Nope. That's Chris Crocker, who I think is actually is gender queer. Si has made statements that si feels like both genders or is halfway between them.

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean
Nope. That's Chris Crocker, who I think is actually is gender queer. Si has made statements that si feels like both genders or is halfway between them.

Oh yeah! That's right...now I remember!

Thanks, Hon!

I appreciate that!

Donna Jean

Link to comment
Guest Robin Winter

The reason I ask is because I got into a mild argument about this, as I was slightly offended. The person I was talking to actually claimed this person was transsexual, was planning to get surgery etc. The person in question claims to be the t-word that Lauras filter changes into crossdresser, whatever that's supposed to mean. I initially got offended at the idea that this person was supposedly a transsexual using the name Johnny Boy, and I felt that he/she was making a mockery of transsexuals for the sake of hits and ratings. After viewing the sites myself, I don't believe this Johnny Boy person is in fact claiming to be transsexual, maybe transvestite, I'm not sure. But I still find the whole thing offensive.

Anyway, the person I was sort of arguing with, I was attempting to educate them on trans issues etc, and I thought if I could get the opinions of other trans people it might help convince her. Maybe I'm just being oversensitive, though, I dunno.

This was the argument, the initial post was her response to something someone else said. I stepped in and it went from there.

Her: Well, he's GOING to be a girl, he's getting surgery. And you shouldn't judge. I've talked to him before, he's a really sweet person.

Me: "She's" getting surgery. If she's transsexual, she's already a woman, she just happens to have an unfortunate birth defect that needs correcting.

Her: Sorry. "She" just calls herself Johnny BOY, sooo...

Me: Then I would question the fact that this person is getting surgery, and if so, what the real reason for it is.

Her: Well, it's just a cute name, it doesn't mean anything. Besides, what do you care?

Me: I care for the same reason I despise old men who diddle little boys (beyond the primary reason that it damages the boys of course). It fuels the social stigma attached to transsexuals. It makes the people who really are in transition look bad, much the same way that homosexuality has been equated with pedophilia.

If you were to speak to the average transwoman, particularly those who have reached a stage in transition where they actually pass as a woman, I doubt you would find a single one who wishes to be addressed by a male name or with male pronouns.

Her: It happens to be a stage name. How exactly does that make transsexuals look bad?

Well, Johnny is definitely NOT average. Everyone's different, remember?

Me: It makes them look bad because it devalues the stress and pain they go through being viewed as the wrong gender. It makes a mockery of them. The suicide rate is almost 50% among transsexuals, and that's only the successful suicides, and only the ones that they know the reason for. The rate is probably much higher, and is definitely much higher for attempted suicides. For someone to cash in on being a "crossdresser" while underlining the fact that they're a man underneath the makeup and glitter is disrespectful. If it's an act for the stage, he should be calling himself a crossdresser or transvestite, whichever is more appropriate, but not a transsexual.

Her: So you're hating on her because she's not trying to kill herself? Johnnyboy is a transsexual, she's getting surgery done. End of story. I have no idea why you care about this so much, but I guess I'll never know.

Me: I'm not hating on her for any reason. I just think it's inappropriate for someone claiming to be a transsexual to refer to themselves as "Johnny Boy". I mentioned the suicide rates to point out that there's an enormous amount of stress and pain in the life of a transsexual for almost every case, and it's disrespectful to glamorize the process for stage purposes.

I care because I'm an advocate for LGBT issues.

Her: Ugh. You obviously have no idea who Johnny Boy is. She's a person, she doesn't have to do what everyone wants her to do. She's not disrespecting anyone, and she's most definitely NOT using this process for stage purposes. This conversation is over. Do not expect another reply.

*EDIT* According to you, if I was a transsexual, I would've tried to kill myself. [so there]

Me: And you obviously have no idea what it means to be transsexual.

Cheers.

The entire exchange took place before I actually looked Johnny Boy up, so everything I said was based on what she said about him/her getting the surgery etc. After the edit to her final post she blocked me, so I guess this whole thing is pointless anyway.

Link to comment
Guest Robin Winter

Hehe, sorry about leaving that phrase in. I didn't even really notice it, I'm so accustomed to that kind of talk on that site. If you ask me though, that was the least objectionable thing she said.

