Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

New Here


Guest shounenbat

Recommended Posts

Guest shounenbat

Allow me to introduce myself. I am an asexual, androgynous-though-male-leaning FTM if that makes any sense. Now, before you all welcome me with open arms, let me say that I'm posting here because I'm looking for opinions and answers. I put very little emphasis on gender, though I was always peeved that I was born female, and puberty was particularly ugly, as most of you can imagine. I didn't know what transsexuality was and can remember sitting on my grandmother's couch late at night and seeing a commercial talking about procedures women could use to make their breasts bigger and thinking, "I'm probably the only person in the world who would ask if there was a way to make them disappear!" I prayed day in and day out over my dilemma, but I should note that I will probably never transition. I might also note that while I did attempt suicide when I was 17, I wouldn't currently call myself suicidal. I'd like to transition, but unfortunately I don't think that would be the best idea.

This is where I ask for your opinions, since this is less of an introduction and more of a survey. Why did you transition or why will you transition or why will you not? What hinders you? What helps you? If you're a Christian or any other religion for that matter, how has being a transsexual hurt or helped your faith? Anything else is helpful, too.

I'll answer myself, not to offend or cause controversy, but just to let you guys know where I'm coming from and give you some insight into a part of me that I keep locked up.

1. I probaby won't, and the reasons will follow.

2. I'm mostly hindered by my faith and love for my family. I'm young, single, and have no plans for marriage or children, but I love my mom, siblings, and relatives, and I know it would kill them (some of them literally) if I "came out." As Spock put it, "The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the one." I can sacrifice a little to keep my family healthy, and I will not be the one to cause a crisis.

3. I'd say that I share my feelings only with God, but I really don't know if it's Biblical. I'm from a family of fundamentalists, so I'd say that I, too, lean that way. However, my recent studies are pushing me in the way of Christian Universalism (not Unitarian). Too many articles about the subject written by Christians keep me at bay. I have no desire to break God's laws, and quite frankly no matter what is done (at least in this time) can change my chromosomes or make me biologically male. That and the fact that I don't believe people shoud dye their hair, let alone take a knife to their body for any reason that doesn't endanger their health.

Before the flaming begins (but I beg for a kind response every once in a while), let me tell you a bit more about myself.

I'm a huge Ron Paul supporter, for one. I will probably never consider Obama to be my President (only Ron Paul is suitable for the job, I feel) and am a member of the Campaign for Liberty. I am not against gay rights, although I do believe that the government should stay out of the matter altogether and let the states ban or grant such a union.

I'm also a huge Legend of Zelda fan, and I collect everything related to it. On that note, I also love anime and animation in general. I also love languages, and am currently studying Japanese.

Well, that's a good enough intro I think, and I look forward to reading your answers. I appologize in advance for any spelling errors, but my keyboard sucks right now and I have to practically punch the keys to make them work.

じゃあ ね。

Link to comment
Guest Karen-1954

Let me welcome you to the forums, we have a lot of wise, well informed people on here. In responce to your question as to why I started my transition, I simply could not handle living a lie any longer. For me it was begin transition or suicide, I chose transition. The feeling of relief, being able to simply be me out weighed all of the losses which I suffered. I held on and started my transition at 53 so, better late than never.

Link to comment
Guest Elizabeth K

Yikes - I wish I had seen you post earlier so I coulda responded! :o

First let me say you are in the right place here - welcome :P

Let me say I am the opposite - MTF and in transition - YEA! And I am older - a T-granny

I am also married with a supportive wife (finally - my second wife took off when I confided in her). :rolleyes:

And most importantly, I am very spiritual. For some reason those here may not be so - not because they don't believe in God but (my opinion only) they just don't have that spiritural interconnectedness yet (I believe it comes - has to). Me? Does God approve? I ASKED Him for a resolution - he led me to where I am now - let me clarify, as a Catholic Methodist (hummm - good story there - ha!) I asked for an intercession from the Blessed Mother, a solution/explaination/support for my gender confusion - guess what? Be careful what you pray for! Yikes! I went to therapy - I was diagnosed transsexual - wow, terrible? NO I was thrilled. My Dear Lord has led me to peace - I told my wife I may never have been so much at peace in my whole life... ;)

Woww - I think I just witnessed! My fundalmentalist sisters would be shocked.

