Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Tennessee Anti-Trans Youth Sports Bill Becomes Law


Carolyn Marie

Recommended Posts

  • Admin

https://www.wbir.com/article/news/politics/gov-lee-signs-transgender-athlete-bill-preventing-students-from-playing-on-teams-aligning-with-gender-identity/51-e7ee92ed-c2ae-40ec-b556-7c5e8bcabfb5

 

I believe this is state #3.  The others are Arkansas and Mississippi.  Its so nice to know that its so much safer for cis-girls now that a non-existent crisis has been ended.

 

Carolyn Marie

Link to comment
  • Admin

In order to participate in school sports a preteen child needs to impregnate another preteen child to for both of them to play school sports?  That is how this bill can be construed, and it can really get ridiculous.  Even the seeming right genitalia does not do the job. 

Link to comment
  • Admin

I'd love to see what happens when a 17-18 year old FtM trans youth signs up to play girls softball, or any other sport, for that matter.  Not that any would, but it would be interesting just the same.

 

Carolyn Marie

Link to comment
9 hours ago, Carolyn Marie said:

I'd love to see what happens when a 17-18 year old FtM trans youth signs up to play girls softball, or any other sport, for that matter.  Not that any would, but it would be interesting just the same.

LOL

Of course we all realize this has nothing to do with sports anyway.

Link to comment
  • Admin
1 hour ago, Jandi said:

OK

I was thinking about that one myself.  I read a couple of pieces on Face Book about his POV on this.

Link to comment

I saw this being mentioned on reddit. As some one who played competitive stick and ball sports most of my child hood. I'm kinda mixed about this, and got ripped a new one by a few people over there. Who probably don't know how munch stronger a 15 year old boy is compared to even a 15 year old girl. Let alone how munch stronger a 18 year old man is then the same 15 year old boy. There is a reason why boys sports leagues are based on real small age groups after 10. 

 

I said I personally don't find it fair for the girls. If a trans girl who went through male puberty is on the other team. I feel like it's fair if she had been on blockers, and hasn't experienced male puberty. I also said a ftm would be at a disadvantage compared to a 18 year old man of the same height and weight. I then was told he can take hormones to be as strong. Yes they are correct, but the avg puberty age for boys is 12. He has a 4 year head start on development, and he might never catch up in strength with a cis male.

 

In the end If I had a daughter. I would be upset if she had to compete against any one. Trans or not that has had testerone in their system period because I know what it advantage is. I'm all for equal rights, but I also feel this has to be put in to palce to save girls sports. 

Link to comment

What about youth level sports "transitioning" to Non-gendered competitive sports categories.  We everybody regardless of gender identity is allow to participate and compete and the "level" of the category you are competing in is based on ability, not gender.
This is done already in things like Varsity vs JV levels, and a multitude of minor-league levels in baseball. 

 

This would be good even for cis-gender youth who maybe don't have the physical attributes in their age bracket to compete at the higher levels (puberty hits everybody differently).  I was like that in my teens.  I loved sports but I could never match up with my cis-male peers.

I thought I might be crazy to think this is possible until I found this article ..


https://www.reuters.com/article/us-britain-lgbt-sport-trfn-idUSKBN1XE0CA

 

but as @Jandi said, this legislation really has nothing to do with sports ?

Link to comment
8 hours ago, Red_Lauren. said:

I feel like it's fair if she had been on blockers, and hasn't experienced male puberty. I also said a ftm would be at a disadvantage compared to a 18 year old man of the same height and weight. I then was told he can take hormones to be as strong. Yes they are correct, but the avg puberty age for boys is 12. He has a 4 year head start on development, and he might never catch up in strength with a cis male.

It does get complicated.  Of course a lot of these bills would also prohibit puberty blockers. 

I do have some mixed feelings on the sports issues myself.  But I feel sports are only being used as an excuse to scapegoat the trans youth community.  Criminalizing trans medical care is kinda oppressive IMHO.  And forcing teachers to out trans kids to a hostile family is… well, cruel and dangerous.

Link to comment
On 3/26/2021 at 11:23 PM, Carolyn Marie said:

I'd love to see what happens when a 17-18 year old FtM trans youth signs up to play girls softball, or any other sport, for that matter.  Not that any would, but it would be interesting just the same.

 

 

It already evident that teenage girls are being allowed to play football in some high schools. I also know that there should be allowances for trans girls to play in girl sports but also that there should be a sizing and strength similarity between the cis and trans. We need to find some form of common ground for all people and we need to tell those in charge. Our government needs to know that. I am, personally, a transgender athlete in bowling. I am looking forward to joining the women's division soon. So my point is if there is equal abilities in both the cis person and transgender person, let them play.

