Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Gender Identity Take 2


Guest Michele H

Gender Identity survey design  

32 members have voted

  1. 1. Which set would you be most comfortable answering on a health survey

    • Set 1: consists of 4 questions: (1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? (M or F), (2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? (Yes, No); (3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? (Male, Female, Androgynous, Gender Queer, Other); (4) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX)
      28
    • Set 2: consists of 2 questions: (1) What best describes your gender? (Male, Female, FtM, MtF, gender Queer, other); (2) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX)
      4


Recommended Posts

Guest Michele H

For those who answered the first poll, thank you. I have taken your feed back to create the promised round 2 (one day late). This time, please choose the question SET that works best for you.

For those who did not see the first survey, here is some background

I am working with a state organization, Rainbow Health Initiative, to redesign their health survey. This organization started life as a Gay and Lesbian non profit and became GLBTQ inclusive about 4 years ago. The volunteers surveys from a variety of venues with high GLBTQ populations - including some Trans specific events in the state. In their existing survey, a large percentage of trans identified individuals are selecting either Male or Female, rather than MtF or FtM. THIS MEANS WE ARE BEING UNDER COUNTED.

PLEASE TAKE THE TIME to complete the short survey. It's purpose is to find question language that will reduce under counting. Also, suggestions as to different wording or other comments will be appreciated.

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean

Set 1: consists of 4 questions: (1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? (M or F),

Assigned "male" at birth.....

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? (Yes, No);

Not any more. I feel that I know my gender now. There was confussion for years.

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? (Male, Female, Androgynous, Gender Queer, Other);

This IS my gender ....I know that and I'm comfortable with that!

(4) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX)

No

I hope that I did this correctly......

Thanks...

Donna Jean

Link to comment
Guest Jewel

Just a note... the language "(sex chromosome other than XY or XX)" would exclude a rather large portion of intersex individuals (for instance those who are XX male or XY female or those XX or XY individuals with atypical genitalia or gonads, such as ovotestes).

Wikipedia Entry on Intersex

Link to comment
Guest Amanda joan

Michele,

Thank you for the work you are doing. I am often unhappy with the lack of choices on surveys. Like the Census I checked both male & female as kind of a protest to their norrowmindedness. I think that when we work with groups like yours we are working to make all of our lives better and safer. Great work.

Peace & Love Amanda

Link to comment
Guest Elizabeth K

Set 1: consists of 4 questions: (1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? (M or F),

male (he couldn't see into my mind)

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? (Yes, No);

Yes - for 61 years - it's now being resolved

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? (Male, Female, Androgynous, Gender Queer, Other);

Female - I have always been female in mind and soul

(4) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX)

I don't know. My therapist wants me to be tested

Lizzy

Link to comment
Guest NatashaJade

Set 1: consists of 4 questions: (1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? (M or F),

They put an M on my birth certificate. The tyranny of anatomy.

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? (Yes, No);

Yes. Actually, not a feeling, but a certainty that has led me to take action to reslove it.

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? (Male, Female, Androgynous, Gender Queer, Other);

Female. Identify with and as.

(4) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX)

I am not.

Hope this helps!

luv

Gin

Link to comment
Guest KellyKat

Hi Michelle

Set 1 Four questions

1) Born male

2) Gender issue - Yes

should have been born female

3) Identify as female

working to get the body to match the mind

4) Intersexed - ???

unknown never been checked

(should there be more than Y/N?)

Hope I helped. Luv Kat :)

Link to comment
Guest Michele H
Just a note... the language "(sex chromosome other than XY or XX)" would exclude a rather large portion of intersex individuals (for instance those who are XX male or XY female or those XX or XY individuals with atypical genitalia or gonads, such as ovotestes).

Wikipedia Entry on Intersex

Thanks Jewel - very helpful link and I will use it to revise the question

Link to comment

Set 1,,,,Question 1,,,,doc assigned as male .

Question 2 ,,,,GID issues ? Yes, BUT, being resolved :)

Question 3,,,,I am a woman ,,just an unlucky one :(

Question 4,,,,Intersexed ??? dont think so . viv :)

Link to comment

(1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? Male

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? No, I have always been female - it is everyone else who are having the issues.

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? The same as always, Female.

(4) Are you intersexed? No.

I may present male and acted as one for my entire life but I have always know the truth and I have no issue with who I really am - others do and that explains my answer on number 2!

