Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Would You Have Voice Surgery?


Guest Zenda

Would you? Have you?  

71 members have voted

  1. 1. Would you have voice surgery?

  2. 2. Do you feel you need professional voice training-either in person or via the net of other media devices?



Recommended Posts

Guest Zenda

Kia Ora

:rolleyes: Emily Ray’s recent post got me thinking…I’ve never had to ‘train’ my voice to sound ‘female’, however what I did find was after a while on HRT and living full time when interacting with others both male and female, my voice would ‘go with the ‘feminine’ flow’ in a more natural way… :groupwavereversed:

When I had my psycho-surgical assessments[prior to have genital surgery], in the reports, my voice was described as “mid-range female”, what I was told was, my voice was slightly deeper than the average female’s but still within the female range

How many trans-women here feel the need to have voice surgery or have professional voice training? Or are you comfortable with how it sounds now? :ThanxSmiley:

:rolleyes: "Let your voice be heard!" :welldone:

Metta Zenda :)

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean

.

Nope!

Not me!

Don't need it!

Sure...early I thought that I'd have to take care of it somehow, but as time went by, my natural female voice came to the forefront.

Of course I worked on it on the way back and forth to work in the car and with a spectrometer...

Now, I live full time and pass/blend all the time...never been called on it!

(Well, except when I got called "Sir" yesterday on the phone by the lady at the Veteran's Administration....

Of course, she had my file right in front of her that said "Donald"....)

What ya gonna do?......lol

Huggs

'Donna Jean

Link to comment
Guest Emily Ray

The last time I was tested profesionally I tested just shy of the crossover range between male and female. That was in january and was a result of my own efforts to conciously raise it. It has been 7 months since someone actually read me because of my voice. I will probably continue as I have been with occasional testing to see if anything is changing or getting worse. I am not sure surgery is necessary for me, but what if I have the tracheal shave which can lower the voice. That is scary. I guess all surgery is risky. I am not sure yet that I need to risk it.

Huggs

Emily

Link to comment
Guest Elizabeth K

Two years of self training. It's inflection, vocabulary, and raised tone that works. I am STILL working on it - successfully I think. I will ALWAYS be working on it. I think I can eventually get it almost perfect.

And some people don't try, thinking where they are now is fine because they feel they pass... but my opinion is we MTF need to CONSTANTLY try to improve, and not be so lazy.

Yes - it would be nice to have a surgical means to gain a totally girl-like voice, but if that was possible every MTF would be getting it done. Maybe someday.

Lizzy

Link to comment
Guest Zenda

Kia Ora,

:rolleyes: I'm sure there's a psychological process also going on in the minds of others when I interact with them in public...

In the visual impact, they just see a 'female', which leads them to dismiss the deeper that average sound of my voice...In other words how I look out weighs how I might sound :doh1: and I'm automatically given the 'benefit of the doubt'femaleacceptance...I guess my voice could be seen as somewhat 'androgynous' but with a more female slant...

:rolleyes: No doubt others here would have experienced something similar...

Metta Zenda :)

Link to comment
  • Admin

I answered no to surgery, only because it isn't very effective currently, from what I've read, and has many side effects.

If it were closer to 100 per cent effective, I probably would.

I'm practicing, but need a lot more work. I do well for short conversations, but when I need to raise my volume, or talk for more than a minute or two, I have difficulty.

Carolyn Marie

Link to comment
Guest Elizabeth K

Kia Ora,

:rolleyes: I'm sure there's a psychological process also going on in the minds of others when I interact with them in public...

In the visual impact, they just see a 'female', which leads them to dismiss the deeper that average sound of my voice...In other words how I look out weighs how I might sound :doh1: and I'm automatically given the 'benefit of the doubt'femaleacceptance...I guess my voice could be seen as somewhat 'androgynous' but with a more female slant...

:rolleyes: No doubt others here would have experienced something similar...

Metta Zenda :)

Bu we aren't always there face to face. The telephone is an example, also the 'order' speakers at drive thrus. There is the real test.

Lizzy

Link to comment
The last time I was tested profesionally I tested just shy of the crossover range between male and female.

Pitch means so little that this would be fairly meaningless measure anyway.

Link to comment
Guest Donna Jean

.

I've played with a spectrograph online...

I can get my pitch right into it!

Unfortunately I sound like Minnie Mouse...