Oh by the way, Spock was a communist. Stay with the American ideal of 'me first.' You will be surprised of the results of outing to your family. :rolleyes:

Hey - just the other day I outed to my 30 year old daughter. Whewwww - hard thing to do, will she hate me?

She said, "I am not surprised." So much for deep dark secrets. :D

I probably won't look for SRS - as you said you wouldn't either - too old me, Cher (Louisiana roots)

Finally - I have never seen flaming on this site - probably never will. ;)

Welcome - welcome - welcome

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...
Guest shounenbat

I haven't been on in a while, but I'd like to thank everyone who posted, particularly Elizabeth. Your story was amazing and I was particularly touched by it. I'm still leaning on the side of spiritual warfare, myself, but your insight was much appreciated. It's difficult to be a Christian in this world. :( But, that's where I draw my inner strength, too.

Anyway, I probably won't be posting very often, so I had to thank everyone now. I've been on the search for homeless shelters, as I think I'm well on my way to officially succumbing to my financial crisis and getting kicked out of my mom's house as the result. There's no way my father would take me in (and I personally don't get along with him at all, so we'd probably just wind up killing each other), I have no friends (officially), and I don't like imposing on people. I think I have until next fall, though, so I'll be able to check back for a while yet. Needless to say, my other problems are way in the back of my mind, but thanks for all your input.

For the sake of nerdiness (nerdyness?), Spock was actually a socialist, although there is but a razor thin line between communism and socialism. I believe it was Gene Roddenbury himself who said that Star Trek was meant to be a socialist utopia. At any rate, I don't agree with Spock's words on a political level, but I do agree with him on a personal level. I've never been fond of the American self-centered way of thinking, unfortunately.

In other Spock words, "Live long and prosper!"

Link to comment

I have to tell you haow I feel about portions of your post - some I agree with and some that I don't. we all have free will and are thinking individuals.

I have started and am currently stalled in my transitioning, because of a pending divorce (becoming true to one's self can carry a hefty price). Once completed I intend to complete the journey all the way through SRS - I am also as old as Elizabeth, but I have a good friend who transitioned at my age and had the surgery and now feels like she is truely complete.

On the subject of religion and faith (there is a world of difference between the two), I haven't come out in my church and when I do I may have to find a new church after 54 of my 57 years on this little planet. I find that my faith has never been altered by my transitioning - I believe that becoming the woman that I have always been is like correcting a club foot or any other birth defect - I don't feel that it is wrong. Others may differ, but I hope to one day be able to find out that I was right and God loves everyone for there souls and not their physical bodies

Religion on the other hand being organized has it's political structures and power struggles within each group - that's why there are so many branches of Christianity! If you don't like this one, form your own. Catholics lost the Lutherans, becasue Martin Luther didn't feel that giving the church money to buy a loved one out of hell was exactly what God had in mind. The next split (that's a pun)was because Henry VIII was tierd of killing the women who could not produce a male hier and wanted to divorce - and the denominations just keep on forming! You can find a Bible verse to support almost any thing that you want to, if you look hard enough and ignore all other verses. A friend of mine used to tell people that the Bible approved of smoking and recited the verse, "and Ruth lit a camel." We all find the verses that make us feel good, that's why I don't read Job every night before I go to bed!

I live in Texas and therefore so often my favorite candidate is usually gone befre the primary here - don't get me started about having a one day primary for the entire contry - I'm tired of a handful of states deciding who I get to choose from!!!

We can only hope that the new president can handle the job - we have a couple of real meses going on!

