Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Why was South Park able to make a mockery of trans women


Guest RainbowGoth98

Recommended Posts

Guest Protoman2050

Hey! I find Mr/Mrs Garrison to be funny! Yes, me and my non-trans friends love to joke and make fun of my own transition, all in good fun.

Link to comment
Guest Claire-G

if they would only target transwoman than yes I would say somehing wrong there but they target about everything so

I don't think it's so bad.

Link to comment
Guest Nicole Thrace

I use to love South Park but quit watching the show many years ago. I do not remember what episode it was, but I felt it crossed the line in being funny and moved into the realm of being derogarity. I have not show again.

If you really want to " put them in their place " do as I did. I emailed all the companies that I had seen ads for during the show and calmly explained to them what I found offensive about the show. Then I explained that I would not be buying their product so long as they supported the show by advertising during it. South Park is still on air, but I was able to have my say and not support something I no longer felt was right. If enough people would do this then the show would no longer be on the air.

As far as it being "Ok" because they make fun of everybody?? NO WAY!! If I use derogarity terms to describe all races that still would not make it right. Hate speech is still hate speech. That is my feeling on the matter...

Hugs,

Nicole

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

You can vote with your channel selector or power switch (my preference)

Link to comment
Guest BrenGirl

I actually see South Park as a satire. They go absolutely crazy on everything to show just how crazy society is on a whole. I haven't seen any super recent episodes but I still love the show.

Link to comment

I'll chime in with those who commented that south park pretty much makes satire of everyone.

And I will note that I seen one or another trans trans person doing or acting in most every way the show has depicted a trans person. They aren't having to make stuff up. While such may not depict the typical trans, like with any group, it becomes good fodder for satire.

It also seems to me, with Mr/Mrs Garrison character, is bassically accepted by the other characters.

Link to comment
Guest KimberlyF

I'm not sure it's possible to tell a joke without at least someone getting offended.

I'm more concerned for people who allow their self-worth to be influenced from South Park.

Link to comment
Guest Robin Winter

South Park rates with Springer as far as I'm concerned. It's trash, and it will not ever be watched in this house, at least not with my knowledge or consent.

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

South Park rates with Springer as far as I'm concerned. It's trash, and it will not ever be watched in this house, at least not with my knowledge or consent.

Most TV is mindless trash and mostly a waste of time (IMHO), there is so much more to do in life, get out there, exercise, read a book, be with friends, anything but TV really, real life awaits.......

Link to comment
  • Admin

I don't watch South Park, but I've seen bits and pieces. They do a pretty good job of skewering just about everyone and every institution, at one point or another. I am certain that everyone so skewered is equally offended.

Sadly, satire as an art form seems a lost cause these days. Skins have become way too thin. Mel Brooks would not be able to make a living in today's world.

Carolyn Marie

Link to comment
Guest Robin Winter

South Park rates with Springer as far as I'm concerned. It's trash, and it will not ever be watched in this house, at least not with my knowledge or consent.

Most TV is mindless trash and mostly a waste of time (IMHO), there is so much more to do in life, get out there, exercise, read a book, be with friends, anything but TV really, real life awaits.......

True :P I actually don't watch much TV, but what I do watch is generally mindless as well. At least it isn't obscene.

Link to comment
Guest Kelly-087

I hardly find South Park that offensive. It really is trashy.

However I am offended by the trans bashing on main tv shows like Family guy. That's much worse.

Link to comment
Guest JeepGirl90

I don't take offense to South Park, They make fun of anything and anyone. they don't just single out Trans Women. THey just kinda make fun of anything that is relevent.

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...
Guest Sabrinaxx

South Park is actually one of my favorite shows, a lot of episodes show what kind of stuff is going on at the time. Like others that responded I agree that they make fun of society as a whole, and transgender people are also a part of that society. The show let's people know trans people are out there, in kind of a messed up way, but that's South Park for ya...

