Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Gender Ideas Illustrated


Guest Evan_J

Recommended Posts

Guest Evan_J

Hmmmm. I don't want this to go anywhere crazy so folks try to keep it "containable".ie no fighting about transmen having babies thats not where I wanna go. But as usual I was wandering around the internet bumping into stuff I didn't know was going to be there. And I came across this photo. It was part of a question about fathers and paternity leave. So it wasn't part of a "joke" or anything. The comments of course about that topic though had a lot to do with gender. In the end it made me wonder how the picture affected people in terms of their ideas and feelings about gender.

Does it have an affect on us here? If so what is it?

(and yes I edited his gown just a little more coverage to pass the censors so forgive the telltale nonartistic attempt:rolleyes: )

Link to comment
Guest A.S.

Never thought they would come across that.... I heard one about a man who gave birth to the baby which he's one of us.... I do remember there was a movie about a man gave birth by doing researching or something... I forgot the name of it. It been a while back if i could recalled.

Link to comment
Guest Princess Elle

That picture made me go :huh: and a little voice went "that's so wrong..." I guess it's because I have never seen a picture of a man who just gave birth to a baby. If I seen more pictures and know the background information on it better, I would see it as normal. That could be true one day in the future and I'm positive that when it happens, I'll support it. (Mainly to teach men how hard it is to give birth :lol:) I kid, I kid! :P

Link to comment
Guest Lee-Asher Geo-James

My reaction to the picture is "mhm"

Really it seems "Normal" to me.

Like I don't think it looks wrong or whatever. :blink:

Maybe because I don't see Gender as anything that has to do with giving birth. :huh:

I don't know. :lol:

Just seems right to me I guess you could say.

I probably made no sense what so ever. <_<

*hugs*

LeeAsher

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean

The picture doesn't assault my senses like it might someone outside of the community.....

Because my being here has broadened my horizons...

But, at first look, I do find it rather incongruous as one would if they saw something totally out of the norm.

A transman having a child? Well, look at how many Transwomen here, have fathered a child. It's just the way it is....

Weird pic, but, totally understandable.....

Donna Jean

Link to comment
Guest lvmyftm
Never thought they would come across that.... I heard one about a man who gave birth to the baby which he's one of us.... I do remember there was a movie about a man gave birth by doing researching or something... I forgot the name of it. It been a while back if i could recalled.

Wasn't that the movie that the Governator (Arnold Schwarzenegger) was in? I remember that one as well. I remember thinking wouldnt that be nice if men could carry babies too. But in reality men are too big of babies to handle being prego and giving birth, sorry but true. Thomas Beattie is the transman that has very publicly given birth. I have issues with him. I live in the same state as him and have gotten inside information from people he contacted prior to getting prego that he did so not only to have a family with his wife but to also make money off it if. If a transman wants to have a baby of his own and give birth to it so be it, its not my place to place judgement on that. But to do so publicly and make a big show of it I think discredits all other transmen and in a way is a step backwards in them being viewed as real men in society. But that is just my opinion for what is is worth.

The pic you posted is very obvious artwork that is meant to make a point. Just cuz you didn't physically give birth doesn't mean you aren't needed at home with a newborn. The pic in and of itself doesn't strike any nerves or reactions with me, more of a thought provoking piece.

Link to comment
Guest My_Genesis
But in reality men are too big of babies to handle being prego and giving birth, sorry but true.

Actually, you are right. :) Women actually have a higher threshold for pain than men do (sorry bros, it's a scientific fact, even though us guys like to act all manly and pretend we're not in pain when we are :P) and the reason women biologically can handle more pain is so that they can better handle the pain of childbirth.

Thomas Beattie is the transman that has very publicly given birth. I have issues with him. I live in the same state as him and have gotten inside information from people he contacted prior to getting prego that he did so not only to have a family with his wife but to also make money off it if. If a transman wants to have a baby of his own and give birth to it so be it, its not my place to place judgement on that. But to do so publicly and make a big show of it I think discredits all other transmen and in a way is a step backwards in them being viewed as real men in society. But that is just my opinion for what is is worth.

I actually agree with you there. I would not want to be pregnant, I think in a way men are biologically programmed to not have such a desire, but women are, because they have that maternal instinct and all. So in a way I feel like a man wanting to get pregnant does not do much to help our case as transmen, because we just want to be accepted as men. So it's mainly the societal implications that I have an issue with. But my personal feelings about it aside, I don't want to judge his decision. But the publicity surrounding it I kinda have an issue with.