Link to comment
Guest Elizabeth K

Shilo - I think you are 100% on all that. But there are confused true transsexuals in denial. Someone that is truly MTF, keeping a male name is weird! But I imagine it can happen.

The real revealing trait that suggests she is not truly transsexual is her using all the trappings, dressing and posing, in such a way to draw attention and to make money.

Most all the t-girls I know, pre and post op - want to NOT be noticed - to fade into womanhood and be accepted for what they are. To exploit your transsexuallity would be a sign of insincerity or worse - such a bitterness over your condition you are really hating youself so very deeply. hummm... that you are making a mockery as a sick, twisted joke on yourself.

Certainly calling yourself Johnny-Boy and parading as a 'gender bending transsexual' is exactly what our community DOES NOT NEED!

Lord deliver us from pretenders and wanna-beeeees

Lizzy

Link to comment
Guest Jean Davis

Hey little Sis

Haven't seen you around for awhile, I was kinda getting worried about you. ;)

Now about your topic.

Personally I don't like titles too much, I do believe that most people know that. Also it doesn't really matter to me what this individual calls themselves, I tend to work off of the persons actions more than anything and from what I have seen from the video she could be considered either way. But the way I see this is that she is not doing direct damage to anyone, she just wants to do her own thing and by us judging her because she's useing a male name make us no better than those who judge us for not being born our correct gender.

Please don't stupe to the level of those who judge us, you are soo much better than that. ;) Just let her do what she wants and she may see in the future that what she's doing is not going to be a very easy life, then and only then she'll make her decision on what she's going to do.

Anyways, that's my opinion, I think. :lol:

LUV

Jean

Link to comment
Guest insanitylives

Ha, Chris Crocker is amusing. Just some of the more intelligent rant videos anyway. The (in)famous 'leave britney alone' thing is a load of some annoying... words I can't say on here :D

I don't think chris is as much of a detriment, as just odd. And there's nothing wrong with eccentricities, right?

johnnyboy, I'm just confused. If someone IDs as female, why use 'boy' in your name? Maybe just an attention seeker, who knows.

Link to comment

Maybe I'm a pessimist, but its not really viewed as eccentric by the non-trans community. People like Chris Crocker and Johnny-Boy, by virtue of being so outrageously flamboyant, become popular, as they're just such ridiculous characters. However, this tends to typify real trans people (I'm with the people who question whether or not she really is trans. No transwoman would exploit/flaunt her birth defect in any way) to the populace. So, since they claim to be trans, they become the rule for trans people to society. This means that when someone learns that we're trans, they assume certain things about us (overly effeminate, emotionally unstable, probably sex addicts, since these people that determine our stereotype tend to flaunt their sexuality in some way) which are seldom true, and quite frankly offensive. This perpetuates the negative stigma attached to any kind of variant gender identity (not that I have a variant gender identity, per se. I consider female to be well within the cultural binary of gender), and keeps us from getting jobs, and at the worst gets some of us murdered. Maybe I'm catastrophizing, but I can't see any way in which people like this could help our image. Perhaps if they were sane people >_>

Link to comment
No transwoman would exploit/flaunt her birth defect in any way

I'm not so sure about that. I don't think we should really be going on any witch hunts and trying to define who is and who isn't "really" transgender based on their attitudes. There are flamboyant people of all orientations and gender identities out there. I think what we ought to be focusing on is more the fact that people attach the stupid stereotypes to us, whereas when a straight guy beats his wife we don't start calling all straight men women beaters. Perhaps a better example would be when a straight woman wears orange jeans, we don't turn around and say all straight women love orange jeans. The problem is the stereotypes themselves - not necessarily the eccentric actions of a few individuals.

Perhaps if they were sane people >_>

To me that statement reeks of the intolerance all transgender people have faced. According to many people you and I are 'insane' because we'd probably be more than willing to change our genitals. If we're going to start judging other people like this then let's toss out everything we've always been saying about how it's unfair to judge us and how people are intolerant and refuse to understand. This person is different- in a way that I personally don't think I would want to be... but she likes being that way. So what? That makes her insane?

If she identifies as transgender, she's transgender. Or are we doing checks on everyone now and giving little stickers only to those we deem to be "true" transgender people?