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   9 Members, 0 Anonymous, 94 Guests (See full list)

    • Cynthia Slowan
    • cela_tracy
    • Abigail Genevieve
    • Ivy
    • MAN8791
    • Mmindy
    • Vidanjali
    • Finn_Pioneer
    • VickySGV
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.8k
    • Total Posts
      769.6k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,071
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Ran91
    Newest Member
    Ran91
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Caridad
      Caridad
    2. Certbunnie
      Certbunnie
      (25 years old)
    3. EstherElle
      EstherElle
      (43 years old)
    4. Juliet
      Juliet
      (43 years old)
    5. MelissaAndProudOfIt
      MelissaAndProudOfIt
      (59 years old)
  • Posts

    • VickySGV
      @Mirrabooka@Abigail Genevieve Let's not neglect the severe divisions within the Trans and NB sector as well along those lines.  Where we have Non Op & Non HRT and Cross Dressers, Gender Benders, Gender Fluid, Agender et al VS. the full surgical route takers with GCS, FFS, BA and vocal surgery,   Which of those segments gets to speak for the others?  How do we turn them into a cohesive force for good just among those nominally under the Trans shade tree?? 
    • Mmindy
      Good morning Felix,   I don't know how aware you are of the motives behind Military Boot Camp, but the most important thing it's designed to do is break you down, physically and mentally, weeding out those who can't make it. If you really want to be a Marine after you graduate high school? Stop believing you do things better when you're high. Clean your lungs by filling them with the fresh air of cross country running. Start small, run around the block, then around the track, then from your house to the track. Run everywhere! Run, run, run, and then when you can't go any further. Run some more. Do this feeling like you're going into Boot Camp in top physical condition, and your training will still break you down. That's what it's designed to do, and you'll earn the right to be called a Marine. The best thing about your wishes to become a Marine, is that it's something you can surely do with a proper mindset. Yes, it's very physical, but most of all it's mental. My brother-in-law is a retired Marine, and I love his stories ranging from his time in boot camp, to his time as a drill instructor. These conversations are not started by him. They're usually started by my nephew who is also a Marine. I can't say enough how proud I am of my family and friends who have or are currently serving in the Armed Forces. I will be equity proud of you too.   Best wishes, stay positive and motivated,   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋
    • Finn_Pioneer
      I was always playing the boy in house, and I HATED wearing dresses. I used to dress up super masc and go out to dinner to just make sure I could still pass as a boy. I thought of it as a game but.. uh.. nope. 
    • Timi
      I took Maybelline's quiz https://www.maybelline.com/babelline-makeup-personality-quiz and I'm "Perfectly Practical" when it comes to makeup.    I carry three things in my makeup bag in my purse that I use any or all depending on my mood.    1) Maybelline magic eraser/concealer. Pretty much a liquid foundation/concealer in lipstick-sized package with built-in sponge applicator. It rules.    2) Maybelline mascara primer. It's the subtlest of enhancements, yet makes me feel confident in my eye communication.    3) Subtle lipstick in a natural/nude shade. Very slight enhancement that again, is mostly for how I feel.    -Timi
    • April Marie
      Thank you!! I finally gave up and dropped the t-shirt. Working in the skort and sports bra was much cooler!
    • April Marie
      Welcome to the forums! Another very late starter here and still haven't made the HRT move. So, I can't help much with your questions. But, you are among friends!!
    • Sally Stone
      I love makeup.  Firstly, I need it to help feminize my facial features, and I'm fascinated by the way it transforms.  I love trying new techniques and new products.  I think the best thing about using and wearing makeup is that helps me feel more feminine.    
    • Sally Stone
      I support everyone's right to say what they think, even when what they say is hurtful or hate-based.  Quite simply, those people should have that right.  However, just because I support a person's right to free speech, never means I have to agree with it.  We should never stifle free speech, but when it is hateful or hurtful we should exercise our free speech right to say how inappropriate their speech is.  The best way to fight hateful and hurtful speech is through discourse.  Sadly, our society has lost the ability to debate.    We have assumed the position that "if you don't agree with me, you must be against me."  This way of thinking prevents discourse and all the good that comes from it. 
    • missyjo
      I'm sure you look smashing in it   I'm just working so denim mini n white sleeveless top..maybe I'll change for hair appointment later   hugs
    • Abigail Genevieve
