Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

ABC News Editor Returns To Being Male


Carolyn Marie

Recommended Posts

Well...ain't that somethin...

It is far from the first flip-flop tho perhaps a whole lot more public than most.

And folks wonder why us folks who been around a long time aren't cheerleaders...in part cause there is no telling where this stuff could lead, what trouble could occur, and things like this.

I have to say the rationale is quite unusual and I wonder if the "amnesia" story is cover to excuse the flip flop. Maybe it is time to give words of caution that it will just come back?

Maybe this is a good time to point out why one year RLT is important? Though really a year is so minimal when it comes to folks flipping back. Oh and yea, they are almost always totally sure it is right when starting.

Somehow I don't think this is the last we going to hear of this.

Unfortunate thing is that it will cause lots of questions and bad potential for those needing to deal with their issues cause it will be harder for them to be taken seriously. But hey, it is more awareness right so must be good!

The way trans has become more fashionable and lots of folks who would have never been considered good transition candidates in the past who are going into transition now, I certainly can see more of these sorts of things in the future.

Link to comment
Guest LauraJen
Unfortunate thing is that it will cause lots of questions and bad potential for those needing to deal with their issues cause it will be harder for them to be taken seriously. But hey, it is more awareness right so must be good!

The way trans has become more fashionable and lots of folks who would have never been considered good transition candidates in the past who are going into transition now, I certainly can see more of these sorts of things in the future.

Unfortunately yes... all this is going to do is reinforce misconceptions and strengthen the opinions of the many unsupportive parents out there on their trans kids' feelings (just a phase, making a mistake, etc). It will serve as an example of how things go wrong when in actual fact detransitioners are in a very small minority. Of course, sceptics won't listen to that...

Not all publicity is good publicity - whoever said otherwise is wrong. This really doesn't help at all.

Link to comment
Guest otter-girl

Most of us know what the mans club is like and what membership of it is like. To get back in means saying, "honest guys, Im not a woman". Alien abduction doesnt wash so I need some other quasi plausible reason to save face.

If I was wearing my usual caring empathic hat Id be more sympathetic because I bet he has gone through hell and might again one day. But today Im stressed out with life.

Never mind

Rachel

Link to comment
  • Admin

This reads like a tabloid and not a bona fide news story. I do not really recognize the pulication, and some of its "other news" is the sensation type of thing. Noting a comptroller candidate as an "ex madam" is not your family news paper. There is no corroboration in the story from the person's colleagues either. "An ancient and fish like smell" to me.

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

I agree Vicky, this story as reported is dubious a "three-month odyssey" as it's called, maybe more like a 3 month oddity, and no it really does not help any of us here (true or not), given whatever exposure it might create in the general population, I was looking for the comments below, but there were none, hmmmm, notice the "exclusive" banner that highlights this article :rolleyes:

Link to comment
Guest Alexis25

I don't even have a comment to this story

Misdiagnosed?

Hormone imbalance, to justify his change?

AND WHAT amnesia as another excuse to why he was a women, well that's strange

And what did they call him a M t F t M

At least he still supports LGBT groups >.>

Link to comment
  • Admin

I don't doubt that he changed his mind. It happens from time to time. What's in question is the why. The story he concocted sounds ridiculous. I read it three times and it still makes no sense. No one noticed that he had amnesia the last 14 years? I know bull doo doo when I hear it. Those of you who said this is going to be adverse to our community are spot on.

Carolyn Marie

Link to comment

The NY Post is one of the big three papers in NYC. Not sure if it is second or third. The post is known for using more sensational headlines/front page.

No one noticed that he had amnesia the last 14 years? I know bull doo doo when I hear it.

As written I read that as a two day bout of amnesia which, when he started he thought it was 1999. Thus it suggested he had forgotten the prior 14 years, not had amnesia for all the time.