愛 Eth

Link to comment
Guest Ryles_D
No transwoman would exploit/flaunt her birth defect in any way

I'm curious what this means- but it's way too close to the "trannier than thou" idea that damages our community for me to be comfortable with it.

If you mean that a trans woman wouldn't exploit her transness for whatever reason- why not? We have enough problems in this world, if someone is comfortable with being employed/(in)famous/popular/whatever because they're trans, then why shouldn't they use it to get ahead? It's like saying "A real gay man wouldn't exploit his gayness- all those guys making a big deal about how they're gay or being really flaming and stereotypical are just fakers in it for the attention". Yeah, some people are just exploiting trans people for shock value- but some people genuinely are that way. Why do we have the right to police the people who genuinely are trans for not being "like us"? And if we have that right- why doesn't society have the right to police us for not being cisgendered?

I don't really get the point of "JohnnyBoy" if sie is a girl, but whatever. Sie has the right to define hir own gender and determine how people see hir just as much as we do.

If you mean that no trans woman would ever stay out as trans or tell anyone she doesn't have to? No. There are trans women who don't go stealth and most of them are doing more for our rights and trans tolerance than the majority of us ever will. If no trans woman ever allowed it to become public knowledge- we wouldn't have any rights.

Link to comment
Guest denisesined

Hi folks

I was attracted to reading your comments and surprised at the variety in them. The person in question does have a right to an opinion and others have a reasonable right to reply. Perhaps it would be more profitable/productive to comment on the options rather than picking fault with the person. I have no idea who anyone is in this group so have no preset idea's concerning anyone.

A simple statement of your beliefs and the options we have would express the same without personal injury to anyone. As a person struggles with their gender identity they make statements that at the time seem right and for some this seems to be bad actions. While we are all a little familiar with each others ideas, some are more progressed than others. It is up to the ones who are advanced to ensure the guidelines are protected without interfering with the individuals growth.

If you feel this person is wrong about things, then simply state that and explain your stand. As a post-op trans I am a little disappointed in the way some attitudes were expressed. We have our needs and we have the right to fight for them. But remember that right or wrong, others also are entitled to their opinions.

I wish you all the best in this discussion.

Denise Holliday

Canada

Link to comment
If she identifies as transgender, she's transgender. Or are we doing checks on everyone now and giving little stickers only to those we deem to be "true" transgender people?

While I would respond to the rest of your post, to do so might incite too much debate.

I will, however, approach this.

I'm not saying she might not be transgender. However, its not difficult to be transgender. Really, all you have to do is claim you are, as you said. I was expressing doubt that she may be transsexual. To fit the category of transsexual, you have to have certain physical characteristics that indicate that you have a gender identity that varies from your biological sex (such as a feminization of either the entire brain or the stria terminalis. The latter is proven, while the former needs more study). I'm not saying that transsexuality is a scale, since it isn't. You're either transsexual or you're not. However, transgender is. Some people may only crossdress, some may be androgyne. The second is "trannier" than the first, if only because it requires more of a shift in lifestyle.

Sorry if my use of "trans" to indicate transsexual in lieu of transgender caused some confusion.

Link to comment

@Soph

I agree with you that there's a certain physical requirement for being transsexual although I don't think we yet understand that requirement quite in full. What I'm saying I disagreed with was believing that anyone who fits that bill is also definitely going to have a certain personality and act a certain way.

If a natal female went around calling herself something like "JohnnyBoy" or similar, but continued to express a desire to be feminine/female, even flaunting being female or her eccentric self-identification, should we then turn around and say she's not "really" a girl because of that? I don't think so, and I don't think a trans* person should have to adhere to different social rules either so I don't think we should turn around and claim to know what they are or aren't "really".

The problem I'm having with the argument is just that it was all based on her personality. If you wanted to argue "If she is a girl/identifies as female, then she's a really odd/eccentric/unusual girl..." I'd probably whole-heartedly agree, lol. Not to say that her personality is "good" or "bad" (because who am I to say that?) but I'll admit it's pretty flamboyant/unique. But to me saying that she's "NOT a girl" because she has that attitude and flaunts her 'transness' is like saying any other girl isn't "really" a girl because she drinks beer and watches football. Maybe it's not what most girls do but it doesn't make her any less a girl if that's what she identifies as.

