Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Dr. Meltzer Or Dr. Mcginn?


Guest BeckyTG

Recommended Posts

Guest BeckyTG

Hello Sweet Sisters,

I am contemplating future surgery and wanting some input on Dr. Christine McGinn from her patients.

She seems fairly new at all this and I'm wondering how her patients regard her expertise, manner and, particularly, the aftercare experience.

I would welcome any knowledge that anyone would care to share, as this is a big step and a life-altering decision.

I'm also curious about Dr. Meltzer, who's been at this longer and wanting to know the same things.

Thank you.

Becky

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean

Our member, Michele, has just had SRS by Dr. McGuinn.

Lizzy

I was just about to say that, Lizzy....

You may want to shoot her a PM, Becky....

She's not been on the boards too much and she just went for her first check up....

'Huggs

Donna Jean

Link to comment

Dr. McGinn is a bravo heroic person a trans women and not only is competent as a surgeon but has a wonderful bed side manner..

A friend went to see her for post op therapy and physical examination and was more than pleased...

mia

xx

Link to comment
Guest ReginaRenea

Hello Sweet Sisters,

I am contemplating future surgery and wanting some input on Dr. Christine McGinn from her patients.

She seems fairly new at all this and I'm wondering how her patients regard her expertise, manner and, particularly, the aftercare experience.

I would welcome any knowledge that anyone would care to share, as this is a big step and a life-altering decision.

I'm also curious about Dr. Meltzer, who's been at this longer and wanting to know the same things.

Thank you.

Becky

Hi Becky; I live about a hundred miles from her clinic and all the research I did on her points to- 20 years experience with trans, she is trans herself, and she was flight surgeon for 2 spaceshuttle missions. everyone that I found she worked on or she's still working with really like her. Dr McGinn is more sensitive to our needs as she went through the same thing. What I hear about Dr Meltzer is he's not so sensitive. He's good but personal I think Dr. McGinn is a better choice. Hope this helps you? HUGS Regina Renea

Link to comment

Becky hon,

Another site i frequent has quite a few that had their surgery by her including her 3rd, there were such good reviews I had a consult with Dr. Mcginn in June, she seems to be a very caring person, has quite strict guidelines she follows and takes lots of time, i was with her for over an hour and another transwoman that met us there and wanted to ask her something and did not have an appointment she took time to accommodate her, the next day i scheduled my date for next year and paid my deposit, i am pleased and am sure i am in good hands. Michelle H had her surgery with her at the end of June, you might try a pm.

As far as Dr. Melzer, i have heard good things about him as well, though he is the most expensive of the srs surgeons.

If you have any one of the top surgeons most are pleased with the results.

Paula

Link to comment

Dr Meltzer has had the most consistant best reputation for over 10 years. I have known several personally who have gone to him and have talked with a couple dozen online through the years. I have never heard a single direct complaint.

The big reason people did not go to Meltzer were two fold. One was cost. He has always been on the more expesive side but far from the most expensive.

Second is that he favored a two step procedure. Vaginoplasty and then some period later labiaplasty. There are very good reasons for this. Essentially fine detail is very hard to maintain if both are attempted at the same time. Other surgeons such as Brassard and Menard in Montreal had been doing a single step procedure but in doing so sacraficed some of the finer detail. For many patients however that was perfectly acceptable. Labiaplasty was never requred with Meltzer, it was an option. Many found the basic vaginoplasty procedure provided satisfying results and did not feel the need for the second surgery. The second procedure as I recall is an outpatient thing so a hospital stay and general anestisa wasn't required. I would not be suprised if Meltzer may offer a single procedure now just because many expect it these days.

I don't have any personal experience with Meltzer and my observatiosn are simply based upon reputation, the several that I know in person who have gone to him and the couple dozen I have met online.

As for McGinn, I think the jury is out on her. She is still new and hasn't developed much of a reputation. In comparison to Meltzer, I know relitivly few (in person or online) who have gone to her. Yet of the few I know of, I have heard of some issues. Complications happen with all surgeons however. She will develop a reputation but at the moment, she gets a good ride from Marci's coat tails since she was trained by Marci.

As for McGinn being trained by Marci, I would point out that Marci is also a newcommer in her own right and received her own training from from Biber who was generally considered to be a fair, but not great surgeon at the time. So to me, the fact that she was trained by Marci doesn't carry a good deal of water. Marci's reputation seems to stem mostly from her television fame.