So the amnesia comes on, he thinks it is 1999 and he is a guy again. Then two days later, his memories come back, remembers becoming a girl but what didn't come back was his identity as Dawn"

Nothing was said as to what triggered the amnesia. Now assuming it isn't all made up to cover a change in heart, perhaps, despite everything reported about accepted, he was still stressed living in a new role, perhaps in a way he wasn't willing to admit, and the stress triggered a dissociative amnesia episode knocking him out of the situation and enabled finding more comforting footing.

I've certainly seen folks push themselves into transition, get more stressed, and convince themselves the only solution is to push thru when the problem was that they pushed themselves too far in the first place and it was only when they backed up and found the right balance things got better.

Lots of speculation can be made in this case, certainly one of the oddest I have heard of.

Link to comment
Guest HughE

I read a story a while ago about Don Ennis transitioning to become Dawn Ennis. The story mentioned he'd been given female hormone treatment as a child and at his age, it's very likely to have been DES. DES and transsexuality is a bit of a hot topic for me, so I tracked down Don's facebook page and tried messaging him (her at the time!).

I was hoping to spark some interest in ABC doing a news story about whether giving mothers medical treatment with artificial sex hormones during pregnancy could cause their children to experience problems with gender identity later in life. Unfortunately I never got a reply, but I've just checked his facebook page and he's calling himself Don now, so I guess the NY post story is for real.

Looking at his FB page it seems like he's a genuine person, so I don't think what he's doing is intended as an attack on transgendered people. Perhaps he's like me and has part of who he is that wants to be a man and another part that wants to be a woman?

Link to comment
  • Admin

The NY Post is one of the top 10 circulated papers in the country. It's now being picked up globally based on this story.

I am considerably southwest and am highly provincial with my news interests. I can get enough drama out here. It still reads like a scandal rag to me, whatever it may be to others. Its not the first time I have missed the elephant in the room. I was aiming at the buffalo.

Link to comment
Guest KimberlyF

Either the timeline to this story isn't meshing up, or Don put zero thought into this decision.

A week and a half ago, 'she' is posting about high heels. Last Wed there is a post that doesn't sound too butch to me about a teddy bear. Maybe not the best post two days before telling people you were really a guy the whole time.

Or did the two day bout of amnesia start right after this bear post? (Wed 7:30 PM) then Friday posts the memo?

Even if the Teddy Bear post is 'Don', the heels one has to be 'Dawn' and after amnesia there still would be at most a full week left before making a major decision and announcement.

Link to comment
Guest Melissa~

Doctor confidentiality is fine and dandy, but this stuff can result in harm, is that crossing the line into harming self or others?

Frankly I have significant family and friends in the publishing business. What I can tell you the whole business is having trouble modernizing, people's jobs are on the line. Was this a shameless ploy to preserve a "boring straight guys" job that was about to evaporate?

A lot could be going on here, that's all.

Link to comment
Guest Sarah Faith

Oooookay.. Well, sound to me like Don/Dawn had a moment of regret and is pulling the old "Im cured!" routine.. The story of having a moment of amnesia and then suddenly being cured sounds like an awfully fishy one to me.. But to each their own I suppose.

Sarah

Link to comment
Guest NatashaJade

I've known Don for a couple of years over FB and correspondence (my spouse counseled his spouse as well) and all I'll say is that for him, the thought of his family breaking apart was horrifying beyond measure and I have to think that played a major role in his decision.

I think the worst part of this story is how very public it all is and I have to think there is going to be a lot of backlash from all sides. I really do wish the best for him and his family and hope they can weather yet another storm.

Link to comment
Guest kyliej

While I agree the excuse, assuming it is an excuse, isn't great, but I like Natasha's call for empathy and compassion. This isn't an easy journey for any of us, and we can't possibly know exactly what he has going on the rest of his life. Getting to the point of starting transition like he did takes a huge effort, and taking it back is almost as big if not harder to endure. I know how important transition is to me and to others, so to feel like one has to call it off is a pretty big deal, and I imagine he must feel terrible no matter what the cause is. I hope he and his family find peace, freedom and joy.