愛 Eth

Link to comment

The problem I have is that she seems to emphasize (and likewise take advantage of) her birth defect. Trans people (referring to transsexuals) are highly unlikely to do this, while a crossdresser or some other thing like that would, as they don't necessarily have any problems with their bodies.

Being comfortable in your skin is all great in theory, but if she is so comfortable as to remind people every 20 seconds then its unlikely that shes trans... its sort of the only way it manifests itself: an intense dissatisfaction with your body. Simply put, a trans person would never be comfortable in their skin, resultant of their being trans.

Regardless, her behavior does add to the social stigma that we face every day (I doubt anyone is going to argue with me there). So I can just as easily oppose her on those grounds.

Link to comment
Regardless, her behavior does add to the social stigma that we face every day (I doubt anyone is going to argue with me there). So I can just as easily oppose her on those grounds.

Sure that I agree with, I just won't decide for her what she is or isn't based on any of that. As for not being comfortable in your skin.. there are some who are, or are once they reach a certain point. Others are just good at hiding what they feel. That by itself just doesn't seem enough evidence for me to come to a conclusion like that.

愛 Eth

Link to comment

That she ignores the primary symptomatic diagnosis criteria for GID indicates that she may not have GID (not that I really like referring to it as GID). There certainly are people who think they may be trans but end up being something else. Otherwise we wouldn't need therapy to filter them out (well, except for dealing with the emotions that Johnny-Boy seems to lack concerning her body).

...before this escalates much further, can we agree to disagree?

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 59 Guests (See full list)

    • Birdie
    • awkward-yet-sweet
    • Carolyn Marie
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.8k
    • Total Posts
      770.3k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,103
    • Most Online
      8,356

    BUGFIEND
    Newest Member
    BUGFIEND
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Bobbijean
      Bobbijean
    2. Bryan
      Bryan
      (61 years old)
    3. jlw5ju
      jlw5ju
      (27 years old)
    4. ladykirabellum
      ladykirabellum
      (47 years old)
    5. Lizzie17
      Lizzie17
  • Posts

