Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Whipping Girl


Guest laeta_lacrima

Recommended Posts

Guest laeta_lacrima

I recently came across "Whipping Girl: A Transsexual Woman on Sexism and the Scapegoating of Femininity" at my local library and I decided to buy it while I was reading "Trans Woman Manifesto" which precedes chapter one. Julia Serano has a very unique approach in writing this book. It's half autobiography and half observation and explanation. It's not entirely one or the other. It's an unusual way to write a book, but Julia uses it to perfection. She brought to my attention how a lot of feminist organizations discriminate against transsexuals. She discusses how transsexuality and femininity in general is portrayed in the media and how it's viewed by mainstream society. It's really hard to describe the book in a way that really shows how good it is. Julia Serano is a biologist and her observations are razor-sharp, and she really does not hold back. It's very empowering read and very informative. Julia brought up ideas about transsexuality, being transsexual, and living in a misogynistic, transphobic, and homophobic world that I never thought of in all of my own personal contemplations.

Although Julia Serano does discuss her own experiences on HRT and compares how she was treated differently when she was perceived male and female, she makes clear that she wasn't going to make a book entirely about her experience of transitioning and her feelings before and after. She does this because she's seen how the media uses these kinds of books as a way of exploiting transsexuals and it keeps transsexuality "exotic" and "strange" in the eyes of most readers. Julia wanted to make sure she was able to relate her views and her feelings in a way that would be different and written in a way that could not be exploited, and she did so perfectly. Not only did she put this much thought into the delivery and structure of the book, but she puts this much thought in pretty much every sentence in the entire book. I might be hyping up the book, but that's pretty much what the entire book felt like to me.

This book is a must read for everyone.

Link to comment
Guest ChloëC

Thank you for the review and comments. I really appreciate you adding the following

She does this because she's seen how the media uses these kinds of books as a way of exploiting transsexuals and it keeps transsexuality "exotic" and "strange" in the eyes of most readers.

It's what I have felt since I first started reading autobios and other stories, expecially in the 70's and 80's. Nice to see it in print.

Hugs

Chloë

Link to comment
  • 2 months later...
Guest Jessie M

from moving mine is still packed and read most of it so far but sure i will go back and look at it again. it has been a great book and have enjoyed it alot.

Luv

Jessie

Link to comment
Guest Lacey Lynne

Hon, this is arguably the best book to date on the matter, IMHO. The media? Mainstream society? Both are utterly insane. Anyway, yes, you are so right about this book! Definitely, it's a keeper and any thinking person would do well to read it and discuss it with anybody willing to actually listen. Great thread and recommendation you've made here. Thanks!

;) Lacey

Link to comment
Guest Mina89

Dealing with social stuff as I do, I've found "utterly insane" applies to every identifiable society, institution, culture, subculture, counterculture, group, and association. The outliers are even weirder. Maybe this whole "sanity" thing needs to be re-evaluated?

Whipping Girl is excellent. My therapist recommended it and I finished it in a week.

-Valerie

Link to comment

Nevermind -_- my phone decided to scroll to the very bottom and all I saw was the last post. Sorry >< I guess I need to stop posting from my phone...

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...
  • 5 months later...
Guest Nikki_R

Bought this book within a week of coming out to myself. A must read. It cleared a lot of things up fast and allowed me to utilize the web more. I do have a little bit left because I've been too busy with classes, but as soon as I'm finished I'm letting the family read it. Also I have been considering buying a bunch to hand out to certain people in my circles for when I come out to them and give them a list of pages/chapters that I think they must read.

Link to comment
  • 2 months later...
Guest AngelSO

Oh wow - we just picked this up at our local bookstore. Szenzie's reading it first then we're swapping books. :D We'll be sure to comment on it when we're finished.

Link to comment
  • 1 month later...
Guest Szenzie

I finished Whipping Girl a while ago and I've been meaning to write my own thoughts but I haven't gotten to it yet. The only value I can add for a review is that this is probably the best book I've ever read in my life. Seriously. At least non-fiction. By far. I've never agreed with a book so much in my life. I was constantly, page by page jumping up out of my chair and being like "YEAH! That's exactly what has been bothering me about _insert aspect of society here_. I usually write in my books and I found my self underlining the entire darn thing (kind of defeated the purpose, amirite?).