Link to comment
1 hour ago, Mia Marie said:

So my point is if there is equal abilities in both the cis person and transgender person, let them play.

Don't some sports have "Handicaps"?

Link to comment

There are in most bowling but I have seen some leagues with no handicap and cis women who could out bowl me on any given day. As for regular junior high and high school sports, no there aren't. I am working toward PBA and there is no handicaps used there.

Link to comment
1 hour ago, Mia Marie said:

cis women who could out bowl me on any given day.

And I was saying this as without any handicap added.

Link to comment
2 hours ago, Mia Marie said:
2 hours ago, Mia Marie said:

cis women who could out bowl me on any given day.

And I was saying this as without any handicap added.

Oh, I totally believe you.

As the parent of 6 daughters - don't underestimate the girls.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   5 Members, 0 Anonymous, 96 Guests (See full list)

    • Petra Jane
    • Betty K
    • April Marie
    • VickySGV
    • JustJack
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.7k
    • Total Posts
      768.9k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,044
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Ladypcnj
    Newest Member
    Ladypcnj
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. AlanaTG
      AlanaTG
    2. Alicia
      Alicia
      (35 years old)
    3. brianna051
      brianna051
      (39 years old)
    4. canofworms
      canofworms
    5. delmori
      delmori
  • Posts

    • April Marie
      Good morning, everyone!   Back to a semi-normal routine after the short vacay. We picked up our dog at the "spa" yesterday so she was very attentive last night. And, awake early but I managed to get her back to sleep for a few more hours.   I have an appointment at 8 to have the damage to my truck appraised after yesterday's accident. Hopefully, it's just cosmetic and there was no damage to the frame.   And, I've got a session with my therapist later this morning, too.   This afternoon will just be some small projects I need to catch up on.    Have a wonderful day, everyone!!
    • Willow
      Good morning      it’s Wednesday morning 3AM. Which reminds me of a Simon and Garfunkel song. But I won’t go there.  I have a lot on my plate this morning.  Waffles - check, OJ - check, morning meds - check, coffee - double check, lunch made -check.  But the real work is yet to come that starts at 4:15.  I’ve got a lot going on today over and above the usual 4:15 shift.  And somehow, I have to get the Asst Mgr to do some of the work for me.  That’s never fun, she and I don’t always see eye to eye.  She’d rather tell me what I did wrong or didn’t do verses help or show me the correct way.  Her status could be a topic for the May 23 meeting since I know the manager was pretty upset with her yesterday and she had a talk with the District manager about it.   well I had a Snoopy picture I tried to copy here but it got lost in the bits and bytes somewhere.  Time to shower and get dressed. Long day ahead likely greater than 8 hours but I’ve got time available in my hours per week.
    • KayC
      Braised short-ribs with all the fixin's (potatoes, onions, garlic, and celery) and homemade brown gravy - Leftovers from 2-nights ago, but even better 2nd time around (I wonder why that is?)
    • KayC
      I saw this on Erin's blog post too.  I definitely think this a BIG positive, but you're right @Carolyn Marie.  Now-a-days you never know how the World will get turned upside-down.
    • KayC
    • awkward-yet-sweet
      I have never been in the military, but my husband was in the National Guard.  Sometimes I wonder, based on the few things he tells me, how some of the "demands of military service" might be somewhat artificial.  For example, the military won't allow a man who is missing a testicle (like from an accident) to serve.  Even though a man with only one testicle still has all functions and plenty of testosterone.  So, why that requirement?  Seems like banning trans folks is similar, in that there's no particular physical reason.    Also, some requirements are detrimental to the physical health of many people in the services.  Soldiers end up with back issues from carrying too much.  My husband has a bad disc in his back, primarily from service.  Even military medical personnel and researchers have talked about this sort of preventable injury for a long time.    Not everybody is in the special forces, or even in the infantry.  Even if trans folks have some sort of physical weakness compared to others, surely there are still plenty of duties they can perform?  I would be interested to know the experiences of some of our military members on this forum - how much physical exertion and risk was actually necessary for fulfilling your duties?  How much difference is there in exertion/risk between one MOS and another?
    • Sally Stone