      There has been discussion before on this.  Not all the TG goals are the same as the LGB+ goals. We can agree on some things, but some gays reject transgender and some transgender reject homosexuality.  I think it is a case of we can work together on some things, but there are limits.
    • Ivy
      Welcome Kati. I was 68 when I realized who I was myself. As far as hormones go, Planned Parenthood does work with trans people.  I don't think they do the therapy though. As of now, NC is an informed consent state.  You can get HRT by signing off on it. If you have a doctor or therapist that is trans friendly, it might be good to work with them.   In NC the urban areas tend to be more trans friendly, but you never know, you might get lucky.
    • MaeBe
      Three treatments down and my skin is no worse for wear.
    • Vidanjali
      @FelixThePickleMan your post reveals a lot of insight, but also mixed with denial. Your desire to strengthen your relationship with your mother is admirable, but it cannot be the sole motivating factor to your giving up an addictive behavior. However, your love for your mother and desire for her love will help strengthen your resolve. But that resolve needs to come from your own will. You say you smoke because you have nothing else to do and you believe you are a better person when you're high. You must come to understand that the creative and charismatic energy that drugs seem to unleash is potentially in you at all times. Make it your project to figure out how to tap into that and channel it without using drugs. Make that your thing to do. It's a challenging and exciting thing to do.    I started smoking cigarettes at age 15. In my late teens, a good friend observed that smoking was the only time she ever saw me calm. That was profound for me. It took a few more years, but eventually I had the epiphany in which I saw my life as nothing but a string of tedium in between each cigarette. It seemed so pathetic to me and that motivated me to give up smoking and learn to live life differently. My story of addiction is much longer and more entailed, but I will focus only on smoking here as it is relevant.    And as I reflect on it, I also should comment on your belief that you have to stop liking the habit before you can quit. That is not a necessary condition for one to quit. In fact, if that were so, hardly anyone would ever quit any bad habit. More accurately, you come to dislike the person you have become while in the grip of the bad, addictive habit. Not in a self-loathing kind of way, as that will not motivate you, but rather depress you. In other words, you come to a place where you are able to take a subjective view of yourself and your life and decide that you want something else, something better. And sometimes that only happens when you hit the lowest point in your life and there's nowhere to go but up. Don't let yourself get even close to that state, if you can help it - and you can help it.   Weed seems to imbue all your activity with a kind of a magical quality. This makes the world, your activities, and yourself much better with weed. But all that is an illusion. Your proof is that it's artificially invoked, only temporary, and destructive to your relationship with your mother. If I may be so bold, frankly, it is a cop out. You have the potential in you to see your life, the world, and yourself as beautiful, captivating, and wonderous without altering your mind. In fact, it is in clearing your mind that you are able to glimpse this. You want something productive to do? Develop a workout routine. Take up meditating. Learn mindfulness techniques which you can practice throughout the day. The magic is in quieting the mind and being present. There is no instant intensity like you get with weed. But you gain power within yourself, and you are the very source. Become addicted to that - that is a good addiction and you will progressively see your life and relationships in a new and brighter light.    
    • EasyE
      I had a pretty serious porn addiction for awhile (thankfully broken about 12 years ago), and so my wife sees my "trans-ness" tied into that ... to her, it is all one ugly thread of sexual sin and dysfunction... sometimes, I do struggle with it, too. Is this just another branch of a sexual addiction thing? Am I looking for a substitute for the porn?   When I sift through everything it seems much deeper than that. And if anything, the HRT has lowered/changed my libido and it hasn't lowered my desire to move in a more feminine direction with dress, etc. It can be confusing, especially when you are in a very religious/moralistic environment...   To get back to the main topic, the fear of change and the unknown is huge. And like others have said, folks on the fringe of just about any cause tend to be what gets played up in the media and what folks see the most. Not many people see good ol' regular transgender people who are just trying to live their lives, hold down jobs, take care of their families, etc.  
    • Mmindy
      Welcome to Transgender Pulse Forums @Kait   Best wishes, stay positive and motivated.   Mindy🌈🐛🏳️‍⚧️🦋
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...