Donna Jean

Link to comment
  • 2 months later...
Guest ChaosEverafter

i voted yes i want voice surgery, and yes i want a voice coach.

i don't think there is any replacement for face-to-face instant criticism from an expert.

and for the surgery, i am for it because i have a very limited vocal range, and while my voice isn't deep, it is clearly male. even my best efforts at female voice turn out horrible. i think i would respond well to it.

Link to comment

I do not want to have any more surgery than necessary - it terrifies me.

I am not going to have any FFS - for better or worse, this is my face.

As to my voice - I am a few months shy of 60 and women of my age and generation (a lot of them smoked for thirty years) do tend to have deeper voices - it is the inflection that helps me - but I have always had that so the visual clues help.

At 6'4" and just a shade under 300 pounds a higher pitched voice would attracted more attention.

I had an instance not long ago at a drive through window _ I was ma'amed right off - something about driving right past the order speaker and making a huge, graceful loop toward the payment window - one of my blondest moments.

Love ya,

Sally

Link to comment
Guest Cafe.Bike.Girl

Even if voice surgery was more effective I don't think I really need it. I do get ma'amed some times at drive through windows and over the phone. It usually happens when I'm relaxed and in a good mood. A few friends have mentioned it weirds them out when I get hit it right but that doesn't happen very often. For myself I don't think there is a lack of ability just a lack of control and socialization so I think a voice coach would be very helpful. Perhaps it will be easier when I'm full time and not bouncing back and forth between the two so much.

Link to comment
Guest oceanangel

ooh my voice is one of my worst areas, ive had surgery and a lot of practise on it but nothing SEEMED to work but well, in the last 6-8 months its got better and more feminine, im not sure whats happened but i think its because im talking more and ive just found it easier

I did find at first i had to put an effort in to it and it tired me out alot from talking but thats gone, also i think because i became out to my office i relaxed more when talking to them but when i speak to clients or use the phone, I higher it (if that makes sense) but when i answer the phone i sometimes have prepare myself so i kinda do a long heeeellllooo when i answer which one of my co-workers has told me off for in a jokingly helpful way she has but i dont know if she knows about me yet, its kinda loooong topic between me and another co-worker who has somehow happily ended up as a really close friend

my speech therapist who after the vocal surgery failed rejected me was very happy with how its just changed.

anyway im wittering on a lot here so i shall say this and end this post

i had bad side effects from the surgery like looking up i feel a pulling inside my throat and i get tired when i talk alot and as i work in a people job, its annoying but kinda good in a way so i can escape from things with the best excuse ever lol x

Link to comment
Guest Melissa 67

I'm currently taking voice lessons, but if they don't help me I'll gladly risk the surgery.

Love ya

Melissa 67

Link to comment
Guest Megan_Lynn

am one of the few lucky ones when it comes to voice. My whole life my voice was always rather high pitched female like. Most all the men I came in contact with in any social setting would tell me I had a sissy voice( the really said it was a B#@%h voice but can not post that) and many though at first I was gay because of it. Even this past week with a cold and sounding very horse (at least to my ears) I was till ma am'ed every time.

Link to comment
Guest Robin Winter

My endocrinologist is getting me a referral for a new program that's been started locally. It's a voice therapy group for trans-women. I'm not certain yet what if any costs are involved, but being a group thing, it has to be cheaper than the traditional coaching, right? We'll see...

Personally, I have a very deep voice, so yes I've considered the idea of surgery and I still think about it now and again. I've not made any decisions, but it would certainly be a last resort for me. I've heard the horror stories.

Link to comment
  • 4 weeks later...
Guest Tasha_A

I haven't even got a therapist yet so I don't have any surgical or hormonal effects on my voice, I find that when played back my voice is quite deep but I am ALWAYS ma'amed on the phone so I don't really know how my voice ranks.

Link to comment
  • 3 weeks later...
Guest Alexandra89

If I was fairly certain it would work. As it stands, no. I'll just take advantage of my therapist's referrals to speech pathologists who are experienced with MtF voice training in the meantime.

My voice never descended all the way into my chest. Its resonance is kind of split between the two and I can't figure out how to separate it, so I'll need help. It's unquestionably male, but I think it sounds whiny.

Link to comment
Guest jenzie

.

I've played with a spectrograph online...

I can get my pitch right into it!

Unfortunately I sound like Minnie Mouse...