Natalie Reed, the woman who authored a couple of the popular "Misconceptions about Trans Women" articles that were posted here also thinks so

and listed it as her top read today. I'm not surprised she's a Julia Serano fan too since I'm a fan of her blogging.

One final plug... if anyone is in the Atlanta area, check out Charis Books & More. They're located at Little 5 and have an excellent feminist collection, free hot tea, and a trans section that let me find this book without having been told in advance that it was the greatest thing since sliced bread. When checking out, the cashier explained to me that it was an awesome book and was recently on thier bookclub list.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 261 Guests (See full list)

    • Vivelacors
    • VickySGV
    • awkward-yet-sweet
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.8k
    • Total Posts
      770k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,091
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Layla Marie hay
    Newest Member
    Layla Marie hay
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Britton
      Britton
      (53 years old)
    2. chipped_teeth
      chipped_teeth
    3. james-m
      james-m
    4. jenny75
      jenny75
      (34 years old)
    5. KASS13
      KASS13
  • Posts

    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Wow, a shop that actually respects a customer's truck?  That seems like a miracle!  My husband does most of his own work, because he really, REALLY hates people who mess with an interior, with grease spots or footprints.  His personal truck is old, but super clean.  And since he's the transportation manager for his company, he's pretty picky about people respecting company equipment.  "Take care of it, and it will take care of you" is the motto.  Drivers should be able to go through a DOT Level 1 inspection without worry. 
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Literally the word means "hatred of women" and so I don't think that's quite the right description for what you encountered.  Possibly chauvinism?  Or maybe just not wanting to bother somebody he figured wasn't interested or capable of doing the job?  Who knows.   But on the other hand...be glad you're passing
    • VickySGV
      Finally found a site that gives the definition of defemination as a process of loss of feminine characteristics or continued loss of them.  Not a word I would use every day, although I can see where it would be a problem for some who value those feminine characteristics.  Yes I have seen it happen and now get the idea, and yes, not in so many words, but yes I have been up against others who do put down my femininity as being a pseudo female at the most polite and I cannot use the words hear for what it is at the worst.   Online, there is little to do about it except leave and block the people who do it and the places it happens, since it affects you much more heavily and negatively than it does the person doing it, and you need freedom from the stress.  The rules here which our "powers that be", namely the staff say we do not put up with members denying the authentic identity of other members. 
    • VickySGV
      I still maintain my "male" skills and almost have to laugh when that sort of thing happens to me with Cis males, and it does happen.  On the other side there, I have activities with the Trans community  here where I live including Trans Men who love to show off their new lives.  I have had a couple come over to my house and I have done some shop teaching that is always fun.  When they offer to help me by doing "male stuff" in a group, I do not take it as misogyny .
    • Thea
      This guy asked me to help with his tire.  So when I turned around and he saw that I'm a woman he's like,  oh nevermind
    • Betty K
      I think that’s an important point. In my case, I’ve found transitioning to be such a relief and a joy that I have no difficulty focussing on the positives. Maybe in your case you could make a practice of noting when you are gendered correctly? Do you keep a journal? I find doing so is major help.   After saying I rarely get misgendered, it actually happened to me yesterday in a local store. After recovering from my shock (the salesman called me “brother”, which to me is about as bad as it gets) I wrote my first complaint letter to a business w/r/t misgendering. That felt good. I also reflected that, to a degree, for those of us who don’t pass, I think gendering is correctly can take a conscious effort. Some Folks seem to automatically see me as feminine, others have to work at it. So if you’re often surrounded by people who have no desire to work at it, that may exacerbate your problem.      
    • Betty K
      I don’t know why anyone would go to the effort of advocating for trans folks only to charge people to read their articles. It seems so counterproductive, and I seriously doubt they’re making more than pocket money out of it. 
    • KathyLauren
      Oh, how I wish we were over-reacting!  But I don't think we are.  The danger is under-reacting. 
    • Ivy