Link to comment
Guest Bellexia

Agreed with Kyliej. Put yourself in her shoes for a minute, realize that you don't have any where near the spotlight on you or your family. It's much easier when it's not publicized.

Link to comment
Guest Bellexia

Also I think it's a little messed up that our community, in general views some trans people as either detriments or assets to be had. Take the Kristen Beck for example, she was hailed as the transgoddess of 2013, yet in this article people are so quick to say this person is a detriment to our community as a whole. How many of you purged and burned before finally accepted yourselves? Add the public light to that and it becomes a spectacle, anything you do becomes publicized. The mere act of trying to forget you were something because this huge mess. It is blatantly unfair.

Link to comment
Guest NatashaJade

Don's story makes me think of Mike Penner (a very public media figure who committed suicide after detransitioning). Detransitioning in the public eye is almost worse than the initial transition.

Remember, the article is from the New York Post. You don't know the real story.

Link to comment
Guest Amanda Whyte

My heart goes out to him actually. Being at a spot in my transition and relationship that I am struggling with more than I have at any other, I can picture someone trying their hardest to figure out a way out. It is unfortunate that it is such a public story but he is still a human going through this.

I dont mean to say this is what he did, I could just understand it if he did. If I knew for sure I could live that way, I would in a heartbeat for my children but I really know in my heart that I would be no good to anybody if I did so I am going to continue with my transition and try my hardest to keep my children in my life.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   6 Members, 0 Anonymous, 151 Guests (See full list)

    • MaeBe
    • Ivy
    • VickySGV
    • Abigail Genevieve
    • Carolyn Marie
    • RaineOnYourParade
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.7k
    • Total Posts
      768.4k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,029
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Selkimur
    Newest Member
    Selkimur
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Anyatimenow
      Anyatimenow
      (23 years old)
    2. Aria00
      Aria00
    3. Ava B.
      Ava B.
      (24 years old)
    4. Claire Heshi
      Claire Heshi
    5. CrystalMatthews0426
      CrystalMatthews0426
      (41 years old)
  • Posts