On a personal level, a friend of mine did go to McGinn and I have met McGinn and have had some dealings with her. In my friend's case, McGinn performed the procedure in a way that a more experience surgeon (Dr Menard) had mentioned is not the best thing to do in a conversation I had with him a couple years earler. It shows in the surgical results in a negative way. To me this was suggestive of inexperience or simply not having had learned from someone with more advanced techniques.

There are certain some things McGinn has going for her regardless. She is lower priced for one. She makes herself available if there are problems. In my friend's case, after a problem developed, she provided her cell phone number so she could directly be reached if the issue got more serious. In my own dealings with her office, they seemed fairly efficient which is a rarity among doctors offices these days. One minor annoyance is that the office did make an error in the gender confirmation surgery letter and my friend got charged a second time to get the corrected notarized copies. Small money, but annoying as it was their error.

So I wouldn't rule out McGinn by any stretch. I only note that she is relitivly new and thus is more of an unknown quantity as far as her skill at performing SRS. As someone else mentioned she isn't new to medical practice.

As an aside, and for purposes of disclosure, my surgeon was Dr Menard. I know the question here was about McGinn and Meltzer, but one also can look to Montreal for reasonable costs and what is generally considered to be the best after care experience by far.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 107 Guests (See full list)

    • Betty K
    • Karen Carey
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.7k
    • Total Posts
      769.3k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,057
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Aleksandria
    Newest Member
    Aleksandria
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Conner_Sent_By_Cyberlife
      Conner_Sent_By_Cyberlife
      (22 years old)
    2. CtN1p
      CtN1p
    3. heyim_finn
      heyim_finn
      (21 years old)
    4. Jayn
      Jayn
    5. joni_girl_1988
      joni_girl_1988
      (51 years old)
  • Posts