The other part of the quote that Spock left out is, "Sometimes the needs of the one outweigh the needs of the many!" It's Dickens from "A Tale of Two Cities" as I recall and he stated both sides of every issue as Cliff Claven noted when he heard the opening passage, "It was the best of times it was the worst of times..", "Boy, that Dickens sure liked to cover his butt!" :D

I have never cared for the me first attitude either, I don't think of it as American - just greedy. Hitler wasn't an American, but me first was certainly a way of life for him!

There, that should stir things up a bit! :lol:

You wanted our opinions and I thought I would make you happy. :D

Love ya,

Sally

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   6 Members, 0 Anonymous, 77 Guests (See full list)

    • BobbiSkunk
    • Ivy
    • SamC
    • Mmindy
    • Ashley0616
    • MAN8791
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.8k
    • Total Posts
      770.8k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,132
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Kay3Seven
    Newest Member
    Kay3Seven
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. AP94
      AP94
      (30 years old)
    2. Clare27
      Clare27
      (50 years old)
    3. Shawnster
      Shawnster
      (54 years old)
  • Posts

    • MAN8791
      SIGHTLINES   I worship at the point of a gun On Friday nights and Sunday mornings. I pray for peace under the watchful eye of hired men With guns holstered on their hips Who laugh with us Eat with us Pray with us -      Dear God, not tonight      Not this morning      Not my friends      Please, not on my watch And I'm fully aware of the irony of the statement Because too often, our ancestors were forced to pray At the point of a gun because they said the wrong prayers In the wrong languages Loved the wrong person Identified the wrong way But today, I do so of my own free will. When I leave, I say thank you -      That it wasn't tonight      It wasn't this morning      It didn't happen while I sang      It wasn't my friends Because this week the guns stayed silent. But next week and next week and weeks afterward Could be the week that guns point in, not out And I can't will myself to believe it could never happen here because      Someone tried to bomb my Temple,       Someone set it on fire,      Someone shot up the clinic where I go for healthcare      Someone shot up the club my friends danced at So when I pray, I offer a wish to the universe That guns be melted into musical instruments and works of art. If someone wishes to shoot me, They will have to beat works of art into tools for the hand Before they can become instruments of war again.
    • MaeBe
      This is important for us all to keep really close to our hearts, especially as we go through a doubting phase or anxiety wave. I always go to the joy I have found being who I am, a person that does not conform with my birth assignment and the gender I defaulted to for many years. That places me under the trans umbrella and I need to feel comfortable and confident about that.   I am so glad you were able to deal with this person and others that confronted you with grace and poise. It seems like this person targeted your session specifically, they didn't want anything from it but to be a thorn in your side. I highly doubt she was there to expand her worldview. It is hard when your goal is to get through the content and someone wants to make the session a dialogue with them only. Challenges to our worldviews are important, they help us shape and define our beings, but that doesn't mean we have to deal with gatekeeping and hate.   I wish there was more content like your session available out there. I understand recording such content is a touchy subject, with the speakers and audience being general targets, but gosh it would be nice. I volunteered at the Time to Thrive event for HRC and got to sit in a few sessions, both as a moderator and a couple just as a participant, and it was very energizing. Thank you for being out there any speaking your truth, @Sally Stone!
    • Ivy
      There are all kinds of us. My situation at the time enabled me to begin living full time as a woman, and get onto hormones.  I realize everyone doesn't have that option - or want it. I also realize there are people who would consider me not truly transgender because I haven't had the surgery, and probably never will. Whatever…
    • Vidanjali
      Yeah. Trans folk still cannot update or renew FL drivers licenses. Florida part of the lawsuit against updated trans student Title IX protections. Florida suing Biden admin over ban on discrimination in healthcare based on gender.  Despite injunctions for individuals of some things including trans youth healthcare and using affirmed pronouns in school, bans still in place. The list goes on. Honestly I have stopped keeping up with news as much as I used to for the good of my mental health. Peace, y'all.  
