Jump to content
  • Welcome to the TransPulse Forums!

    We offer a safe, inclusive community for transgender and gender non-conforming folks, as well as their loved ones, to find support and information.  Join today!

Things people ask when they don't know you are transgender (after transition)


Ravin

Recommended Posts

So, I have not had reason or occasion to tell coworkers at my new job I'm trans. I do mention my husband with some frequency, so they probably assume I'm gay.

Today, I showed a coworker a picture of my kids. She asked if they were biological siblings.

Pre-transition, people who knew I was married always assumed I was their biological mother. Now, some assume they are adopted, I guess?

Has anyone else run into unexpected social side effects of transition?

Link to comment
  • Admin

Too many to keep separated and categorized. (Whew, almost said "keep straight") My own kids (now adult) do not call me Mom since that is for their biological mother, but they get questions on if I am their mother and it can get puzzling on how to answer. I have several younger Trans* friends who do playfully call me Mom and that is no problem at all. I refer to myself as "parent" or "grandparent" when talking about my children or grand children, and most of the time get away with it. The one where I do feel a teeny tiny bit sorry is when I gel read as my oldest daughter's daughter or younger sibling!! I also get taken for my youngest brother's younger sister ( I am 12 years older than he is.) when he was the family baby of my generation. My ex wife got taken for my mother one time on record. (OHHHH!!)

In a nutshell, this is common.

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

It has actually taken time for me to say the words my wife in public. That continues in certain situations. It seems a double wammie. First i'm trans* and i manage to come out. Then i'm a lesbian and have learn to come out yet again. This was something i never thought of. I'm sure it was one of the things my wife had to accept right away. I am pained to think that i wasn't as understanding as i could have been. Perhaps the process of transition was as much as i could take on.

With my grand kids i'm Grandie and that works. With my son i'll always be dad ( i just hope he remembers to use grandee when we're out). How others see the family i'm not sure and may depend upon the person and situation. It would be nice it it were not an issue but i'm afraid i'll always live with it.

Hugs,

Charlize

Link to comment
Guest Deanna

The first time this happen was at a parent teachers conf.. The My Wife and I walked in with our son and the teacher asked " Which one of you is the mother?". Basicly, she was going to ignore the other person. I said we are both the parents.

Deanna

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

I have been cogitating a bit. My wife is in a wheelchair with MS. One woman helping another seems to be accepted but twice i've been asked if she is my mother. Fortunately she only heard the comment once. I was also asked what my relationship with the "other woman" was. "my very best long time friend" was the answer. That was not long after going full time and in the rural south. The gentleman who asked was pleased as he responded that his mom took care of his aunt as well.

I like the "which one of you is the mother".

Hugs,

Charlize

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

On the day after "Mom's weekend" at the college, I had a "Frat boy" call our house, and began to charm me with kinky questions.

He asked "do you paint your toenails and if so, what color ?" I told him they were "Peach", and he could not get his head around this, I had to explain what Peach was :)

Then he asked me "can you touch your nose with your tounge ?", I told him no, but I know that Gene Simmons (bass player for KISS) could. He did not know about Gene Simmons (age thing), so I got to enlighten him on Gene Simmons tounge :rolleyes:

C -

Link to comment
  • Forum Moderator

Those things crop up all the time. Sometimes when talking to someone who doesn't know something comes out or is said in a way that confuses them. Usually now I just smile and go right on. And they drop it or maybe puzzle about it some but don't ask. I am not trying to hide that I am trans but at the same time I didn't transition to live as a transman but as a man . So mostly I just let it slide unless asked a direct question and no one has. Unless they knew me before and already knew. Humans are curious by nature but at the same time come across puzzles and things that they don't understand all the time and just let them go most of the time.

I've had to develop a whole new set of speech habits too. I no longer say "Whe I had my daughter" but instead say "When my daughter was born". And have to watch for "When I was a little girl" creeping in rather than "When I was a kid".

One of the worst things was a couple of years ago when a guy and I were taking waiting in a line and something came up about looking intimidating-O apparently still do when I am annoyed as I was at someone who cut in life. Anyway I popped off with something about not worrying because I hadn't hit anyone in a couple of decades -not since my ex who had it coming. Now as a woman saying that when I was 5'5" and he was over a foot taller and did physical labor was one thing but saying it as a man implied I had hit a woman and had a whole other vibe. Really chilled the conversation and there was really no way to explain that would make it any better.

As a result of transition I've had to develop a whole new censor in my head.