Donna Jean

Ooo, where can i find this online spectrograph? :D

Link to comment

I voted no because I seriously do not need it. I am 6'3" tall so having a feminine voice was the only break I was given on this journey. I get ma'am'd all the time at work and on the phone. I still work on it to make it sound more pleasing to me which annoys the hell out of my family who tell me I don't need to change it. But I ignore their words because I know they have an agenda... and well both of my therapists have said I have a feminine voice and if they couldn't see me they wouldn't know but I still work on it.

I think voice is one of the hardest things for us to work on but as Julie T said something we need to constantly try to improve until perfect.

Link to comment
Guest Riana

I always had a fairly well-trained voice because I like to sing and hum a lot, so my voice control was always very good. I've been training my voice since the beginning of the year, and my friends online tell me I sound like a perfect girl, very passable. I've passed on the phone several times as well, including once with someone from the gender clinic who thought I was F2M! But I'm still not really happy with my voice yet, it costs me too much effort to maintain it and shouting is out of the question. It's also not quite how I'd like it to sound, but that's just practice I suppose. For now I'm happy, I don't need to pass 'out there' yet. :)

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...
Guest Little_cherry

well I'm 18 and I started hormones with 16. Luckily my voice never got really deep. it defenitely got deeper, but on the phone people call me mrs. so thats a good thing I think :)

but for the ones who do have a very deep voice, I recommend singing songs of female artists. I've been a huge avril lavigne fan so I always sang her songs and I dont know, but maybe this also helped me that my voice never got that deep and / or I can talk like that in a feminine voice.

I don't think voice surgery / removing adams apple is a good thing because you can read everywhere that its very risky and the resulsts aren't that satisfying.

best wishes cherry xxx

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   12 Members, 0 Anonymous, 121 Guests (See full list)

    • Lydia_R
    • Betty K
    • Penrose-Pauling
    • Ivy
    • Abigail Genevieve
    • SamC
    • Timi
    • Vidanjali
    • KathyLauren
    • MaeBe
    • Willow
    • MaryEllen
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.7k
    • Total Posts
      768.8k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,038
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Justine76
    Newest Member
    Justine76
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. April Marie
      April Marie
    2. daniela...
      daniela...
      (59 years old)
    3. Emily May
      Emily May
    4. Felixr
      Felixr
      (20 years old)
    5. Leann
      Leann
      (56 years old)
  • Posts