Link to comment
Guest My_Genesis
The pic you posted is very obvious artwork that is meant to make a point. Just cuz you didn't physically give birth doesn't mean you aren't needed at home with a newborn. The pic in and of itself doesn't strike any nerves or reactions with me, more of a thought provoking piece.

Sorry for the double post. I agree with you here as well.

Link to comment
Guest Lee-Asher Geo-James
Thomas Beattie is the transman that has very publicly given birth. I have issues with him. I live in the same state as him and have gotten inside information from people he contacted prior to getting prego that he did so not only to have a family with his wife but to also make money off it if. If a transman wants to have a baby of his own and give birth to it so be it, its not my place to place judgement on that. But to do so publicly and make a big show of it I think discredits all other transmen and in a way is a step backwards in them being viewed as real men in society. But that is just my opinion for what is is worth.

He really did it for money!?!?!?!??!?!?

Link to comment
Guest Evan_J
He really did it for money!?!?!?!??!?!?

I can't decide if the "!?"'s indicate sarcasm or you really didn' t know, so assuming you didn't yes, the strong word in the vine is he did it for money.

That aside though. I (like many of you ) thought cerebrally that I was "used to" the idea of a male body having a baby cuz its discussed in trans circles from a lot of perspectives but when I saw the "graphic"/actual visual of it it "jarred" me and like princess elle's words my viseral response was that it was outside of what I put in the actions/functions of males.

No real statements about it. Just gauging my reaction I suppose. Found that interesting that even being trans and talking about all kinds of stuff when confronted with a visual of the body that was what I had. Wondered about others.

Link to comment
Guest Ami James
Wasn't that the movie that the Governator (Arnold Schwarzenegger) was in? I remember that one as well. I remember thinking wouldnt that be nice if men could carry babies too. But in reality men are too big of babies to handle being prego and giving birth, sorry but true. Thomas Beattie is the transman that has very publicly given birth. I have issues with him. I live in the same state as him and have gotten inside information from people he contacted prior to getting prego that he did so not only to have a family with his wife but to also make money off it if. If a transman wants to have a baby of his own and give birth to it so be it, its not my place to place judgement on that. But to do so publicly and make a big show of it I think discredits all other transmen and in a way is a step backwards in them being viewed as real men in society. But that is just my opinion for what is is worth.

The pic you posted is very obvious artwork that is meant to make a point. Just cuz you didn't physically give birth doesn't mean you aren't needed at home with a newborn. The pic in and of itself doesn't strike any nerves or reactions with me, more of a thought provoking piece.

I believe so that it was who played by Arnold Schwarenegger. Ain't too sure... It been forever since I watched that darn movie...

I got to agree what ya post about the pic.

Link to comment
Guest Lee-Asher Geo-James
I can't decide if the "!?"'s indicate sarcasm or you really didn' t know, so assuming you didn't yes, the strong word in the vine is he did it for money.

I really didn't know. Honestly.

That's horrible that he did that. :(

Link to comment
Guest NatashaJade
I believe so that it was who played by Arnold Schwarenegger. Ain't too sure... It been forever since I watched that darn movie...

I got to agree what ya post about the pic.

A film called "Junior." Strangely successful film in that weird line of Schwartzenegger/DeVito comedies.

luv

Gin

Link to comment
Guest Ami James

On Thomas Beattie topic,

I would be shame of him if he done for attention.

Back on the Movie....

I remember it now... Junior. That's it then... and yeah it is strange movie... I didn't think that movie going to popular back in old days

Link to comment
Guest Ami James
The cross realities of our biology is what be have to deal with and work with everyday

Hate to say... I got to agree with bernii.

Link to comment
Guest Ami James

Ok, I got a question...

When trans man gave birth, what would make him a daddy still or a mommy?

Does that ever come cross y'all minds?

Link to comment
Guest Elizabeth K

Before you go off the subject. I raised a newborn daughter - all but the first two months when my mother helped me - for about a year and a half - without help, after my wife died in birthing her. Yes I am trans and had the instincts perhaps. But I didn't know it at the time. People are capable of being a mother or a father (I am really both) if they just get past the stereotyping!