Love ya,

Sally

Link to comment
Guest Michele H

I really appreciate the responses I'm getting. I meet tomorrow with the director of RHI and based on the responses so far, will present set one - question 4 in set one will be modified to correct the problems identified by Jewel. I DO need to hear from the guys and those who identify as androgynous and gender queer. Your input is really needed

Link to comment

1) Doctor assigned me to live the life of a male. What an awful misdiagnosis.

2) Not a gender identity issue as much as a body issue.

3) I'm female. That is an immutable fact about me.

4) Intersexed? The definition needs to be very clear; many people consider transsexualism to be an intersex condition, and I'm one of them.

Link to comment

Set 1: consists of 4 questions:

(1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? (M or F) M

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? (Yes, No) Yes

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? (Male, Female, Androgynous, Gender Queer, Other) Female

(4) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX) I had a karyotype test done the results were XY, however

there are some indications that i could be even though the test said otherwise, since only a small sample was tested.

I voted for set 1, i think it will give you the greatest chance at having accurate reporting.

Here is what i would answer for set 2, your reporting would be skewed and inaccurate.

Set 2: consists of 2 questions:

(1) What best describes your gender? (Male, Female, FtM, MtF, gender Queer, other) i would answer Female

(2) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX) I had a karyotype test done the results were XY, however

there are some indications that i could be even though the test said otherwise, since only a small sample was tested.

Paula

Link to comment
Guest Flistan

(1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? (M or F),

Female

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? (Yes, No);

I've learned a lot about myself since January and new things keep coming up for me to have questions about, but I think I finally have everything figured out.

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? (Male, Female, Androgynous, Gender Queer, Other);

Androgyne

(4) Are you intersexed

Not sure because I've never been tested. I wish, but 99% of me says I'm not... *sigh*

Link to comment
Guest My_Genesis

Set 1: consists of 4 questions:

(1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? (M or F)

F

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? (Yes, No);

Yes, though if you want to discuss terminology here I wouldn't call it a mental health "issue", but a medical/biological one. And I like to think I was born male, not with a "gender identity issue" per se.

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? (Male, Female, Androgynous, Gender Queer, Other);

Male

(4) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX)

Possibly, not sure, hoping to find out soon

Looks like everyone likes Set 1 so far

Link to comment
Guest Ryles_D

I like "what is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth", I've seen a lot of trans people refer to their birth sex as "assigned-gender/sex". They don't see themselves as having been born anything but who they are- it's just that the doctor/their parents saw them as something else. I'm not sure if people will like answering what their assigned-sex is, though, especially if they're post-op. And adding in the "do you feel you have a gender identity issue" while asking what your gender identity is, that's a great idea. Then even people who feel that they're no longer trans or don't see it as a gender identity issue will still be counted. You also might want to add in a questioning option for the gender one.

(1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? (M or F),

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? (Yes, No, ?);

It's hard to say... I don't feel that I have issues with my gender identity, but society's views of gender combined with my unusual gender identity result in issues. So... sort of?

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? (Male, Female, Androgynous, Gender Queer, Other);

(4) Are you intersexed

No. There's a mild chance- and the definitions of intersexed seem pretty wide and not set in stone, so what one doc considers intersexed might not be seen that way by another... But it's highly unlikely.

Link to comment
Guest Cayden

(1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? (M or F)

Female

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? (Yes, No)

Yes Since I was five and now I am almost 20.

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? (Male, Female, Androgynous, Gender Queer, Other)

Male

(4) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX)

I do not know

I hope this helps.

Link to comment
Guest childofwinter

(1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? M

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? Yes

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? Androgynous

(4) Are you intersexed? No, AFAIK

(1) What best describes your gender? Androgyne

(2) Are you intersexed? No, AFAIK

Link to comment
Guest Melanieshaman

Set 1: consists of 4 questions: (1) What is the gender the doctor assigned you at birth? (M or F), Male

(2) Do you feel that you have a gender identity issue? (Yes, No);No-I know what i was meant to be.