    • Sally Stone
      Post 14 “I’m not Trans Enough”   I have mentioned in other posts my affiliation with the Keystone Conference in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania.  For several years, I facilitated a conference workshop titled “Making the Most of Part-time Womanhood.”  Each time I ran the workshop, it was standing room only, so I know for a fact, the idea resonates with many.   When I originally planned the workshop the target audience was geared towards girls like me, those who weren’t planning permanent transition.  I also expected to attract girls who may have been on the path to permanent transition but because of timing or life circumstances couldn’t.  What I didn’t expect as part of my attracted audience were hecklers and naysayers.  Thankfully, I only had to deal with a couple of those, but it only takes one to ruin everybody’s day.   Sadly, there exists a radical fringe that has permeated our community from the beginning.  The fringe mindset holds to the idea that being a trans woman means you were born a woman trapped in a man’s body, and the only recourse is to live as a woman fulltime.  Anything or anyone not fully aligned with this idea, is a threat to real trans women.  Apparently, my lifestyle choice, and my workshop were just the kind of threats that needed to be eliminated.   I was several minutes into the workshop, had just given a short overview of what I was going to cover when one person told me I should make certain everyone in attendance knew that I wasn’t speaking on behalf of trans women, that instead, I should be quite clear that I was speaking as a crossdresser.  The comment caught me off guard initially, but I rallied pretty quickly and tried to remind this person that the term transgender was an umbrella term that covered a wide spectrum.    Of course, she wanted to argue the point and went on to point out that since I was not going to live my life as a woman on a fulltime basis, I couldn’t be transgender, and then adding cruelty to her rhetoric, she reminded me and my audience that I was nothing more than a man in a dress.    I’m pretty non-confrontational most of the time, but her comments really pushed my buttons.  I could feel my defensive hackles raising and I knew I had to be careful not to stoop to her level.  So, instead of any stinging retorts, and believe me, I was thinking of many, I took the high road and as politely as I could, informed her that if she continued to disrupt the workshop, I would have her removed.  She responded by telling me she was going to report me and my workshop to the conference organizers.  I told her reporting me was her prerogative, and actually encouraged her to do it immediately as a way of getting her out of the room.   She didn’t take the bait and stayed for the entire workshop.  Thankfully, there were no further outbursts, but she used all sorts of overt body language to show her displeasure with my blasphemous views.  When the workshop ended, she cornered me and continued to berate me, insisting I was a simple crossdresser that tended to make real trans women look bad.  I wanted to just let things go, but her cruel comments had pushed me too far, so I reported her to the conference staff.  I figured if she had targeted my workshop, it was likely she would target others.  Conference officers informed her that her views were outdated, bigoted, and not in keeping with the conference’s commitment to inclusiveness.  She was reminded that by persisting in voicing those kinds of views and being disruptive, she wouldn’t be welcome at the conference.   I facilitated this particular workshop for four-years, and thankfully, this was the only serious confrontation I experienced.  However, there were others that espoused similar views, only they didn’t raise their disagreements to a confrontational level.  It bothers me immensely that some within our own community, would seek to marginalize another trans person.  Of course, I’m not naïve enough to think our community would be any different than society as a whole.  Sadly, there will always be some (only a few, thankfully) who inflate their sense of self-worth by putting down others.   It's difficult enough dealing with a general population that doesn’t understand us, but when we are attacked by our own, it tends to hurt even more, and it can cause us to question ourselves.  Ultimately, we cannot let others tell us who we are, and certainly, we cannot let them decide if we are trans enough.  Being transgender is being transgender, period.  Yes, we can be different, but we must remember there is no measurement that ranks how trans we are.   Hugs,   Sally
    • MaeBe