      I understand your feelings. I have the same fears.  NC has made a swing to the right as well, and I'm not optimistic.  I want to tell myself I'm over reacting.  But seeing what these people are  saying, and doing when they do get into power can't be dismissed.  It's proof of what they will do if they take over the federal government. I'm getting kinda old now anyway.  It took me over 60 years to get here, and I'm not going back.  I suppose they can revert my gender markers, but I will still be legally Ivy.  And I have every intention of dying as Ivy Anna.  If I can't find my hormones somehow, I'll do without.  The physical changes I do have are permanent.   Trans people have always existed.
    • Willow
      @KymmieL I think we all have had to deal with a person who would not apologize when they were wrong no matter what.  In my case it was my MIL. Actually called me a lier I front of my wife.  Even when she realized she was wrong she wouldn’t admit it to my wife, nor would she apologize to my wife for any of the things she later admitted she had done that affected my wife.  I had a boss that accused me of saying things I did not say in a manner I did not use.  Even another employee told him that I had not said the things nor used the words but he still refused to back down.     Unfortunately, all too many people in this world believe they are always right no matter what.  Some are very famous.  lol   Willow    
    • KatieSC
      I wish I could cope as well as others. I feel very defeated in that all of the consideration, and then treatment to transition, could all be wiped out by this time next year with the united effort by the R party to eradicate all that is transgender. I fear that the national election could turn out to our detriment, and we will face a national push to eradicate us. Tracking us down will not be that hard to do. Once they know who we are, forcing the legislation to reverse our name changes, gender marker changes, and other records, will not be that hard. We saw an example when the AG in Texas was data mining the driver licenses for those who had gender marker changes. Who will we appeal to? The Supreme R Court? We would have an easier time trying to convince a Russian court.    We need to get out and vote in November. There is not enough Ben & Jerry's to improve my outlook on all of this. In some ways it is a cruel thing in a way. In the early 1930s, Germany was working hard to hunt down the LGBTQ population and eradicate it. Now Germany has better protections there than we have in many of our own states. About 90 years ago, Germany was seeing the rise of their very own dictator...Now the US is on the verge...Oh never mind. What a difference 90 years makes...    History may repeat itself, but sometimes it shifts the focus a little...
    • Nonexistent
      I have the same problem as you, my face is the main reason why I get misgendered I'm pretty sure. I think it's mostly up to genetics how your face will look (T can help, but still genetics will determine how you end up). You can't change your facial structure really, you can get facial masculinization surgery but it's expensive so not an option for most unless you're rich lol.    Experimentally (I haven't done it but want to), you could see if any plastic surgeons around you will give you Kybella in your cheeks. It is an injection that removes fat, and is usually used underneath the chin/on the neck below the jawline, but some may use it off-label on the face. The only potential problem with this is that if your face would naturally thin out at an older age, it could thin out extra and make you look older (though I'm not certain on this). Another option is to get filler in your jaw/chin, which would make your jawline look more square and your face more masculine. I want jaw filler but I'm poor lol, it only lasts one year up to a few years depending on what kind you get, so it would have to be done every so often and can get expensive. I did get chin filler once, only 2 small vials so it didn't make that big of a difference. I would recommend going for the jaw if you can only choose 1, I wish I had done that.   Those are the only options I know of that will bring legitimate noticeable changes.
    • April Marie
      Welcome to the forums, Blake!! We are happy that you found us!!
    • Mmindy
      Good evening Blake.   Welcome to Transgender Pulse Forums.   Best wishes, stay positive and motivated.   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋
    • Nonexistent
      Thank you.    Trans men and trans women each have their own struggles for sure, but I agree, it can be a hard time to be a non-passing trans guy. There is no specific "man clothes" that only men wear. People could just think I'm butch (which sucks to think about, if people think I'm a lesbian when I'm a dude!!). I mean I would feel better if I got gendered correctly even if I don't fully pass, it would maybe raise my confidence to think maybe I do pass well lol! Instead I'm just reminded I don't.   Though I may just focus on the times I don't pass and ignore the times that I do. Because I rarely remember getting gendered correctly, but I hone in on the times that I don't. 
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...