Another problem is children. I worked with children my whole life and they are naturally drawn to me. When I looked like someone's grandmother it wasn't a problem but now it has been a couple of times. Yesterday n a pet store a little girl about 8 started talking to me about a kitten I had paused to look at. I just said it was a nice kitten but she stated telling me all about how much she wanted a cat and why she didn't have one. I just smiled and moved on but she followed me. I had to frown at her and almost be rude . It was so against my nature and felt bad but a man-especially an older man-just can't talk to an unsupervised child- especially a little girl -or have her follow him around a store. I never saw the girl's family-in the past I would have taken her to them-but was concerned about the implications and repercussions of doing even that. I miss interacting with children more than anything else that changed in transition. But the reality is that I have had to relearn how I react around children. Find a way to be non threatening but not inviting as I always was before. f

I think that is to some degree something FTMs who have been mother's will face because we will be read altogether differently is we are motherly to children who are not our own now. Even to the comments we make about pictures of other people's children. It's sad and hard but a reality of the way things are in the world now

Gender roles are complex and our histories cross gender make it really challenging sometimes.

Johnny

Link to comment
Guest KerryUK

I was asked once if my wife is my mother. She heard and was absolutely mortified. I was mortified for her. I just replied with, "no, she's actually my best friend and that it's not a very nice thing to ask because it implies that you think she looks old." They apologised but we haven't been back since - they lost our custom.

Link to comment

Hi Ravin,

Yeah, I frequently am asked by female wine tour guests: "have you had any children", to which I simply reply "no I haven't had any children" without elaboration. So far that has been sufficient, which is good, since that awkward question comes up a lot. Besides I do like to be truthful, and the truth is that I was just born without the ability to bear children, so that is what I will say if anyone wishes me to elaborate. I avoid the subject of past relationships, that way I avoid being perceived as bi or lesbian. Instead I talk about my boyfriend Alex, and stuff. Occasionally I am unavoidably seen as a lipstick lesbian whenever Alex needs to show I.D. , this happened when I had a car repair, and also when he purchased a motorcycle for his commute to U.C. Davis. Fortunately that issue should be resolved next month when our official name, and gender changes are done. :)

hugs,

Stephanie

Link to comment
Guest Lizzie McTrucker

Has anyone else run into unexpected social side effects of transition?

Well, when I was changing my name at the bank after it was made official/legal, the lady asked if I got married.

Link to comment

These are all great. I know what you mean about that internal censor, Johnny. I am taking it slow with my coworkers because this is a conservative culture, and while there are traditional concepts about gender that are less hostile, they aren't necessarily common knowledge and there is also a lot of conservative Christian influence on the culture. They all seem fine with me being gay because I'm not one of them--I get the impression it would be more frowned on for one of their own.

Link to comment
Guest sydney

My wife and I were visiting my parents in South Florida last April and they have two community pools in their neighborhood. My wife and I were at one of them and we both were wearing just a one piece bathing suit and we started chatting with some of the women there. This one woman I was talking to asked if we were a couple and I said yes and told her we were married. She said I'm glad you were able to do that. She then tells a story about her lesbian sister in NY was in a relationship with her partner for 20 years and built a life together. (Bought a house together, etc.) Before they got married her partner died unexpectedly from an aneurysm and her partner's 25 year old son from a previous relationship who had been supportive of her mother's lesbian relationship came in and got everything and her sister got nothing because she had no rights.

She then asked when did we get married. I didn't want to lie but I also didn't want to out myself since there was no legal gay marriage 18 years ago anywhere when we married in 1997, so I said we had a ceremony 18 years ago but we did all the legal stuff in June 2014 (when I did my name change, but she didn't need to know that.)

Link to comment
Guest noeleena

Hi,

Most of whats talked about here did not effect me or change my answers to people. as they all had been told yes nation wide , so very few ,s were asked of Jos and I and our children and grandkids,

as im my interviews we talked about Jos who gave birth to our children and what we were going to do later in our life together , and that took 14 years to work out, so the main difference was and is they knew our background so nothing was hidden , an open book if you like just part of our life and who we knew and many we still do ,an acceptance that comes with being well known .

People and asking ?.s

Okay what about to day and when i meet new people so what shoulds i say when asked do you have children yes we do and Jos gave birth to our 3 and so who,s the dad ,i am , yet your a female , yes . an intersexed female , and if they wont to know more thay can ask and some do as many have no idear of us and our bodys and why we are like this ,

Children and this.....

your a boy ,,, oh am i ..yes okay then what if i say im a girl and just a little different ...oh...no your a boy , well i had Dejarn with me and yes many others around us , our grandchild Dejarn you tell this lad what i am she was 8 , she is a girl ... no shes not shes a boy ...thinking ,, your a girl then ...yes ,,,okay funny as his grand Mom and Dad were there very imbarrast with it all, i said dont be . this was at our Pack n Save Mall with many people watching ,

you know what i have a ball when this happens , apart from the fun side im able to teach others we can be different and just be part of socitey and talk with others as just normal people even though they find us different and its just part of life , and i enjoy it , am i crazzy maybe ,....