    • Heather Shay
    • Heather Shay
      Do you use make-up? If so, why and what  types?
    • Heather Shay
      Pride is primarily about yourself, even when it is not you who did something that you are proud about. You can also be proud of something someone else did, who you associate with, such as your children or your favorite football team. People can feel proud of their culture, their family name, or their appearance, none of which require them to actively contribute to the praiseworthy thing1. However, the opinions of others are of crucial importance, as best demonstrated when you purposefully do something that other people praise. Pride is a social emotion, and to feel proud, you need other people’s (real or imagined) confirmation that you have a reason to feel that way. Because of this, other people can also ‘be in your head’ and prevent you from feeling pride. Namely, what is praiseworthy is subjective. Things that may be considered good in a certain (cultural) group may not be praiseworthy in another (e.g., if you grew up in a family that greatly values academics, your athletic abilities may not evoke much praise). Moreover, what is praiseworthy is relative (e.g., if you are a good runner in an athletically average school, you may regularly feel proud about your times; but if you move to a school with highly competent athletes, these same times may seem unremarkable to you). Thus, the more exclusive your quality is in your surroundings, the prouder you feel. Pride has recognizable features. Although its static facial expression (typically a smile or laugh) does not clearly distinguish it from other positive emotions, it typically results in a bodily posture, gestures, and behavior that are clearly recognizable: lifting your chin, looking people in the eye, walking confidently, or in extreme cases, raising arms above your head. In a way, you try to make yourself larger and more noticeable, as if to say: ‘look at me!’ You may also exhibit more perseverance in your activities2. People generally find it very pleasant to experience pride, as it elevates our feeling of social self-worth and status3. At the same time, many social groups, religions, and cultures (especially those that are highly collectivistic, such as the East Asian or African culture) believe that pride needs to be checked. Unchecked pride leads to arrogance and misplaced feelings of superiority (‘letting something get to your head’, ‘hubris comes before the fall’), and social groups typically do not tolerate members feeling like they are superior or deserve special treatment.  
    • Heather Shay
    • Heather Shay
    • Heather Shay
    • April Marie
      Thank you @missyjo! You do wonders for my ego.   It turns out that pastel colors were the "thing" at Kentucky Derby Day so my dress was perfect. I went with white 5" heeled sandals and a wide-brimmed fuscia hat. Dinner and Mint Juleps added to the fun of watching the (recorded) festivities and races.   Perhaps, we'll repeat it for the Preakness in 2 weeks.   Right now it's just blue striped sleep shorts with pink flowers, a pink t-shirt and flip flops. I can't tell you how much wearing  sleep-rated breast forms at night has done to quell my dysphoria. 
    • April Marie
      I can still rock 5" heels.
    • April Marie
      Good morning, everyone!!   My wife and I had our yearly Kentucky Derby Day evening. Dresses, heels, hats, Mint Juleps and a light dinner while watching the festivities and races. Relaxing and fun. I think we'll do the same for the Preakness in two weeks.   It's rainy and cool here today so it's pretty much going to keep me indoors. Ahh, well. A day of rest.   Enjoy and be safe!!
    • Ladypcnj
      Thanks Sally Stone
    • KymmieL
      Thanks, Mindy. It has been so far. Tomorrow, work some more on the wife's grand monkey. Got the right side of the hood primed, just need to do a little more work on the left then I can prime it. Then a 600grit wet sand.   I promised the wife we would take out the bike this weekend.   Kymmie
    • JessicaMW
      During my last visit with my psychologist (who has agreed to provide required letters of recommendation along with a colleague to provide the second) we discussed the shift towards my wife's acceptance. It was a long discussion but one point I mentioned was how much the two of us sitting down and watching this documentary helped:  The Kings | A transgender love story (2017)
    • Betty K
      Oops, I did not mean to post that comment yet! I was going to also say, having read a mountain of commentary on the Review, I think Julia Serano’s response (linked by Vicky above) is the most accurate and thorough. You can also read a non-paywalled version at Substack: https://juliaserano.substack.com/p/the-cass-review-wpath-files-and-the   To me the three key areas in which the review is deficient are:   1. As has already been said here, its views on social transition;   2. Its attempts to give credence to the “ROGD” theory (without ever actually mentioning ROGD because presumably a canny editor knows that would be too transparently transphobic);   3. To me, most crucially, its claims about trans youth and suicide, which are dealt with summarily in about five pages and do not stand up to any deeper scrutiny.    I will be writing about each of these issues in isolation over the next few weeks and appearing on a radio show and podcast to discuss them late in the month. I will post links to these on TP later if anyone is interested.   All that said, I actually think it’s dangerous for us to respond with outright vitriol and condemnation to the review since, like any effective piece of disinformation, it does actually contain some factually based and even helpful recommendations. The Tavistock Gender Identity Service really was underfunded and understaffed and certain staff were not adequately trained. Trans kids really were funnelled away from mental-health support once they started gender-affirming care too. So yes, more investment in youth psychology services would help, as would a less centralised model of care, more training in treatment of trans kids, and more research.   One last thing for now: beware the claim that Cass ignored 98% of studies. That’s not strictly true. She seems to have taken other studies into account but leaned heavily on the 2% that met her standards. Nor does she ever claim that only randomised controlled trials are good enough evidence to justify the use of blockers for kids; just as with ROGD, she strongly suggests this, but is too canny to say it, because she knows such trials would be impossible. For now, I think the best response to this comes from the Trans Safety Network: “[…] we believe there to be systemic biases in the ways that the review prioritises speculative and hearsay evidence to advance its own recommendations while using highly stringent evidence standards to exclude empirical and observational data on actual patients. “ (https://transsafety.network/posts/tsn-statement-on-cass-final-report/)   To me, the scariest aspect of all this is that, if it follows Cass’s recommendations, the NHS will very likely follow Finland’s recent model of trans care, which seems to amount to a prolonged form of conversion therapy. I can’t find the link right now, which is probably lucky for anyone reading this, but I bawled my guts out reading the testimonies of kids who had been mistreated by that system. Truly horrific. To me, at least from my Australian perspective, the Cass Review is the most frightening development in trans rights in recent years. To me, the safe care of trans kids is THE number one issue in politics atm.   Ruth Pierce has a good summary of responses from trans folk and their allies sk far: https://ruthpearce.net/2024/04/16/whats-wrong-with-the-cass-review-a-round-up-of-commentary-and-evidence/    
    • Sally Stone
      Welcome to the wide, wild world of transgender, M.A.  It can definitively be overwhelming, but everyone here is amazing, so no doubt you'll get bunches of wonderful support. I think you'll be happy you found us.   
    • Sally Stone
      @Ladypcnj  This is so true.  I think all of us here have had a post or two that didn't get a response.  Sometimes, it's as simple as adding to your original to post for a clearer explanation, or re-reading what you wrote originally, and rephrasing it.  But don't despair, we aren't ignoring you.   Hugs,   Sally 
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...