      I read the postulation as: “what if <insert social media company> was charged by government agencies or congress to create algorithms to identify, collect information on, and for reporting on LGBTQ+ people? So as to target them for “reasons”.”   This would be infringement of a few protections in the Constitution & Bill of Rights, but given government’s history with shady surveillance practices we wouldn’t know anything about it until it was likely in use. Probably in the realm of a suspense novel, but we know algorithms used for suggesting content already can identify people’s proclivities—even when they don’t have a clue themselves. So the tech is there, it’s just the dark room conspiracy that would be missing. 
    • MaeBe
      How insidious would it be for them to take it easy on the LGB as a strategy to try to create a fracture between the TQ+? There’s enough of the “drop the T” nonsense out there that they could leverage.   I’m happy the FLA folx are getting some reprieve though!
    • Carolyn Marie
      I note that most of the "backing off" touted in the article concerns Gay and Lesbian rights.  Nothing so far about the anti-trans laws and regulations that DeSantis and his ilk have gotten approved.  The only saving graces for our community in Florida have been in the courts.  So, as the saying goes, I'll believe it when I see it.   Carolyn Marie
    • Vidanjali
      It's kind of like the very slow recovery after a devastating hurricane (which mercifully I've not lived through). Rainbows do tend to appear post-storm.    About the Don't Say Gay settlement. Teachers are now allowed to talk about LGBTQIA+ stuff & to be LGBTQIA+, as long as it's not part of the curriculum. So still no formalized education allowed.    The overall impression on the culture of Florida and its influence on US and world culture has had its effect. I do consider myself an optimist and a realist, and do not mean to seem pessimistic. It is good that DeSantis has cooled his jets to whatever extent he has. But the collateral damage here (and by extension elsewhere) is palpable. Yes, people rejoice - we can gather once more and celebrate pride. But it seems to require more guts than just a few years ago bc so many h8ers have been enabled and empowered by policies and demonizing rhetoric over the last few years.    The wonderful thing about hurricane recovery, returning to that comparison, is that it often brings out the very best virtues in people such as compassion, kindness, generosity, and a deeper sense of fellowship and goodwill.
    • VickySGV
      Seems like they caught him pumping gasoline onto a political fire for sure.  I do think that for the time being he has been cooled down a bit. 
    • Davie
      It was Fran Jeffery, manager of The Animals, who signed Jimi Hendrix and brought him to England—launching the career of the best guitarist of all time.
    • VickySGV
      I am not completely sure what you mean here.  To be "held responsible" means that they have been investigated and brought to justice by any number of legal and financial means.  That would be a good thing, and has been done recently in a case for slander and libel where the organization agreed to pay its victims many millions of dollars.  In that case the victims were NOT Trans, but the platform was "held responsible". If you mean simply "found to be responsible" by evidence obtained from various credible sources, then of course there are options for the victims to pursue to "hold them responsible" in monetary or terms of personal freedom of the officers.  There are many such organizations that do foster hatred of our community and we have taken different forms of action which includes exposing their hatred and intentions to other public media.  It is not a "what if" the groups do this, it is done regularly.  As long as they are deemed to be private and not government supported, the best we can do is avoid such places.  If the site is Government Supported, then there is a chain of legal events that one or many legal organizations that support the Trans Community can bring actions to have corrected via the Courts or other agencies as dictated by law. 
    • Davie
      RIP, Doug Ingle, front man of rock band Iron Butterfly, dies aged 78. Singer and organist wrote 17-minute classic In-a-Gadda-Da-Vida,
    • Davie
      Florida’s LGBTQ+ residents relieved after easing of DeSantis’s anti-gay laws Past 12 months show evidence of radical change in political climate, starting with judge again allowing children at drag shows. Leaders of Florida’s much-embattled LGBTQ+ communities say the worst of Governor Ron DeSantis’s three-year onslaught against them may be over, with the official start of Pride month celebrations only days away. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/article/2024/may/27/florida-lgbt-law-ron-desantis
    • Ashley0616
      I have four purses. A Coach purse being the only big-name brand but it's not in great shape. I might get another Coach purse because I like their design. 
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...