    • KatieSC
      Precisely my point. These legal "protections" only go so far. When they actually take the time to find out what we need, and mandate all of the coverages, then we will have something tangible. There are many dimensions to the who issue of being transgender. We live in a society where there is much polarization, and I understand the angst from both sides of this issue. Without question, we need better protections, and there needs to be greater sensitivity by all parties as to how to move along to mutual acceptance. We have been demonized across the country, and it is hard to get folks to pull back when the hair on the back of their neck is raised about our mere existence. I will go out on a limb and say that it is also likely that any "in your face" tactics by us, can have a rather negative effect in getting folks across the country to understand and care about us as human beings. That does not even include the political dimensions. I see examples of politicians that sicken me, not just about gender issues, but basic stuff like worrying about defenseless animals, or letting poor kids go hungry by blocking food aid programs. Given Gov. Noem's proclivity for putting animals down with a firearm, it is likely a good thing that none of her children are transgender (at that we know of).   The world is a whacky place at best. The anti-trans sentiments are not only strong in this country, but many countries. Yet, there are places that accept us. I will be dead and decayed by the time they ever figure any of this out.
    • Ivy
      That sux.  I'm in a similar situation with my VA therapist.  She wasn't an intern, but got moved to a different position.  I was really comfortable with her (she was part of the queer community)  I'm supposed to meet with a new one in June.
    • Ivy
      True. I currently get my HRT from the VA (with a copay) but despite the talk, surgery is out.
    • Ivy
      There is something to this.  Young people I know work, but still can't afford to live on their own.  They certainly can't start a family.   I don't think Trump actually did much good for the working class.  He, like most politicians, took care of his rich donors.  Tax cuts always sound nice, but they went mostly to the wealthy.  The tax cuts to the working class were mostly an illusion, small, and temporary.   I'm going to shut up now or I'll get in trouble.
    • missyjo
      but on a real naive level..isn't my sexuality, who I have sex with, like my genitals .only relevant to those I'm inviting to share my bed?   I don't know..but I think he's trying n that's all I can ask. I believe he's struggling to be able to mesh his religious thoughts with somehow still having a sibling..though I'm fairly certain he would pay me, literally, if  I'd I would "just  act normal."."act like a man"and puz all this "sissy -transgender- " stuff aside..and all those other expressions that erase us n ignore us   he asked me not to drag him to any -transgender- bars...like Applebee's? laugh   oh well, trying is better than not, much better   enjoy Tuesday dears   hugs
    • Ivy
      For the most part, yes. But there are some that actually are calling for our eradication - in so many words.  That still means what it means.   https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/cpac-speaker-transgender-people-eradicated-1234690924/  
    • Mmindy
      Both dinners sound great.    We had bratwurst, purple cabbage, scalloped potatoes and applesauce. Followed by a slice of carrot cake and cinnamon tea.    Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋
    • Mmindy
      Good morning everyone,    I hope you’re ready for a beautiful day. We’ve had several days of rain and this morning was a clear sunrise leading into a near summer like day. My tulips have dropped all their petals so now it’s time to fill in around them with pansies.    I’m just finishing up my second cup of coffee and getting ready for a day in the shop putting the final touches on a propane training prop. Simulating a bulk transport tank.    Best wishes, stay motivated,   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋    
    • Lydia_R
      Congrats Carla!   Hugs, Lydia
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Last night we had a soup made of sausage, potatoes, spinach, and onions.  Also some whole wheat flatbread.   Our meals here are often simple, because we have a huge family. We have to cook cafeteria quantities of everything.
    • Mirrabooka
      Tonight we had a couple of thin cut scotch fillet steaks fried in butter, with a tomato/onion/breadcrumb bake, accompanied with peas & broccolini, with instant mushroom & garlic gravy. 
    • KymmieL
      Happy Birthday, @April Marie
    • Lydia_R
      This is what I've been working on the last few days:   3:38am (the next day) I just pulled up a website to do the arc tangent function because the Windows scientific calculator doesn't do that function.  I entered in the .577 number and did an atan on it and it came back with .523 which is what I was expecting.  The .577 number is the result of the opposite over the adjacent and the .523 is the circumference measure to 30 degrees and is one of those numbers I memorized in February 2004.  That's an interesting story in my book.   So, the lessons I learned last night are that .577 is the result of a ratio.  The idea here is how to convert that decimal back to a ratio.  Andy helped with that last night.  He said "just divide by 10!"  I was like, oh my, that makes sense!  Andy is good for a laugh like that!  I had come home from a walk to the store and was hot on the idea of division and the musical connect to Ed Sheeran and Pink Floyd's The Division Bell.  I don't know either one of them very well, but I am hot on the idea of writing a function that does division.  And that brings up the subject of how a computer does multiplication.  I talked with Andy about that and I said that my dad just beat the multiplication tables into me.  I remember not getting it.  I would tell my dad "why do I have to memorize this stuff?"  And he would say "you just do."  And ironically, it was the same way with trigonometry on the streets.  With trig, the numbers only matter so that you can grasp the concept of it all.  They don't matter, but there is the magic of the sine of 30 degrees being .5 and how that points to 12 and the overtone series / cycle of 5ths.  That's pretty amazing stuff and then Andy was trying to draw a conclusion to 24 hours a day.  I insisted that that application of 24 was man-made and he was not convinced.  Then he brought up the year being about 360 days, or perhaps I brought that up.  