Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

"born This Way"


Guest someone or other

Recommended Posts

Guest someone or other

Does anyone else find this song incredibly problematic, if not a huge "love you" to trans folks?

I'm beautiful in my way,

'Cause God makes no mistakes

I'm on the right track, baby

I was born this way

And then she tries to make up for it by throwing this in at the end:

No matter gay, straight or bi

lesbian, transgendered life

Not to mention the racial slurs and such... I was just wondering what others' thoughts on this were.

Link to comment
Guest kelise

I'm not seeing your issue. I love this song. (plus it came out on my birthday)

I AM beautiful in my way

God DOESN'T make mistakes (I am not a mistake)

I AM on the right track baby

I WAS born this way!

Link to comment
Guest someone or other

I guess I interpret her wording as discouraging folks from transitioning, and coming from a white, able-bodied, cisgender woman who fits society's standards of beauty exactly, it sort of rubs me the wrong way.

Link to comment
  • Admin

Hon, I looked at the lyrics again to make sure I didn't miss something. I'm as mystified by your comments as Kairi. While there has been a little

controversy about the drag queen references, most commentators, as well as I, see it as her way of including the entire spectrum, as well as

Gay and Lesbian.

I saw no racial slurs in those lyrics, and the first set of lyrics you posted are, in my eyes, a wonderful affirmation that we are God's children as much

as anyone else.

I love the song.

Carolyn Marie

Link to comment
Guest kelise

I assure you, Gaga's got nothing but love for us. She owes her fame to the play she got in gay clubs. She has a special affection for Drag Queens, well, because many of them perform as her, and they help get her music and image out there long before anybody had even heard of her.

It's the first mainstream song in history to name us directly. For that alone she deserves our thanks.

Link to comment
Guest KimberlyF

Love her music, but I just didn't care for this song.

And yet, the idea that a hit song would just mention a transgendered life in my life makes me want to cry. And my wife downloaded it right away which made me happy too.

Kim

Link to comment
Guest someone or other

I guess I'm overly critical (too much queer theory will do that to you). Sorry to be such a downer! I will say, though, that "chola" and "orient" are not exactly PC. =/

Link to comment
Guest Orva26

Okay I don't have a problem with the song. You shouldn't expect a pop star to be divulging deep into transgenderism anyway!

Even the line:

Don't be a drag just be a queen

Doesn't bother me at all. Look at its meaning people! Its basically saying don't fall into a sterotype, just be yourself. That's a lesson that gets mentioned here ALL THE TIME! Now to my knowledge a good amount of drag queens aren't actually trans, rather they are gay or straight MEN who dress extremely over the top for entertainment purposes but here's the kicker. People KNOW what drag queens are and with pop music you kind of have to go with what people know about.

Overall I think the message of the song is a good one. Plus it has given me major respect for Lady Gaga. I'm not big into pop at all actually find most of what I ran into to be mindless dribble but then she comes along and BAM! Makes a pretty deep song.

Link to comment
Guest Doodlen

I was wondering about this song too. I really like it, but I was always wondering if transpeople really could relate to it. She includes us in the "no matter gay straight bi transgendered" line (something like that) but if the message of the song is that you were born the right way and all isn't that somethings transpeople can't relate to?

There is, of course, taking the lyrics to mean mentally instead of physically, so that makes sense.

Either way, I still love the song, still love Gaga. ^_^

Link to comment
Guest Leeny

I guess i can see why some people may interpret the song differently and might get negative feelings. But to me this song is pure love and i love her for making this wonderful piece. I just get such positive vibes from it and i feel loved, spoken to in so many ways. <3

I think she tells us, that we are all worth being loved and accepted as who we are, nomatter our appearance, disabilities etc. and what anyone believes is right or wrong. She also touches the subject of being bullied or worse for just being who you are and that you should be strong, continue to live, cause you arent wrong in any way. I dont believe in god, but she says the words i would have told any religious person who is being closeminded, then goes ahead to tell someone they are wrong cause of some writing, believe etc.

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...
Guest Cole Turner

I love the Song and it makes me feel confident as a Transgender. The song says don't fall into Stereotypes, Labels, just be yourself, Born the way you want to be.

Link to comment
Guest Melanie Dawn

I'm not seeing your issue. I love this song. (plus it came out on my birthday)

I AM beautiful in my way

God DOESN'T make mistakes (I am not a mistake)

I AM on the right track baby

I WAS born this way!

/thread!

this is exactly what it is.

Link to comment
Guest DésiréeG

I'm not seeing the issue either. born this way" doesn't mean "don't transition." To me it means: I was born with the brain of a female and the physical body of a male so I have to transition. I was born with this issue. It's a slap at all the people who say this is a choice.

I do have an issue with the orient and cholo lines though, as the words seem to have been chosen for meter and rhyme rather than for PCness, which does somewhat undercut the message of the song. I usually hate pop music (I'm a metalhead from long ago) but even I can't resist the catchiness of this tune.