(3) What is the gender you most closely identify with today? (Male, Female, Androgynous, Gender Queer, Other); Female

(4) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX) No

Link to comment
Guest Penelope

In response to set one:

1) Male

2) Yes

3) Male but I'm beginning to suspect that I'm Androgynous

4) No; but I've never been tested

Link to comment
Guest insanitylives

(1) What best describes your gender? (Male, Female, FtM, MtF, gender Queer, other)

Ftm

(2) Are you intersexed (sex chromosome other than XY or XX)

As far as I know, no. I get periods, so that rules out most intersex conditions

but you never know without a test i suppose

Note on 2nd set: suggest to change from "other than XY or XX" to "that do not match your physical sex", there's a difference. A few weeks ago I saw a 10min clip of a doccumentary about a woman who was XY , but born physically female

it happens

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   4 Members, 0 Anonymous, 190 Guests (See full list)

    • Ivy
    • awkward-yet-sweet
    • Abigail Genevieve
    • RaineOnYourParade
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.8k
    • Total Posts
      769.7k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,077
    • Most Online
      8,356

    gender_equality_nccu
    Newest Member
    gender_equality_nccu
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Alexa Amorosa
      Alexa Amorosa
      (48 years old)
    2. Bluestem
      Bluestem
      (39 years old)
    3. CharlotteSW
      CharlotteSW
      (26 years old)
    4. Daisy91
      Daisy91
    5. jriddle1990
      jriddle1990
      (30 years old)
  • Posts