      Post 9 “The Jersey Years”   If it wasn’t for the property taxes, I’d still be living in New Jersey.  The state gets such a bad rap but it is actually a beautiful place, with lots to do, and it is extremely trans friendly.  Moving to New Jersey was quite uplifting from a trans perspective.    Because of my new and very flexible work schedule, I was suddenly getting a lot more time to express my feminine side, and I took every opportunity to do so.  Additionally, I became a member of a trans dinner group.  It was the perfect way to meet other trans women, and I made quite a few friends.   The dinner group was actually a throwback from a time when going out dressed as a woman was still something of a novelty, and it was created as a safe haven for girls that still weren’t comfortable being out in the world by themselves.  When the group was formed, it was a necessary resource, but that need waned over the years, and it morphed into more of a social group.  It still occasionally served its designed purpose as we often had newcomers just emerging from the closet, but for most of us it was an opportunity to get together and catch up.   The move to New Jersey also coincided with an important trans milestone for me.  I made the decision to keep my legs shaved.  This wasn’t a decision I came to easily.  It meant I was going against my wife’s wishes.  While she had always been supportive of me, shaving my legs was just a “bridge to far” for her.  I honestly believe, that in her mind, dressing like a woman was always a temporary thing, but shaving my legs, well, that was more of a permanent condition, and I think it scared her.    To me, shaving was a rite of passage.  I had made the decision to be a woman part time, but I wanted something exclusively feminine to signify my inner woman, even when I wasn’t presenting as a woman.  Finally, I decided not to wait any longer, and in deference to my wife’s concerns, I started shaving my legs regularly.  For the longest time, she remained unhappy about my decision, and while there were times, I thought about giving in just to keep the peace, I stayed the course I had plotted.  Over time, my smooth legs became less and less of an issue, and now it’s been ten-years since I last had hair on my legs.  Thankfully, my smooth legs are no longer much of a concern for my wife, and now, I can’t imagine ever going back.   So, how does a part-time woman who isn’t stealthy by most measures, get along so well in the world?  In two words it’s attitude and mannerisms.  At one of the Keystone Conferences, I kept noticing another trans woman always staring at me.  At the time, I didn’t know her but the attention she was paying me was becoming borderline creepy.  Later, while I was sitting at the hotel bar enjoying a cocktail, this same woman took the empty seat next to me.  Before I could decide whether to stay or leave, she turned to me, introduced herself, and then apologized for her stares.  She went on to tell me she was staring at me because I intrigued her.  She told me that of all the people she had met or observed during the conference, I was the most “girly” (her words, not mine).  She said if it wasn’t for my height, she’d never have guessed that I was trans, because I had the poise, attitude and mannerisms of a very feminine woman.       I met another girl through the dinner group, who was living fulltime and preparing for GRS.  She and I became the best of friends, a bond I believe was formed over us both serving in the military.  Often, she would comment on how authentic I was.  She would always tell me I was so feminine and womanly; I could easily go fulltime.    There have been other acquaintances who made similar comments, and the truth is I could probably live my life as a woman without too much trouble.  The thing is, I don’t want to.  Yes, I thoroughly enjoy being a woman, and when I am, I am quite convincing, but that doesn’t mean I’d be truly happy.  If I had never met my wife, and didn’t have two super great kids, and I didn’t enjoy being a guy, perhaps I would have given serious consideration to transitioning.  Maybe I’m just selfish, but I want to walk in both worlds, male and female, and I see nothing that should prevent me from doing so. Does my part-time life make me any less a woman.  If how much of a woman I am was measured by how much time I spend expressing that part of my personality, then yes, I probably could be considered less of a woman.  But it wouldn’t change at all how much of a woman my feminine half is.  Her time for self-expression is limited yes, but when she’s out, she’s every bit the woman anyone else is.   Hugs,   Sally
    • Adrianna Danielle
      Meeting up with a therapist I seen back in 2001.Seen I am better,saw her after being honorable discharged from the Army.I was beaten up and sexually assaulted by a fellow soldier.Nothing was done about it and did report it.It put a toll on me.Was 22 at the time and we did not get along at times,bullied me too.
    • Adrianna Danielle
      Army doing 4 years,I ended up be discharged after my 4 years were up.Another guy in the same unit I was in beat the crap out of me including sexual assaulting me.Nothing was done about it,reported it and it put a toll on me.Had anxiety issues which I did get help and did recover from it
    • April Marie
      Welcome to the forums, Ash! You’ll find lots of information and resources here to help with your journey. Jump in where you feel comfortable.  I look forward to learning more about you.
    • April Marie
      Welcome to the forums, Justine! We’re glad you found us. You’ll find many of us here who embraced our true selves late in life for many reasons. Each of us is unique, yet we often share much in common. Read, ask questions and jump in where you feel comfortable.
    • Mealaini