Link to comment

I applaud lady Gaga for her attempt. It is a good song and its nice that someone mainstream acknowledges us in a positive light. For me the song is too simple and over hyped. While it speaks and in some cases empowers her LGBT audiences I don't think its going to make "normal" people stop and think about their perceptions of the LGBT community. Too simplistic and not revolutionary enough for me and didn't Madonna do something similar anyway? Oh well, I hope that maybe this will start a trend in this region of world and lead to more powerful and inspirational LGBT positive music in the mainstream world. Meanwhile... Dana International is a transsexual singer from Israel who has videos in English, Hebrew, French, Russian and gibberish on you tube. GaGa is far from the first to sing mainstream music pro TS, L or G. Dana is very famous in Europe. She represented Israel in 1998 in the Eurovision song contest and was voted winner! And will be representing Israel again this year! I would reccomend her song Diva or Ding Dong. Diva can be found in english and with subs, and Ding Dong is a mix of Hebrew and English but is mostly english and good as well. So, Back to GaGa, thank you for this. It is appreciated, please keep it up. Good song and I hope for more, and possibly something more profound. Let's open minds instead of speak only to minds who are already open ;)

Link to comment
Guest Nicodeme

I guess I interpret her wording as discouraging folks from transitioning, and coming from a white, able-bodied, cisgender woman who fits society's standards of beauty exactly, it sort of rubs me the wrong way.

This.

All the way.

Let's not forget her blatant transphobia after certain accusations regarding her anatomy.

Link to comment
Guest Melanie Dawn

This.

All the way.

Let's not forget her blatant transphobia after certain accusations regarding her anatomy.

Link to a quote please.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 76 Guests (See full list)

    • Justine76
    • Abigail Genevieve
    • MaybeRob
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.7k
    • Total Posts
      768.9k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,042
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Mealaini
    Newest Member
    Mealaini
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. AlanaTG
      AlanaTG
    2. Alicia
      Alicia
      (35 years old)
    3. brianna051
      brianna051
      (39 years old)
    4. canofworms
      canofworms
    5. delmori
      delmori
  • Posts