Lizzy

Link to comment
Guest Evan_J
Before you go off the subject. I raised a newborn daughter - all but the first two months when my mother helped me - for about a year and a half - without help, after my wife died in birthing her. Yes I am trans and had the instincts perhaps. But I didn't know it at the time. People are capable of being a mother or a father (I am really both) if they just get past the stereotyping!

Lizzy

That actually is very true. Cisgendered "man's men" can be very maternal. Likewise there are quite a few ciswomen who are lovin being women who do a great job of fathering.;

And to answer your question to the best of my knowledge......

Ok, I got a question...

When trans man gave birth, what would make him a daddy still or a mommy?

Does that ever come cross y'all minds?

In their family of course that depends on whats been decided.

Legally and on paper it depends on the state you are in , whether or not you are legally your transitioned sex on paper , and what that state allows if you are male. I say thtat because I do know of one father who is listed on his childs birthcertificate as the father.

Link to comment
Guest Ami James

Don't mean to offend anyone if i ever did but I am learning. It is pretty cool to able to be who we are... Such as being both mom and dad.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   5 Members, 0 Anonymous, 78 Guests (See full list)

    • Amy Powell
    • Roach
    • Siobhan F
    • awkward-yet-sweet
    • April Marie
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.9k
    • Total Posts
      771.3k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,159
    • Most Online
      8,356

    katheryn
    Newest Member
    katheryn
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Amber_Dawn
      Amber_Dawn
      (27 years old)
    2. AnnaOlivia
      AnnaOlivia
    3. cananna
      cananna
    4. CerealKiller
      CerealKiller
      (21 years old)
    5. country6389
      country6389
      (35 years old)
  • Posts