    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Not to justify it, but this is what happens when folks rely on accepting money from the government.  It just isn't secure!  When the times change and different winds blow, you find yourself coming up short on funds.  Don't trust the feds, don't trust the state.    I don't believe in separation of church and state.  I believe the USA is a Christian nation, but that Congress doesn't make an establishment of which kind of church that refers to.  Reading the writings left by the Founders (who were mostly Christian or Deist), I think it is pretty clear that they wanted to avoid the bloody Protestant vs. Catholic conflicts that had been going on in Europe for the previous 250 years.    I think one huge problem is that we've had a separation of culture and state already.  There's been an abandonment of traditional American culture, or at least a significant change in it.  People often act servile, not independent.  People seek government help rather than taking care of themselves and those around them.  Its like everybody is waiting for an answer, like baby birds in the nest chirping to have something delivered to them from up above.    To me, the federal government has two purposes - to keep foreign forces and influence out of our territory, and to tax foreign trade to protect domestic economy.  They've pretty much failed at both. 
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Actually, yes!  Its how I met my two trans friends.  My husband helped to arrange jobs and housing for both of them.  And in the process, they also fell in love, and so far their relationship is going well.  I'm glad to have been part of helping out.
    • KathyLauren
      I am not sure what "it" you are asking about.  The surgery, or the increased urgency of peeing?   I haven't felt any increased urgency.  I can hold it for as long as I used to, I think.  One thing that is different is that, once I start, it is almost impossible to stop the flow.  My pelvic floor physio said I had really good control of my pelvic floor muscles, but it didn't help with that.   My goal for surgery was just to have a female body.  I think I was foreseeing the persecution that is rising now.  Part of my reasoning, though I didn't plan it out clearly in those terms, was that I would be able to pass a strip-search gender check.  I was thinking more about passing in locker rooms, but passing in police lineups may be more necessary if certain political elements get their way.  
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Wow.  That's crazy that somebody just comes onto your private place and starts demanding stuff.  You're absolutely right to press charges.  It seems like there's very little respect for private property these days. 
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Actually, my husband has two different job titles at his company.  He's transportation manager, and also one of the project managers.  Its funny because he's got an office in the main building, and a smaller one in the transportation building, and he's rarely in either one.  He's got three site foremen who report to him, and also the shop supervisor and drivers' supervisor.  So he usually spends his days at installation sites, meeting clients, or handling all the paperwork that keeps the transportation side of the business compliant with FMCSA rules.    But he's definitely a truck driver by personality, and he taught me how to drive and helped me get my CDL.  Kind of a backup option for a job if I ever needed one.  I think this week is going to be one of those "all hands on deck" kind of occasions, so we'll probably take a load or two.  I'm looking forward to it.  Its really funny when I'm driving and we get into a truck stop.  I get out of the cab, and I get a lot of stares because of my size and looking like I'm a teenager.  And we get more stares when we share a shower.  
    • Lydia_R
      Yep, this thing is a red flag that people should be super aware of on this site.  I've been working from home exclusively for 12 years.  I'm a house cat like that, so this isn't much of a deterrent for me.  I've been venturing out into the women's restrooms a little bit lately, but as is typical of people like me, I'm just in there to do my business and get out.  I avoid that as much as I can and use those single bathrooms whenever I can.  I went over a year without going to a public restroom.  I just don't go out much.   I haven't stood to pee in 7 years now.  The idea of surgery is very, very scary for me (I wrote a book about it).  I'm likely going to do it though.  I would like some evidence from other transwomen of what it is really like.  I'm not one to take plane flights, but taking a flight for that is well justified.  Before my testosterone was blocked, there was a much larger sexual side to M->F transition.  Now sexuality plays a back seat to the idea of wanting to pee like a woman.  It's always been in my mind, but the desire for that has grown.   Respectfully, Lydia_R
    • April Marie
      Just a black skort and a yellow t-shirt with sneakers today.
    • Birdie
      Wearing my new top for my Zoom meeting today. ☺️
    • Lydia_R
      I've gotten to the point lately where I'm thinking of the extension of the separation of church and state to separation of culture and state.  Government's purpose to ensure a construct of civility.  Food, clothing, shelter and justice for the individual.  That includes the roads as far as they pertain to the distribution of food, clothing and shelter.  And "ensure" is different than "provide".   I think that there is no way to truly express yourself or have a good foundation without having a personal culture.  I like telling stories and teaching lessons through my culture, but I always hope that people don't think I'm promoting my culture beyond it just being visible as an option.
    • KatieSC
      I would imagine the GOPers are holding that by bull in their hand and paying attention to the Trump version with the nine commandments highlighted.
    • Adrianna Danielle
      Having to call the police on a woman that was being a Karen.Was in my shop fixing my car and wanted me to fix hers.Told her it was my personal shop and told her no.Would not take no for an answer and called the police.I did decide to press trespassing charges on her.I knew she was one of those entitled people
    • Ivy
      It is scary, (and as you say, thrilling) at first.  But the more you do it the easier it gets.  I dress fem 24/7 (almost always skirts and dresses) and I live in a conservative county of a "red state".   Sure, there are places I avoid, but I have little desire to be there anyway.  It gets to just be part of who you are.   My experience is that most people don't care, some are curious, and surprisingly many (usually other women) friendly.   The first steps are the hardest.  It's similar with bathrooms.
    • Ivy
      Don't know how this posted itself.  To continue…   There was a time when I tried to make excuses for them.  But I am coming to the realization that in their eyes, I, and those like me, are 2nd class citizens at best.
    • Ivy
      There is a rather large part of the GOP that is determined to strip the rights of trans citizens, despite us being a small minority, some with families, who work, pay taxes, and who do - and have served in our armed forces, are medics, nurses, etc.   They insist that the US is a "christian country" - referring to their particular brand of christianity.  And this is despite the constitution, that they claim near worship of, expressly prohibiting this very thing.    
    • Lydia_R
      Oregon has a law that allows you to change your name and gender once in your lifetime without involving the courts.  It took me about 2.5 months to complete and was relatively easy.  It came up yesterday about how I changed my gender on my ID to F instead of X.  I identify with M->F, not X.  I passed over the line into F, but I'm still near the middle in the spectrum.  And I intend to keep going in the F direction.  There is another transwoman named Rachel Rand who is about 10 years older than me and I use her as a model for where I want to be in 10 years.   I'm a proud Gen X'er, but it's based on latchkey arcade games, not gender.
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...