I think in many ways its easyer in my case because im not trying to be like a girl / woman or a boy / male theres no issues as i see it in how i interact with people middle road if you like and you find people just see you for who you are, and they get to know the real me as a person .

I have people work for me in different aspects of what we do they come to me if theres an issue they dont go ...oh dear are you a male or female its your a female lets just get on with the job inhand and do it and after so we going to do this again at a later date , hope so yes ,,iv allways been hard on myself in how i look ya ya facial features yet its really not an issue , just how i see myself ,

so yes i fit in and accepted .

When others see in you and know what you can do and how you go about things ,issues , and problems , do you think they are going to ? you because of how you look ,,, in my case ... im asked to be there and take charge does that not say acceptance in its highest form and your just accepted as any normal person , i know it does .

...noeleena...

Link to comment
Guest KerryUK

She then asked when did we get married. I didn't want to lie but I also didn't want to out myself since there was no legal gay marriage 18 years ago anywhere when we married in 1997, so I said we had a ceremony 18 years ago but we did all the legal stuff in June 2014 (when I did my name change, but she didn't need to know that.)

This is something that my wife and I have not come across yet. I like your style Sydney, I may even copy you.

Kerry x.

Link to comment

I don't think I would be inclined to outright lie to avoid outing myself, but I avoid discussing parenting topics like childbirth and breastfeeding from a first person experience perspective, and when talking about my daughter's birth talked about when she first "arrived."

If my kids are actually around, stealth is beyond possibility because I'm still "mom" to them.

Link to comment
Guest sydney

She then asked when did we get married. I didn't want to lie but I also didn't want to out myself since there was no legal gay marriage 18 years ago anywhere when we married in 1997, so I said we had a ceremony 18 years ago but we did all the legal stuff in June 2014 (when I did my name change, but she didn't need to know that.)

This is something that my wife and I have not come across yet. I like your style Sydney, I may even copy you.

Kerry x.

Thank you. Feel free to use it :)

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 120 Guests (See full list)

    • SamC
    • Ivy
    • Lydia_R
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      80.8k
    • Total Posts
      770.5k
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      12,116
    • Most Online
      8,356

    Tiffany Cross
    Newest Member
    Tiffany Cross
    Joined
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Clara_D
      Clara_D
      (53 years old)
    2. Deborah121
      Deborah121
      (64 years old)
    3. Kerry_Autumn
      Kerry_Autumn
      (38 years old)
    4. OC
      OC
  • Posts