      I've perused a few introductions on here.  To say that my situation is unique would be silly, but it is my situation.  I have had questions about who I am my whole life.  At an early age, I was exposed to traumatic experiences in both the emotional and sexual realm.  I've been through many therapies, and over the last year and a half, I finally found a therapist worth her title. After using EMDR, I have been finally able to convince my brain (for the most part) that I am no longer in danger, and am no longer being abused.  With some of the worst of my experiences faced and accepted, I have been working with my therapist with Internal Family Systems.  I highly recommend the book "No Bad Parts" to get an idea of what IFS is and how it can be used to reunite the fractured internal family.  The main idea of the internal family systems theory is that trauma can fracture the Self into different parts - and each part takes on a role that tries to protect the Self.  In order to repair these parts, and to bring these wounded parts back so that they can unload their burdens (the traumatic experiences), I have had to learn who they are and how they should fit in within my Self.  It is a long and difficult  process getting to know these parts.  I have been able to work within on a few of the parts, and one of the parts that has shown herself as an important character in my whole Self has been Mealani (Gaelic for Melanie and sounds the same).  I've been familiar with this internal part since I was about 10 years old.  I am now 55 years old, and I am realizing that she had an important role in my complete Self - a role that has led me to conclude that I have been hiding from my true gender.  As of now, I identify as Gender Fluid.  My pronouns are He, They, and Them.     I have been married for 30 years.  I have two kids who are both LGBTQ+ - one is Queer and the other is Transgender.  As I have worked through this with my Therapist, I have realized that my kids have been fortunate to have a father who has been accepting of them from the start.  I am their biggest supporter and have never questioned their identity.  My wife has had a lot of trouble accepting both my kids and their identities.  She is doing better now, but it nearly tore us apart.  My wife is a devout Catholic, and I have deconstructed my faith and am now a Faithful Atheist who tries to practice Radical Awareness.  Coming out as Atheist was another thing that nearly tore us apart.  Defining myself as Gender Fluid might just be the last straw.  As both of my kids are fully grown, I am not too worried if this ends the relationship because I want my wife to have a complete life with someone who is able to be the person she expects.  BUT, I am not ready to break the news to anyone yet.  That is  why I found this site.  I am going to hang out in the chats, ask some questions, learn some things, and make some hard decisions.  I thank anyone who reads this.  There is so much more to my story, but I am not fully prepared to spill the beans here. ....I am a process, not a fixed thing, and I've come a LONG way to get here today!  :)
    • KathyLauren
      Hi, Justine.  Welcome to Trans Pulse.   Many of us can relate to your story.  Please feel free to check out the various forums and to join in on any discussions or start your own.
    • Justine76
      I'm AMAB been experimenting with a more feminine presentation for some time as an adult. At first, I'm not sure I was really conscious of it being a desire to look more feminine. I'd buy male skinny jeans and fitted tees, but that didn't feel quite right so I'd cuff the jeans into capris. Then I added an ankle bracelet, which I liked, but it kind of felt like the limit for an ostensibly cis-male in public and even drew surprise from my wife. So, I moved on to trying more things in private and, somewhat to my own surprise, feel really comfortable and sexy adding some platform heels to my capris and donning a more feminine top and wig; I'm older and don't have much hair of my own anymore ;) Make-up is still difficult but I'm practicing when I can. On the first attempt I just looked like some dude from Motley Crue, which could be fine but not what I'm going for day to day :P   Not sure exactly how I got here or where it's going. I've had to search my past a bit to speculate why this would be emerging now, in my 40s. I've always been a more effeminate individual; it just bleeds through somehow. I grew up being called '-awesome person-' or 'fairy' constantly, although there was never any question in my mind that I liked girls. In junior high I briefly experimented with applying make-up until a friend convinced me I'd get my butt kicked if anyone from school discovered it (mid 80s). Remembering these things lead me to think I perhaps just buried this aspect of myself for ages in fear. I learned to be masculine and the teasing eventually stopped.   I'm still relatively new on my journey, so I'm here to learn and figure myself out more. After lots of reading I suppose I currently identify as transfemme. Haven't come out to anyone yet. I feel like I need more experience and searching to be sure. But I'm definitely having fun along the way! Cheers everyone!             
    • Ivy
      Yeah…  As an exvangelical in my case. Guess I'll listen to that part of me this time.
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...