    • Willow
      Well it was a good day at work I got everything done I needed to do. My audits came out right and everything.  I had to fix the printer on one pump. It wouldn’t cut the paper and needed two parts replaced.  The District Manager left us Thank you bags,  Murphy Bucks and candy.  We can use Murphy bucks to buy things in the store, or pay for gas.  I guess next week the Area Manager will be around to check on things.  He would be the next layer higher.  Well my eyelids are starting to get heavy, time for a nap.thats the only thing about opening the store it definitely causes me to need a nap.    
    • Vidanjali
      Interesting point. I was raised Catholic and was intensely intrigued by the lives of saints. Similar to your obsession with Mulan, I was particularly drawn to Joan of Arc, a 15th century saint who took on the guise of a man to lead the French army to victory over the English in the Hundred Years' War. Later, she was sold out by the Burgundians to the English who brought multiple charges against her as a heretic, including claiming she could communicate directly with God (which undermined the church's authority), and wearing men's clothes. At one point, while imprisoned, she was made to dress in women's clothes, which she did, but was later found again in men's attire which she said she preferred. She was eventually burnt at the stake at age 19. Rather gruesome tale, but not atypical of the stories of Catholic martyrs. 
    • Abigail Genevieve
      I just read something a FB friend posted about guilt.  I am changing it somewhat for here.   There are things you should not feel guilty about because they are not wrong.  Being transgender is one. People like to send us on guilt-trips about it, intentionally or unintentionally.   There are things you have actual guilt about whether you feel guilty or not.  If you murder someone, you may not feel any guilt.   The FEELING of guilt can be widely separated from objective guilt. All of us need to train ourselves to not feel guilty about things we are not guilty of,, and to feel guilty about the things we are guilty of.  It is not easy.
    • Abigail Genevieve
      Jeans, t-shirt, flip-flops.
    • Vidanjali
      Good news. That just means you're normal!   Understand that thoughts leading to thoughtlessness is a VERY high ideal. Those who aspire to that may spend their entire life working on it and only ever glimpse momentary stillness. In fact, I'm reminded of a story which was relayed to me recently about a yogic master who was interviewed and asked - In deep meditation, how long can you sustain a still mind before another thought creeps in? You may expect the master to reply hours or perhaps even days. His answer - 7 seconds. The thing is, as long as you're operating with a human brain, thoughts will go on. In Bhagavad Gita chapter 6, verse 34, Arjuna (who represents every individual) complains to Lord Krishna (who represents the Higher Self), "The mind is very restless, turbulent, strong and obstinate, O Krishna. It appears to me that it is more difficult to control than the wind." Such is the nature of mind. The difference, though, is in learning gradually to not identify with thought, but rather to become the dispassionate witness of thoughts, like clouds passing in the sky, or often more poignant a simile, like high speed trains rushing by. 
    • Jamey-Heather
      It's very warm here in the Willamette Valley after a couple of weeks of rain. So I thought I'd get springy 🥰🥰🥰
    • Cynthia Slowan
      Hi Ivy!  Thanks so much! 💗Cynthia                      
    • RaineOnYourParade
      As a guy with a mom constantly throwing around "she/her", I feel you.   I think trans people in general hold ourselves to an impossible standard to be more girly or manly. There are some people who look or act a lot like the opposite gender, even if they're completely comfortable in their AGAB. That thought helps comfort me sometimes. If being a man was a set of boxes to check off (beyond the obvious chromosome things), I'm sure there'd be plenty of cis guys that would suddenly find themselves no longer being guys. It can be hard when it feels like evidence is stacked against you, but you don't have to be a certain way to turn into a guy. Some people will make it sound that way, but you're already a guy, regardless of how you look or act. After all, men don't look or act one way.   Moving on from that, your mom'll probably (unfortunately) be an issue until you're able to put some distance between yourself and her. Finding a good group of people that support you and your identity can help some -- even if you can't stop her from misgendering you, the more people that you find that respect you can sometimes make it easier to drown out that voice.   I wish you the best of luck <3
    • RaineOnYourParade
      Dang, this post started a loooooong time ago :o   I'm not the most masculine guy, and I would be way too terrified to talk about any desire to be a boy tbh. Everyone said I was girl, I was told I had girl parts, all that, so I figured there was no other option, even if I wanted to be a boy. So, I basically masked the few remaining "signs" I would have after taking away some stereotypical guy things. I was a bit of a tomboy, but I didn't mind wearing fem clothing, and I was seen as just that -- a bit of a boyish girl.   Though, one internalized sign I did have and never talked about was my obsession with Mulan. A girl who got to go and be a guy. She got to hang out with the guys, eat and sleep with the guys, act like a guy, learn the same things the guys in the movie did. I thought every girl would be jealous of that... apparently not, lol 
    • RaineOnYourParade
      It depends what you consider "rich". "Rich" as in there's plenty going on in there? Yeah, sure. Doesn't mean it's high quality junk. There's a lot of complicated stuff I'm still working on sorting out, so even if I've got a lot in my inner life, it's such a mess that it looks more like a hoarder's den than the nice, temple-like space a "rich inner life" makes me think of.     Then I'm definitely doing something wrong with thinking haha 😅 My brain is physically incapable of not thinking about something. I can focus on one thing if I try really hard or if it's a specific interest of mine, but I have to keep thinking on it, otherwise my brain just starts jumping around. If I leave my brain alone, it sometimes jumps to some stuff that kinda scares me, so I don't think my thoughts will ever go to silence     Great minds think alike, I suppose! :D
    • Ivy
      I will add, Sometimes it's just a look of recognition from a woman, say like in a coffeeshop, store, etc. that helps me feel like I do belong.  I don't get that recognition from men anymore - and don't miss it.
    • Ivy
      I wanted to say this too. One thing that is hard for trans women is not having had the girl's socialization growing up.  A lot of the time we just don't know how to act, and that shows. For myself, sometimes I hold back maybe more than I should out of fear of seeming "creepy." Acceptance varies.  Some women are quite accepting, others less so.  I usually wait to be invited to participate.  I don't want to push myself on anybody.   These days I don't have much interaction with men anyway.  Perhaps my seeing men as "other" gets picked up on by women.  I don't know.  I seem to fall back on "it's complicated."   I think when you understand what women go through in this patriarchal society it helps to understand better.  As trans women, we do get some of this as well, but most of us didn't have to grow up with it. Over time, and even pre-transition, I've developed a very feminist view of our society.  (Also raising 6 daughters helped a bit.)  But that is a whole other subject.