    • KymmieL
      Well, I am now jobless. It seems I cannot be trusted. So they say. I am upset but doing eh. My youngest is OK with what happened I just hope my wife is the same.   Back to the hunt.   Kymmie
    • MaeBe
    • missyjo
      easye, go for it sweetie. it sounds cute   just simple denim mini n blue top from the shop   hugs to all
    • Nicola_Atherton
      Thank you! Eager to find other writers and readers!
    • Davie
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kM753ilB8ns 41st Annual Long Beach Pride Parade, broadcast by NBC.  
    • MaeBe
    • Sally Stone
      I liked it, Mae.  No apologies necessary.  
    • MaeBe
      Sorry for the schlocky poetry, feeling a little moody.
    • Sally Stone
      Post 13 “My Compartmentalized Life” In the interest of “full disclosure” I thought I should point out that my part-time life is also a very compartmentalized life.  Long time friends and close family don’t know Sally.  Most of the acquaintances I have made as Sally, have never met my male persona, and only a few close friends, know both personas.  It sounds complicated, I know, but it happens to fit my current transgender lifestyle.  But, how did I get here?   It started years ago when I didn’t know why I felt like a girl.  The only choice I thought I had, was to keep my feelings, and the crossdressing that went along with it, a closely guarded secret.  My Army career forced me to be even more guarded, so the need for secrecy became a habit.  Later, I wanted to emerge from my closet.  I wanted Sally to experience the world but because I still didn’t understand my true transgender nature, I wasn’t ready to share my feminine side with people I knew.    As Sally’s social life expanded, it was only natural that her circle of friends and acquaintances would also expand.  This resulted in a situation where suddenly, I was simultaneously in and out of the closet.  My transgender life had become compartmentalized.  Again, because I didn’t know where my trans journey was taking me, keeping my feminine side a secret from close friends and family, was still the logical choice.  I knew the situation might change if my destination was going to be full transition, but I decided to cross that bridge if or when I came to it.   It would be many more years before I understood completely, my trans nature.  When it became clear to me that I could be happy and fulfilled living my life as a part-time woman, I didn’t have to cross the full transition bridge.  And, because I had become quite adept at keeping my two lives compartmentalized, I saw no benefit to changing things.  I was walking in two completely different worlds.  My male persona had his world with his acquaintances, and Sally had her own world, with her own acquaintances.  For a very long time those two worlds didn’t overlap, but a few years ago, that changed.   Through my New Jersey dinner group, Sally became close with a couple, one trans, the other her spouse.  My wife became good friends with them as well.  We went out together often, and because our friends only knew me as Sally, I always presented to them that way.  That was until one time, when my wife and I had a commitment earlier in the day that made it impossible for me to transform before we were scheduled to meet our friends for dinner.  My first reaction to the situation was to cancel.  I had this overpowering aversion to letting them meet my male persona.  My wife convinced me that my concern was silly.  Still, I was so spring-loaded to maintaining my compartmentalized life, I actually called my friends to ask them if they would be okay meeting my “alter-ego.” As if they would have said no.  It was a ridiculous concern, and of course, they were actually perfectly happy to meet my “other half."    It turned out that letting our friends meet and interact with my male persona wasn’t as terrifying as I had imagined, and since that initial reveal, I have come out the same way to more of Sally’s close friends.  It’s easier now, but still not natural for me.  I’d still rather Sally’s friends interact only with Sally.  I guess all the years of compartmentalizing my two personalities, has formed a habit that I struggle to break.    When it comes to family and longtime friends, they only know my male persona, and based on my current trans lifestyle, I have no plans to introduce Sally to them.  There just isn’t anything about the way I live my life right now, that would make it necessary.  I won’t deny that sometimes, because I’m hiding a big part of my personality, I feel like a bit of a fraud. After all, they aren’t seeing all of the real me. I do sometimes struggle with this conflict.  On the one hand, I want everyone to know the real me but on the other hand, why run the risk of alienating family members or long-time friends when it isn’t absolutely necessary?   Believe it or not, there have been some in the trans community, that have argued I’m not actually trans since I haven’t gone through the ordeal of coming out to family and friends, that I haven’t experienced the one true transgender right-of-passage.  I know it has been way more difficult for those who have had to face the coming out challenge with friends and loved ones, but the level of difficulty one experiences doesn’t define someone’s level of transness.  In a future post, I’ll reflect on an incident when I was called out publicly for not being trans enough, and how it affected my confidence and self-worth.   I do have some family members and longtime friends that I have seriously considered coming out to, and I may follow through at some point. But again, because I am part-time, the timeline for doing so is really up to me and my comfort level, instead of a matter of necessity.           It’s obvious that unlike so many in our community, I haven’t had to “face the music.” I know how gut-wrenching and life changing coming out to close acquaintances can be, so I do consider myself fortunate.  It is important to note that I have not chosen a part-time trans life just to avoid the pain and tribulations of coming out.  Living part-time honestly has to do with not having to choose between one personality over the other, because ultimately, I could never be happy or fulfilled if I had to choose only one.   Yes, my life is seriously compartmentalized, with Sally in one compartment and my male persona in another.  Based on where my trans journey has taken me up to this point, and where it looks like it is headed in the future, I don’t anticipate much of a change. Walking in two worlds is a choice that works for me.  I know I am different, but each of us is, so I don’t think I need to make any apologies for living my life this way.    Hugs,   Sally       
    • MaeBe
      Mourning the Boy   As I sit Pants at the knees The first tear hits Rolls down a slender wrist A wave of loss So profound As I come To mourn the passing Of the boy A boy that once was
    • VickySGV