    • Ashley0616
      Still building 
    • Ashley0616
    • MaeBe
      Thank you for sharing your story with us, Kay! It’s not nonsense of which you write! I am glad to hear your family is with you. It truly is wonderful having support at home.    💜Mae
    • MaeBe
      Dreams, the latest battleground of dysphoria.   My dreams have been a battlefield between my socialized gender and the gender I’m living.   I feel like I should personify myself in dreams as feminine, however I find I’m “male” is many. It’s been difficult waking up when I remember the dream, as if the dream is telling me I am male and I am lying to myself. In these dreams, I do tend to have gender struggles, though; a recent dream had me choosing between gendered bathrooms, being “forced” into the men’s room by the women’s being opened from the inside by a woman and “scaring” me off. I felt wrong going into the men’s room, same as I do in waking hours, and it adds to my stress that I don’t seem to honor myself in my dreams.   How do you dream? Do you embody your lived gender or your socialized one?
    • Kay3Seven
      Hello! I'm Kay. And, I'm no good at introducing myself. Far too indecisive to be simple or easy. So I figure if I put it all out here, transparent and honest with y'all and myself, maybe I can make some real connection, maybe some life long... dare I say... friends!... anyhooo. The "quick" overview of my life: I'm 38, was born in 87 in Idaho where I still live(sigh) A happy little boy, I ran and jumped and played in the dirt. I was exactly what most imagine when they think of happy little boy, but only on the outside. By first grade I knew I was different. I got along with the girls better, and had lost most interest in boy dominated things. I was raised with 1 older and 1 younger sister. We played dress up, and with barbies, and I was happy. I still had lots of boy qualities tho, loved getting dirty and climbing things etc. So, nobody saw that I was different. By third grade I knew that I wasn't supposed to be in this body. I started a new school, lost my couple friends, couldn't explain to anyone why I was sad, and mad and I started acting out. I got into trouble nearly daily. I was diagnosed ADHD, and stuffed full of meds. It just made things worse. I remember feeling like I could tell anyone anything that I felt inside. So I acted out more, getting into fights, skipping school to just wander around town alone. Then the summer between 3rd-4th grade came.. that summer was spent with my dad and step mom, and step siblings. That summer I was molested by my older step brother, he also molested my sisters and a couple neighbor kids. It messed me up in ways I didn't understand until I was much older.  I was scared, but finally told my mom just before Christmas that same year. Then it all unfolded, life was never the same. But not in the way you might think.  My step brother went away, and all of the kids including myself went into therapy. For years.  (Now, the part I didn't understand for a long time)  I knew that what happened was wrong, and I was not to blame. But, I also never felt like I was damaged from it. It was a thing that happened, but I moved on very quickly. I did not want to be in therapy, so I refused to cooperate for years. I went thru a handful of counselors and therapists. I tried to open up once, about wanting to be a female. They said "it must be a way to cope with a male taking advantage of me" and "you don't want to be a girl, your confused"... it really put me behind mentally having an adult tell me that I didn't know how I wanted to present externally. It was the first person I told anything to, really made me shut down.  I didn't get a passing grade in any class since that day. I kept my secret, and lashed out at the world.  My poor mom, I drug her thru the mud for years. She's the most amazing person, I wish I would have known that she would love me no matter what. But... I didn't. I got into fights, out past curfew, and ended up on probation, even did some time in juvenile detention. It wasn't all a bad childhood tho. My mom loved us kids, we grew up poor, but loved.  *Details you'll need later: I spent a lot of time cross dressing from about fourth grade on. Even more confusing, once I discovered my sexuality by myself, I knew I was very primarily attracted to women, but also learned that I very much enjoy an*l play... very confusing set of circumstances at a young age..  Back to it now. Once seventh grade came around my older sister came out as bi-sexual. She was in ninth grade, and she was my hero. And it nearly gave me the strength to talk to my mom about myself. But before I could I overheard a conversation between my dad and stepmom, tearing my mom down, saying that my sister would be "normal" if she had a better mom... it hurt my soul so much watching her get bullied, losing friends, and being the odd one out. I went deeeep back into my hole. I didn't come out of that hole for 22 years.  I dropped out of school the day I turned 16, and went to work. I found lifelong friends in the automotive racing community, I forced myself to be an alpha male type. It was the hardest years of my life. But at least I wasn't alone. I'm still great friends with a couple of them to this day.  Years after high school, and probation and all the woes of youth I found myself to be very lost in life. I had just gone thru a major heartbreak, I was 22 and spiraling into a dark place. My best friend talked me into moving across state to go to college with him, and so off we went. I would call boise Idaho huge, but it was big to me. That's where I met my now wife of ten years. She's amazing. We have a nearly nine year old daughter, finally this year bought a home. She has a great career, I'm still not super set on a career, but have always had a good paying job. (I think I might go to back to school, shhhh, let's keep it between us as to not jynx it...., hopefully I find a job I can love instead first.) My loving wife is the reason I was finally able to come out, to process my hectic life, to start transitioning, and to be myself for once. I had a coming apart a couple years back, I was horrified that I would lose her, lose my daughter, my close family and my friends. I was so wrong. Apparently she's always known something was off. She had some mild worries that I might be interested in men from the way I carry myself, my interest in more femme things. She was relieved when I finally told her, she had been living with the fear that I was going to leave her someday for a lifestyle that better fit me. She was scared to lose her best friend. I'm now happy to say, my wife and daughter, mom and 3 sisters, and my closest friends are all in the loop. And they all support my changes.  I'm very lucky, dare I say blessed... lol. I'm still not out publicly, if your from idaho you might understand. It's very hard to be different here.  But I'm coming up on 8 months on hrt, have had 6 laser sessions on my face, still working on my weight, I'm a chunker(sugary things are my weakness lol.. and I've been slowly over the last couple years wearing things I love. I paint my nails, I wear mascara, I'm not really hiding things from the world. But also not pushing it into the light. Wow... I can go on like this forever! If you've made it here, thank you for sticking with me!  It feels good to be able to put all of my nonsense somewhere.  xoxo, Kay  