    • Abigail Genevieve
      I was thinking in particular of BLM, who years ago had a 'What We Believe' section that sounded like they were at war with the nuclear family.   I tried to find it. Nope.  Of interest https://www.politifact.com/article/2020/aug/28/ask-politifact-does-black-lives-matter-aim-destroy/   My time is limited and I will try to answer as I can.
    • Ivy
      Well, I suppose it is possible that they don't actually plan on doing what they say.  I'm not too sure I want to take that chance.  But I kinda expect to find out.  Yet, perhaps you're right and it's all just talk.  And anyway, my state GOP is giving me enough to worry about anyway. I remember a time when being "woke" just meant you were paying attention.  Now it means you are the antichrist. I just don't want the government "protecting" me from my personal "delusions."
    • MaeBe
      1.  I think there are some legitimate concern.   2. Thoroughly discussing this will consume many threads.   3. I disagree partially with @MaeBe but there is partial agreement.   4. The context includes what is happening in society that the authors are observing.  It is not an isolated document.   The observation is through a certain lens, because people do things differently doesn't mean they're doing it wrong. Honestly, a lot of the conservative rhetoric is morphing desires of people to be treated with respect and social equity to be tantamount to the absolution of the family, heterosexuality, etc. Also, being quiet and trying to blend in doesn't change anything. Show me a social change that benefits a minority or marginalized group that didn't need to be loud.   5. Trump, if elected, is as likely to spend his energies going after political opponents as he is to implementing something like this.   Trump will appoint people to do this, like Roger Severino (who was appointed before, who has a record of anti-LGBTQ+ actions), he need not do anything beyond this. His people are ready to push this agenda forward. While the conservative right rails about bureaucracy, they intend to weaponize it. There is no question. They don't want to simplify government, they simply want to fire everyone and bring in conservative "warriors" (their rhetoric). Does America survive 4 year cycles of purge/cronyism?   6. I reject critical theory, which is based on Marxism.  Marxism has never worked and never will.  Critical theory has problems which would need time to go into, which I do not have.   OK, but this seems like every other time CRT comes up with conservatives...completely out of the blue. I think it's reference is mostly just to spark outrage from the base. Definitely food thought for a different thread, though.   7. There are groups who have declared war on the nuclear family as problematically patriarchal, and a lot of other terms. They are easy to find on the internet.  This document is reacting to that (see #4 above).   What is the war on the nuclear family? I searched online and couldn't find much other than reasons why people aren't getting married as much or having kids (that wasn't a propaganda from Heritage or opinions pieces from the right that paint with really broad strokes). Easy things to see: the upward mobility and agency of women, the massive cost of rearing children, general negative attitudes about the future, male insecurity, etc. None of this equates to a war on the nuclear family, but I guess if you look at it as "men should be breadwinners and women must get married for financial support and extend the male family line (and to promote "National Greatness") I could see the decline of marriage as a sign of the collapse of a titled system and, if I was a beneficiary of that system or believe that to NOT be tilted, be aggrieved.   8.  Much of this would have to be legislated, and this is a policy documented.  Implementation would  be most likely different, but that does not mean criticism is unwarranted.   "It might be different if you just give it a chance", unlike all the other legislation that's out there targeting LGBTQ+ from the right, these are going to be different? First it will be trans rights, then it will be gay marriage, and then what? Women's suffrage?   I get it, we may have different compasses, but it's not hard to see that there's no place for queer people in the conservative worldview. There seems to be a consistent insistence that "America was and is no longer Great", as if the 1950s were the pinnacle of society, completely ignoring how great America still is and can continue to be--without having to regress society to the low standards of its patriarchal yesteryears.    
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Cadillac parts are pretty expensive, so repairing them costs more.  But they don't seem to break down more than other makes.  Lots of Lincoln models use Ford cars as a base, so you can get parts that aren't much more expensive.    My family has had good luck with "Panther platform" cars.  Ford Crown Victoria, Mercury Marquis, Lincoln Towncar or Continental.  4.6 V8 and 5.0 V8.  Reasonable fuel economy, and fairly durable.  Our county sheriff's office was running Chargers and SUV's for a while, but has gone back to older Crown Victorias for ease of maintenance.  GF rebuilds them here.  But they are getting more scarce, since the newest ones were made in 2011.    1992-1997 years were different than the later years.  1998-2001 they did some changes, and apparently the best years are 2003 to 2011.  Check Craigslist, and also government auctions.  GF has gotten a lot of them at auction, and they can be had in rough-but-running shape for around $1,000.  Ones in great shape can be found in the $5,000+ range.  Good for 200,000 miles without significant rebuilding.  Go through engine and transmission and electrical systems, and they go half a million.    Some Chrysler models are OK.  The 300 mostly has the same engines as the Charger and Challenger, so parts availability is pretty good.  But they tend to get timing issues.  The older Chrysler Sebring convertibles were pretty reliable, sometimes going 200,000 miles without tons of problems, although after that they were pretty much worn out. 
    • Abigail Genevieve