      This was from my May 2018 Face Book post and a friend of mine IRL asked to use it on a blog spot for the Personal Stories Project which is an effort of love for he and his husband.   From Diversity To Sameness, A PRIDE Meditation    May 21, 2018   It is Pride season again, and on Saturday I was at the Pride event in Long Beach CA to help out the San Gabriel Valley LGBTQ Center which I volunteer at these days. This was the first of several events I will be going to over the next few weeks, and others stretching over the next month or two. One of the people I was with made the comment that “We really are a diverse group here!!” The comment got me thinking, and re-opened my eyes to something that has amazed me in the relatively few years I have recognized that I am part of the LGBTQIA**** (the letters keep adding on) alphabet soup of life that does and will exist. My friend was right about the scope of the diversity that does exist and is on display at Pride events without shame and yes, with PRIDE in what and who each individual really is. To many people Diversity is one of those concepts that ranks up with blasphemy against a deity and the most horrendous of demons the Evil One (human imagination) has ever created. A person who is different is to be hated, feared, shamed and made valueless. The fear of diversity fuels minds to pull away from others, and to protect themselves by taking on feelings of superiority and exclusiveness above the different person. For the most part people with those feelings are good people in many many ways, but the fear and false god of superiority they have created masks that goodness terribly. At Pride events such as the one I was at, the diversity is so intense and so visible that after a moment or two the differences become the sameness of those who participate in them. We celebrate our differences to achieve our sameness and oneness by mentally stripping off the visual differences that at first overload us and can be dizzying to the point of a feeling of sickness for some who fit the pattern I described above. With the sameness we become even more aware of the other person’s humanity, and begin to look for the good elements that we share and find them more readily. Our conversations become how to help each other and take that helpfulness beyond those immediately with us. We reassure ourselves of our value, and explore new ways to add to that value in all ways, not just for ourselves, but those of our fellow humans who fear us and thus hide themselves deeper and deeper from the good that we could share fully. The LGBTQIA**** margin is not the only place where this can be present. The reason for other Pride events such as cultural gatherings of people “othered” and devalued, or even those of persons with what are declared to be disabilities, or mental diversity do the same thing, and people of different margins, as well as those who consider themselves “mainstream” are invited to submerge themselves in those groups by the same process of celebrating the diversity that will create the sameness of humanity. One group though who has suggested that it hold massive “Pride” events does not suggest their pride to be a celebration of diversity within that group, but rather enforced rigidity of an imagined sameness for only that group. Where that has been tried in recent months, there has been universal tragedy in many ways, the least of which has been murder. A celebration of false arrogance and even more false superiority is a hell on earth, and not a thing of pride, only of tears that they are afraid to show. I could have been in this last group believing it’s agenda and set of beliefs, but I was not allowed to be there because of something strange and wonderful in me that I did not accept about my life for over 50 years until it was to celebrate or die with my Gender Dysphoria. Today it is so “ordinary” for me to see inside of the differences in the outsides of people that I forget the lesson I relearned this past week.   Pride and Peace be in your lives.
    • VickySGV
      I for one am actually pleased with how this one played out.  Local issues need to remain local and I am not on the States Rights bandwagon for all cases.  The facts of the matter did not constitute a case or controversy since the plaintiffs did not show actual or immediately impending harm to their children.  Now if the parents can show that the child had developed some type of sleep and eating disorder because they were in a bathroom with a Trans child or are involved in self harm over the idea (which is probably the parent's doing and not the school) then there might be something of a case or controversy for the court to take up.   I have six text books on U.S. Constitutional Law grinning down evilly at me that all say the SCOTUS should avoid this type of case, and shows where they have done it consistently for a couple of centuries. 
    • Ladypcnj
      When I was a kid growing up, I was considered the baby sibling of the family. I was often the last to know of everything, and since I wasn't old enough just yet to stay home by myself, I had to tagged along with my family members who drove their cars, this included going to church. I never knew other religions existed; all I knew was about the teachings of Christianity. It's easy to join a church, but what if things aren't what it appears to be than what is preached? Strange things began going on at the church in which group leaders didn't want the news media to know about it, such as an almost drowning during a baptizing among other things. The preacher/minister began to sense I wanted out of the cult. Followers that was nice to me in the beginning, was now talking behind my back, not encouraging me to find another church that I would feel more spiritually connected to.     
    • Ivy
      An option to opt out is one thing, but removing the content entirely (for everyone) is something different.  I don't think it's beneficial to isolate one's kids from the broader culture since they are going to have to live in it eventually.  If something about it bothers you, you need to explain why.  Pretending it doesn't exist is a disservice to them.   In my (and my ex's) more conservative past, we considered homeschooling.  But we also realized our kids had to live in the broader culture and needed the socialization. Two of my adult children do homeschool now.  I have mixed feelings about that. Another of them is a public school teacher.   I personally would prefer that scarce resources not be diverted from public education.  The current move against public education bothers me.  For many kids it's all they have. 
    • April Marie
      Looking in the mirror brings joy.   The woman smiles back at me.
  • Upcoming Events

Contact TransPulse

TransPulse can be contacted in the following ways:

Email: Click Here.

To report an error on this page.

Legal

Your use of this site is subject to the following rules and policies, whether you have read them or not.

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Community Rules

Hosting

Upstream hosting for TransPulse provided by QnEZ.

Sponsorship

Special consideration for TransPulse is kindly provided by The Breast Form Store.
×
×
  • Create New...