That is not a man-made number (365) and it's really odd having that and the connection to 12.  It's just a coincidence, buy Andy was trying to draw some conclusion from it.  And then I brought up the thing with the moon appearing to be the same size as the sun.  And that got Andy brining up more conclusions.   Then I abandoned the conversation and my next thought on the subject was that this whole thing is about ratios and how I was using ratios to do my collision detection before I started studying trig.  I then took a look at the calulators on my screen.  What is this .577 number?  That is not the arc tangent of 30 degrees, is it?  I swear that I'm correct about the arc tangent of 30 degrees being .523.  I've been spouting that number off consistently since Feburary 2004.  So then I got out my Plane Trigonometry book and looked up 30 degrees.  Sure enough, .523 is correct.  But then from having looked at that row of numbers, I got the idea that if you had any one of those numbers and knew which function it was under, then you should be able to figure out the rest.  They are all the result of a ratio and the idea is to convert them back to ratios and cross multiply and divide.  And I mentioned that to Andy, or did he bring up cross multiplying and dividing when I was talking about ratios?  We basically got to that at the same time and I was impressed that Andy knew about it.   So, I think all the keys are here and it's almost time for me to start coding a division function and then a trigonometric function.  If it can be done, I should be able to have this coded in the next couple days, although I'm stretched pretty thin with this political stuff.  We'll see.  It's an interesting project.   One of the key things that got me going on this the other day was how the .3333 number came up.  I had recognized that as 30 degrees expressed in grads.  And that brought up the thought of base 10.  All these hard number calculations started off with 30 degrees which is equivalent to 33.33 grads.  90 degrees = 100 grads, 360 degrees = 400 grads.  I learned that over a decade ago by entering in some of these numbers into a calculator and playing with the grads button.  Anyway.  I love triangulation.  
    • Lydia_R
      Oh my, here it comes...     It looks like there is a half moon out my window...  4:51am    
    • KatieSC
      While it is encouraging that they have deemed that they cannot ban the treatment, the bigger question is what treatments they will cover as a result. Speaking as a transgender female, this is a difficult definition. A fair number of insurance plans already cover the basic vaginoplasty, however, for those of us who have a rather masculine appearing face, a heavy beard, a deep voice, and other defining characteristics, attaining a passing feminine appearance is difficult without gender-affirming facial feminization surgery, genital and facial electrolysis, speech therapy and if necessary, gender affirming voice surgery, as well as other body contouring procedures. I view all of these procedures as life-saving in the sense that blending in, and thus avoiding an assault can come down to looking and sounding like you are female. I think the transgender males have a bit more ease with blending in than we do. There will be disagreements as to what constitutes enough surgery to be your truest self. We all pretty much understand that our true gender is locked in our mind. The issue is what can we do to modify our bodies enough to get the congruence between what is in our head, and how we perceive ourselves in the world. Is some of it cosmetic? That is hard to say for sure. I have had insurance companies insist that facial electrolysis is purely cosmetic. Well, most women do not have an Abraham Lincoln beard coming through. Some insurance companies have insisted that speech/voice therapy, as well as voice surgery, are purely cosmetic. I scoured the cosmetic counters for any makeup that would enhance my voice. Being feminine and passing does not mean I get to look and sound like Fred Flintstone in a dress. That kind of weirds folks out, and sets us up to be ridiculed and assaulted in my estimation.   My one insurer told me that beyond the vaginoplasty that all of this was cosmetic. In an appeal hearing, I asked the group that if they had a 14 year old daughter who was in an accident that resulted in a large facial scar, would they want the child to receive the best care to remove the scar? Of course they would. I pointed out though, that while she may have the scar, she could live with it. I asked them if the removal of the disfiguring scar in a 14-year old would be difficult for the child when the other kids made fun of her. Of course, they all nodded their head. I explained to the group that for folks like us, it is no different. While it may be cosmetic to a point, these procedures are essential to our well-being, and not something we are doing to be on a YouTube channel.   Now some who are trans, or gender fluid, may not want to opt for the procedures. There are quite a few of us that do, but the cost is prohibitive. What also clouds the issue are the surgeons who operate out of large medical centers who participate in the large insurance pools. How many of our sisters and brothers have had to pony up some major dollars to a surgeon who is out of network? Good luck trying to get the surgery paid for by your insurer. They may pay you what they pay the surgeons in network, but you won't get that much in reimbursement. A fair number of insurance companies balk at speech and voice therapy, and many will not cover voice surgery. Then there is the issue of electrolysis. A day at the "spa" for electrolysis with anesthetics will run around 3,000 bucks or so, and you may need many repeat visits. Many of the insurers fail to pay for that as well. Just about none of the insurers will cover body contouring procedures such as a panniculectomy, or liposuction. When the insurance companies will just help us become our truest selves, then we will have progress with gender identity laws.   The one good thing that this decision does is preserve the primary care for transgender individuals. I have to wonder how Florida and the rest of the states who have banned having Medicaid cover transgender healthcare are going to act. This should be an interesting fight. When we have the ability to seek care and get what we need for our true needs, without any pre-judgements, then these court orders will mean something. A court order without parameters for the insurance companies is hollow.
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...