    • Vidanjali
      I spend time reflecting on this too. I do so in terms of transcending mind. I study Vedanta, mystical yoga philosophy, under guru's guidance. The mind-body complex is spoken of where "mind" is further parsed as ego, mind, intellect, unconscious all interacting with each other. It is said that one's real Self is soul and from a transcendent point of view, soul is not individualized, but One. It is through the illusion of ignorance we experience a world of multiplicity. Soul reflected through conditioned mind projects our seemingly subjective experience. When our unconscious is steeped in negative impressions, the ego is inflated. That inflated ego influences intellect which is the faculty of discernment, reasoning, and will, to direct the mind to project the negativity it believes is true. Negative experience of the world creates further negative impressions in the unconscious and thus a vicious cycle occurs. But likewise we are able to exert self-effort to control the mind, break that cycle and plant seeds of positivity in the unconscious by doing good practices in many ways.    It is said that mind is the cause of bondage and release. My guru once said if your thinking lead to more and more thinking, then there is something wrong with your thinking. But if your thoughts lead to thoughtlessness, then you are on the right track. That is, one can do many things with the mind - make the mind one-pointed, make the mind distracted, or make the mind so still that it negates itself. That is a taste of bliss.   So, do I have a rich inner life? I would say I do. But that was not a given; I aspire for it. It requires persistent effort and patience. And the term "rich" is not literal. Lord Jesus said, blessed are the poor in spirit for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. By this, "poor" is also not meant literally. Poor in spirit is the state of cessation of ego and attachment - there is no "me" or "mine". In that state the kingdom which is Absolute Bliss is attained.
    • Ivy
      Welcome Cynthia
    • Sally Stone
      Post 11 “The Move West”    I mentioned in previous posts how many of the places I lived impacted my comfort level, and from my perspective, living in New Jersey was the perfect location for a trans woman.  However, other factors, such as property taxes and living costs, meant my wife and I couldn’t comfortable retire there.  Additionally, my wife wanted to live closer to our kids, and I couldn’t deny her that desire, especially since she dutifully followed me around the globe during my military and flying career.  Because the boys both lived on the “left” coast, we were going to retire somewhere in the western half of the United States.    Searching for places to retire, we wanted a locale that was easy on taxes and benefitted retirees.  However, I was ever vigilant for a place that was going to be trans friendly.  We actually passed on many places because, based on the research I did, they were not considered good locales for alternative lifestyles.  The internet has its issues, but there are numerous LGBTQ resources that helped us make an informed decision.  Despite the research we did, you really can’t know if you are going to be comfortable somewhere until you’ve actually lived there.   The plan was to select a location, and move when I retired.  However, the demand for real estate in New Jersey put our house in high-demand, and our real estate agent suggested we sell as soon as possible to take advantage of the market.  We put the house up for sale and it sold in under 15-days.  Suddenly, we had to find a new place to live, so instead of waiting until I stopped working, we relocated immediately.    Nevada had always come up as a great retirement location.  There was no state tax, and the cost of living was much lower than any of the other places we had on our list.  Surprisingly, many of the larger Nevada municipalities scored high as LGBTQ locations.  Las Vegas got the best LGBTQ ratings but we didn’t want to live in such a large city.  However, both Carson City and Reno looked like acceptable alternatives.  We chose the Reno area, although the house we bought is about 50-mile away from the city.   In the back of my mind, I kept wondering if the research I had done about Reno being LGBTQ friendly was accurate.  Clearly, I had assumed some risk here, since the research results didn’t specifically address the transgender community.  Adding to my anxiety, I couldn’t find any local trans groups, and the Reno LGBTQ community center’s transgender page hadn’t been refreshed in several years.  The only way for me to know for sure what things would be like for me, was to put myself out there.    Sally’s first day in Reno would be a June Saturday morning.  The plan was to do some shopping and find a place to eat lunch.  I started my day by stopping at Starbucks for coffee.  It was a pleasant surprise to greeted so openly by the staff, and this seemed a first positive sign.  Then it was off to the mall.  I shopped at a few of the department stores, and strolled through the mall proper.  It was a busy Saturday, with lots of people out and about, but I never noticed an odd or disparaging look, nor did I encounter a personal interaction that wasn’t anything but pleasant and cordial.  After the mall, I stopped at PF Chang’s for lunch.  Since I was alone, I asked the hostess if I could get food at the bar.  The young lady tending the bar that day was so sweet, and we immediately became friends.  The next thing I knew, I was being introduced to other servers, and became the center of their attention.  They raved about my outfit and the boots I was wearing.  Talk about feeling special.    So, my first day as Sally was awesome, and since that first outing, I have never had an uncomfortable moment in Reno.  I have also noticed several trans women in my travels, so obviously there is a population here.  It kind of surprises me there isn’t an active social group, but then maybe the women I’ve encountered have settled into society here, and don’t need it.  I don’t actually need a trans specific social group either.  My wife is my BFF, and she and I get out together often enough that I don’t feel lonely or alone.   I bet there are other girls out there; however, who are still in the closet, or perhaps don’t know how much fun Reno is.  For those girls, I have considered starting a social group.  In fact, I have already coordinated a “girl’s” weekend for this coming September.  The plan is to spend the weekend enjoying all Reno has to offer, but centered around a Saturday evening concert.  It should be lots of fun, and I’m looking forward to it.  The challenge is getting the word out.  I probably need to coordinate with the local LGBTQ center to help spread the word.   Turns out Reno is a fun place to live even though I am trans.  The people Sally has met have all been very friendly, but I can’t imagine it being any other way, since Sally is also friendly, and based on my interaction with others, very likeable as well.  I think I’m living proof that when you are open, friendly, have a positive attitude, and smile a lot, people respond in kind, even when they might know, or have a hint you weren’t born the gender you are presenting.    One could assume that my positive social experiences have just been dumb luck, but when I consider how long I have been out as Sally, it can’t just be luck.  I know in my heart, that I am doing something right, that my female personality resonates in a way that ensures I am accepted as the woman I am trying to be.   Hugs,   Sally
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...