      I think I have read everything the Southern Baptists have to say on transgender, and it helped convince me they are dead wrong on these issues.  They can be nice people.  I would never join an SBC church.
    • Abigail Genevieve
      You come across as a thoughtful, sweet, interesting and pleasant person.    There are parts of this country, and more so the world, where evangelicals experience a great deal of finger wagging.
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      It has been an interesting experience being in a marriage in a Christian faith community, yet being intersex/trans.  I stay pretty quiet, and most have kind of accepted that I'm just the strange, harmless exception.  "Oh, that's just Jen.  Jen is...different."  I define success as being a person most folks just overlook. 
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Well, I live in an area with a lot of Southern Baptists, Evangelicals, etc...  We've experienced our share of finger-wagging, as the "standard interpretation" of Scripture in the USA is that the Bible only approves of "one man, one woman" marriage.  My faith community is mostly accepted here, but that has taken time and effort.  It can be tough at times to continue to engage with culture and the broader population, and avoid the temptation to huddle up behind walls like a cult.    Tolerance only goes so far.  At one point, my husband was asked to run for sheriff.  He declined, partly because an elected official with four wives would have a REALLY tough time.  (Of course, making way less than his current salary wasn't an option either). 
    • Abigail Genevieve
      My bone structure is far more female than male.  I can't throw like a guy, which has been observed by guys numerous times, and moving like a woman is more natural.  It just is.  I'm not going out of my way to act in a fem. way, as you say, but I am letting go of some of the 'I am not going to move like that because I am a guy' stuff I have defensively developed.  The other breaks through anyway - there were numerous looks from people at work when I would use gestures that are forbidden to men, or say something spontaneously no guy would ever say.   At one point, maybe a year or more ago, I said it was unfair for people to think they were dealing with a man when they were actually dealing with a woman.    Girl here.  'What is a woman' is a topic for another day.
    • Willow
      Mom, I’m home!  What’s for lunch?   Leftover pizza .   ok.    Not exactly our conversation but there is truth in the answer.     @KymmieLsorry you are sick. Feel better soon.   Girl mode, boy mode no mode, not us. Nothing functional for either of us.   anyone here have or had a 10 year old (plus or minus) Caddy, Lincoln or Chrysler?  How was it?  Lots of repairs?  Comfortable seats? Anything positive or negative about it?  I need to replace my 2004 Ford Explorer Eddie Bauer, it’s eating $100 dollar bills and needs a couple of thousand dollars worth of work and that doesn’t even fix the check engine code.  Obviously, it isn’t worth putting that kind of money into a 20 year old car with a 174 thousand miles.   Willow
    • Ashley0616
      Oversized pink shirt, pink and black sports bra
    • Abigail Genevieve
      I think you mean the worst possible interpretation of 2025 situation.  Keep in mind that there are those who will distort and downright lie about anything coming from conservatives - I have seen it time and time again.  It's one of the reasons I want to read the thing slowly and carefully.  They want you to be very, very afraid. 
    • Abigail Genevieve
      Here is where the expectation is that the stereotypical evangelical comes in finger wagging, disapproving and condemning.    Not gonna do that.   You have to work these things out.  Transgender issues put a whole different spin on everything and God understands what we are going through. I have enough trouble over here.  :)
    • Ivy
      You do you. You seem to be in a safe place if we end up with a 2025 situation.  But a lot of us are not.
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      Well, my marriage is different.  I'm actually part of a multi-partner marriage.  Like you see in the Book of Genesis.  My husband has four wives...and me.  I was kind of an accident, as our community sets the "reasonable maximum" at four wives, but that's a long story.  Plural marriage is approved in my faith community, with the exception of spiritual leaders, as described in 1 Timothy 3.  We believe that anything that isn't specifically prohibited is permitted.    The purpose of marriage is for people to work together, demonstrate the love of God, and to have children.  My faith believes in exponential reproduction - big families with lots of kids, both as a blessing and with the intention of using the size of our population for political ends.  Being intersex/trans and unable to bear children, I wouldn't have been a good candidate to be somebody's only spouse (the majority of our community tends toward traditional couple marriage).  Since my husband has other partners, I don't have to worry about the childbearing aspect, and I help out with raising our family's kids.  I'm a "bonus parent."    I'm not 100% open about my intersex/trans nature, although my community's leaders are aware of me.  Being transgender isn't condemned, but it is seen as a health problem derived from an imperfect, fallen world and an environment polluted with chemicals.  Since I'm married, I have a safe place to be, and I can live how I need to live.    I firmly believe the advice given in 1 Corinthians 7.  We don't totally own our bodies.  God gets a say, as I believe He created us to be male or female, not something outside the binary.  I don't think that transition without discussion with partners is OK....again, we don't totally own ourselves.  When I started to figure myself out, that was actually the main thing on my mind - will my partners accept me?  How will my position in the family change?  Since my partners don't really have a problem with the mild version of transition that I wanted to do, it has all been good. 
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...