    • Adrianna Danielle
      Meeting up with a therapist I seen back in 2001.Seen I am better,saw her after being honorable discharged from the Army.I was beaten up and sexually assaulted by a fellow soldier.Nothing was done about it and did report it.It put a toll on me.Was 22 at the time and we did not get along at times,bullied me too.
    • Adrianna Danielle
      Army doing 4 years,I ended up be discharged after my 4 years were up.Another guy in the same unit I was in beat the crap out of me including sexual assaulting me.Nothing was done about it,reported it and it put a toll on me.Had anxiety issues which I did get help and did recover from it
    • April Marie
      Welcome to the forums, Ash! You’ll find lots of information and resources here to help with your journey. Jump in where you feel comfortable.  I look forward to learning more about you.
    • April Marie
      Welcome to the forums, Justine! We’re glad you found us. You’ll find many of us here who embraced our true selves late in life for many reasons. Each of us is unique, yet we often share much in common. Read, ask questions and jump in where you feel comfortable.
    • Mealaini
      I've perused a few introductions on here.  To say that my situation is unique would be silly, but it is my situation.  I have had questions about who I am my whole life.  At an early age, I was exposed to traumatic experiences in both the emotional and sexual realm.  I've been through many therapies, and over the last year and a half, I finally found a therapist worth her title. After using EMDR, I have been finally able to convince my brain (for the most part) that I am no longer in danger, and am no longer being abused.  With some of the worst of my experiences faced and accepted, I have been working with my therapist with Internal Family Systems.  I highly recommend the book "No Bad Parts" to get an idea of what IFS is and how it can be used to reunite the fractured internal family.  The main idea of the internal family systems theory is that trauma can fracture the Self into different parts - and each part takes on a role that tries to protect the Self.  In order to repair these parts, and to bring these wounded parts back so that they can unload their burdens (the traumatic experiences), I have had to learn who they are and how they should fit in within my Self.  It is a long and difficult  process getting to know these parts.  I have been able to work within on a few of the parts, and one of the parts that has shown herself as an important character in my whole Self has been Mealani (Gaelic for Melanie and sounds the same).  I've been familiar with this internal part since I was about 10 years old.  I am now 55 years old, and I am realizing that she had an important role in my complete Self - a role that has led me to conclude that I have been hiding from my true gender.  As of now, I identify as Gender Fluid.  My pronouns are He, They, and Them.     I have been married for 30 years.  I have two kids who are both LGBTQ+ - one is Queer and the other is Transgender.  As I have worked through this with my Therapist, I have realized that my kids have been fortunate to have a father who has been accepting of them from the start.  I am their biggest supporter and have never questioned their identity.  My wife has had a lot of trouble accepting both my kids and their identities.  She is doing better now, but it nearly tore us apart.  My wife is a devout Catholic, and I have deconstructed my faith and am now a Faithful Atheist who tries to practice Radical Awareness.  Coming out as Atheist was another thing that nearly tore us apart.  Defining myself as Gender Fluid might just be the last straw.  As both of my kids are fully grown, I am not too worried if this ends the relationship because I want my wife to have a complete life with someone who is able to be the person she expects.  BUT, I am not ready to break the news to anyone yet.  That is  why I found this site.  I am going to hang out in the chats, ask some questions, learn some things, and make some hard decisions.  I thank anyone who reads this.  There is so much more to my story, but I am not fully prepared to spill the beans here. ....I am a process, not a fixed thing, and I've come a LONG way to get here today!  :)
    • KathyLauren
      Hi, Justine.  Welcome to Trans Pulse.   Many of us can relate to your story.  Please feel free to check out the various forums and to join in on any discussions or start your own.
    • Justine76
      I'm AMAB been experimenting with a more feminine presentation for some time as an adult. At first, I'm not sure I was really conscious of it being a desire to look more feminine. I'd buy male skinny jeans and fitted tees, but that didn't feel quite right so I'd cuff the jeans into capris. Then I added an ankle bracelet, which I liked, but it kind of felt like the limit for an ostensibly cis-male in public and even drew surprise from my wife. So, I moved on to trying more things in private and, somewhat to my own surprise, feel really comfortable and sexy adding some platform heels to my capris and donning a more feminine top and wig; I'm older and don't have much hair of my own anymore ;) Make-up is still difficult but I'm practicing when I can. On the first attempt I just looked like some dude from Motley Crue, which could be fine but not what I'm going for day to day :P   Not sure exactly how I got here or where it's going. I've had to search my past a bit to speculate why this would be emerging now, in my 40s. I've always been a more effeminate individual; it just bleeds through somehow. I grew up being called '-awesome person-' or 'fairy' constantly, although there was never any question in my mind that I liked girls. In junior high I briefly experimented with applying make-up until a friend convinced me I'd get my butt kicked if anyone from school discovered it (mid 80s). Remembering these things lead me to think I perhaps just buried this aspect of myself for ages in fear. I learned to be masculine and the teasing eventually stopped.   I'm still relatively new on my journey, so I'm here to learn and figure myself out more. After lots of reading I suppose I currently identify as transfemme. Haven't come out to anyone yet. I feel like I need more experience and searching to be sure. But I'm definitely having fun along the way! Cheers everyone!             
    • Ivy
      Yeah…  As an exvangelical in my case. Guess I'll listen to that part of me this time.
    • Willow
      Day was fine at work.  The District Manager was there.  She actually likes me so everything was fine.  Since I was the lowest level person there she had to ask me the questions they ask every time they come.  Then apologized for having to ask me. (Yes I answered them correctly). After she left I learned that there was a meeting scheduled with her for May 23rd for the entire management team (4 of us). I’m not certain what that’s about.  No sense speculating it’s probably just getting ready for the summer crush.   good night 3 am comes early tomorrow.   Willow    
    • Ashterlin27
      Hey I'm Ashterlin or Ash for short and I'm from the US  I play French horn I also love reading and my favorite book right now is The Tailor's Daughter by Janice Graham my pronouns are He/Him or any Neo I prefer masc terms when being referred to  and this is my pronouns page
    • April Marie
      Thank you. It seemed to me when I was driving home that I had a bit more bounce in the rear end over bumps so I'm wondering if the frame was bent. I will have them check it tomorrow morning when the do the appraisal.
    • Abigail Genevieve
      There is just a feeling that this is normal when I wear f clothes.  As a biological male I am supposed to, I suppose, experience dysphoria in f clothes. Instead it is reversed.  Sometimes there is euphoria about being a girl, but it is because my self-perception is lining up with my self-expression. Clothing is actually secondary.  Or third.  Secondary is what my body looks like.  I am a girl regardless of what I look like. I just am one.  As I get used to this I will probably stop talking about it.  Most women do not go around announcing they are women all the time.  They talk about themselves but the presupposition is that they are women.  Never a matter of debate.
    • LittleSam
      Do you feel euphoria when wearing feminine clothes? I'm curious about why you think you are supposed to feel dysphoria in fem clothes. I totally get why you would feel dysphoria with masc clothes. For me what urged my transition forwards was the amount of gender euphoria I got from dressing like a guy , and my dysphoria from wearing anything remotely fem got worse and worse until i get rid of evey fem article in my wardrobe and all my makeup, so I could concentrate on just being me and chasing the euphoria. Dysphoria didn't go away though, because I've been misgendered constantly and it hurts more when dressed in my man clothes . However now I'm on T, my doubts and dysphoria have massively lifted and I'm excited to see the masc changes to my body happening. I do have to learn patience though lol.
    • EasyE
      You're still cool to this Catholic... no worries... ;-)
    • Mmindy
      Well that's no way to start off a birthday. Be sure to look at your frame just behind your rear axle to make sure it wasn't bent. When I was rear ended... At first look it appeared that my bumper was folded down, however the frame was bent which also bent the floor of the bed. I'm glad everyone is okay    Happy Birthday,   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...