    • Mikayla2024
      thank you !! 😊   thank you girly! I was at Walmart today and my head shifted towards the women’s clothing while carting (not Mario Karting - just to be clear) by it. I felt all kinds of euphoria.    See, I would buy online but I don’t really know my size(s) off the bat yet or what fits me, but I want to start presenting as feminine at home and socially asap. Going out in androgynous clothing even though it’s mostly lulu is causing gender dysphoric symptoms to flare a bit. Once I figure out my size(s) I do plan to shop online, SHEIN being one of those places as my wife is also addicted.    I heard jersey and I assume you’re a sports fan!! But, I can SO imagine your walk-in closet 😍😍😍
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      I think trans women have more visibility simply because there are more of them.  Note the numbers on this forum...way more folks are MtF than FtM, it seems, and the FtM subforum is less busy than other areas.  I have some guesses about why that might be in society, but its not very relevant.  Being a minority of a minority of a minority is just part of our experience.  Not good or bad, it just is.    But yeah, you don't have to be MtF to experience crime.  I was assaulted and injured back in 2022.  My attacker didn't know about me being FtM/intersex, but clearly identified me as being under the LGBTQ+ umbrella.  It was reason enough, I guess.  Since then, it is really rare for me to leave home by myself for any reason.  Not that my problems are any worse than anybody else's.... quite the contrary, as I suspect I probably have it easier due to my family situation.  Just a personal example that crap happens and none of us are totally shielded. 
    • MaryEllen
      Rule # 4 of the community rules  4    Be supportive of all members. Implying that a particular member's problems are less pressing or valid than those of others is not allowed. Likewise, invalidating the experiences of another member or suggesting they're overreacting to their situation or faking a crisis is forbidden. If you feel unable to respond supportively to what a member is discussing, choose instead not to respond at all.
    • Nonexistent
      That's interesting, I didn't know that.   I do need to work on this with my therapist. I have so much self-hatred/embarrassment, and a lot of it relates to being trans. Thanks.
    • Amy Powell
      I love shopping for girl clothes as well, I usually stick to online shopping though. My latest purchase were some pink thongs. Whilst taking some suggestions from this post I have found thongs that are quite feminine but have a bit of a pouch to hold it all. They are really comfy ;-)
    • Vidanjali
      It's generally not helpful or kind to respond to anyone's sharing of their struggles but replying, "You think that's bad? Look at my problems." There is some value to taking a "it could be worse" point of view. But not when it's explicitly invalidating someone's particular struggle, and worse, a struggle which they made themself vulnerable to share. It is beneficial to consider one's blessings and practice gratitude. But that's not inherently the spirit of such one-up-personship (gender-neutral version of one-upmanship lol).   I'm glad your friend apologized and that you've forgiven her. But evidently you're haunted by the impression left on your mind. Each of us deserves compassion and understanding. We deserve safety.    The fact that this is troubling you so much reveals you are a compassionate and thoughtful person. Don't direct that against yourself, though, because doing so is not kind to yourself. If something like that happens again, I would suggest taking a deep breath and then telling the friend that you hear them and acknowledge their struggle. That you don't rank your and their struggles because they are real and present to each of you. Then try to direct the conversation to learning about each other's perspectives and how you can better support each other. Meanwhile, as you're clearly curious, engage in some reading to learn more about how to be an ally to trans women and people of color. That's a productive thing you can do.   I would also suggest for your consideration that this may have triggered some internalized transman phobia based on the fact that you're conflicted about the validity of your own struggles as a trans man. That can be difficult to detect when it rears its ugly head, so just think about it - it's possible it may help to make some sense of how you're feeling. In light of that, I'll repeat. Your struggles are no less significant than someone else's because you are the subject of that experience. One must take responsibility for their own emotions and reactions - you're ultimately the one who navigate you through this life, from a practical point of view. Therefore, don't indulge unduly in despair but try to focus on personal progress. And what aids that is service to others too by the practice of compassion, charity, and mercy. So, that practice requires balance - don't leave yourself out of it.
    • Vidanjali
      Also, I'd heard of Judith Butler, I think referenced in other works I'd read, and was intrigued to read them, but hadn't gotten around to it yet. So this was a very good primer especially given all the historical references, robust defining of terminology, and contemporary contextualization.
    • Vidanjali
      Excellent video. It may be lengthy, it's so compelling, enlightening and entertaining. All her videos I've seen are great, but this one is especially riveting.   I was thinking I wanted to share it with my husband who's recently expressed a renewed interest in reading and learning more about philosophy and social justice. And then at the end come to find out Abigail is an actor on the video game, Baldur's Gate 3 which my husband is super into. So when I told him he's now very interested to watch.    I'd love to share this with one "friend" who freaked me out several months ago by "coming out" rather guns blazing as a TERF. But I still haven't had the opportunity to speak with her about it (mostly she's been busy or withdrawn, and partly I'm not inclined to seek her out). Perhaps whenever we do reconnect I can challenge her to watch and she if she's willing and able to identify and break out of her own phantasm.   Thanks for sharing, @Ivy.
    • Ashley0616
      Congratulations and have fun! I love clothes shopping. Although I don't really buy in person unless it's at a thrift store. It's mostly online. I love SHEIN! Affordable and good quality. I have a walk-in-closet full of clothes. I remember when I completely got rid of all my male clothes. I have some androgenous shirts and a jersey and that is it. 
    • christinakristy2021
      Congrats, Mikayla. 
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...